Gov. Murphy's budget is bad for local news
Nearly seven years ago, Gov. Phil Murphy took a bold step toward reviving, strengthening, and transforming local media and civic engagement.
In August 2018, eight months into Murphy's first term, he signed a widely popular, bipartisan bill establishing the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium, an entity formed to provide financial aid to create and support trustworthy, community-based news.
'I believe the Consortium is a viable means to begin to combat the widespread proliferation of deliberately false or misleading information that threatens our democracy and contributed to getting President Trump elected,' Murphy said then.
State funding for the consortium has risen from $500,000 to $3 million.
Now, with nine months left until Murphy leaves office, his last budget plan proposes quite a different commitment to the consortium: zero dollars. His spending plan also includes a planned 75% cut in state subsidies to NJ PBS, which operates NJ Spotlight News. The state's current budget provides $1 million in funding to NJ PBS; Murphy's plan would slash that to $250,000.
March 16-22, 2025, is Sunshine Week, a nonpartisan collaboration among groups in the journalism, civic, education, government and private sectors that shines a light on the importance of public records and open government.
As I write this, transparency advocates nationwide are commemorating the 20th anniversary of Sunshine Week, an annual observance that highlights the importance of your right to know what your government is up to. For New Jersey citizens, the sunshine is slowly being blotted out by the Murphy administration, which also helped the Legislature take an ax to our public records law last year.
Murphy's office declined to comment but noted the governor said when he presented his budget plan to lawmakers last month that it would include some belt-tightening. Even with Murphy's proposed cuts, the state would spend a billion or so dollars more than it takes in.
'And while, yes, every responsible budget, including this one, requires hard decisions — like scaling back programs that we would rather increase funding for — we can, and we must, make those decisions while also keeping our promises, whether it be making the full payment into our pension system or fully funding our public education system,' he said.
I'll remember this when Murphy signs a budget in June that will undoubtedly be stuffed at the last minute with hundreds of millions of dollars for lawmakers' pet projects.
If you're unfamiliar with the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium, take a look at its recent grant recipients, which range from hyperlocal news site Montclair Local to conservative think tank Garden State Initiative to the New Jersey Coalition to End Homelessness. Its purpose is not to funnel money to corporate media; it's legitimately interested in aiding news outlets, community groups, and other organizations that seek to broaden civic engagement.
(Full disclosure: While the New Jersey Monitor has not received any funding from the consortium, I have applied for some. My thoughts on Murphy's plan to end state subsidies for it would be the same regardless.)
Chris Daggett, the consortium's interim director, urged lawmakers this week to restore funding to the group (the Legislature has until June 30 to strike a budget that will get Murphy's signature). Daggett told me that with the tsunami of change coming from Washington, D.C., local news is more critical than ever if we want to bridge the nation's widening partisan divide.
'For me this is not about saving journalism, this is about democracy,' he said. 'When people aren't informed, they aren't engaged, and when they aren't engaged, democracy dies.'
Mike Rispoli works for the nonprofit Free Press, founded in 2003 to support independent journalism and protect public media. Rispoli — who sits on the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium board but stressed he was not speaking on its behalf — said he understands that states are making very difficult budgetary decisions right now.
But Rispoli said today's media landscape, where the Trump administration is going after media organizations it doesn't like and billionaire media moguls are putting editorial pressure on their newsrooms to protect themselves from the president's onslaught, demands more.
