logo
Evidence yet to back up claimed benefits of cold water therapy

Evidence yet to back up claimed benefits of cold water therapy

Every week in the UK, thousands of mostly middle-aged women take the plunge into freezing cold seawater.
Members of the "Bluetits Chill Swimmers" say the initiative has drastically improved their lives, but the jury is still out on the benefits of cold water immersion (CWI).
From ice baths to cold showers, the claimed benefits of CWI are prolific; a strengthened immune system, anti-inflammatory effects, mood boosts and improved sleep, among others.
But experts say there is more evidence for the harmful nature of CWI than its benefits — the nature of which remains "speculative" and "anecdotal".
Claims made lack quality evidence, research
In a paper published earlier this year, a group of researchers from the University of South Australia sought to answer the question of whether science supports the cold water fad.
Given that the benefits of CWI are increasingly marketed to the public, they looked for studies on the general population (rather than elite athletes).
Photo shows
A stylised graphic with three silhouettes of unidentified a female footballer, tennis player, basketballer
ABC Sport and Deakin University have partnered to produce the first ABC Elite Athletes in Australian Women's Sport Survey.
They found just 11 papers considered "quality" enough to include, with a range of conflicting findings.
Researchers were unable to find any evidence of mood improvements, but some evidence for decreased stress levels (albeit only 12 hours after CWI).
They likewise failed to find any evidence of a positive impact on immune function.
But in a quirky finding, one of the 11 studies concluded that those who underwent CWI had a 29 per cent reduction in sickness absence. There was a twist, however: while this group took less leave from work, they reported being ill for the same number of days as other participants.
Tara Cain, a research assistant and lead author on the project, admits this is difficult to interpret.
"It could be that they had better resilience or willingness to push through, just based on their involvement in the trial," she said.
Four-time Formula 1 world champion Max Verstappen in an ice bath.
(
Mark Thompson: Getty Images
)
"We don't want being part of a study to affect how people act in their general life, but they could have wanted to make the effort to keep going to work, even if they were sick."
The research team also found some evidence of improvements to sleep quality when CWI was combined with heat training, as well as self-reported quality of life measures, but Ms Cain cautions against drawing too much from their analysis.
There was no consensus among the papers, for example, on the method of CWI (e.g. ice baths vs cold showers), duration of CWI or cold water temperature, while only one study included female participants.
"I think the overarching message from this study is that there's such limited evidence out there that needs to be explored more to apply to the general population," Ms Cain said.
"Most of the information that's out there on social media is word of mouth, and anecdotal evidence.
"
A lot of [beneficial] claims made don't have that evidence-based research.
"
Just one 'proven' positive impact of cold water immersion
Mike Tipton, a cold water expert from the University of Portsmouth in the UK, agrees there is little evidence to support the "positive" impacts of CWI.
In fact, Professor Tipton is comfortable claiming just one "evidence-based" benefit of CWI: "perceived mental health benefits", as illustrated in the example of the Bluetits.
The Bluetits Chill Swimmers are a popular group in the UK.
(
Supplied: Bluetits Chill Swimmers
)
"I've had some of the Bluetits ladies come up to me in tears telling me how this has changed their life, how they used to have mental health problems and don't have them anymore," he said.
"The problem with that is that the evidence is anecdotal. Anecdotal evidence is still evidence, but it's the weakest form.
"It's fine if that's what they want to do: I'm definitely not the fun police … but I want to make sure that I give them information to make sure they can do it as safely as possible.
"And as a scientist, I want to understand: what is the mechanism [that produces the effect]?"
