logo
It's not hard to see through RFK Jr.'s ‘radical transparency' pledge

It's not hard to see through RFK Jr.'s ‘radical transparency' pledge

Washington Post24-04-2025

Peter Lurie is executive director of the Center for Science in the Public Interest. Aaron Kesselheim is a professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School. Joshua Sharfstein served as principal deputy commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration during the Obama administration.
In his inaugural speech upon taking over as secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. declared that his plans include 'radical transparency.' He has subsequently repeated that phrase multiple times, but what it actually means — to Kennedy and for the rest of us — is far from clear.
Government transparency efforts generally start with the premise that an open and engaged agency functions more effectively and inspires public trust. Transparency programs have involved more public explanation of government action, quicker release of documents and databases, more opportunities for public comment, and an aversion to sudden, unexplained major changes in direction. In its conventional form, transparency operates neutrally, without regard to specific political objectives.
To date, Kennedy's 'radical transparency' looks nothing like this. After an initial pause on agency communications, HHS eliminated communications teams across the department. These teams include people who understand how to reach the public and clinicians to share information on drug and device recalls, outbreak investigations, and other health topics. Beyond the communications teams, there has been little effort to make knowledgeable people available for public engagement: HHS has not permitted experts from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, for example, to brief the country on one of the worst measles outbreaks in decades.
Also gone are most of the staffers who respond to requests for government documents under the Freedom of Information Act — one of the most important federal statutes related to open government — even though the department already faced formidable backlogs. (One exception appears to be the sparing of staff fulfilling requests for vaccine data filed by Kennedy's campaign lawyer, who is known for vaccine-related petitions and litigation.)
Kennedy's team also appears to be undermining the integrity of and access to important health datasets. Before Kennedy's confirmation, HHS interpreted President Donald Trump's executive orders on gender and diversity as requiring certain national health datasets to be hidden, at least temporarily, from public view. After a judge required the department to make the information available again, its websites presenting these data now state — without further explanation — that they are 'being modified to comply with President Trump's Executive Orders.'
Meanwhile, HHS has dismissed entire teams supporting major national studies. These include the National Survey of Drug Use on Health, the nation's leading effort to understand addiction, and the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System, a critical source of information on risk factors for preterm delivery and other adverse birth outcomes.
Even completed scientific studies are being delayed, altered or quashed. After three-quarters of a century of uninterrupted publication, the department failed to publish the CDC's flagship Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report for several weeks, delaying information on the spreading avian flu epidemic. Public Health Reports, a journal of the Surgeon General's Office, is now demanding revisions of accepted, peer-reviewed articles to conform with bans on certain terms.
Public participation in department decision-making has also been restricted. The Food and Drug Administration and the CDC have canceled or postponed open advisory committee meetings on vaccines. And HHS rescinded a federal commitment made in 1971 allowing public comment on rules related to public property, loans, grants, benefits and contracts.
Kennedy has yet to explain major changes at the department itself. HHS has dismissed approximately 10,000 employees (some erroneously) and is embarking on a major reorganization, with only a brief media statement explaining what appears to be the fundamental reshaping of multiple agencies. NIH has canceled hundreds of grants on the grounds of ill-defined 'gender ideology,' 'DEI,' or 'no longer effectuat[ing] agency priorities.' Also poorly explained: Why NIH has stopped multiple grants to South Africa that are critical to understanding how best to fight the global scourges of tuberculosis and AIDS. And Kennedy has yet to answer questions about why HHS pushed out an FDA leader in charge of reviewing vaccines, brought on a well-known anti-vaccine activist to reexamine vaccine safety data or prompted a leading food scientist at NIH to claim he was being censored.
With so much obfuscation and opacity at HHS, it has become crystal clear that 'radical transparency' is not about openness and engagement. So what does the term actually mean?
The HHS website on 'radical transparency' includes five items. One, inexplicably, is 'Ending Anti-Semitism on College Campuses.' A second is a press release stating that Kennedy has ordered the FDA to 'explore rulemaking' to stop food additives from entering the food supply without the agency being notified. A third is a list of terminated contracts that provides no explanations for the terminations.
The two remaining points are aggregations of data already in the public domain. One brings together information on chemical contaminants from several existing datasets. The other includes details on conflicts of interest among members of the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, a key focus of Kennedy's attention. In the past, he has claimed that 97 percent of the committee's members have conflicts of interest and has stated that 'almost all' have 'severe, severe conflicts of interest.' The new website, which aggregates information disclosed at the committee's public meetings, actually demonstrates that Kennedy is wrong. Many meetings involve no conflicts of interest, and at others, members regularly disclose conflicts and abstain from relevant votes.
Meanwhile, Kennedy's signature Make America Healthy Again Commission held its first meeting behind closed doors.
So far, the selective releases of 'radical transparency' seem to be little more than tactics in pursuit of the secretary's own agenda. With so much at stake for their health, Americans deserve to understand what HHS is up to and why. 'Radical transparency' needs a lot more transparency.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army
The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army