'If people care about our communities and what they need in this moment, being able to make sense out of a very chaotic world, this is the moment where we need to be investing more into independent journalism, not less,' he said.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
a day ago
- Politico
100 percent back
Presented by Good morning and welcome to the weekly Monday edition of the New York & New Jersey Energy newsletter. We'll take a look at the week ahead and look back on what you may have missed last week. 100 PERCENT BACK — POLITICO's Ry Rivard: Gov. Phil Murphy is making an end-of-term push to turn his 100 percent clean energy pledge into law before he leaves office early next year, and a leading environmental ally has a new plan to help sell it. It's been two years since Sen. Bob Smith, the Middlesex County Democrat who leads the Senate's environment and energy committee, began circulating such a bill that, at least on paper, would allow the state to claim it gets all of its power from zero-carbon sources by 2035. A new version has been floating around in recent weeks and the term-limited Democratic governor is pushing to get over the finish line in the year-end lame duck legislative session. 'We feel this is the right moment in history for this legislation,' Murphy's top climate adviser, Eric Miller, said in an interview. The contours of the law remain similar to previous drafts, but new language is designed to make the law more flexible, increase in-state generation and ensure that by 2045 generation is 'clean firm,' a term that didn't appear in the last posted version of the bill and means power that is both emission-free and available on demand. That could help assuage unions that worried past versions would lead to out-of-state clean energy construction and it could help supporters pitch the law as a response to power prices that are climbing because of a regional supply-demand crunch. As part of a push to get it over the finish line, the New Jersey League of Conservation Voters has done polling that suggests it can sell a 100 percent plan, with a top line number showing about 60 percent of the electorate agrees that the state should transition to air pollution-free energy sources. The group's polling, done by Global Strategy Group in late May and early June, looked at 600 likely voters statewide and 800 likely voters in battleground legislative districts and will help inform environmentalists in coming months. 'What this poll shows is what we know in our gut, that there is overwhelming, broad support for clean energy by 2035,' said Ed Potosnak, the head of the New Jersey League of Conservation Voters. GRID WARNING SIGNS: The late June heatwave that enveloped a swath of the country strained New York's grid — requiring it to rely on emergency imports from neighboring regions as some fossil fuel power plants unexpectedly shut off. The New York Independent System Operator has been warning for years that the aging fossil fuel fleet, retirements of some units and slow buildout of new resources threatens reliability. 'For years we've been saying the system is changing … and we don't want to become like a Texas or California,' said Kevin Lanahan, NYISO's top spokesperson. 'What we just experienced looks a lot like what we've been warning against.' Behind-the-meter solar — rooftop and distributed solar that shows up simply as reduced demand on the system — contributed to meeting demand at high levels but began to drop off as the sun dipped lower. Wind also contributed significantly during the heat wave, which is not always the case on hot summer days, Lanahan said. But it dropped off as temperatures and demand for electricity rose. The sweltering heat caused load to peak during the heatwave around 6 p.m. on June 24 at 31,857 megawatts. That's slightly higher than the forecasted summer peak NYISO expected in its summer readiness assessment. The all-time summer peak was in July 2013 at 33,956 MWs. Lanahan said that if solar, wind and demand response resources hadn't been available, the June heatwave would've been at a historic peak. 'The behind-the-meter solar masked the load in effect,' he said. 'What if you don't have the solar in the next one? What if you don't have the wind in the next one?' The system was most strained in the evening on June 24, when the grid operator declared a 'major emergency' as neighboring regions cut scheduled exports to New York as they also grappled with high demand. 'The heat dome spread across New England, the Northeast and large parts of the Midwest, so everybody was scrambling,' Lanahan said. About 1,000 megawatts of fossil fuel units were also not available. 'The age of these units showed, and we did have some of them trip offline,' he said. NYISO made emergency energy purchases from neighboring grids to fill the gap and keep operating reserves — an essential cushion to keep the system running smoothly — at acceptable levels. The emergency state was declared at 6:13 p.m. and ended at 7:58 p.m., according to an initial report on the event. More detailed findings and 'lessons learned' are being evaluated by the NYISO. A report will be made to federal regulators, as well. — Marie J. French BPU RA — The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities is holding a technical conference on Tuesday to discuss resource adequacy. The conference follows two reports in 2021 and 2023 and comes weeks ahead of a September regional conference organized by governors from PJM states. BPU President Christine Guhl-Sadovy said the goal is to look at getting as much capacity as the state can get at the lowest price. It comes amid legislative pushes to restructure the state's utilities, build small modular nuclear reactors, study leaving PJM and to keep data centers from hogging grid power. 