Shares in lenders soar after motor finance court ruling
Barclays and NatWest shares lifted 2% as the wider sector also received a shares boost.
Lloyds said it believes any change to the group's cash set aside for motor finance compensation was 'unlikely to be material' following the court ruling (Yui Mok/PA)
Lloyds and Close Brothers are seen as the most exposed to the motor finance saga and have put by hefty provisions for possible compensation bills relating to the affair.
The UK's highest court ruled that lenders are not liable for hidden commission payments in car finance schemes, finding that car dealers did not have a relationship with their customers that would require them to act only in the customers' interest.
The decision has been seen as a 'win' for lenders by significantly limiting the potential payouts in compensation, according to experts.
But the judgment left open the door for potential redress claims for very large commissions, which the Supreme Court said were unfair and therefore potentially unlawful.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said on Sunday that it would consult on an industry-wide compensation scheme, meaning millions of drivers could be owed a share of up to £18 billion – though most payouts are expected to be less than £950 each.
Close Brothers – which together with South Africa's FirstRand Bank had mounted the legal challenge against a Court of Appeal ruling that 'secret' commission payments on motor finance were unlawful – said over the weekend that it welcomed the Supreme Court judgment.
It had put by £165 million to cover potential redress, which sent it slumping to a £103.8 million half-year loss, and warned in March over a further £22 million hit to annual figures from legal and other costs linked to the motor finance case.
Close Brothers said there 'remains uncertainty as to the range of outcomes, and the financial impact to the group, including any impact on its provisioning assessment' until the outcome of the FCA's consultation is clear.
On Monday, it added: 'We look forward to engaging with the FCA in respect of the consultation.'
Lloyds said it believes any change to the group's cash set aside for motor finance compensation was 'unlikely to be material', following Friday's court ruling.
It has aside £1.2 billion to cover potential costs and compensation related to commission arrangements.
The group is exposed to the motor finance market through its Black Horse business.
But Lloyds said there continues to be a 'number of uncertainties' and will continue to review its provision.
Lloyds said: 'After initial assessment of the Supreme Court judgment – and pending resolution of the outstanding uncertainties, in particular the FCA redress scheme – the group currently believes that if there is any change to the provision it is unlikely to be material in the context of the group.'
Matt Britzman, senior equity analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, said the court ruling was 'a win for UK lenders, bringing some much-needed legal certainty'.
'But it's not a home run as the FCA announced plans to explore a compensation scheme that could cost the industry £9 billion to £18 billion.'
He added that Lloyds investors should be 'relatively pleased with this outcome'.
'It's broadly aligned with existing expectations, helping to alleviate fears that the final bill could be significantly higher.'
The FCA said on Sunday that the consultation will be launched by early October. If the compensation scheme goes ahead, the first payments should be made in 2026.
It urged consumers who are concerned they were not told about commission and think they may have paid too much to their motor finance lender to complain now.
