logo
SC dropped probe on Allahabad HC judge Shekhar Kumar Yadav after Rajya Sabha alert

SC dropped probe on Allahabad HC judge Shekhar Kumar Yadav after Rajya Sabha alert

Hindustan Times7 hours ago

The Supreme Court was preparing to initiate an in-house inquiry into Allahabad high court judge Shekhar Kumar Yadav's controversial speech at a VHP event last year, but dropped the plan after receiving a categorical letter from the Rajya Sabha secretariat that asserted exclusive jurisdiction over the matter, people aware of the matter said.
The people cited above confirmed that then Chief Justice of India (CJI) Sanjiv Khanna had set the process in motion to assess whether the judge's conduct warranted scrutiny in the wake of an adverse report from the Allahabad High Court chief justice. However, the move was halted after the Rajya Sabha secretariat's letter in March underlined that the constitutional mandate for any such proceeding lies solely with the chairman of the Rajya Sabha, and ultimately with Parliament and the President.
This letter effectively stalled the judiciary's plan to initiate an in-house inquiry – an internal mechanism laid down through judicial precedents to examine complaints of misconduct against sitting judges of the superior judiciary, against Justice Yadav, whose comments at the VHP's December 8, 2024, event in Prayagraj drew widespread condemnation for violating the principles of secularism and judicial impartiality.
HT reached out to the Rajya secretariat for a response on the next course of action but did not get one immediately.
In February, Rajya Sabha chairman and vice president Jagdeep Dhankhar said that only Parliament and President have the jurisdiction over the matter
'The jurisdiction for the stated subject matter constitutionally lies in exclusivity with the chairman Rajya Sabha and in an eventuality with the Parliament and honourable President. Taking note of public domain information and inputs available, it is expedient that the Secretary General, Rajya Sabha shares this information with the Secretary General, Supreme Court of India,' he said in Parliament on February 13.
Justice Yadav, addressing a gathering organised by the legal cell of the VHP within the Allahabad High Court Bar Association premises, made a series of incendiary statements that targeted the Muslim community and invoked majoritarian themes.
In his speech, he reportedly asserted that 'India should function according to the wishes of the majority,' claimed 'only a Hindu can make this country a 'Vishwa Guru',' and linked practices such as triple talaq and halala to societal backwardness, calling for their abolition under the proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC). Video clips of the speech, which went viral on social media, show him allegedly using derogatory communal slurs.His remarks framed the UCC as a Hindu-Muslim binary, stating that while Hindu customs had evolved to address historical wrongs, Muslims had resisted reform.
The speech triggered outrage among political leaders, jurists and civil society, with senior advocate Kapil Sibal leading a group of 55 opposition MPs in filing a notice in the Rajya Sabha seeking Justice Yadav's impeachment for 'grave violation of judicial ethics.' The Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms (CJAR) also demanded an in-house inquiry and his immediate suspension, citing a clear breach of the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life adopted by the Supreme Court in 1997.
Amid mounting criticism, the Supreme Court swiftly sought a report from the Allahabad High Court chief justice on December 10, 2024. A week later, on December 17, the apex court collegium, comprising CJI Khanna and Justices Bhushan R Gavai, Surya Kant, Hrishikesh Roy and Abhay S Oka, summoned Justice Yadav for a 30-minute closed-door meeting to ascertain whether his public comments violated the Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct or judicial ethics outlined in internal codes.
While Justice Yadav reportedly assured the collegium judges he would apologise publicly, he failed to do so in the weeks that followed. Instead, in a January 2025 letter to the chief justice of the Allahabad High Court, the judge doubled down on his remarks, claiming they had been misrepresented by vested interests and asserting that his speech reflected societal concerns 'consistent with constitutional values.' Appointed in 2019, Justice Yadav is set to retire on April 15, 2026.
People cited above said that CJI Khanna subsequently sought a fresh report from the Allahabad High Court chief justice, referring to additional complaints against Justice Yadav from a law student and a retired IPS officer. But by then, an unexpected development complicated matters.
In March 2025, the Supreme Court administration received a formal communication from the Rajya Sabha secretariat, informing it that the matter of Justice Yadav's conduct, arising out of the December 13 impeachment motion signed by 55 MPs, was already under active consideration.
'The court's secretary general brought the letter to the notice of the then CJI, who was clear that an in-house inquiry, being a non-statutory and internal mechanism, should not run parallel to a statutory process under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968,' a person familiar with the matter told HT. 'The Rajya Sabha's categorical assertion that it was seized of the matter prompted the judiciary to defer to the parliamentary process,' this person added.
The Judges (Inquiry) Act mandates that a motion seeking removal of a High Court or Supreme Court judge for 'proved misbehaviour or incapacity' must be admitted by the presiding officer of the House concerned. To be sure, the Vice President and Rajya Sabha chairman, Jagdeep Dhankhar, has yet to decide on the admissibility of the motion and whether to constitute a formal inquiry committee.
'The idea was not to create constitutional friction or undermine parliamentary privilege…That's the sole reason why no in-house probe was set up despite the initial steps,' the person cited above added.
Another person aware of the deliberations within the collegium said that all members were informed of the decision to halt the in-house inquiry after the receipt of the Rajya Sabha's letter. 'There was a kind of consensus that the matter, being under legislative scrutiny, should not be clouded by a simultaneous judicial process,' the person said.
Opposition lawmakers, meanwhile, continue to push for clarity on the status of the impeachment motion. Speaking to HT on condition of anonymity, a senior MP said last month that his party planned to raise the matter during the monsoon session. 'During the budget session, the chairman had said that he was assessing the veracity of the signatures on the notice. We would like to know the status of that notice too...the notices have been given in both the Houses and it is imperative it should be taken up,' the lawmaker said.
In his formal reply to the complaints, Justice Yadav reportedly maintained in January that he has done no wrong. He described his speech as an articulation of issues affecting society and claimed that his references were misconstrued. On the criticism of his previous judicial orders related to cow protection, he is said to have responded that these reflected India's cultural ethos and legal recognition of cow protection, not any form of judicial bias.
Notably, Justice Yadav did not tender an apology in his correspondence, reinforcing his stance that his speech was neither communal nor violative of judicial conduct. He rather asserted that judges, who often face unfair attacks, deserve protection and support from senior members of the judiciary.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

