Apple must face consumer lawsuit over iCloud storage, US judge rules
must face a proposed class action accusing the iPhone maker of illegally monopolizing the market for digital storage and causing consumers to overpay for its iCloud service, a federal judge in California ruled on Monday.
US District Judge Eumi Lee in San Jose, California, said the plaintiffs in the case had sufficiently alleged Apple violated antitrust law by requiring iPhone customers to use its iCloud data storage service to back up core data and device setting files.
Lee's new order revived the plaintiffs' lawsuit after she dismissed an earlier version of it. She said the consumers added substantial new allegations about the importance of data storage for all iPhone files, including restricted ones like settings data.
Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The company has denied any wrongdoing.
An attorney for the consumers had no immediate comment on the ruling.
A Los Angeles resident who said she was paying $2.99 monthly for an iCloud storage plan filed the lawsuit last year.
Apple allows third-party storage for photos and videos but not for some users' data files that are needed to "restore" an Apple device.
Apple has defended its policy as designed to guarantee high levels of security. The company also urged Lee to dismiss the plaintiff's claims as untimely. Plaintiffs generally face a four-year window to bring claims under U.S. antitrust law.
In her ruling, Lee said it was premature to dismiss the claims as time-barred, but suggested the issue could be revisited later in the litigation.
The plaintiff's lawyers want to represent a nationwide class of at tens of millions of consumers who purchased iCloud storage plans.
The case is Felix Gamboa v. Apple Inc, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 5:24-cv-01270.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
16 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Is Target in trouble? TGT stock falls after CEO Brian Cornell steps down amid sales struggles, COO Michael Fiddelke takes charge
TGT stock: Target's CEO Brian Cornell will resign on February 1st amidst declining sales and operational challenges. COO Michael Fiddelke will succeed him, focusing on merchandising, store experience, and technology investments to revitalize the retailer. Target reported a 21% drop in net income, with shares plummeting, reflecting concerns over store traffic and customer loyalty. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Target COO Michael Fiddelke Tapped as New CEO Michael Fiddelke Plans Rapid Changes to Revive Target's Retail Edge Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Target's Weak Quarterly Results Spark Market Reaction Store Traffic and Customer Loyalty on the Decline Target Reiterates Lowered Full-Year Forecast FAQs Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads l will be stepping down from his position on February 1 next year as the Minneapolis-based chain struggles with low sales, messy and understocked stores, and eroding customer loyalty in a post-pandemic marketplace, as per a 66-year-old Cornell will be replaced by, a 20-year company veteran who has helped drive some of Target's most significant operational decisions, including overhauling its supply chain and building out digital services while cutting costs, as per an AP firm had announced in May that Fiddelke would lead a new office focused on faster decision-making to help accelerate sales growth, as reported by AP. Meanwhile, Brian will transition to the role of executive chair of the Board of Directors, as per Target's READ: Billionaire Taylor Swift offered jaw-dropping Vegas residency — bigger than Celine Dion or Elvis, report claims Fiddelke said that he will be stepping into the role with urgency, with three priorities, which include reclaiming the company's merchandising authority, improving the shopping experience by making sure shelves are consistently stocked and stores are clean, and investing in technology at the company's stores and in its supply network, as reported by said, 'When we're leading with swagger in our merchandising authority, when we have swagger in our marketing, and we're setting the trend for retail, those are some of the moments I think that Target has been at its highest in my 20 years,' as quoted in the READ: Morgan Stanley: AI boom could add $16 trillion to markets, but workers may pay the price as 90% jobs may be impacted Target also reported another quarter of sluggish results on Wednesday, with a 21% decline in net income in the quarter ended August 2, according to the AP report. Even the firm's sales were down, with a 1.9% dip in comparable sales from established physical stores and online channels, as per the shares of Target have fallen about 60% from its all-time high in late 2021, as per the report. While Target stocks fell about 10% in premarket trading following the results and CEO announcement, reported READ: Apple just dropped 2 free iPhone apps with iOS 26, and users can't stop talking about them According to CNBC, Target's yearly sales have been almost stagnant for the past four years, and its inconsistent performance has tested the loyalty of shoppers and also shaken the confidence of Wall Street. Analytics firm found that the store traffic at the retailer has dropped nearly every week since late January, as reported by retailer also reiterated its full-year forecast, which it had cut in May, as per the report. Target also said that it expects a low single-digit percentage decline in sales and adjusted earnings per share, excluding gains from litigation settlements, to be about $7 to $9, as reported by is stepping down amid falling sales, operational issues, and waning customer loyalty. He's transitioning to the role of executive COO Michael Fiddelke will step in as CEO on February 1, 2026.