'I think things have changed pretty drastically in the last couple of years when it comes to load projections,' Guhl-Sadovy said. The technical conference 'has to inform all of our policy decisions.' Expect speakers from Brattle Group, PJM, PSE&G, the Nuclear Energy Institute, NRDC and more. — Ry Rivard HAPPY MONDAY MORNING: Let us know if you have tips, story ideas or life advice. We're always here at mfrench@ and rrivard@ And if you like this letter, please tell a friend and/or loved one to sign up. Want to receive this newsletter every weekday? Subscribe to POLITICO Pro. You'll also receive daily policy news and other intelligence you need to act on the day's biggest stories. Here's what we're watching this week: TUESDAY— The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities is holding a technical conference on Tuesday to discuss resource adequacy, 9:30 a.m., Room 115 of the Education Building, The College of New Jersey, 2000 Pennington Road, Ewing, NJ 08618 — and online. AROUND NEW YORK — How faulty electrical equipment caused a subway explosion last year. — 'You Gotta Believe the IBX Is Coming.' Around New Jersey — It wasn't a windmill: 'Whale killed off Jersey Shore after bashing boat, throwing passenger into water' — Op-ed: 'Investing in N.J. cooling centers is a matter of public good and justice' What you may have missed SIERRA CLUB'S MAGA ALIGNMENT — When Taylor McFarland, the New Jersey Sierra Club's conservation manager, heard Cranbury officials were looking to seize a 21-acre farm to build housing, 'It was just like a gut punch.' The Sierra Club sided with some in the MAGA movement to oppose the town's eminent domain move against the farm, known as Andy's Farm, which would make way for 130 units of affordable housing. TRENTON WATER ON THE BRINK — POLITICO's Ry Rivard: New Jersey's capital city continues to be served by a water system 'on the brink of catastrophic failure,' the state's top environmental regulator said in a letter urging Trenton's mayor and city council to act faster to find a fix. A new DEP website documents some of the problems. R.I.P. WIND LEASES — POLITICO's Kelsey Tamborrino: The Interior Department said Wednesday it is formally rescinding all designated wind energy areas on the U.S. outer continental shelf where the federal government could hold offshore wind lease auctions. Those areas spanned the Gulf of Mexico — which the Trump administration has renamed Gulf of America — as well as the Gulf of Maine, the New York Bight, California, Oregon and the central Atlantic. BEHIND THE CURTAIN — POLITICO's Zach Colman and Alex Guillén: EPA's efforts to dismantle the endangerment finding mark a major victory for conservatives' decades-long campaign to block the federal government from using landmark environmental laws to tackle the pollution driving climate change. BPU x PSC — New Jersey's ratepayer advocate is urging the Garden State to follow New York's lead and look at killing a major offshore wind transmission project. Last month, as Marie reported, the New York Public Service Commission abandoned a transmission project intended to support offshore wind in the Empire State. Citing 'commonalities' between the two states, the New Jersey Division of Rate Counsel said in a filing that his state's Board of Public Utilities should 'take similar steps to ensure that New Jersey ratepayers do not bear the unjustifiable risk.' PAY-SSAIC — Occidental Chemical Corp., known as OxyChem, filed an appeal that looks to upend the $150 million deal approved late last year that attempted to settle the federal government's claims against scores of companies accused of contaminating the Passaic River.
Politico
a day ago
- Politico
The mysteries of megabill 2.0
IN TODAY'S EDITION:— A Senate buzzkill for megabill 2.0— California Dems prep new congressional map— Murphy looks to revive doctor pay revamp Republicans are going through the motions on the road to megabill 2.0. But a growing number of GOP lawmakers are skeptical about what's to come. Despite Speaker Mike Johnson's push for second and third budget reconciliation bills, it's becoming clear that Senate Republicans aren't so sure what the party can deliver after a grueling battle over the 'big, beautiful' tax and spending plan that became law last month. Mia, Jordain Carney and Cassandra Dumay are out this morning with a look at the big reasons why GOP skepticism abounds. No direction — A White House official tells Mia that President Donald Trump really does want Congress to craft another domestic policy bill using the party-line budget reconciliation process. But Republicans say they're still waiting for the administration to provide specific instructions about what they should consider. Among those in the dark are committee leaders including Budget Chair Lindsey Graham and Armed Services Chair Roger Wicker. Commerce Chair Ted Cruz says he doesn't even know what the administration's broader legislative priorities are heading into the fall. 'You have to have a reason to do it,' Sen. Mike Rounds says. 'It's not easy to do, so you have to have a purpose for doing it in the first place.' Some Senate Republicans are working to fill in the gaps. Sen. Ron Johnson, a deficit hawk, is looking to cut spending. Senate Finance Chair Mike Crapo says he'll sort through roughly 200 tax proposals that were left out of the first reconciliation bill. No deadlines — Even if the White House floats some policy asks, it's not likely Republicans will feel as much pressure to advance a bill. With megabill 1.0, they had to avert a year-end expiration of Trump's 2017 tax cuts and head off a debt ceiling crisis. 'Without the pressure, I don't see how you get it done,' says one Republican senator granted anonymity. 'I don't think I see what the pressure is here.' GOOD MONDAY MORNING. Mia's out for the week. Email us: crazor@ and bguggenheim@ THE LEADERSHIP SUITE The latest on redistricting Democratic state lawmakers in California are expected to unveil a new congressional map this week. One draft that's circulating would give Democrats five new seats, potentially offsetting a GOP redistricting effort underway in Texas. Gov. Gavin Newsom wants to put the redistricting effort on the ballot in November. 