Yahoo

time32 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army

President Donald Trump plans to speak at Fort Bragg on Tuesday to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army as he deploys the military in an attempt to quiet immigration protests in Los Angeles. Trump has promoted the Army's anniversary as a reason to hold a military parade in Washington, D.C., on Saturday, which is also his 79th birthday. Here's the latest: Trump's Tuesday schedule, according to the White House 12:25 p.m. — Trump will travel to Fort Bragg, North Carolina 2:40 p.m. — Once he arrives, Trump will observe a military demonstration 4:00 p.m. — Trump will deliver remarks to service members, veterans and their families 6:00 p.m. — Trump will travel back to the White House Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to face Congress for first time since Signal leaks He's expected to field sharp questions from members of Congress about his tumultuous start as Pentagon chief, including his sharing of sensitive military details over a Signal chat, in three separate Capitol Hill hearings beginning Tuesday. Lawmakers also have made it clear they're unhappy that Hegseth hasn't provided details on the administration's first proposed defense budget, which Trump has said would total $1 trillion, a significant increase over the current spending level of more than $800 billion. It will be lawmakers' first chance to ask Hegseth about a myriad of other controversial spending by the Pentagon, including plans to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on security upgrades to turn a Qatari jet into Air Force One and to pour as much as $45 million into a parade recently added to the Army's 250th birthday bash, which happens to coincide with Trump's birthday on Saturday. ▶ Read more about Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth RFK Jr. ousts entire CDC vaccine advisory committee Kennedy on Monday removed every member of a scientific committee that advises the CDC on how to use vaccines and pledged to replace them with his own picks. Major physicians and public health groups criticized the move to oust all 17 members of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. Kennedy, who was one of the nation's leading anti-vaccine activists before becoming the nation's top health official, has not said who he would appoint to the panel, but said it would convene in just two weeks in Atlanta. Although it's typically not viewed as a partisan board, the entire current roster of committee members were Biden appointees. ▶ Read more about Kennedy's latest move Trump pushes ahead with his maximalist immigration campaign in face of LA protests Trump made no secret of his willingness to take a maximalist approach to enforcing immigration laws and keeping order as he campaigned to return to the White House. The fulfillment of that pledge is now on full display in Los Angeles. By overriding California's Gov. Gavin Newsom, Trump is already going beyond what he did to respond to Black Lives Matter protests in 2020, when he warned he could send troops to contain demonstrations that turned violent if governors in the states did not act to do so themselves. Trump said in September of that year that he 'can't call in the National Guard unless we're requested by a governor' and that 'we have to go by the laws.' But now, he's moving swiftly to test the bounds of his executive authority in order to deliver on his promise of mass deportations. What remains to be seen is whether Americans will stand by him once it's operationalized nationwide. For now, Trump is betting that they will. ▶ Read more about Trump's efforts to fulfill his immigration promises Trump heads to Fort Bragg while facing criticism for deploying military at Los Angeles protests Trump plans to speak at Fort Bragg on Tuesday to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army as he deploys the military in an attempt to quiet immigration protests in Los Angeles. Fort Bragg, located near Fayetteville, North Carolina, serves as headquarters for U.S. Army Special Operations Command. Highly trained units like the Green Berets and the Rangers are based there. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Army Secretary Dan Driscoll will also be at Tuesday's event, along with service members, veterans and their families. Trump has promoted the Army's anniversary as a reason to hold a military parade in Washington, D.C., on Saturday, which is also his 79th birthday. Trump, who sees the military as a critical tool for domestic goals, has used the recent protests in Los Angeles as an opportunity to deploy the National Guard and U.S. Marines to quell disturbances that began as protests over immigration raids. ▶ Read more about Trump's Fort Bragg trip

The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army
The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army

