Malaysia's third-ranked judge to take on Chief Justice duties until position is filled
Judge Hasnah will exercise the powers of the Chief Justice 'until that position is filled', said the Chief Registrar's Office of the Federal Court of Malaysia on Thursday.
Malaysia's top two judiciary positions are vacant after Tengku Maimun retired as Chief Justice when she turned 66 on Wednesday, and Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim retired as the President of the Court of Appeal when he turned 66 a day later.
Judge Hasnah reached the mandatory retirement age of 66 in May, but her term was extended by six months until mid-November by Malaysia's king.
The Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak, Abdul Rahman Sebli, will retire this month when his six-month extension ends.
The statement by the Chief Registrar's Office did not mention the role of the Court of Appeal president, but it added: "The Malaysian Judiciary remains steadfast in carrying out its responsibility as the guardian of justice and will continue to serve the people and the nation with utmost dedication.'
The judicial vacancies at the highest level have caused disquiet in Malaysia's legal and political circles.
On Monday, the Malaysian Bar slammed the 'silence and indecision on matters concerning the highest level of the judiciary', calling it 'indefensible' and a 'failure in institutional responsibility'.
'A breakdown in governance risks damaging public confidence in the judiciary and opens the door to speculation and unhealthy conjecture,' said Malaysian Bar president Mohamad Ezri Abdul Wahab, whose body comprises the country's 21,400 advocates and solicitors.
The Democratic Action Party (DAP), which is part of Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's governing coalition, on Tuesday called for a six-month extension for Tengku Maimun and Abang Iskandar 'given their contributions and performances'.
There will be 'many vacancies left in the Federal Court due to the recent and impending retirements of Federal Court judges', the DAP's central working committee said in a statement.
CNA reported in February that nine of the 14 judges of the Federal Court, the country's apex judicial body, are reaching the retirement age within months of each other.
Extending Tengku Maimun and Abang Iskandar's terms would 'ensure a smooth transition of new appointees to the Federal Court in due course', the DAP committee added.
However, Communications Minister and government spokesperson Fahmi Fadzil said the Cabinet did not deliberate in detail on the appointment of a new Chief Justice during its meeting on Wednesday.
The Cabinet meeting was chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi as Anwar is currently on a week-long working visit to Italy, France and Brazil, Fahmi said, as reported by news outlet Malay Mail.
PRIME MINISTER'S ROLE IN APPOINTMENT OF JUDGES
The Chief Justice is appointed by the king, also known as the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, on the prime minister's advice and after consultation with the Conference of Rulers made up of the heads of the country's royal households.
Malaysia established a Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) in 2009 that proposes qualified judicial candidates to the prime minister.
The JAC Act was meant to ensure that the selection process of judges would be unbiased, but lawyers told CNA previously that, in practice, new appointments often attract intense lobbying by politicians and segments in Malaysia's royal households.
There has been talk that Terrirudin Mohd Salleh – Malaysia's former Attorney General who was appointed to the Federal Court in November 2024 with the backing of Anwar –is being promoted by politicians and segments of the royal households to be the next Chief Justice, CNA reported in February.
In April, then-Chief Justice Tengku Maimun said removing the prime minister's role in the appointment of judges could free it from any perception of political influence.
There have been proposals to amend the JAC Act 2009 and the Federal Constitution to remove the role of the prime minister in the appointment of judges, she said in a speech at the 24th Commonwealth Law conference in Malta, as reported by news site Free Malaysia Today.
'Such changes, in my view, would reinforce the impartiality of the selection process, ensuring that judicial appointments remain firmly grounded on merit and free from any perception of political influence,' she said.
Anwar said on Monday he has never interfered in judicial matters including the appointment of judges.
"When someone retires, their service is not automatically extended," he said at the Prime Minister's Department monthly assembly.
"Some asked if this is the prime minister's decision? But if one understands the Federal Constitution, they would know the process," he said, as reported by media outlet New Straits Times (NST).