AAP leaders visit Madrasi Camp to support residents
AAP leaders visit Madrasi Camp to support residents

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

AAP leaders visit Madrasi Camp to support residents

NEW DELHI: AAP leader and Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Singh along with the AAP Delhi state president Saurabh Bharadwaj, visited Madrasi Camp in Jangpura on Sunday to support affected residents. Singh has written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, urging an immediate halt to the eviction drive in Delhi's jhuggi clusters and proper rehabilitation for displaced families. He stated that families living in Madrasi Camp for over five decades are being forcibly displaced in the name of development, despite earlier BJP promises of housing under the slogan 'Jahan jhuggi, wahan makan'. 'Bulldozers rolled into Madrasi Camp without notice. Women, children, and the elderly were forced to run for safety and left with nothing. No arrangements were made for relocation, no rehabilitation, no humanity,' added the AAP MP. He said that residents have valid documents, including Aadhaar and voter IDs, and their livelihoods, schools, and community ties are based there. He criticised the alternative housing in far-off Narela as unviable. Singh demanded an immediate stop to all demolitions and called for on-site rehabilitation.

Chenab Bridge is a ‘mile sur mera tumhara' moment. Now Bollywood should return to Kashmir
Chenab Bridge is a ‘mile sur mera tumhara' moment. Now Bollywood should return to Kashmir

The Print

timean hour ago

  • The Print

Chenab Bridge is a ‘mile sur mera tumhara' moment. Now Bollywood should return to Kashmir