Hamilton Spectator

time33 minutes ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

The Latest: Trump heads to Fort Bragg to celebrate 250th anniversary for US Army

President Donald Trump plans to speak at Fort Bragg on Tuesday to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army as he deploys the military in an attempt to quiet immigration protests in Los Angeles. Trump has promoted the Army's anniversary as a reason to hold a military parade in Washington, D.C. , on Saturday, which is also his 79th birthday. Here's the latest: Trump's Tuesday schedule, according to the White House 12:25 p.m. — Trump will travel to Fort Bragg, North Carolina 2:40 p.m. — Once he arrives, Trump will observe a military demonstration 4:00 p.m. — Trump will deliver remarks to service members, veterans and their families 6:00 p.m. — Trump will travel back to the White House Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to face Congress for first time since Signal leaks He's expected to field sharp questions from members of Congress about his tumultuous start as Pentagon chief, including his sharing of sensitive military details over a Signal chat , in three separate Capitol Hill hearings beginning Tuesday. Lawmakers also have made it clear they're unhappy that Hegseth hasn't provided details on the administration's first proposed defense budget , which Trump has said would total $1 trillion, a significant increase over the current spending level of more than $800 billion. It will be lawmakers' first chance to ask Hegseth about a myriad of other controversial spending by the Pentagon, including plans to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on security upgrades to turn a Qatari jet into Air Force One and to pour as much as $45 million into a parade recently added to the Army's 250th birthday bash, which happens to coincide with Trump's birthday on Saturday. ▶ Read more about Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth RFK Jr. ousts entire CDC vaccine advisory committee Kennedy on Monday removed every member of a scientific committee that advises the CDC on how to use vaccines and pledged to replace them with his own picks. Major physicians and public health groups criticized the move to oust all 17 members of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. Kennedy, who was one of the nation's leading anti-vaccine activists before becoming the nation's top health official, has not said who he would appoint to the panel, but said it would convene in just two weeks in Atlanta. Although it's typically not viewed as a partisan board, the entire current roster of committee members were Biden appointees. ▶ Read more about Kennedy's latest move Trump pushes ahead with his maximalist immigration campaign in face of LA protests Trump made no secret of his willingness to take a maximalist approach to enforcing immigration laws and keeping order as he campaigned to return to the White House. The fulfillment of that pledge is now on full display in Los Angeles . By overriding California's Gov. Gavin Newsom, Trump is already going beyond what he did to respond to Black Lives Matter protests in 2020, when he warned he could send troops to contain demonstrations that turned violent if governors in the states did not act to do so themselves. Trump said in September of that year that he 'can't call in the National Guard unless we're requested by a governor' and that 'we have to go by the laws.' But now, he's moving swiftly to test the bounds of his executive authority in order to deliver on his promise of mass deportations. What remains to be seen is whether Americans will stand by him once it's operationalized nationwide. For now, Trump is betting that they will. ▶ Read more about Trump's efforts to fulfill his immigration promises Trump heads to Fort Bragg while facing criticism for deploying military at Los Angeles protests Trump plans to speak at Fort Bragg on Tuesday to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army as he deploys the military in an attempt to quiet immigration protests in Los Angeles. Fort Bragg, located near Fayetteville, North Carolina, serves as headquarters for U.S. Army Special Operations Command. Highly trained units like the Green Berets and the Rangers are based there. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Army Secretary Dan Driscoll will also be at Tuesday's event, along with service members, veterans and their families. Trump has promoted the Army's anniversary as a reason to hold a military parade in Washington, D.C. , on Saturday, which is also his 79th birthday. Trump, who sees the military as a critical tool for domestic goals, has used the recent protests in Los Angeles as an opportunity to deploy the National Guard and U.S. Marines to quell disturbances that began as protests over immigration raids. ▶ Read more about Trump's Fort Bragg trip Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

Why Trump turned against ‘gold standard' mRNA vaccines
Why Trump turned against ‘gold standard' mRNA vaccines

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Why Trump turned against ‘gold standard' mRNA vaccines

