Mint Primer: Can border fight help settle big vs small screen row?
Last week, India's largest multiplex chain PVR-Inox moved the Bombay High Court against the upcoming Hindi film Bhool Chuk Maaf and producer Maddock Films. What is its complaint and what does it tell us about the troubles of India's cinema owners?
Also Read | Mint Primer | This rice is set to make your meal climate-friendly
What happened to the film Bhool Chuk Maaf?
Maddock Films and Amazon MGM Studios' Hindi comedy Bhool Chuk Maaf was set to hit the theatres on 9 May and advanced bookings were open. But on 8 May, the producers said they will ditch theatres and directly release the film online on Amazon Prime Video. They cited heightened security due to the border tensions between India and Pakistan and solidarity with the 'spirit of the nation'. Several other events were also cancelled last week out of solidarity with the country, including an album launch by actor Kamal Haasan and concerts by singers Arijit Singh and Usha Uthup.
Also Read | Mint Primer | Will IT get better or worse? TCS points to cautious growth ahead
What is PVR-Inox's complaint?
The multiplex chain moved the Bombay High Court on 9 May against Maddock Films, its founder producer Dinesh Vijan, film distributor Pen Marudhar, and Amazon India among others, alleging breach of contract. PVR-Inox argued that its agreement with the makers of Bhool Chuk Maaf included a clause saying the film must run in theatres for at least eight weeks before it was released online on a subscription-based streaming platform. It also said that the makers could not arbitrarily decide not to release the film in theatres due to border tensions because cinemas were open and functioning normally.
Also Read | Mint Primer | India's economy looks strong. What could go wrong?
What is the status of the case?
The court stayed the online release and will hear the case again in June. PVR-Inox has demanded compensation from the film's makers for loss of shows and the money spent on promoting the film. Damages reportedly amount to nearly ₹60 crore. Before moving the court, PVR-Inox had asked Maddock for compensation. But the company refused to do so.
Why is this case important?
Theatre chains have been faced with low footfall and fewer movie releases as people increasingly switch to OTT platforms. PVR- Inox has been demanding that filmmakers run movies in cinemas for eight weeks before releasing them online. Actor-producer Aamir Khan made a similar plea at the government's WAVES summit in May saying a very narrow theatrical window was killing films. This case may decide the debate on a mandatory minimum eight-week theatrical window for films released on the big screen.
So why are filmmakers doing this?
Releasing films in theatres is getting expensive as producers are forced to spend more on film promotion. Besides, ticket and food prices for a multiplex outing are much higher than the cost of an annual subscription to an OTT platform. The current consumer slowdown means viewers increasingly find value in watching films at home. Producers, too, say it is easier and more profitable to simply sell their film to an OTT platform without having to worry about marketing budgets and box office collections.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
14 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Will Kamal Haasan say a simple five-letter word? Or will his politician's hat come in the way?
In the 1994 film Nammavar, an unruly student mob threatens to destroy college infrastructure if the Vice Principal doesn't apologise to a hooligan student. The VP, played by Kamal Haasan, tries to emulate Mark Antony's approach and work his way around apologising without actually expressing regret or saying the word 'Sorry'. However, he finally says the magic word and tells his supporters, "I have no qualms in apologising if the students can study without any worry, and violence and hooliganism can be averted." Who would have thought that 31 years later life would imitate art, with a state's linguistic groups, senior politicians, cinema associations, and High Court asking Kamal Haasan to tender an unconditional apology? That is exactly how events have played out after his speech at the Thug Life event in Chennai became a contentious issue in Karnataka. In the speech, he said, "The language of Kannada was born out of Tamil." And thus was born the controversy that has made headlines. On this occasion though, he has his qualms. This isn't the first time external factors have affected a Kamal Haasan film. Back in 2013, he faced his biggest setback ahead of the release of Vishwaroopam. The film, which was cleared by the censors, didn't get the clearance from the Tamil Nadu government. Voices for a re-censoring and even a ban grew louder among Muslim groups in the state, alleging that Vishwaroopam had scenes that would harm religious sentiments. Kamal Haasan went to court after the district collectors issued orders to the theatre owners not to screen the film, citing a potential law and order fallout. When he organised a press meet and said such situations make him think of leaving the country for good and ply his wares in another country where artistic freedom is respected, scores of people thronged his residence in solidarity. It wasn't just his Tamil fans that turned up that day. It was people in whom his art resonated, and that group isn't restricted to just his fans in Tamil Nadu. Nevertheless, it took almost two weeks of to-and-fro between various stakeholders before the film finally hit the screens in Tamil Nadu after its initial release across the world. Kamal Haasan decided to mute five scenes to accommodate its smooth release. And one of the states that offered him and Vishwaroopam temporary solace was Karnataka, where the film ran for a day before the police advised the theatre owners to take down the film. Nevertheless, Karnataka did give him a day of support and solidarity. But in 2025, that wasn't the case with Thug Life. The state isn't budging, and neither is Kamal Haasan, and the situation is at an impasse. Linguistic politics is a strong issue in both Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, and the situation has reached a place where both cannot pull back their punches. While Kamal Haasan is an actor and a filmmaker par excellence, it is important to note that he is an active politician, who is also on the way to the Rajya Sabha with a ticket given to him by his ally, the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, which is heading the TN government. Can Kamal Haasan backtrack from his statement that Kannada originated from Tamil? Will his apology be construed as acceptance of the argument that both Kannada and Tamil are sister languages? Incidentally, even before the Chennai event where all hell broke loose, Kamal and the Thug Life team were in Bengaluru, where he spoke about his love for Annavaru Dr Rajkumar, the love from his Kannada fans, and how he has lakhs of homes in Karnataka where he is seen as one of their own. But will Karnataka understand its adopted son's steadfast approach? Does Kamal only think of Thug Life or his life after Thug Life? However, the calls for apologies are ringing louder with every passing day. Theatre owners in Karnataka hope things get sorted out because the film has the potential to be a huge pay day for them. At a time when theatres are shutting down, especially the single-screen ones, all it takes is one big financial loss to change things. Kamal Haasan can cut his losses, but can everyone else? Will the director and Thug Life co-producer Mani Ratnam, who made his directorial debut in Kannada with Pallavi Anu Pallavi, be okay with the film not finding its way into Karnataka theatres? Will this become a state vs state issue? Will it be a one-off? Will things become alright after the June 10 hearing? And most importantly, will Kamal Haasan stop sending long-winded press notes, and just say the simple five-letter word? Well, as Sakthivel Nayakkar, the protagonist of Mani Ratnam and Kamal Haasan's seminal film, Nayakan, succinctly said, 'Theriyalaye pa…'
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Janhvi Kapoor stuns in a jacket inspired by mom Sridevi's film: 'Mumma is like an angel fairy princess...'