Unfortunately, Professor Tipton says, there is much more evidence for how dangerous CWI is (than how beneficial).
As he explains it, human beings are "tropical" animals who ideally want to exist naked, in 26-28 degree air.
Taking that animal and plunging it into cold water (which he defines as 15 degrees Celsius or lower) induces a state of physiological stress termed "cold water shock".
A lot of evidence around cold water immersion is anecdotal.
(
Costfoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images
)
At worst, cold water shock is a precursor to drowning and cardiac arrest. As a standard occurrence, it will produce an acute inflammatory response.
"The body responds with a 'fight or flight' response driven by the sympathetic nervous system … [because] as far as it's concerned, it's under attack," Professor Tipton said.
'Habituation' to cold water could help with other stressors
As dangerous as cold water shock can be, it's also what might drive the potential "benefits" of CWI.
Repeated exposure to cold water, Professor Tipton explains, might "habituate" the body to this type of inflammatory stress response, with potential future benefits.
"Habituation is a decreased response to repeated stimuli… and a reduction in the alerting response that you get," he said.
Most people will have their "worst" reaction to an ice bath the second time they try it — because they're well aware of how cold it's going to be.
England footballers Alessia Russo and Lucy Bronze in an ice bath.
(
The FA via Getty: Naomi Baker
)
"After that, their 'stress' response will start to decline to the point where it's generally halved with about six three-minute immersions," Professor Tipton said.
Theoretically, he adds, CWI could be beneficial if the body learns to adapt this habituation response to other types of stress.
"At a cellular level, it may make you more resilient to stressors that evoke those kinds of responses," he said.
At present, however, he can point to only one study that lends weight to this theory.
His team conducted an experiment where they looked at people's responses to training at altitude.
They split participants into two groups, with both exercising in an altitude chamber. One group then did repeated warm water immersions, and the other did cold water immersions.
The cold water group performed much better in the second altitude training session than the warm water group.
Participants in Toronto's "Polar Bear Dip" where the water temperature is about 3 degrees Celsius.
(
Julia Cherkasova: Getty Images
)
"So the hypothesis is that the benefit that comes from cold water immersion is that physiologically you can habituate to stress. You become less responsive to those stressors, and maybe that generalises to other stressors."
As promising as the "habituation" theory may be, Professor Tipton warns that the evidence base is still largely "speculative".
Effects of cold water immersion could be 'placebo'
It's also possible that CWI could be subject to placebo effects.
Professor Tipton references a study from 2023 that looked at whether athletes who underwent CWI after a soccer match would see improvements in their recovery outcomes.
The athletes were split into three groups. One group underwent CWI, one group simply rested, and one was given a placebo: a drink they were told had been shown to reduce inflammation and improve muscle recovery.
Both the CWI
and
placebo groups showed improvements in recovery over the "rest" group, suggesting CWI may be no better than placebo (but still produces an effect).
According to Professor Tipton, the question of whether CWI is better than other forms of "active" recovery (such as walking, or yoga) is also unanswered.
As he puts it, this is the problem with most claims on the "benefits" of CWI: we still don't understand the "mechanism" behind its positive effects.
Going back to the anecdotal claims of the Bluetits Chill Swimmers, Professor Tipton argues there are many beneficial factors at play:
"Nobody has really done properly controlled studies to isolate the active ingredient in the experience of going for a dip… is [the benefit] coming from green therapy, blue therapy, exercise, meeting people, having cake and coffee, or all and any of those?"

