logo
Tribunal bundle reveals new details in Sandie Peggie case

Tribunal bundle reveals new details in Sandie Peggie case

Ms Peggie was ultimately cleared, with the health board saying earlier this week that the panel "found that there was insufficient evidence" to back up the four allegations made by Dr Beth Upton.
Following the announcement, Scottish Labour's deputy leader, Dame Jackie Baillie, called on NHS Fife to settle the tribunal and bring "this sorry saga to an end.'
READ MORE
The minutes of the investigation form part of the evidence bundle — the compilation of all documents relevant to the employment tribunal, including the original complaint, witness statements, internal correspondence, screengrabs of WhatsApp messages, Facebook posts, disciplinary records, and responses from legal representatives.
The Herald on Sunday is the only newspaper to have accessed the bundle.
Ms Peggie, an experienced A&E nurse, was suspended after a confrontation with Dr Upton, a transgender medic, on Christmas Eve 2023 at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy.
Dr Upton ultimately made four complaints about Ms Peggie.
The first was that Ms Peggie was carrying out observations on a patient in the resuscitation area when Dr Upton entered the cubicle. Rather than continue, Ms Peggie allegedly "stopped, exited the cubicle and told Beth Upton to complete the observations herself."
The second concerned an incident on December 18, when a child left the department without being seen. Dr Upton said they asked Ms Peggie for her "advice and assessment from a triage perspective," but the nurse refused to answer and "chose to speak through a colleague."
The third allegation was of misconduct: that Ms Peggie told Dr Upton they "did not have the correct chromosomes to be within a female changing room," and referred to "a recent news story that involved a transgender woman in a female Scottish prison."
The fourth was that she misgendered her colleague by referring to Dr Upton as "he/him, including in discussions with colleagues."
However, the minutes of the investigation suggest that the potentially career-ending patient safety allegations were quickly dismissed.
Dr Beth Upton (Image: Getty) Dr Upton told investigators their "concerns were more in relation to potential issues that could happen in the future" and that they "did not feel patient safety was compromised for this patient at this time."
Ms Peggie's managers also said they had no concerns about her practice.
Esther Davidson, Ms Peggie's supervisor, told the panel she had "never received any concerns about anyone's safety in relation" to the nurse's practice.
She did refer to "one occasion around eight years ago when a newly qualified nurse felt intimidated by Miss Peggie and eventually snapped." An early resolution meeting was held, followed by a short monitoring period. "There were no further issues after this."
Also included in the evidence bundle is a letter sent by Dr Kate Searle, Dr Upton's supervisor, to all emergency department consultants.
The email, circulated shortly after the Christmas Eve incident, appeared to condemn Ms Peggie outright — before any formal investigation had taken place or Ms Peggie had been asked for her account of events.
Dr Searle wrote: "Beth was approached in a very confrontational and aggressive manner by SN Sandie Peggie in the changing room. She stated that she had no right to be in the female changing room, and that Sandie was not the only member of staff who felt this way, and that she found Beth's presence in there intimidating.
"She then proceeded to use other offensive terms, including alluding to her presence in the female changing room being akin to the situation of a convicted rapist being housed in a woman's prison earlier this year.
"Beth is understandably shaken and distressed by the episode, and indeed felt unsafe and threatened at the time. I have had a long chat with Beth today and ensured she knows we all support her and that we condemn the actions of Sandie."
Dr Searle added that she had ensured Dr Upton would not share shifts with Ms Peggie over the next month, had filed a formal Datix report, contacted NHS Fife's equality lead, referred Dr Upton to occupational health services, and arranged for managers to meet Ms Peggie.
Dr Searle is due to give evidence and be cross-examined at the tribunal on Tuesday.
"I felt upset and afraid"
Dr Upton told investigators that early on, they found Ms Peggie to be "someone that didn't want to engage with her."
They said they "felt things were challenging enough with the changing room situation" and "wanted to ensure that she was not contributing to making things difficult within the department" and that their "concerns did not warrant going to speak to someone at that point."
Asked about the impact of the Christmas Eve incident, Dr Upton said they "felt upset and afraid, and has remained so since."
READ MORE
They took two months off work in March 2024 after learning Ms Peggie was returning to the department. They told the panel they had suffered "daily panic attacks," and that "her wife was concerned about safety at work."
"I feel people — especially in this country — can be prejudiced towards trans people," they said.
"I was conscious of the potential for this situation to become so much bigger, which it has subsequently done."
They said there had "been leaked pre-transition photos of her and harassment of her and her family, all of which has been very distressing."
They said journalists had turned up at their door and harassed them and others around them.
Personal logs and earlier difficulties
Dr Upton kept notes of their interactions with Ms Peggie on their phone. In one entry dated August 2023, they wrote that Ms Peggie had walked into the changing room while they were there and "abruptly walked out" and waited outside.