Janhvi Kapoor paid tribute to her mother, Sridevi, by wearing a custom denim jacket inspired by the film Jagadeka Veerudu Athiloka Sundari. She expressed her admiration for the movie and her mother's performance after rewatching the re-released print. Janhvi is currently enjoying a successful phase in her career with several upcoming projects, including Devara: Part 1 and Param Sundari. Janhvi Kapoor recently took to social media to pay a heartfelt tribute to her legendary mother, Sridevi , blending nostalgia and style in a unique way. By wearing a custom denim jacket inspired by Sridevi's iconic film Jagadeka Veerudu Athiloka Sundari, Janhvi not only honoured her mother's cinematic legacy but also shared her deep emotional connection to the beloved cult classic. In her Instagram post, Janhvi expressed deep admiration not only for the jacket but also for the film itself, which holds a cherished place in her heart. Check out the post here: She captioned, 'Obsessed with this jacket!!!! Obsessssssssed with this movie!!!! I had the pleasure of rewatching the rereleased print a couple days back and was reminded of the magic created by the whole team," she wrote. Recalling her mother's ethereal screen presence, she added, 'Mumma is like an angel fairy princess and so funny and so cute. Chiranjeevi Konidela sir and his inimitable humour, bravado and swagger and both of them together Raghavendra sirs vision Amrish Puri sir the music, sets, costumes, story!!! All the actors!!!!!" she continued. Janhvi also lauded the team behind the film's revival, saying, 'The revival of this new print couldn't have been executed by more able hands and is a gift to cinema lovers today, it felt like a visual spectacle that would give our contemporary films a run for their money'. The cult classic Jagadeka Veerudu Athiloka Sundari was recently re-released in theaters, giving Janhvi the special chance to relive her mother's iconic performance on the big screen. On the professional front, Janhvi Kapoor is enjoying a successful phase. She was most recently seen in Devara: Part 1 alongside Jr NTR and has a packed slate of upcoming projects. Her next films include Param Sundari with Sidharth Malhotra , Homebound featuring Ishaan Khatter and Vishal Jethwa, Sunny Sanskari Ki Tulsi Kumari with Varun Dhawan , and Peddi starring Ram Charan. Check out our list of the latest Hindi , English , Tamil , Telugu , Malayalam , and Kannada movies . Don't miss our picks for the best Hindi movies , best Tamil movies, and best Telugu films .
NDTV
20 minutes ago
- NDTV
Exclusive: Amid Kannada Language Row, Kamal Haasan's "No Apology Over Gunpoint"
Chennai: A day ahead of the pan-India release of his much-anticipated film 'Thug Life', actor and politician Kamal Haasan addressed the media but refrained from revisiting the controversy over his recent remarks about the Kannada language. The film will release across India and globally on Friday - except in Karnataka. Mr Haasan, who has been under fire for saying Kannada was born out of Tamil, earlier made it clear he has no intention to apologise or withdraw his remarks. "There can be no demand for an apology in a gunpoint situation," a person in the know of these developments told NDTV, alluding to pressure from fringe groups and political outfits. Mr Haasan told reporters he would speak at length later, as "a Tamil who wants to speak a lot." On Tuesday, he said his comments were made purely out of affection for the late Kannada actor Rajkumar and his family, and denied any malice toward Karnataka or the Kannada language. Amid strong observations from the Karnataka High Court, the actor, who approached the court seeking protection for the release of the film, later said he would not release the film in Karnataka. When asked the idea behind this, the person added, "There could be a sense of fear; audiences may avoid theatres. A Karnataka release will happen only in a conducive atmosphere." This suggested Mr Haasan is prepared to forgo revenue. Another lamented how freedom of expression often becomes the first casualty during such controversies. "Fringe groups tend to have their way threatening to trigger law and order problems. In a democracy, there should be conversations even amid disagreements," the source said. Support came from the ruling DMK, which had also backed Mr Haasan for his nomination to Rajya Sabha. KN Nehru said there was nothing wrong in what Mr Haasan commented. "Tamil is the root of south Indian languages like Kannada, Telugu and Malayalam. What he said is correct and historically factual."