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Isn't a great look': Boss makes wild demand after worker breaks leg
‘Isn't a great look': Boss makes wild demand after worker breaks leg

News.com.au

time8 hours ago

  • News.com.au

‘Isn't a great look': Boss makes wild demand after worker breaks leg

A leaked text message exchange has revealed the wild request a boss made to an employee after they'd suffered a serious injury. UK workplace expert Ben Askins has found his sweet spot online by sharing anonymous text message exchanges between workers and their managers and then offering advice. It started out innocently enough: a boss texted a worker to find out why they couldn't attend their shift the next day. 'I broke my leg coming off my bike. I am in hospital at the moment,' the worker said. The boss replied, 'S**t, I'm really sorry to hear that!' This was a solid start ... but things quickly took a turn. 'When do you think you will be back?' The boss asked. The worker replied and said they weren't sure when they'd be back because they needed to be on bed rest for a few days before trying out walking on crutches. 'Ideally I need you in for the Friday shift. Do you think you can make it? I can get you a chair,' the boss texted back. 'If the doctor says it is all good. Then yep no worries,' the worker replied. 'They are always overly cautious. I kind of just need you to commit too it,' the boss pressured. 'Like I said if the doctor is happy I will do it. But if they say no, I can't,' the worker wrote back. The boss then doubled down and claimed it 'isn't a great look' for the worker to take time off because they'd only started working at the company two weeks ago. 'Then let me make it even easier for you. I quit,' the worker replied. Mr Askins said that the worker's actions were 'fair enough' considering how unreasonable the boss was being. He argued that no one ever plans to break their leg and how long ago the worker started at the job is irrelevant. He also was in disbelief that the boss asked a worker to ignore their doctor's orders and come to work. 'You're putting in writing to go against medical advice? In what possible scenario does that end well for you?' He asked. 'It is the stupidity that gets me sometimes.' Mr Askins praised the worker and said they couldn't have been more 'reasonable' in the exchange, then slammed the boss. 'He hasn't done it on purpose, he hasn't gone, and 'do you know what? That Friday shift is looking a bit rough for me I'm going to come off my bike and break my leg,' Mr Askins argued. 'What this boss was playing at? I have absolutely no idea!' Online, people shared their own horror stories of when they'd gotten sick, and their managers still demanded they work. 'My former employer said I couldn't have picked a worse time to have a miscarriage,' one shared. 'My boss didn't believe I'd broken my arm. I sent him six Dr letters (which he claimed he didn't receive), photocopies of my x-rays, and a photo of me in a sling, and I also came in to show him. Took them to small claims court and won when they fired me,' someone said. 'I completely lost my voice and was told to stay off work and not speak for over a month. I work in a primary school, and my head said, 'Could I not just sit at the back of the class?' another student said. 'I was a nurse. I collapsed at work and was found to have had a bleed on my brain. My manager came to the ward I was on after I'd just had a lumbar puncture and was asking when I'd be back at work because I was scheduled for night duty the day after and I 'should know how hard it is to get cover,' someone else said

Qantas plane, Australian passengers stuck in Azerbaijan after medical emergency
Qantas plane, Australian passengers stuck in Azerbaijan after medical emergency

ABC News

timea day ago

  • ABC News

Qantas plane, Australian passengers stuck in Azerbaijan after medical emergency

A Qantas Airbus A380 flying from London to Singapore has been forced to make an urgent landing in Azerbaijan, after a passenger suffered a life-threatening cardiac emergency mid-flight, disrupting the journey for hundreds onboard. The aircraft touched down safely at 7:55am local time at Heydar Aliyev International Airport in Baku, Azerbaijan, between Russia and Iran. Australian doctor Hamish Urquhart said the passenger, a woman in her 60s, experienced a major cardiac event during the flight. Dr Urquhart, along with an ophthalmologist and a retired surgeon from Melbourne, helped stabilise the woman while the plane was preparing to land. "The lady was really quite unwell and needed intravenous access while we were trying to land, which was a bit challenging," Dr Urquhart said. He said the pilot had to make a "dramatic 180 degree turn" to reach Baku, the closest airport capable of accommodating a large plane. "In the air it was a bit stressful as we were flying towards Afghanistan," he said. He said the woman, who was travelling from the United Kingdom with her husband, has since been transported to a nearby hospital. "They're currently trying to find 400 hotel rooms in Azerbaijan while they fly a new plane from London," Dr Urquhart said Monday morning local time. "Apparently we'll be here on the tarmac for several hours as Qantas has to sort visas for everyone for Azerbaijan and all the hotel rooms in Baku." Dr Urquhart said passengers were told the airport rarely saw an Airbus A380. "Everyone seems to be taking it in their stride which is nice to see. People realised the lady was very unwell," he said. In a statement, a Qantas spokesperson said QF2 diverted to Baku "due to a medical incident onboard". "We apologise to customers for the disruption and are working to get them on their way to Singapore as soon as possible," they said. The spokesperson said the "diversion caused the operating crew to reach their duty limits, meaning the flight could not continue onwards the same day". They said all customers would be provided with overnight accommodation and passengers were expected to depart for Singapore on Tuesday.