"Can't help but feel slightly off, upset, put off by this. Disappointed it appears that she chose not to enter because of me and didn't think I belonged there. Sad times."
A second note, from October 2023, said Ms Peggie again left the changing room when Dr Upton arrived.
After the Christmas Eve incident, Dr Upton wrote that they were "distraught."
"I feel attacked and cornered. I explained, this is the first time I've experienced anything like this in person."
Asked why they kept a log on your phone, Dr Upton said "if you're having difficult interactions with people, that you should keep a track of it."
They added that their wife and mother "also advised her to keep a track of difficult interactions and any repeat behaviours."
Dr Upton told the panel they were "feeling uncomfortable in the situation and felt it was good to keep track."
They also confirmed they "had previous difficulties with a colleague during her FY1 placement, and had kept a log of that."
Ms Peggie's legal team sought an order for Dr Upton's phone to be inspected by forensic expert Jim Borwick. However, this was rejected by the tribunal.
They wanted to discover the date and time the notes were created and when they were edited.
Mr Borwick is due to give evidence on Tuesday.
The nurse's response
The panel also sent supplementary questions to Ms Peggie. None were about patient safety. The first four were about her general use of pronouns.
In a formal reply, Ms Peggie's solicitor, Margaret Gribbon, said a disciplinary hearing should 'proceed on the basis of concrete allegations of clearly specified allegations of misconduct, normally on a specified date. An invitation to an employee to make a general confession is neither usual nor fair."
Asked how she refers to Dr Upton, Ms Peggie said: "Beth."
She added: "Pronouns are not used to address people, so I do not use pronouns, either preferred pronouns, or correct sex pronouns, to address anybody, patients or colleagues."
Asked why she told colleagues before Christmas Eve that she would speak to Dr Upton directly, Ms Peggie said: "No one appeared willing to speak to Beth on behalf of myself or my colleagues.
"I hope that by speaking to him personally, he might be able to realise he was making us feel uncomfortable by changing in a female changing area, and the reason why, in the hope he would understand and change elsewhere."
She said she entered the changing room to change her trousers, which were soiled due to menstruation, and that the situation made her feel "embarrassed."
Asked whether her feelings contributed to the interaction, she said: "Yes."
Asked if she had discussed the incident with a supervisor, she replied: "I wasn't upset I was menstruating.
"I was upset because my dignity as a woman was being violated because I was being forced to deal with the situation with a male being present in the female changing room at a time when I felt vulnerable and in dire need of privacy and a single-sex space.
"I didn't feel comfortable speaking to the staff I was working with, especially as it was a personal and embarrassing matter. I was keen to go home, especially as it's Christmas Day, and discuss my upset with my husband and my family."
She said the incident lasted just two minutes and that she hoped the conversation might help Dr Upton understand.
Asked why she didn't report the matter, Ms Peggie said: "I was hopeful that Beth would accept my concerns and the reasons why I felt uncomfortable.
"I tried to give him an example so he could appreciate the severity of the situation. I told them I had a difficult history with men."
"I didn't think it was necessary to speak to anyone, because I was hoping, on reflection, Beth would understand."
She said she was "upset that the interaction did not seem to have had any influence on the way Beth felt, and I realised from his reaction that he did not seem to care about the stress he was causing me."
"I was left shaken following his response. It was on my mind throughout the shift, but I did not want it to impact my work."
Sandie Peggie (r) with solicitor Margaret Gribbon (Image: Jeff J Mitchell/Getty) Ms Peggie denied ever referring to chromosomes.
"I am a nurse and don't need to ask a person what their chromosomes are, because I already know. I deny referring to chromosomes during my interaction with Dr Upton."
Asked about the reference to the Scottish prison story, she said: "It was in the media at the time. I was trying to give [Dr Upton] an example of how I and other women feel."
Asked whether she treated Dr Upton with dignity and respect, Ms Peggie replied: "Yes, because Dr Upton's presence there and the board's decision to permit him to use a female-only changing room was unlawful.
"I felt upset, humiliated and harassed to find him there, particularly when I had a menstrual flood to deal with. I remained as calm as I could, but I felt strongly that he should not be there.
"His insistence that he was entitled to be there meant I felt I had no option but to try different explanations of why his presence made me and many of my colleagues uncomfortable.
"I should not have been put in this position, and I handled it as well and as calmly as I could, given the difficult circumstances in which management had put me."
NHS Fife's findings
In a statement released on Wednesday, NHS Fife said: "The panel found that there was insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct."
Ms Peggie's solicitor, Ms Gribbon, said her client was "relieved and delighted that this 18-month long internal process has concluded and cleared her of all allegations."
The tribunal continues.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Investigation launched into SNP ministers over huge eye operation delays as thousands of Scots are forced to go private
Investigation launched into SNP ministers over huge eye operation delays as thousands of Scots are forced to go private