'We discovered that we indeed could, consistent with the Voting Rights Act, put five Republican seats in play,' Rep. Zoe Lofgren, chair of the California Democratic congressional delegation, told CNN Sunday. 'We're unanimous in wanting to move forward.' As the White House ramps up pressure on red states to pursue redistricting, Vice President JD Vance said in a Fox News interview that he told Indiana state officials last week 'we want a unified Republican team.' Vance also said a new census sought by Trump could add 10 GOP seats and lead to 9 fewer Democratic seats. POLICY RUNDOWN COURT AFFIRMS CONGRESS' POWER OF THE PURSE — The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals is giving the Trump administration until Friday to put back online a public database that tracks federal spending, Kyle Cheney and Josh Gerstein report. The three-judge panel's unanimous decision over the weekend comes after the administration decided in March to shut the database down, claiming it threatened Trump's ability to manage federal spending. The judges declared that action was an affront to Congress' authority over government spending. MURPHY PREPS DOC PAY REVAMP — Rep. Greg Murphy, a House Ways and Means member and co-chair of the GOP Doctors Caucus, is looking to revive legislation aimed at shielding doctors from recurring cuts to their Medicare payments. It's a potential menu item for a year-end health care deal that lawmakers are beginning to sketch out. Doctors have seen declines in their Medicare payments for decades even as the cost of health care has steadily increased. The tax law that Trump enacted last month included a 2.5 percent bump for 2026, after Senate Republicans scrapped a House-backed provision that would have permanently tied the doctor fee scale to an index that tracks rising medical costs. Murphy wants a second shot. 'I cannot overemphasize how much damage these persistent cuts to the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule have done,' Murphy tells Benjamin. Best of POLITICO Pro and E&E: THE BEST OF THE REST Affairs, fraud and attack ads: The dirty fight for the Texas Senate, from Benedict Smith at The Telegraph Bernie Sanders thinks Democrats have turned on their base. Now it's time to fight back, from Veronica Stracqualursi at CNN THE CARRYOUT Welcome back to your Inside Congress hosts' favorite recess activity: sharing lawmakers' Capitol Hill food recommendations. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen said her go-to is a ham and swiss sandwich on rye from Capitol Hill Supermarket. What's your regular order in the neighborhood? Email crazor@ CAMPAIGN STOP CHIP ROY FOR AG? — Rep. Chip Roy is eyeing a bid for Texas attorney general as current AG Ken Paxton campaigns to oust Sen. John Cornyn, reports Mychael Schnell in The Hill. IOWA WATCH — Arizona Sen. Ruben Gallego attended the Iowa State Fair over the weekend. Asked by a reporter about a potential 2028 bid for president, the Arizona Democrat said he's 'focused on 2026' for now. TUNNEL TALK NEW EATERIES ON CAMPUS — The renovated Rayburn Cafeteria is scheduled to open this morning. It features the new CHA Street Food, which is available today, and Java House, which is expected to open Tuesday. Also opening today is the Starbucks Kiosk and Longworth Convenience Store, as well as the Common Grounds coffee shop in the Cannon basement. The Longworth and Ford cafeterias are closed for renovations. HAPPY BIRTHDAY Former Rep. Dan Kildee … former Sen. Tim Hutchinson … Billy Long (7-0) … NYT's David Brooks and Lyndsey Layton … Charles Blow … POLITICO's Toby Eckert, Michael Roberts and Danielle Bello … Lauren Maddox of Holland & Knight … Jesse Barba of Cengage Group … Kedrin Simms Brachman … former USTR Charlene Barshefsky … Marissa Secreto … Colin Cunliff … Thad Huguley … Greg Michaelidis … Ilana Drimmer … Sam Myers Jr. … National Journal's Emily Akhtarzandi TRIVIA FRIDAY'S ANSWER: Jim Wholey correctly answered that Theodore Roosevelt was the first president to receive the Nobel Peace Prize. TODAY'S QUESTION, from Calen: Name the current senators who have cast more than 10,000 votes. The first person to correctly guess gets a mention in the next edition of Inside Congress. Send your answers to insidecongress@
Wall Street Journal
4 days ago
- Wall Street Journal
How Phil Murphy Caused New Jersey Electricity Prices to Soar
Despite flat electricity demand for the past two decades—and some of the lowest energy usage per capita among the 50 states—New Jersey residents pay some of the highest retail power prices in the country. As of April 2025, the Garden State ranked No. 12 in the nation, with prices more than 15% above the U.S. average. This gap has widened further in the wake of the recent decision by the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities to approve an additional 17% to 20% rate increase for most utility customers starting in June. A decade ago, the outlook for New Jersey electricity prices was much brighter. The state was adding natural-gas generation capacity to take advantage of abundant, low-cost Marcellus Shale gas located next door in Pennsylvania. By 2016, New Jersey achieved energy independence by supplying all its power needs with in-state generation for the first time in its history, partially fueled by Pennsylvania gas. Then the state threw it all away. Since electing Gov. Phil Murphy in November 2017, New Jersey has shut down all its coal plants, reduced its natural gas-generation capacity, and increased its reliance on intermittent wind and solar power. Trenton is on a quixotic quest to achieve 100% 'clean' electricity production by 2035. Under Mr. Murphy's leadership, New Jersey has tilted at offshore windmills—none of which have been completed to date, mainly due to cost overruns, despite the state's generous financial incentives. New Jersey has also subsidized the rollout of solar power (mostly nonutility scale) even though the state experiences only 94 days with less than 30% cloud cover in an average year. The state ranks seventh in the country for small-scale solar power generation, with rooftop and utility-pole solar panels now ubiquitous.
