US lawmaker backs tariffs, calls for changing China's trade status

Voice of America

08-03-2025

Calls to revoke China's Permanent Normal Trade Relations (PNTR) status have grown louder in recent months.
In a memo released on the first day of his second term, President Donald Trump asked his Cabinet members to "assess legislative proposals regarding PNTR." Three days later, Republican Representative John Moolenaar, the chairman of the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party, and Democratic lawmaker Tom Suozzi introduced the first bipartisan bill that would revoke China's PNTR status.
China has held PNTR status since 2000, when Congress first passed legislation on the matter. Prior to that, Beijing's trade status was reviewed annually.
VOA recently sat down with Republican Representative Tom Tiffany of Wisconsin, who also proposed legislation, along with Republican lawmaker Chris Smith, to revoke China's PNTR status. He said China is stealing American technology, setting up police stations in various cities across the U.S. and engaging in unfair trade practices. "One of the most important things we can do is to revoke China's PNTR and have it renewed on an annual basis," he said.
This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity.
VOA: The relationship between the U.S. and China has gone through dramatic changes since China entered the WTO in 2001. How do you describe the current state of U.S.-China relations? How did we get here?
U.S. Representative Tom Tiffany: I think the goodwill of the American people has been abused. When you look at the theft of intellectual property — I just mentioned the police stations, something that is anathema to American society — I believe this goes back to when most favored nation status was given to Communist China and that's why I've introduced legislation with Representative Chris Smith from New Jersey to revoke that permanent status and have it be renewed annually. I believe we will get much greater accountability by the Communist Chinese government. I think this is one of the most important things that we can do. We have the largest consumer base, and that has led to prosperity for China over the last few decades. I believe they should respect that, and they have not. One way in which we can deal with this is to have an annual renewal for most favored nation status.
VOA: You represent Wisconsin's 7th congressional district. How have the actions taken by China affected people in your district, especially on the trade front?
Tiffany: I'll give you one example. We grow almost all the ginseng in my district, in northern Wisconsin, and the Communist Chinese have used this as a weapon in trade negotiations. Because Wisconsin is such an important state, in terms of elections, they've tried to turn the ginseng growers against Republicans, against President Trump, by saying we're not going to take your ginseng anymore. Because China took a lot of America's ginseng — it's the best that is produced in the world — they've used trade, specifically in regard to ginseng, as a political weapon and that should not be the case. I'm hoping that the Communist Chinese will relent on this now and allow ginseng to be imported into their country once again in the same volumes that they did a decade ago.
VOA: Do you support imposing tariffs on Chinese goods coming to the U.S., and what are the other urgent steps that the U.S. should be taking to deal with China's unfair trade practices?
Tiffany: I do agree with tariffs, and I like the president's idea of having reciprocal tariffs. If you're going to tariff 25% on a particular product, then we're going to tariff 25% on a particular product. We would prefer to just see free trade, but it has to be fair trade.
I think there's a couple other things that we watch very closely here in America. We see the abuse of the Uyghur people in Western China. That is unacceptable in a free society. We do not want companies importing goods that are using slave labor. We haven't had a full accounting of what happened in the Wuhan lab with the coronavirus ... it appears almost certain that it came from that lab and caused incredible damage to not just America, but countries around the world. We need a full accounting in regard to those things and China needs to provide that.
VOA: Where do you see U.S.-China relations heading in the next decade?
Tiffany: If we continue with the policies of President Trump, I think we have the potential to have good relations. You know, maybe [Chinese President] Xi Jinping chooses not to give up communism, and that's how he wants to rule his country, and that would be very unfortunate. But I think we'd end up with better relations when we have a strong America.