Daily Mail​

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mail​

Investigation launched into SNP ministers over huge eye operation delays as thousands of Scots are forced to go private

An investigation has been launched into long waiting times for cataract surgery in light of MailOnline's revelations that thousands of hard-pressed Scots are having to go private. The Scottish Liberal Democrats are heaping pressure on SNP ministers after it was revealed 8,500 Scots were forced to raid their savings to pay for basic care last year – more than double those who went private in 2019. Nearly 19,000 people are stuck on NHS waiting lists for the eye op across Scotland – with one patient in NHS Grampian waiting for more than three years. Party leader Alex Cole-Hamilton has now filed more than 20 written questions to the Scottish Government to uncover the reasons behind such long delays. He said: 'I'm pleased to see MailOnline drawing attention to this important issue and piling the pressure on the Scottish Government. Patients having to go private or facing waits of up to three years to be able to see again is simply not on. 'Ministers need to ensure that cataract surgery waits come down and people can get the care they need swiftly. I want these patients to know that I am on their side. These questions are part of an effort to get to the bottom of what is holding back patients from getting the care they need.' Mr Cole-Hamilton has asked about staffing levels, the reasons for waiting times, and what contact Health Secretary Neil Gray has had with NHS boards over the delays. Earlier this month, the party revealed figures showing the true scale of cataract surgery waiting times with NHS Grampian admitted that one person had been on their treatment list for 1,253 days. Delays recorded at other health boards include 869 days in NHS Shetland, 824 days in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, 680 days in NHS Ayrshire and Arran, 644 days in NHS Borders, 548 days in NHS Fife, 532 days in NHS Lanarkshire and 508 days in NHS Highland. In total 18,956 Scots are on a cataract surgery waiting list, with the longest list in NHS Ayrshire and Arran, where 3,207 people have been referred. NHS Fife is second, with 2,440 patients waiting for the surgery. MailOnline's own investigation found 8,500 Scots paid for cataract ops out of their own pocket in 2024, more than double the 4,075 people forced to go private for the surgery in 2019. Grandfather David Samson from Tayport in Fife has been waiting more than 19 months for a cataract operation on his right eye. The 87-year-old was first diagnosed in January 2024 and was originally told he would be treated within 18 weeks. That then became 18 months – and later almost two years. Mr Samson, a former kitchen designer and builder, hopes to finally be seen at Dundee's Ninewells Hospital in October. He said: 'It's not affecting my driving yet but I am anxious about it. My condition is slowly getting worse.' Mr Samson has a relative in England with the same condition who expects to be treated in 16 weeks. He added: 'I am 87. When I'm in my box I want to see where I'm going.' A spokeswoman for NHS Tayside said it hopes to cut surgery waiting lists to 52 weeks by the end of the financial year. Mr Cole-Hamilton added: 'Our NHS is being held back by neglect and mismanagement from SNP ministers. 'The SNP has repeatedly demonstrated that the NHS will never be its priority.' A Scottish Government spokesman said: 'This year, we are investing a record £21.7 billion in health and social care including £106 million to help health boards tackle the longest waits and deliver over 300,000 additional appointments. 'The Scottish Government is clear that no one should face a lengthy wait for important surgery and procedures.'