'Backs to the Wall' for surfing's cancer survivor Flores
'Backs to the Wall' for surfing's cancer survivor Flores

News.com.au

time4 days ago

  • News.com.au

'Backs to the Wall' for surfing's cancer survivor Flores

Jeremy Flores faced numerous challenges in the water as he carved himself a hugely successful surfing career but nothing prepared the Frenchman for the tumultuous months that followed his retirement in 2021. Within months of stepping away from competition, Flores, the most successful male European in surfing history, was diagnosed with a brain tumour that turned his life upside down. He survived to tell the tale, after years of silence, in a new documentary "Dos au mur" ("Backs to the Wall") which premiered in Paris on Wednesday. "I told myself it was time to talk about it," he told AFP. "I needed to get it off my chest, to send a message to my children and others who might need it. This was clearly the hardest ordeal of my life." - Inoperable - Flores was born in Reunion, an island in the Indian Ocean which is a paradise for surfers - in spite of the large number of sharks. His father Patrick coached him from the age of three and he duly became one of the best in the world, competing for 15 years on the professional circuit, winning four prestigious championship tour events. Blessed with talent in the tubes, he was also quick with his temper. "I think I've got the most fines on the professional tour," he admits in the film which is directed by Julie and Vincent Kardasik. Yet in 2021, having become a father for the second time, he decided to retire without really explaining why. "For several years, I had a lot of migraines," he tells AFP. "I was always tired, unmotivated." A few months later, he was diagnosed with a tumour at the base of his brain. Worse yet, many surgeons considered it inoperable. "That explained why I wasn't feeling my best. The news shattered me," admits Flores. Brain tumour survival rates do not make pretty reading: just a third make it through five years although that figure improves for people under 40, according to medical figures in France. In theory Flores stood a fighting chance if he could find a surgeon who would operate. Fortunately he did. In 2022, he finally underwent brain surgery in Montpellier supervised by pioneering neurosurgeon Hugues Duffau. Flores was awake for all of it. "The operation went well," he recalls, still traumatised by the operation and the effects. "After that, it was a mission. I'd been warned. I had to relearn how to speak, write, and read. "I suffered significant memory loss. My children had become strangers to me." But with the constant support of his wife Hinarani de Longeaux, a model and former Miss Tahiti winner, Flores began to rebuild. He also had the support of the surf community, notably his old friend and rival Kelly Slater. "He called me almost every day, before, during, and after the operation," says Flores. "I was lucky to have great support." - Olympic gold - A little over a year after the operation, he was invited by the French Surfing Federation to manage the surf team at the 2024 Olympics: the event was to take place in Teahupo'o, Tahiti, where he had lived for several years. "I thought: why not? This will allow me to stimulate my brain, and surfing is what I do best," he says. The team consisted of four surfers who included his sister-in-law Vahine Fierro, and a young Tahitian Kauli Vaast who, according to Flores, was a natural on the pro tour. The veteran turned coach convinced them that they had what it took to win everything. And it worked. Fierro won the Tahiti Pro in 2024, the first French winner since Flores in 2015 while the team picked up two Olympic medals. Johanne Defay took bronze in the women's shortboard while Vaast went on to win gold in the men's shortboard, with Flores screaming his support from the water during every round. "It was truly special, the highlight of my career," says Flores. "He's my little brother, and I'm very attached to the notion of passing on the knowledge. I experienced it as a cycle." Three years after his operation, Flores' memory is "gradually returning". The tumour, however, is still there, a reminder of the dark days of 2021 even if it no longer haunts him. "I continue to monitor it with MRIs every three months," says Flores with a clear-eyed calm.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store