"Just look at the recent appointments where they go to the King, then are presented for discussion with the Conference of Rulers. So all these procedures must be followed,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
3 hours ago
- CNA
China foreign minister Wang Yi slams South China Sea ruling as ‘farce' at regional meeting
KUALA LUMPUR: Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi restated Beijing's rejection of the 2016 South China Sea arbitration ruling on Friday (Jul 11), on the eve of the ruling's ninth anniversary, amid renewed tensions and growing speculation about a potential second legal challenge. Calling the decision a 'farce', Wang said the case, brought by the Philippines against China 's South China Sea claims and ruled on by a tribunal of the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, was 'orchestrated and manipulated by external powers'. Their purpose 'was to destabilise the South China Sea for their own benefit', Wang said during the annual East Asian Summit foreign ministers' meeting in Kuala Lumpur. He said China works to maintain stability in the region and has been speeding up the negotiation of a binding South China Sea code of conduct with Asean. 'All attempts to stir up trouble or sow discord will ultimately fail,' he added at the meeting attended by top diplomats of 18 countries, including the 10 ASEAN member states and the United States. The Philippines filed the case with the court in 2013, but Beijing refused to participate. The court, in China's absence, ruled on Jul 12, 2016, in support of most of the Philippines' submissions, including its contention that China's extensive claim via the 'nine-dash line' appearing on Chinese maps since 1953 was invalid under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Additionally, the court ruled that China's land reclamation projects in the area were environmentally harmful. The ruling also held that no land features in the disputed Spratly Islands could be classified as 'islands', meaning that China could not claim exclusive economic zones around the reefs it occupies, while the Philippines could extend its zone from its coastline to include those reefs. Despite having signed UNCLOS in 1982 and ratified it in 1996, China strongly rejected the ruling and improved ties with former Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte by 'putting aside' the ruling during his 2016-2022 term. However, tension has escalated since the current Philippine president, Ferdinand Marcos Jnr, took office. It has been reported that Manila is considering filing a new UN arbitration regarding the maritime conflicts. In his remarks on Friday, Wang repeated China's declaration of 'four noes' in the case – no acceptance, no participation, no recognition and no implementation. He contended that the case addressed the issues of territorial sovereignty and maritime delimitation, which exceed the jurisdiction of both UNCLOS and the arbitration tribunal's authority. China and other major world powers, he said, had excluded maritime delimitation when they joined the convention. 'The tribunal's handling constituted an overreach, abusing the convention's dispute resolution mechanism and undermining international maritime rule of law. They are violating the convention under the banner of the convention,' Wang said. He added that the Philippines did not seek prior consultations with China before filing to the tribunal, and that therefore the initiation of the arbitration was legally flawed. He also accused Manila of breaking its commitment to the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China calls for South China Sea disputes to be solved through dialogue, as well as its bilateral promises to Beijing. Wang also condemned the tribunal's 'flawed and erroneous' decision to classify the Taiping Island (Itu Aba) of the Spratlys – a 0.5-square-kilometre island with fresh water and vegetation occupied by Taiwan – as a 'rock' that could not sustain an exclusive economic zone. 'If this standard were applied globally, the international maritime order would be rewritten, potentially depriving many nations ... of their maritime rights,' he said, referring to how the reefs of countries like the US and Japan would similarly lose their basis for claiming maritime rights and interests. "Would these countries be willing to give up their claims as well?" Besides the Philippines, three other ASEAN members – Malaysia, Brunei and Vietnam – have competing claims with China in the South China Sea. Beijing sees the self-governed island of Taiwan as a rogue province, to be reunited eventually with the mainland, by force if necessary.
CNA
15 hours ago
- CNA
Singapore needs trusted media that can offer balanced views: PM Wong
Prime Minister Lawrence Wong said Singapore needs trusted media that can offer balanced views. Speaking at The Straits Times' 180th birthday dinner, he added that media that can separate fact from fiction can help navigate a complex world. Mr Wong also said that the government will support the public service media to ensure that quality journalism remains viable, independent and accountable to Singaporeans. Nadirah Zaidi reports.