I nearly died in a freezer... and now I receive strange messages from dead people
I nearly died in a freezer... and now I receive strange messages from dead people

Daily Mail​

time7 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

I nearly died in a freezer... and now I receive strange messages from dead people

A grief counselor from California has revealed how she has been able to see dead people since a childhood accident nearly killed her. Susan Grau, who refers to herself as an intuitive medium, told that she nearly died of hypothermia and lack of oxygen after getting trapped in a home freezer when she was only four years old. While screaming for her life, Grau said she experienced a life-changing vision, where beings of light took her to another dimension, where she heard the prayers of other children. Once she was rescued from the freezer, Grau was left with a startling power, the ability to see and hear beings who had just entered the spirit world. 'I just connected. I would lie in bed and I'd hear, you know, 'Wake up. I just died,'' Grau explained. For years, she kept quiet about her experiences, before finally learning that her ability to communicate with the dead meant she was a medium - someone capable of serving as an intermediary between the physical world and the spirit world. She worked in addiction therapy and grief therapy without revealing her abilities before eventually admitting what she had been seeing in a Facebook message to her family. 'I was highly sensitive and highly attached to people and the spirit world. I feel like I'm half in and half out,' Grau said. Near-death experiences (NDEs) are complex and not fully understood, but scientific research suggests they are likely neurological phenomena arising from specific brain activity during moments of critical illness or near-death. While various theories exist, a key aspect involves the brain's continued activity, even after the heart stops, potentially leading to altered states of consciousness and vivid perceptions. Grau's journey started when some fellow children told her to climb up into her garage freezer for some popsicles, but the freezer had unknowingly been unplugged. 'Because I was so young, I didn't recognize that it wasn't plugged in anymore. My mom had unplugged it. She was supposed to turn it towards the wall, and she didn't,' Grau explained. When she heard the door close behind her, everything changed, and Grau was now in mortal danger of suffocating or freezing to death. 'I heard the garage door thud, and it was silence. And I remember just screaming in terror,' she recounted. What happened next changed Grau's life forever. The medium was screaming for help and trying to free herself from the locked freezer when three bright lights appeared, and she felt herself being pulled out of her physical body. Grau said that she saw a 'light version of herself' in a group of three beings as her spirit left the freezer. The beings told her to stop screaming, and promised to get her mother, which calmed the four-year-old down. Grau recalled seeing a beautiful building with beautiful pillars, a cracked stairway, and a mysterious well in the middle of the room. She also remembered seeing words and hearing prayers that seemed to come from other children, saying: 'I'm going to turn 16. 'Please make my mom and dad get me a car,' and 'God, and my mom is sick. Please don't let her die.' Grau added that she travelled down a beautiful yellow road, which she called the 'yellow brick road' because it was the only way to describe it. She saw people dropping to their knees and saying, 'Dear God, you know, nothing's working the way I want it to. Everything's going wrong. Why don't things go my way?' Then the people vanished. Grau believed it was a message for her to understand later, that 'what you try to control controls you. What you run after chases you.' The medium said she moved through different dimensions, and the angels who rescued her from the freezer told her she had a huge amount to take in during this journey. Grau said she attempted to ascend to the top of a mountain where a beautiful being of light was waiting but she wasn't able to. That's when the being came to her instead. 'The minute I thought, I need to get there, I saw this gorgeous, powerful beam of light come to me. It came to me, and it was love, pure, pure love,' Grau explained. At that point the angel told Grau it was time to go back and that her mother was waiting for her. The light being added that she was going to go through a lot in life, and that Grau was going to help people and she needed to remember the things she learned during her journey to accomplish that task. At the same time, Grau said her mother began hearing a voice quietly saying, 'Your baby's in the freezer.' 'She said, all of a sudden she heard it loud, like a scream, 'Your baby's in the freezer!' And she ran outside, and she said she saw the door closed [in] the garage,' the medium revealed. When Grau was found, her skinned had already turned gray, her fingers were blue, and she fell forward onto the cement as she started to breathe again. That's when her new ability to see spirits manifested. 'I could see things around me. I covered my head and said, 'Go away. Go away. Go away.' And they didn't,' she explained. Grau said she kept seeing the beings all around her, but they were beautiful and they never harmed her, so she quickly stopped being afraid of them. Now a mother, grandmother, author, and inspirational speaker, Grau has continued to work with children who have had near-death experiences, using her skills as a medium to help with her counseling.

