Federal court upholds SEC ‘gag rule' in 3-0 ruling over free speech objections
Twelve petitioners had been appealing the SEC's decision in January 2024 not to amend the rule, including eight people whose SEC settlements triggered it.One petitioner, former Xerox chief financial officer Barry Romeril, took a similar case to the US Supreme Court in 2022 in an appeal backed by billionaire and longtime SEC critic Elon Musk, but that court refused to consider it.In Wednesday's decision, Circuit Judge Daniel Bress said that while some defendants find the rule coercive, they remained free not to settle, and instead to speak out against the SEC.He also said the SEC had an interest in deciding how to try its own cases, including by giving defendants different options, knowing that scrapping the rule could lead to fewer settlements."Provided that any limitation on speech remains within proper bounds, and given the background ability to waive First Amendment rights at least to some extent, the SEC has an interest in giving defendants the option to agree to a speech restriction as part of a broader settlement agreement," Bress wrote.Bress said challenges to applying the rule could still be brought before the SEC brings enforcement cases, while judges consider settlements, or when the SEC reopens settled cases because of alleged breaches.The petitioners included the New Civil Liberties Alliance, which challenges perceived administrative law excesses.NCLA senior litigation counsel Peggy Little said in a statement the nonprofit was disappointed. "Past practice does not excuse unconstitutional government action," she said.The SEC had no immediate comment.SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce dissented from the regulator's decision not to amend the rule.She found "scant factual basis" for the rule, and said prohibiting denials of wrongdoing "prevents the American public from ever hearing criticisms that might otherwise be lodged against the government, let alone assessing their credibility."- Ends
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
4 minutes ago
- First Post
Trump announces 100% tariff on computer chips and semiconductors, exempts firms 'building in US'
Trump has announced a 100 per cent tariff on imported computer chips and semiconductors, aiming to push companies to manufacture them within the country. The move which exempts US-based producers. read more Trump has taken an extraordinary bet on the importance of American market in global economy and believes that he has a leverage so unique that he can do almost anything. Image: AFP US President Donald Trump on Wednesday (August 6, local time) announced plans to impose a 100 per cent tariff on computer chips and semiconductors, while exempting companies that manufacture them within the United States. The move is expected to drive up the cost of a wide range of electronics, cars, appliances, and other essential tech-driven products. 'We'll be putting a tariff on of approximately 100 per cent on chips and semiconductors,' Trump said while speaking at the Oval Office. 'But if you're building in the United States of America, there's no charge.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The announcement follows Trump's decision to impose an additional 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods over its continued oil trade with Russia, effectively doubling the overall tariff rate to 50 per cent. The new tariffs are scheduled to take effect in 21 days, allowing time for India and Russia to negotiate with the US administration over the proposed import duties. The global chip shortage during the Covid-19 pandemic had already led to rising car prices and contributed to broader inflation. Since then, demand for semiconductors has continued to surge, with global sales rising 19.6 per cent in the 12 months ending June, according to the World Semiconductor Trade Statistics organization. Trump's latest tariff move marks a sharp departure from current strategies aimed at boosting domestic chip production through subsidies and incentives. Instead, he's opting for a more aggressive approach, using tariffs as leverage to push companies to manufacture within the US. By making imported chips more expensive, Trump is betting that firms will be compelled to shift production domestically, even if it risks squeezing profits and raising consumer prices on products like smartphones, televisions, and appliances.
India.com
4 minutes ago
- India.com
With Trump's 25% Tariff Imposed, How Much More Could India Lose If Russian Oil Is Next?
New Delhi: India now faces a full-blown tariff offensive from Washington. U.S. President Donald Trump has already imposed a 25% tariff on Indian exports, alongside a 10% penalty aimed at punishing India's continued energy trade with Russia. The combined blow could push duties on Indian goods to 35%, shaking the foundations of one of India's largest trade relationships. According to an internal government assessment, the new measures directly affect nearly $64 billion worth of Indian exports to the United States, roughly 80% of total outbound goods to the country. Four senior officials, familiar with the matter, confirmed the estimates. 'The impact is real and immediate,' said one of the sources, flagging potential export losses due to price disadvantages. India exported around $81 billion worth of goods to the United States in 2024. Sectors such as garments, pharma, petrochemicals, gems and jewellery now stand at risk of losing their edge in the global market, especially when competing against countries not facing such steep tariffs. The government has acknowledged the looming fallout. 'The erosion of price competitiveness is already visible,' said another official, pointing to intensified rivalry from nations facing lower duties. The high-value items now caught in this tariff net had so far enjoyed relative strength in the U.S. market. Trump on Tuesday declared that the 25% tariff would rise 'substantially within 24 hours' and followed through. On Wednesday, he announced his administration would finalise the Russian oil penalty after assessing progress on its Ukraine policy push. Last week, Trump lumped India with Russia, calling both 'dead economies' and accusing New Delhi of maintaining unfair trade barriers and backing Moscow through energy purchases. The rhetoric found sharp resonance in the new trade measures, signalling a hard pivot in U.S.-India economic ties. Despite the escalation, the Reserve Bank of India stayed firm. In a post-policy meeting on Wednesday, it left GDP growth forecasts unchanged at 6.5% for the current fiscal year. Interest rates also remained steady. RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra addressed the brewing storm by stating, 'We are contributing about 18% to global growth, more than the United States, which is contributing about 11%,' he said. He dismissed the 'dead economy' label and pointed to India's momentum. He also cited International Monetary Fund (IMF) figures projecting India's 2025 growth at 6.4%, compared to America's 1.9%. India's global goods exports stood at $443 billion in 2024, with the United States accounting for nearly a fifth of that. The latest penalties threaten to drag down a major chunk of this pipeline. The internal trade impact report emphasises that losses may not only come from reduced volumes but also from long-term erosion in market share. Sectors that had steadily built footholds in the American market now face re-evaluation and possibly redirection. As of now, India is holding its line diplomatically while crunching numbers and exploring trade alternatives. But with Trump's tariff hammer already falling, the damage may already be underway.
The Hindu
33 minutes ago
- The Hindu
YSRCP leaders urge SEC to ensure peaceful conduct of ZPTC election in Pulivendula
A delegation of the YSRCP, led by Perni Venkataramaiah and V. Srinivas, and comprising MLCs Lella Appi Reddy and R. Ramesh Yadav, former MLA Malladi Vishnu, Mayor Rayana Bhagya Lakshmi, met State Election Commissioner (SEC) Nilam Sawhney here on Wednesday, and urged her to ensure peaceful by-election to the Pulivendula Zilla Parishad Territorial Constituency (ZPTC), while taking to her attention the violence allegedly unleashed by the TDP-backed activists during the campaign and the evidence of it. The YSRCP leaders highlighted a series of incidents, including the attack on Mr. Ramesh Yadav and party leader Velpula Ramu allegedly by 30 TDP men armed with sticks. They alleged that the victims were chased, dragged out of their vehicles, and assaulted near Nallagondavaripalli, and the police deliberately remained mute spectators. The TDP was creating fear among the voters and misusing power to disrupt the election, going by the manner in which bindover cases were being booked against the YSRCP leaders and arrests made on false grounds, the YSRCP alleged, requesting the SEC to take stern action and ensure free and fair local body elections in Pulivendula and across the State.