He has promised our Kashmiri brothers and sisters a vision of a Kashmir free of terrorism, a 'location for shooting films and a hub of sports'. Due to the neglect by political parties pushing their own agenda, the people of Jammu and Kashmir had stopped dreaming and had accepted terrorism as their fate. With certain vested interests in cahoots with Pakistan, terrorism had been perpetrated in the snow-covered slopes of Kashmir. PM Modi and home minister Amit Shah have stood firm and tall in the face of opposition and taunts. Today, their commitment to the region stands vindicated in the form of the structural marvel of the Chenab Bridge, soaring 359 metres above the riverbed. This week brought a new bridge to the divine valley of Shiva and Parvati, as Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the world's highest rail bridge, a wonder of sorts. Jammu and Kashmir's development and the aspirations of its youth will not be shaken by the Pahalgam terror attack, he said. All eyes are truly on Reasi now, which, exactly a year ago on 9 June, was the scene of a dastardly terror attack on Hindu pilgrims by the TRF—the very perpetrators of the Pahalgam attack. PM Modi has given a befitting reply to Pakistan-sponsored terrorism by inaugurating the highest rail bridge in the world. Bridge to peace The Kashmir Valley has remained mostly cut off from the rest of the country due to the obsolete Article 370, as well as physical barriers. The Chenab Bridge has forged a connection, the missing link on the Jammu–Baramullah train route, which in turn connects the Valley with the rest of India. After 1947, the Valley saw periods of alternating peace and turmoil until 1989, when it spiralled into a vortex of Pakistan–sponsored terrorism, after targeted killings of Hindus by militant groups such as the Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front. This led to a mass exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from the region. Prior to this period, the Kashmir Valley saw a period of peace, when it was the favoured location for Yash Chopra—my favourite director—who filmed iconic scenes from classics like Daag and Silsila. Who can forget Shammi Kapoor's song, Yahoo Chahe Mujhe Koi Junglee Kahen? Today, the breathtaking Baisaran Valley has gained infamy due to the tragic terror attack, but it once formed the backdrop against which Shammi Kapoor and Sharmila Tagore romanced in the 1964 hit Kashmir ki Kali. It was also the setting for Arzoo and Jab Jab Phool Khile. In the 1970s, iconic hits such as Kabhi Kabhie and Roti had scenes that were shot in the valley. And who can forget the musical Neela Aasman So Gaya? After 1990, a period of insurgency restricted access to the Valley, and only a handful of films were shot well up to the early 2000s, including Roja and Mission Kashmir. These blockbusters had the Kashmir unrest and insurgency as the primary theme. Even in relatively recent films such as Haider and The Kashmir Files, the focus has been on the post-1990 suffering of the Kashmir Valley. The hope is that the Chenab Bridge and the Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla rail link will bring Bollywood and other film industries back to the Valley. The film–tourism synergy is substantial, and Kashmir's annual tourism industry is worth Rs 12,000 crore. Also read: Srinagar train reminds us Kashmir was secured by iron and rock, that's how soldiers moved in Bridge to national integration The Chenab Bridge is a prime example of India's unity. There was no North-South, Hindu-Muslim divide at play during the execution of the iconic structure. The entire country worked as one for its construction and execution. Rock engineering specialist G Madhavi Latha, a professor at IISc, Bengaluru, spent 17 years working on the stability of the foundation. Her team used a 'design as you go' approach—the terrain was so complex and challenging that the team had to keep modifying calculations and the design was continuously evolving. IIT Delhi professor KJ Rao was a project consultant, and IISc professor TG Sitharam was the geotechnical consultant during 2005-2020. 'The Chenab Bridge is more than a technical achievement — it is a story of human endeavour, of teamwork, of innovation under pressure, and above all, of patriotic purpose,' Sitharam wrote. His words echo the pride of all Indians. Researchers and engineers like Sitharam across the country take pride in this monument to India's technical talent. The steel used in the columns was manufactured by engineers from Steel Authority of India Limited in their plant in Bhilai, including 5,922 tonnes of TMT Steel, 6,454 tonnes of plates and 56 tonnes of structural steel. The remaining steel was brought in from SAIL's Bokaro, Rourkala, and Durgapur plants. Afcons Infrastructure Limited, headquartered in Mumbai, was the contractor for the construction. The project provided employment to over 1,000 Reasi locals. And while the area comes under Northern Railways, the branch was only pleased to partner with Konkan Railways, given the latter's expertise in railroad construction in difficult terrain. Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) provided inputs to make the bridge blast-proof. We can safely state that the Chenab Bridge is a mile sur mera tumhara moment in Indian history. Bridge to self-governance I have been told by friends and acquaintances in the Valley that the Governor's rule ensured a period of peace and stability in Kashmir. However, conducting free and fair elections is one of the main pillars of democracy. And the BJP government fulfilled its commitment to democracy by ensuring that elections were peacefully held for 90 Legislative Assembly seats in 2024. The INDIA bloc won 49 seats, leading to Kashmir's first elected government after the abrogation of Article 370, which paved the way for self–governance for the Kashmiri people. Critics of the BJP's handling of Kashmir may read my piece, which appeared in ThePrint on 14 October 2024. Omar Abdullah was elected CM in a peaceful election process that saw a whopping 63.8 per cent turnout. 'Many people dreamt of this train service. What the British could not do, you [PM Modi] got it completed, and Kashmir Valley has now been connected with the rest of the country,' CM Abdullah said during the inauguration ceremony. The bridge will now serve as a gateway for the process of self-governance for the Kashmiri people, with Panchayat elections on the anvil as the electoral rolls have been updated in January. Also read: 'Modi made our dream honeymoon possible'—couple on board the Srinagar Vande Bharat Bridge to prosperity On the day of the Pahalgam terror attack, there was an unprecedented footfall of tourists in Kashmir. Tourism had surged in recent years, peaking at 3.5 million in 2024, and in 2025, was expected to breach that number by the end of the summer holidays. The Chenab Bridge is predicted to boost tourism in the region, as the rail link from Srinagar to Jammu will connect onward to New Delhi and provide a more economical travel option for tourists. Apple growers are also likely to benefit. Over 75 per cent of the country's apple production comes from the Valley, which also accounts for 8 per cent of Kashmir's GDP. 'Poor connectivity has negatively impacted the economic development of 70 percent of the Valley's population, which is dependent on farming and perishable fruit cultivation,' read the article by Ayjaz Wani in ORF's 'Expert Speak'. Beyond apples and plums, all–weather rail connectivity and access to rail cargo services will provide access to newer markets for Kashmiri almonds, walnuts, saffron, cherries, and other fruit. The Chenab Bridge will serve as much more than a connection between two banks of the Chenab River. It will become the lifeline to the Kashmiri economy, linking the once–isolated Valley to the rest of the country. The bridge and the rail link provides a physical manifestation of what every Indian lived by—Kashmir is an integral part of India, and it won't be left behind on the highway to Viksit Bharat 2047. Our Kashmiri brethren will walk into a new dawn of development and prosperity, unlike their neighbours in the Pakistan-occupied part of Kashmir. Bridge of technology India supplies the world with STEM talent. Why should this technical talent not be used for the advancement of our national interest? The Chenab Bridge is 35 times the height of the Eiffel Tower and 1,315 m long, with an imposing steel arch span of 467 m. Designed to withstand zone V earthquakes and wind speeds of 256 km/hr, it straddles a seismologically rugged Himalayan terrain in the comparatively young mountains of the Pir Panjal Range and is connected with two steel pylons. The bridge has a lifespan of 120 years and can support a train speed of up to 100 km/hr. This technological marvel is capable of withstanding high-intensity explosions equivalent to 40 tonnes of TNT and extreme temperatures down to -20 degrees Celsius. Also read: Anubrata Mondal threatened a police officer & may go scot-free. It's a blot on TMC Bridge of gender equality Symbolically, the Chenab Bridge is also a bridge to gender equality in India. The presence of women in leadership roles, such as G Madhavi Latha, challenged stereotypes and inspired a generation of young women to pursue careers in STEM. Latha has been a trailblazer her entire life. 'At a particular slope cutting, I remember spending sleepless nights as my inputs were required at every stage,' she said while sharing the challenges her team faced in executing the project. The Jammu–Srinagar travel time has been reduced to around three hours, and the Vande Bharat trains are a safe and convenient way to travel. Thus, the bridge is critical for the autonomy and mobility of women in the region. Even critics like Iltija Mufti have admitted that the bridge is a 'welcome step'. The photo of PM Modi holding the Tricolour and marching confidently on the bridge showcases India's resolve and resilience: Nothing can deter us from achieving our goals of prosperity and peaceful coexistence. Like the steel used in the construction of the Chenab Bridge, Indians have forged a new future that is different from the traps set for us. Our stellar resolve will take us forward. This grateful citizen thanks all the researchers, engineers, workers, and agencies involved in the execution of this project, but most of all, our honourable prime minister, who helped bring it to fruition despite the many challenges. Meenakashi Lekhi is a BJP leader, lawyer and social activist. Her X handle is @M_Lekhi. Views are personal. (Edited by Prasanna Bachchhav)