Glasgow care home fined after resident found dead in car park
Glasgow care home fined after resident found dead in car park

The National

time7 hours ago

  • The National

Glasgow care home fined after resident found dead in car park

77-year-old Hugh Kearnis was a resident at Chester Park home in Kinning Park, Glasgow, and left the building through a fire escape during the early hours of Boxing Day 2022. According to BBC reports, his body was discovered in the car park six hours later despite staff falsely claiming to have checked on him throughout the night. READ MORE: Man charged after death of Scottish mother more than 30 years ago Owners of the home, Oakminister Healthcare Limited, have now plead guilty to a breach of health and safety and were handed a fine of £53,750. Glasgow Sheriff Court heard that, based on the nature of the guilty plea, the company was not found to have caused Mr Kearin's death. The admission of guilt related to a failure to ensure there was a system in place to confirm the internal fire alarm door was operational. It was stated in court that the company will pay the imposed fine over the next six months. Sheriff Joan Kerr said: "I wish to make it clear that the court recognises that the fine cannot compensate and no fine can be adequate "The court sends its sincere condolences for his loss." The court was told that Mr Kearins had dementia and was considered at risk of "absconding or wandering." A care plan had been implemented requiring staff to check on Mr Kearins every hour. Prosecutor Blair Speed said: "A senior care assistant and a care assistant who had responsibility for his care falsified care records. "They falsely stated that they performed tasks involving Mr Kearins at the time when he was no longer in the care home. "A close observation chart completed by the senior care assistant stated he had checked on Mr Kearins every hour between 2am and 8am. READ MORE: Greenpeace activists arrested as Forth Road Bridge protest ends "Both carers were unaware that he was not in his room until news of his death became known in the home following the discovery of his body in the car park." The carers were later dismissed from their positions and are currently under investigation by the Scottish Social Services Council. It remains unknown which staff member last accessed the internal fire door. Following the incident, the company introduced a new system requiring every exit and entry point to be checked at the end of each shift to ensure alarms are working. An additional alarm has also been installed at the top of the stairs outside Mr Kearins's former room to alert staff if someone enters the area.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store