They do not need to use a claims management company or law firm and doing so could cost them around 30% of any compensation paid, according to the FCA.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
7 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Maker of Gordon's and Guinness ramps up cost-cutting after year of plunging profits
Scroll down to find out how much experts think the minimum wage must increase by GORDON BLANKS Maker of Gordon's and Guinness ramps up cost-cutting after year of plunging profits GORDON'S and Guinness maker Diageo is ramping up cost-cutting after a tough year of plunging profits. The UK-based FTSE 100 firm, which also owns brands including Johnnie Walker whisky, said operating profits had fallen by 27.8 per cent to £3.3billion in the year to June 30. Advertisement 1 Gordon's and Guinness maker Diageo is ramping up cost-cutting after a tough year of plunging profits Credit: Getty In response, the spirits giant plans to cut costs by £625million over three years, increasing its original target of £500million. Nik Jhangiani, interim boss of the firm, said the savings plan is 'not about job cuts' but added 'there will be some' as a result. He stressed that the group could still increase its overall workforce. Diageo said it expects to secure savings over three years from advertising and promotion efficiencies, reduced overheads and supply chain improvements. Advertisement The increased savings plans come amid a period of upheaval after the departure of its boss last month. Debra Crew stepped down with 'immediate effect' and by 'mutual agreement', after a recent decline in Diageo's share value. Tariffs, cautious consumer demand and increased cost pressures have weighed down businesses across the drinks industry. The global company's net sales dipped 0.1 per cent last year, mainly due to currency issues and changes to its brand portfolio. Advertisement But sales were up by 6.7 per cent in Britain thanks to a strong demand for Guinness. Dua Lipa downs pint of Guinness as she celebrates five-night sold-out stadium gigs LOW PAY CALL THE minimum wage will need to rise by 4.1 per cent next year from £12.21 to £12.71 an hour, says the Low Pay Commission. The wage has surged in recent years, with 6.5 per cent of workers relying on it. The Government is also reviewing minimum wage age bands, aiming to reduce the gap for younger workers. Advertisement The commission will provide its recommendations in October, with new rates set to apply from April. LOANS ALARM MILLIONS of us are spending thousands more on loans due to poor credit scores, say financial experts Totallymoney. A £5,000 loan over three years could cost £6,678 extra in interest, while a £10,000 loan could cost an extra £13,541. Only one in four have checked their credit report in recent years. Advertisement Alastair Douglas at TotallyMoney said: 'Check your report every six months for errors that hurt your score.' CAR SALES' ELECTRIC PLUG NEW car sales fell five per cent in July to 140,154 as drivers waited for Government EV grants. Electric cars accounted for 21.3 per cent of sales, says the Society of Motor Manufacturers & Traders, with discounts of £1,500 to £3,750 now available on Citroën models. Meanwhile, RAC data found UK cars are getting older. A typical motor is now nine years and ten months, and 41 per cent are more than a decade old. Advertisement Experts say this is slowing the move to greener electric cars.
The Sun
7 minutes ago
- The Sun
Maker of Gordon's and Guinness ramps up cost-cutting after year of plunging profits
GORDON'S and Guinness maker Diageo is ramping up cost-cutting after a tough year of plunging profits. The UK-based FTSE 100 firm, which also owns brands including Johnnie Walker whisky, said operating profits had fallen by 27.8 per cent to £3.3billion in the year to June 30. 1 In response, the spirits giant plans to cut costs by £625million over three years, increasing its original target of £500million. Nik Jhangiani, interim boss of the firm, said the savings plan is 'not about job cuts' but added 'there will be some' as a result. He stressed that the group could still increase its overall workforce. Diageo said it expects to secure savings over three years from advertising and promotion efficiencies, reduced overheads and supply chain improvements. The increased savings plans come amid a period of upheaval after the departure of its boss last month. Debra Crew stepped down with 'immediate effect' and by 'mutual agreement', after a recent decline in Diageo's share value. Tariffs, cautious consumer demand and increased cost pressures have weighed down businesses across the drinks industry. The global company's net sales dipped 0.1 per cent last year, mainly due to currency issues and changes to its brand portfolio. But sales were up by 6.7 per cent in Britain thanks to a strong demand for Guinness. Dua Lipa downs pint of Guinness as she celebrates five-night sold-out stadium gigs LOW PAY CALL THE minimum wage will need to rise by 4.1 per cent next year from £12.21 to £12.71 an hour, says the Low Pay Commission. The wage has surged in recent years, with 6.5 per cent of workers relying on it. The Government is also reviewing minimum wage age bands, aiming to reduce the gap for younger workers. The commission will provide its recommendations in October, with new rates set to apply from April. LOANS ALARM MILLIONS of us are spending thousands more on loans due to poor credit scores, say financial experts Totallymoney. A £5,000 loan over three years could cost £6,678 extra in interest, while a £10,000 loan could cost an extra £13,541. Only one in four have checked their credit report in recent years. Alastair Douglas at TotallyMoney said: 'Check your report every six months for errors that hurt your score.' CAR SALES' ELECTRIC PLUG NEW car sales fell five per cent in July to 140,154 as drivers waited for Government EV grants. Electric cars accounted for 21.3 per cent of sales, says the Society of Motor Manufacturers & Traders, with discounts of £1,500 to £3,750 now available on Citroën models. Meanwhile, RAC data found UK cars are getting older. A typical motor is now nine years and ten months, and 41 per cent are more than a decade old. Experts say this is slowing the move to greener electric cars.
