Brazil Supreme Court shields citizens from foreign legal decisions
WHY IT'S IMPORTANT
The ruling responds to a request from Brazilian mining lobby Ibram related to Brazilian cities initiating lawsuits abroad over compensation claims for mining accidents, such as the dam collapses in Mariana in 2015 and Brumadinho in 2019.
The decision could have broader impacts, too. It comes after the U.S. imposed sanctions against Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who oversees the trial of former President Jair Bolsonaro. The U.S. accused the judge of authorizing arbitrary pre-trial detentions and suppressing freedom of expression.
CONTEXT
Bolsonaro, an ally of U.S. President Donald Trump, is on trial for allegedly plotting to overturn the 2022 election. Trump's administration imposed levies on imports from Brazil largely in response to the prosecution of Bolsonaro that he has called a 'witch hunt.'
KEY QUOTE
Justice Dino 'suspended the effectiveness of judicial decisions, laws, decrees, and executive orders of foreign states in our country that have not been incorporated or obtained the assent of the sovereign bodies under Brazil's Constitution and laws,' the court said in a statement.
'The decision applies to this specific case, which involves compensation claims related to the environmental accidents in Mariana and Brumadinho, Minas Gerais, but the judge's arguments apply to all similar cases,' it added.
WHAT'S NEXT
The ruling may prompt further legal and diplomatic discussions regarding Brazil's dispute with the U.S. over tariffs.
The U.S. State Department's Bureau of Western Hemisphere Affairs said later in the day on social media that 'no foreign court can invalidate United States sanctions — or spare anyone from the steep consequences of violating them.' It also said U.S. citizens are prohibited from transacting with Moraes, and citizens elsewhere should 'tread carefully.' - Reuters
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
14 minutes ago
- The Star
Exclusive-Brazil judge targeted by US sanctions confident of Trump reversal
Brazil's Supreme Court Judge Alexandre de Moraes looks on during a session of the Supreme Court in Brasilia, Brazil, August 19, 2025. REUTERS/Adriano Machado BRASILIA (Reuters) -The judge at the center of escalating tensions between Brazil and the United States told Reuters he is counting on a change of heart from President Donald Trump to unwind sanctions against him, which he said lack consensus within the U.S. government. Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes has ratcheted up restraining orders against former President Jair Bolsonaro during his trial for an alleged 2022 coup plot. Trump demanded an end to the case that he calls a "witch hunt" as he slapped a 50% tariff on Brazilian goods and hit Moraes with financial sanctions that are putting Brazil's banks on edge. Despite fears of a spiraling crisis for bilateral relations, the judge expressed confidence in a late Tuesday interview at his Brasilia office that sanctions would be unwound against him via diplomatic channels or an eventual challenge in U.S. courts. "A judicial challenge is possible and I have not yet found a U.S. or Brazilian lawyer or scholar who doubts the courts would overturn. But at this moment, I've chosen to wait. That's my choice. It's a diplomatic matter for the country," said Moraes. The standoff with Trump is the highest-profile test yet for the 56-year-old jurist, whose bald visage and muscular frame have come to define the Brazilian high court he joined eight years ago. He has taken the lead on many of the court's most prominent cases, cowing Elon Musk in a showdown over his social media platform, sending hundreds of right-wing rioters in the capital to prison and barring Bolsonaro from running for office. Navigating the U.S. crackdown on his personal finances and bilateral trade with Brazil has done little to change his routine, he said, which includes boxing, martial arts and a new favorite book: Henry Kissinger's "Leadership," the late U.S. diplomat's final volume on 20th century statecraft. Moraes said he trusts diplomacy will restore his standing in Washington. He said prosecutors blamed the current fallout on a campaign by allies of Bolsonaro, including the former president's lawmaker son Eduardo, who is in the U.S. and under investigation in Brazil for courting Trump's intervention in his father's case. "Once the correct information has been passed along, as is being done now, and the documented information reaches the U.S. authorities, I believe it won't even require any legal action to reverse (the sanctions). I believe that the U.S. executive branch itself, the president, will reverse them," Moraes said. Pressed on the reason for that confidence, Moraes said he was aware of internal divisions in the U.S. government that had slowed the sanctions and could still undermine them. "There was reluctance in the State Department and great reluctance in the Treasury Department," he said, without elaborating or explaining how he received that information. A State Department official with knowledge of the matter told Reuters separately that the sanctions against Moraes had faced substantial pushback from career officials. The actions against Moraes were "completely, legally inappropriate," said the source on condition of anonymity, adding that officials from the Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control had initially said no but were overruled. A Treasury spokesperson said: "The Treasury Department and Office of Foreign Assets Control, along with the entire Trump administration, is in lockstep that Alexandre de Moraes has engaged in serious human rights abuse. Rather than concocting a fantasy fiction, de Moraes should stop carrying out arbitrary detentions and politicized prosecutions." The U.S. State Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Brazilian courts could punish Brazilian financial institutions for seizing or blocking domestic assets in response to U.S. orders, Moraes also said in the interview. (Reporting by Brad Haynes and Ricardo Brito in BrasiliaAdditional reporting by Gabriel Stargardter and David LawderEditing by Rosalba O'Brien)
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
Brazil's Lula extends comeback as approval ticks up
SAO PAULO (Reuters) -Support for Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva's government continued to rebound in August, extending a recovery from a low point earlier in the year, a poll showed Wednesday. According to the survey by Genial/Quaest, approval for Lula's administration rose to 46%, up from 43% in July and 40% in May. Correspondingly, the government's disapproval rate fell to 51% from 53% last month and 57% in May, the highest-ever disapproval in Lula's three non-consecutive terms in office. The Genial/Quaest poll surveyed 2,004 eligible voters in person from August 13 to August 17. The poll has a margin of error of plus or minus two percentage points. (Reporting by Andre Romani and Alexandre Caverni in Sao Paulo; Editing by Kylie Madry)
Malaysiakini
8 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
DAP MP counters ex-CJ: Karpal's legacy lives on in many politicians
DAP lawmaker RSN Rayer emphasised that while he holds former chief justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat in the highest regard, he respectfully disagrees with her sweeping claim that politicians are the greatest threat to the Constitution. Citing DAP chairperson Karpal Singh, whom he hailed as the 'fiercest defender of the Federal Constitution until his last breath', the Jelutong MP said there are many other politicians who embody the same commitment.