President Trump's administration has slammed the brakes on development of messenger RNA (mRNA) vaccines, which proved their lifesaving potential during the COVID-19 pandemic but have come under increasing scrutiny among skeptics of mainstream science. The vaccines marked a breakthrough in medical technology, drastically reducing the timeline for development of targeted vaccines and even showing promise in cancer research. Trump called mRNA the 'gold standard' when he rolled out the first COVID-19 vaccines. But now they are under assault by Trump's Health and Human Services (HHS) secretary, longtime anti-vaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and his allies in the 'make America healthy again' movement. HHS in late May canceled $766 million awarded to Moderna through the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA) to develop a potential mRNA vaccine for bird flu. HHS spokesperson Andrew Nixon said of the decision, 'This is not simply about efficacy — it's about safety, integrity, and trust.' 'The reality is that mRNA technology remains under-tested, and we are not going to spend taxpayer dollars repeating the mistakes of the last administration, which concealed legitimate safety concerns from the public,' he added. Unlike traditional vaccines that contain fragments or weakened versions of a virus, mRNA vaccines send messenger ribonucleic acid into cells to teach the immune system to recognize proteins connected to virus cells. According to Joseph Varon, president and chief medical officer of the Independent Medical Alliance (IMA), the concerns for mRNA vaccine skeptics are the expedited timeline and conditions in which the COVID-19 vaccine was approved. 'The biggest concern is that this rushed treatment still remains in use, even under an Emergency Use Authorization in some cases. It needs to be sent back through proper studies and vetting,' Varon told The Hill. 'There needs to be an established database of vaccine injuries that can be accurately quantified with full transparency, without politics or big money pressure influencing the data,' he added. 'There's a growing body of peer-reviewed studies that indicate the spike proteins are causing havoc in certain recipients.' The IMA, previously known as Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance, launched a campaign in support of Kennedy's nomination to be HHS secretary. The group drew controversy when its founders promoted ivermectin as a 'miracle drug' for COVID-19. Myocarditis, or inflammation of the heart muscle, is of particular concern among mRNA vaccine opponents. An analysis published in 2022 found that myocarditis occurred in about 31.2 cases per 1 million second doses of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine, or 0.003 percent. Rates of myocarditis are significantly higher among people with COVID-19 infections than immunizations, however. The development of the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine was aided by the Trump administration's Operation Warp Speed, something Trump has boasted about at numerous points. In remarks in December 2020, the same month the first COVID-19 vaccines were deployed, Trump praised Operation Warp Speed's ability to develop a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine at a 'breakneck speed,' adding 'the gold standard vaccine has been done in less than nine months.' Though research on mRNA and its potential uses has been ongoing for decades, use of the vaccines in humans is relatively new. The first mRNA vaccine candidate tested in humans was for rabies in 2013, but it wouldn't be until the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 that this technology would achieve commercial viability and widespread use. To Kennedy, this is too much of a coincidence. In his book 'The Wuhan Cover-Up: And the Terrifying Bioweapons Arms Race,' published in 2023, Kennedy suggests it was more than just happenstance that allowed for the deployment of Moderna's mRNA technology to coincide with the global pandemic. He pointed to a meeting attended by Dr. Anthony Fauci and former BARDA Director Rick Bright in which the officials met with virologists months before the COVID-19 pandemic broke out. The fact that attendees discussed the need for innovation in influenza research and vaccines became a point of conspiracy online. Kennedy noted that Bright called for something 'completely disruptive, that's not beholden to bureaucratic strings and processes,' writing, '[Bright] hinted that only a global crisis — like a pandemic — could induce government and industry to commit the billions of dollars necessary to create a new generation of 'plug-and-play' mRNA vaccines.' In the conversation Kennedy references, Bright was discussing the challenges of making influenza research 'sexy' for Ph.D. and postdoctoral students, surmising that something 'completely disruptive' would be needed to incite excitement in the field. Proponents of the mRNA technology point to its deployment in the COVID-19 pandemic and its role in reducing transmission as evidence of safety and efficacy. 'In the U.S., you know, we have a lot of real-world experience now with huge numbers of doses given. We have been following for significant or serious adverse events for a long time, and the rate of those serious adverse events is on par with what we see for other vaccines,' E. John Wherry, director of the Institute for Immunology and Immune Health at the University of Pennsylvania, said of mRNA vaccines. As Wherry notes, all vaccines have adverse side effects, but their safety compared with the diseases they inoculate against is 'incontrovertible.' And while critics take issue with the speed at which mRNA vaccines are developed, Wherry said this difference is precisely what sets these shots apart from older generations. 'mRNA vaccines have a couple of key benefits or features that really stand out compared to other vaccine platforms. One, they can be generated very, very quickly. So, you can adapt to changes very rapidly. This is much easier with an mRNA vaccine, where the COVID strain or flu strain mutates and changes from year to year,' Wherry said. 'The second is that it's relatively simple. So, we don't have to worry about, you know, impurities in, you know, an egg-grown vaccine or a cell-based grown vaccine synthesizing mRNA. There are very few components that go into it, and it can be synthesized with high purity.' Such mRNA vaccines are also potentially applicable for numerous conditions or even multiple different strains of the same virus, giving it more flexibility than traditional vaccinations. 'So, there are substantial benefits in flexibility, in speed, in simplicity of manufacturing and that probably also affects the cost of goods at the end of the day, which is perhaps a last advantage,' Wherry added. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store