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
Is Target in trouble? TGT stock falls after CEO Brian Cornell steps down amid sales struggles, COO Michael Fiddelke takes charge
TGT stock : Target's CEO Brian Cornel l will be stepping down from his position on February 1 next year as the Minneapolis-based chain struggles with low sales, messy and understocked stores, and eroding customer loyalty in a post-pandemic marketplace, as per a report. Target COO Michael Fiddelke Tapped as New CEO The 66-year-old Cornell will be replaced by Chief Operating Officer Michael Fiddelke , a 20-year company veteran who has helped drive some of Target's most significant operational decisions, including overhauling its supply chain and building out digital services while cutting costs, as per an AP report. The firm had announced in May that Fiddelke would lead a new office focused on faster decision-making to help accelerate sales growth, as reported by AP. Meanwhile, Brian will transition to the role of executive chair of the Board of Directors, as per Target's website. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Undo ALSO READ: Billionaire Taylor Swift offered jaw-dropping Vegas residency — bigger than Celine Dion or Elvis, report claims Michael Fiddelke Plans Rapid Changes to Revive Target's Retail Edge Fiddelke said that he will be stepping into the role with urgency, with three priorities, which include reclaiming the company's merchandising authority, improving the shopping experience by making sure shelves are consistently stocked and stores are clean, and investing in technology at the company's stores and in its supply network, as reported by AP. Live Events He said, 'When we're leading with swagger in our merchandising authority, when we have swagger in our marketing, and we're setting the trend for retail, those are some of the moments I think that Target has been at its highest in my 20 years,' as quoted in the report. ASLO READ: Morgan Stanley: AI boom could add $16 trillion to markets, but workers may pay the price as 90% jobs may be impacted Target's Weak Quarterly Results Spark Market Reaction Target also reported another quarter of sluggish results on Wednesday, with a 21% decline in net income in the quarter ended August 2, according to the AP report. Even the firm's sales were down, with a 1.9% dip in comparable sales from established physical stores and online channels, as per the report. The shares of Target have fallen about 60% from its all-time high in late 2021, as per the report. While Target stocks fell about 10% in premarket trading following the results and CEO announcement, reported CNBC. ALSO READ: Apple just dropped 2 free iPhone apps with iOS 26, and users can't stop talking about them Store Traffic and Customer Loyalty on the Decline According to CNBC, Target's yearly sales have been almost stagnant for the past four years, and its inconsistent performance has tested the loyalty of shoppers and also shaken the confidence of Wall Street. Analytics firm found that the store traffic at the retailer has dropped nearly every week since late January, as reported by CNBC. Target Reiterates Lowered Full-Year Forecast The retailer also reiterated its full-year forecast, which it had cut in May, as per the report. Target also said that it expects a low single-digit percentage decline in sales and adjusted earnings per share, excluding gains from litigation settlements, to be about $7 to $9, as reported by CNBC. FAQs Why is Brian Cornell stepping down now? Cornell is stepping down amid falling sales, operational issues, and waning customer loyalty. He's transitioning to the role of executive chair. Who is replacing Brian Cornell? Target's COO Michael Fiddelke will step in as CEO on February 1, 2026.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
NYT Strands hints August 20: Theme, Spangram and answers to solve today's puzzle
Puzzle enthusiasts looking for something new beyond Wordle and Connections are increasingly drawn to NYT Strands , The New York Times' brain-teasing word game. If you get stuck on today's puzzle, don't worry, as here are the hints, answers, and Spangram for Wednesday, August 20, 2025, as per a report by Beebom. What are NYT Strands? NYT Strands is part of The New York Times' expanding collection of word games. The goal is simple but difficult: connect letters in a six-by-eight grid to reveal words that all fall under a specific theme . Each puzzle also includes one "special" word known as the Spangram, which connects the themes and runs across the board vertically, horizontally, or diagonally. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo ALSO READ: Apple iPhone 17 Air and Pro get surprise release date change — here's the new timeline What's today's theme? On Wednesday, August 20, the theme was "Mint Condition." As the clue implies, all of the answers centered on currencies and legal tenders used around the world. This puzzle challenged players to think beyond dollars and euros, delving into lesser-known currency names. Live Events NYT Strand Hints for August 20, 2025 To help you out, here are two useful hints from today's puzzle: First hint: South Africa's main currency. Second hint: The primary currency of Angola. What about the Spangram clue? A word that begins with "GL" and refers to a global currency system. NYT Strands Spangram for Today Spangram's answer for August 20, 2025 is: GlobalCurrency It ran vertically across the puzzle and served as the key to unlocking the remaining answers. All the theme words in today's NYT Strands puzzle Here's the entire list of words that fit today's theme: EURO RUPEE DOLLAR POUND RAND PESO KWANZA Each of these represents a major currency from various parts of the world, which fits neatly into the "Mint condition" theme. How does Spangram help? The Spangram is the foundation of all Strands puzzles. It's a single word that encompasses the entire theme and spans the grid, assisting players in connecting the dots. Once solved, identifying the remaining theme words becomes much easier. Tips for Solving NYT Strands Puzzles Faster Check the corners first, as many theme words begin or connect near the grid's edges. Use hints as needed - Finding just one theme word can lead to the discovery of more. Think outside the box: Themes can be literal, figurative, or even pun-based. Concentrate on the Spangram - Solving it early divides the puzzle in half and reveals the larger picture. So if today's Strands puzzled you, you now have the answers. Tomorrow's grid will present a completely new challenge, but remember, the Spangram is your best friend when it comes to cracking the code. FAQs What was today's Strands theme? The theme was "Mint condition," which focused on global currencies. What is the Spangram for August 20, 2025? The Spangram was GlobalCurrency, which ran vertically across the grid.