CNA
16 hours ago
- CNA
Manage differences responsibly, ASEAN foreign ministers tell global powers
KUALA LUMPUR: Top diplomats of the 10-member Association of Southeast Nations (ASEAN) urged major powers to manage 'their differences in a constructive and responsible manner', said Malaysian Foreign Minister Mohamad Hasan after three days of meetings in Kuala Lumpur on Friday (Jul 11). 'To ensure that the region remains peaceful, stable and prosperous, we underscored the importance of dialogue and cooperation through ASEAN platforms with (a) focus on commonalities rather than differences,' he told the media at the end of the 58th ASEAN Foreign Ministers' Meeting in Kuala Lumpur. The meetings took place amid geopolitical and trade uncertainties as US President Donald Trump announced revised tariffs on countries, including those in Southeast Asia. To develop a more coordinated regional response to economic headwinds and rising trade tensions, ASEAN foreign and economic ministers are set to hold a joint meeting in October ahead of the ASEAN Summit, said Mohamad. 'Politics and economy now go hand in hand. We are not going to separate them,' he said. The event and related meetings saw United States Secretary of State Marco Rubio, China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi, Russia Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, United Kingdom Foreign Secretary David Lammy and Australia Foreign Minister Penny Wong among high-level attendees. With Trump's latest tariff announcements, Malaysia – this year's ASEAN chair – now faces a 25 per cent tariff from Aug 1, Laos and Myanmar 40 per cent, Cambodia and US ally Thailand 36 per cent, and Indonesia 32 per cent. Last week, Trump announced Vietnamese goods would face a 20 per cent tariff and trans-shipments from third countries through Vietnam will face a 40 per cent levy. On Thursday, the Philippines and Brunei received letters informing of tariff rates of 20 per cent and 25 per cent, respectively. Malaysia Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim had slammed the tariffs in his speech as the meetings opened, saying 'tools once used to generate growth are now wielded to pressure, isolate and contain'. "Tariffs, export restrictions and investment barriers have now become the sharpened instruments of geopolitical rivalry," Anwar said, without specifically naming the US. He also urged ASEAN foreign and economic ministers to work more closely together to tackle the rising trade tensions. ASEAN secretary-general Kao Kim Hourn told news agency Bernama on Friday that member states have held six rounds of discussions focussed on the impact of US trade policies and other global economic shifts. He said ASEAN is now actively working to eliminate non-tariff barriers to realise the vision of a single market. While the US remains an important partner, ASEAN's trade diversification strategy is strong, with free trade agreements with China, Japan, Korea, India, Australia and New Zealand, Kao told Bernama. Intra-ASEAN trade and investment continue to grow, he added. Asked about Malaysia balancing its relationships with the US and China, minister Mohamad said that as a trading nation, the country could not be seen as leaning towards any side. 'The US is the largest investor in our country and China has (been) our largest trading partner for many years,' he said. 'We have to navigate our foreign policy, even for that matter ASEAN foreign policy, so that we are not seen to be leaning towards anybody. We are a zone of peace. We are neutral and we balance it properly.' When asked how difficult it was for ASEAN to be neutral, he said that being neutral was the best thing to do. He added that the bloc however did take positions on issues such as Gaza or Israel's attack on Iran because they were violations of international law. When asked if the bilateral spat between Thailand and Cambodia was discussed during the meetings, Mohamad said it was not. 'That is their internal affairs. (According to) the ASEAN charter, it is not to interfere in the internal affairs of any country,' he said. The neighbours have been at loggerheads since a Cambodian soldier was killed in late May as troops exchanged fire in a disputed border region. Ties have worsened since a leaked phone conversation in June between then Thai Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra and former Cambodian leader Hun Sen caused an uproar in Thailand and led to her suspension as the country's leader. ASEAN SUPPORTS 'ALL EFFORTS TOWARDS PEACE' Key meetings that took place on Friday, the final day, included the 15th East Asia Summit Foreign Ministers' Meeting and the 32nd ASEAN Regional Forum Foreign Ministers' Meeting. Both meetings included the 10 ASEAN members and key partners such as the US, Russia and China. In his East Asia Summit opening remarks, Mohamad made a call for 'decisive actions to end all conflicts' guided by the principles of justice, fairness, equality and humanity. He said ASEAN welcomes and supports all efforts towards peace, including in Ukraine and the Middle East, based on international law. The 'unjust and illegal occupation of the Palestinian Territory', which he called the 'longest conflict of modern history', must be brought to an end, he told representatives of the 18 members of the East Asia Summit. 