Legal group asks for judicial review of case against Judge Alain Bégin
The provincial court judge has faced scrutiny for his comments and actions in a number of cases, and has been harshly criticized by the province's top court for his conduct.
In a March decision, a review committee who looked at the complaints against Bégin said the judge should be reprimanded, but not face a judicial council hearing that could strip him of his job.
The three-person committee said an undiagnosed mental condition contributed to Bégin's questionable behaviour.
Now, a coalition made up of the Nova Scotia Criminal Lawyers' Association, the Elizabeth Fry Society of Mainland Nova Scotia and the Mi'kmaw Legal Support Network is requesting a judicial review of that committee's decision.
In court documents filed Monday, the coalition has asked for public interest standing. That's a legal mechanism that allows individuals and organizations to bring cases of public interest before the courts even if the matter does not affect them personally.
"All of the coalition partners work within the justice system and have a strong interest in ensuring fairness, transparency, and accountability in all its processes, including the judicial complaints review process," the coalition said in a statement.
Public hearing
One of the things the coalition wants the court to rule on is when a matter should be referred to a public hearing.
"The public must have confidence there is judicial accountability, including that complaints of judicial misconduct will be reviewed properly, and determined fairly," the statement read.
In one of the incidents that touched off the committee review process, Bégin referred to an accused in a sexual assault case as a "deviant" but then tried to walk back his remarks. That drew a strong rebuke from the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal, the province's highest court.
No date has been set yet for a hearing in Supreme Court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Ottawa Citizen
28 minutes ago
- Ottawa Citizen
'You may not have the best hand': Former U.S. ambassador on Canada negotiating with Trump
Article content Cohen also said tariffs can be helpful as leverage to negotiate things like boosted defence spending for NATO. 'I think that's a good thing,' he said. Article content But he also criticized Trump's across-the-board high tariffs, like the 25 per cent tariff on potash, an essential farming input that's scarce in the U.S., as making no sense. Article content A: 'I think he's in a very difficult position because (he's not a free agent but a personal representative of President Trump, but …) he's from a border state and has a longstanding understanding of the U.S.-Canada relationship and its importance from his Michigan roots,' Cohen said, noting how the former representative for Michigan's 2nd congressional district has gone out of his way to repeatedly talk about the importance of the Canada-U.S. relationship. Article content Article content 'I think he's doing the best job he can to continue to send a message about the value that he personally and that the country puts on the U.S.-Canada relationship.' Article content Q: Any final advice for Canadians about their relationship with the U.S.? Article content A: 'There's almost an inferiority complex in Canada — lines like 'we're the stepchild' or 'not big enough to matter' — I always hated that,' he said, noting how Canada undervalues its importance as a friend, partner, and ally. Article content 'There are things Canada can do that the United States cannot, because internationally, (the U.S.) is the 800-pound gorilla. Canada, though, gets to be in conversations in the global south where it can express views about promoting democracy and democratic values that, if promoted by the U.S., would fall on deaf ears. Canada can open the door and help achieve America's No. 1 foreign policy goal, which is the promotion of democracy and democratic values around the world.' Article content Article content Canada should never also never undervalue the role it has played in its actions, Cohen said. 'When the United States went into Afghanistan, Canada was the first country to join us. Americans should never forget what Canada did in the (Canadian) Caper, getting our last diplomats out of Iran safely (after the 1979 revolution), at great danger to the individual Canadian diplomats and to Canada on the international stage. Article content
CTV News
28 minutes ago
- CTV News
RCMP executes search warrant at cannabis store in Millbrook, prompts protest: N.S. RCMP
One man was arrested after a search warrant was executed at an illegal cannabis storefront in Millbrook, according to a news release from the Nova Scotia RCMP. Millbrook RCMP and Colchester County District RCMP executed a search warrant under the Cannabis Act at a storefront on Willow St. on Wednesday. Police say a man was arrested, released and will not be charged. 'Investigators anticipate that other people will face charges as the information and evidence collected during the search warrant execution is analyzed,' the release from the RCMP said. During the search, police say officers seized a quantity of illegal cannabis and unstamped tobacco. While the search warrant was being executed, a group of protestors gathered outside the storefront. 'The RCMP respects the rights of everyone to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly, and notes that demonstrations were peaceful, lawful, and safe for all parties involved,' the release continued. 'The RCMP reminds residents that the only legal way to purchase cannabis in the province is at licensed locations.' For more Nova Scotia news, visit our dedicated provincial page
CTV News
28 minutes ago
- CTV News
Markham sports coach previously charged with sexual assault linked to 1994 incident in Toronto: police
Police say a Markham sports coach at the centre of a sexual assault investigation is facing more charges after additional victims came forward, including one who linked him to an incident which occurred more than 30 years ago. In June, York Regional Police arrested 58-year-old Garth Morris after one of the individuals he coached reported a number of sexual assaults. The victim alleged that the assaults began in 2017, when they were under the age of 16, and continued until 2021. Police told CTV News Toronto that the initial reported timeline by the victim has changed since Morris was first identified as suspect. Investigators released an image of Morris at the time, saying he had coached youth basketball, tennis, and volleyball in Markham, in an effort to identify any other individuals who may have been victimized by him. In an update on Friday, police said that since then additional victim have come forward with historical reports of sexual assault. One of those incidents, police said, dates back to 1994, when Morris was coaching in Toronto. No other details were released. Police released an updated image of Morris in announcing the new charges against him, including two counts of sexual assault and one count of sexual exploitation. Morris was previously charged with invitation to sexual touching under 16 years of age, sexual interference with a person under 16 years of age, sexual assault, and sexual exploitation. Police are asking anyone with information related to the investigation to contact them at 1-866-876-5423, ext. 7071 or Crime Stoppers anonymously.