After MP's ‘demand', Pune's Sarasbaug Garden closed by civic body
After MP's ‘demand', Pune's Sarasbaug Garden closed by civic body

Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • Indian Express

After MP's ‘demand', Pune's Sarasbaug Garden closed by civic body

The Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) on Sunday kept the famous Sarasbaug garden in the heart of the city closed for the day, allegedly on the demand of BJP Rajya Sabha MP Medha Kulkarni, who cited that Bakri Eid celebrations in the garden would disturb the sanctity of a historical temple in the centre of garden. The PMC administration had closed the gate of Sarasbaug garden with a board on display saying the garden was closed for the day and eating food was not allowed here. The civic administration did not respond to calls seeking reasons for the garden's closure. In a communication to PMC on June 6, BJP Rajya Sabha MP Kulkarni said, 'There is a Peshwa-era Ganesh temple in Sarasbaug and is a place of worship for lakhs of Hindu people. The garden is situated around the temple. It has been observed that people of Muslim community turn up in large numbers in Sarasbaug Garden and consume meat by violating garden rules. This hurts sentiments of Hindu community.' Various Hindu organisations have become aggressive towards the consumption of meat in the garden, she said, adding that they too had decided to hold a social event at Sarasbaug on June 8. 'There is a possibility of communal tension between the two communities if they come face to face. There seem to be truth in complaint by Hindu organisations as many people of the Muslim community come together and consume meat, which is spoiling the sanctity of temple. This can't be tolerated,' said Kulkarni. The BJP MP said, 'The PMC should keep the garden closed on Sunday and only allow temple visitors through the gate. This should be done to avoid any untoward incident that would disturb the peace. However, the temple should be kept open for the Hindu community.' Activist Anwar Sheikh has sought an explanation from the PMC on the exact reason why Sarasbaug Garden was closed. 'The decision to close Sarasbaug on the demand of an MP has violated the rights of the Muslim community. The PMC's decision to close the garden on the occasion of Bakri Eid is against the fundamental right of people of the Muslim community. If the people of the muslim community are paying tax to the PMC, then they have the right to use public spaces like gardens and parks. Keeping them out due to the demand of an MP goes against the values of democracy,' he said. He said that Muslims take their families to the garden the day after Eid to celebrate, but this year, Sarasbaug Garden was kept closed without giving any reason. Sheikh has urged the PMC to not take such decisions in future to avoid hurting feelings of any religious community, protect the rights of Muslims and not to fall prey to the pressure of elected representatives. 'The incident is sending a message that it was done to target only people of one community,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store