'Eighty years of impunity have emboldened Israel to the extent of openly committing genocide, including through mass starvation that includes babies and children. This is unacceptable. It must not be allowed to continue. It must stop,' he said. Indonesian Foreign Minister Sugiono also highlighted the conflict in Gaza, saying the 'ongoing genocide' there was a clear reminder of what happens when fundamental principles of respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity are ignored. As geopolitical tensions intensify, there is a need to reinforce the foundation of peace in the Indo-Pacific. This, he said, meant a steadfast commitment to the United Nations (UN) Charter and international law. At the ASEAN Regional Forum, an Asia-Pacific-wide security dialogue with 27 participating countries, Mohamad cited maritime tensions, cyber threats and climate change as the region's most pressing challenges. The forum 'must be better equipped to respond swiftly and effectively', he said. 'Beyond dialogue, it should play a stronger role in early warning and response, especially in humanitarian crises, health emergencies, and conflict prevention,' he added. 'Malaysia calls for stronger cooperation through joint projects in key areas, such as, maritime security, counter-terrorism, and disaster preparedness, and better coordination with other ASEAN-led platforms.' TARIFFS POSE COMPLEX CHALLENGES, SAY ASEAN MINISTERS In their joint communique issued on Friday, ASEAN Foreign Ministers expressed 'concern' over rising global trade tensions and growing economic uncertainties, particularly 'unilateral actions relating to tariffs'. Tariffs are counter-productive, risk exacerbating global economic fragmentation and pose complex challenges to ASEAN's economic stability and growth, they said. They called for a predictable, transparent, inclusive and rules-based multilateral trading system with the World Trade Organization at its core. In the 32-page document, the ASEAN foreign ministers also expressed concern over the 'growing risks of nuclear danger and conflict' and expansion and modernisation of nuclear arsenals. Last month, Israel and the US attacked Iran's nuclear facilities but Israel said this week that some of Iran's stockpile of near-bomb-grade enriched uranium survived the attacks and may be accessible to Iranian nuclear engineers. Progress on nuclear disarmament is urgently needed, the ASEAN ministers stressed, as well as strengthening of the commitment to a world free of nuclear weapons amid the heightened geopolitical tension. They also reiterated the commitment to preserve the Southeast Asian region as a nuclear weapon-free zone and free of all other weapons of mass destruction as enshrined in the the Treaty on the Southeast Asia Nuclear Weapon-Free Zone and the ASEAN Charter. The wide-ranging communique also touched on conflict in Myanmar, the situation in the South China Sea and the humanitarian situation in Gaza, among other issues. The ministers expressed 'deep concern' over the escalation of conflicts and humanitarian situation in Myanmar, and encouraged progress on the implementation of the five-point consensus aimed at a peaceful resolution. On the South China Sea, some foreign ministers raised concerns on land reclamations and 'serious incidents' in the area that have damaged the marine environment and increased tensions. All ministers emphasised the importance of non-militarisation and self-restraint in the conduct of all activities by claimants and all other states. They welcomed the completion of the third reading of the Single Draft Code of Conduct in the South China Sea negotiating text. On Gaza, they expressed grave concern over the 'dire humanitarian situation' and called for an immediate and permanent ceasefire and the immediate release of all hostages. 'We reaffirmed our longstanding support for the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people, including the rights to self-determination, and to their homeland,' they said, urging parties to work towards a peaceful resolution, with a view to realising the two-state solution in accordance with international law.