Rhyl Journal
3 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
BP increases staff cuts to 6,200 and signals further possible reductions
The oil giant said it now expects 6,200 jobs to go – about 15% of its office-based workforce – which is higher than the 4,700 cuts announced at the start of the year, with a focus on artificial intelligence (AI) to help drive cost efficiencies. BP also said it had already slashed 3,200 contractor roles since January, with another 1,200 to go by the end of 2025, adding it will 'continue to rigorously review the remaining contractor activity across our businesses and functions'. The group raised the possibility of further cuts as bosses unveiled plans to look for more cost savings and conduct a 'thorough' review of its portfolio as it comes under pressure from shareholders. Its 100,000-strong worldwide workforce will be reviewed further as part of the new push, it confirmed. BP did not give a country breakdown of the extra job cuts this year, but said they will go across its UK and overseas sites. The firm employed about 14,000 UK workers at the start of 2025. It comes as chief executive Murray Auchincloss pledged the FTSE 100 firm would do 'better for its investors' and said there was 'much more to do' under its current three-year plan. BP has been under pressure from shareholders to boost profits and cut costs, with activist investor Elliott Management recently taking a 5% stake in the group. Half-year profits on Tuesday showed profits tumbled by nearly a third as weaker oil prices weighed on earnings, although it posted a better-than-expected performance for the second quarter. It reported a 32% fall in underlying replacement cost profits – the group's preferred profit measure – to 3.73 billion US dollars (£2.81 billion) for the six months to June 30. 2Q has been another strong quarter, both operationally and strategically. We are delivering our plan to grow the upstream and focus the downstream. — bp (@bp_plc) August 5, 2025 Underlying profits fell 15% year-on-year to 2.35 billion dollars (£1.77 billion) between April and June, although this was a significant improvement from 1.38 billion dollars (£1.04 billion) in the first quarter and better than most analysts had forecast, helping shares lift nearly 2%. BP is already working on a plan announced in February to cut costs by up to five billion dollars (£3.8 billion) by the end of 2027. It has also said it will offload 20 billion dollars (£15.1 billion) of assets by the end of 2027. The group's results showed it has already stripped out 900 million dollars (£677 million) in costs over the first half, or 1.7 billion dollars (£1.3 billion) since 2023. BP's aims to ramp up its overhaul process follows talks with incoming chairman Albert Manifold who starts next month, Mr Auchincloss said. Mr Auchincloss said: 'He and I have been in discussions and have agreed that we will conduct a thorough review of our portfolio of businesses to ensure we are maximising shareholder value moving forward. 'We are also initiating a further cost review and, whilst we will not compromise on safety, we are doing this with a view to being best in class in our industry.' 'BP can and will do better for its investors,' he added. In a presentation to analysts and investors, Mr Auchincloss said AI was playing a key part in its overhaul, adding 'technology is helping improve capital productivity and drive cost reductions across the portfolio'. In another move to appease shareholders, the FTSE 100 firm also said it would buy back another 750 million dollars (£565 million) in shares and hike the quarterly dividend payout by 4%. Mr Auchincloss said: 'We are two quarters into a 12-quarter plan and are laser-focused on delivery of our four key targets – and while we should be encouraged by our early progress, we know there's much more to do.' Mr Manifold was recently named to replace incumbent chairman Helge Lund after a difficult past few years in the role. Formerly chief executive of building materials firm CRH for 10 years, Mr Manifold joins the oil giant as chairman-elect on September 1 before taking over as chairman on October 1.
