Apple must face consumer lawsuit over iCloud storage, US judge rules
Apple
must face a proposed class action accusing the iPhone maker of illegally monopolizing the market for digital storage and causing consumers to overpay for its iCloud service, a federal judge in California ruled on Monday.
US District Judge Eumi Lee in San Jose, California, said the plaintiffs in the case had sufficiently alleged Apple violated antitrust law by requiring iPhone customers to use its iCloud data storage service to back up core data and device setting files.
Lee's new order revived the plaintiffs' lawsuit after she dismissed an earlier version of it. She said the consumers added substantial new allegations about the importance of data storage for all iPhone files, including restricted ones like settings data.
Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The company has denied any wrongdoing.
An attorney for the consumers had no immediate comment on the ruling.
A Los Angeles resident who said she was paying $2.99 monthly for an iCloud storage plan filed the lawsuit last year.
Apple allows third-party storage for photos and videos but not for some users' data files that are needed to "restore" an Apple device.
Apple has defended its policy as designed to guarantee high levels of security. The company also urged Lee to dismiss the plaintiff's claims as untimely. Plaintiffs generally face a four-year window to bring claims under U.S. antitrust law.
In her ruling, Lee said it was premature to dismiss the claims as time-barred, but suggested the issue could be revisited later in the litigation.
The plaintiff's lawyers want to represent a nationwide class of at tens of millions of consumers who purchased iCloud storage plans.
The case is Felix Gamboa v. Apple Inc, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 5:24-cv-01270.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
Apple's Back to School offer 2025 live in India: Big discounts on iPads, Macs and accessories for students
Apple's Back to School offer 2025: Apple has officially launched its Back to School offer in India, giving students an exciting chance to grab iPads, Macs, and accessories at special discounted prices. This limited-time Apple offer runs from June 17 to September 30, 2025, and is available both online and at select Apple retail stores in Delhi and Mumbai. Let's take a closer look at what Apple is offering under this student-exclusive promotion. What is Apple's Back-to-School Offer? The Back to School offer by Apple is a special promotion designed for students, teachers, and educators. Eligible customers can enjoy education discounts on selected Apple products such as MacBooks, Macs, and iPads. In addition, they can also choose from a range of discounted accessories like AirPods, Apple Pencil, and more. Who is Eligible for the Offer? The Apple Back to School offer is open to: Current and newly admitted university students Parents buying on behalf of their children in higher education Teachers and staff working at any level of education Buyers need to verify their eligibility using a valid student or faculty ID during checkout. Where Can You Get the Offer? The Back to School offer is available through: Apple Store Online (India) The Apple Store app Apple retail outlets in Delhi and Mumbai Make sure to shop during the offer period — from June 17 to September 30 — to take full advantage of the deal. What's Included in the Apple Back to School Offer? Bundle Offers for Students Depending on which Mac or iPad you choose, you get the chance to select from exciting accessories at no extra cost or at a discounted price. Here's how it works: Buy iPad Air: Choose between AirPods or the Apple Pencil Pro Buy MacBook Air or MacBook Pro: Choose from Magic Mouse, Magic Trackpad, Magic Keyboard, or AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation Buy iPad Pro or iPad Air: Select either the Apple Pencil Pro or AirPods 4 These bundles allow students to personalise their Apple setup according to their academic needs — whether for creative work, note-taking, or entertainment. Important Terms and Conditions Before making a purchase, keep in mind the following: The offer is valid for one eligible iPad and one eligible Mac per customer The offer does not include: iPad mini iPad 10th Generation Mac mini Mac Pro Mac Studio Refurbished Apple devices This Apple offer is strictly for new purchases of eligible models only. Why Students Should Not Miss This Apple Offer This is one of the best times for students in India to invest in iPads and Macs. Not only do they get access to Apple's premium devices, but they also enjoy discounted high-end accessories that boost productivity. Whether you're an art student needing the Apple Pencil, or a programming student who benefits from a Magic Keyboard, there's something for everyone. With the Apple Back to School offer, students can experience seamless learning, creativity, and performance with top-notch Apple technology — all while saving big. Apple's Back to School offer is a great chance for students to upgrade their tech with special pricing on Macs and iPads, plus get premium accessories at a low or no cost. The offer runs till September 30, so don't wait too long to grab these deals. What are the offers? Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 1. What is the promotion period for Apple's Back to School offer in India? The Apple Back to School offer in India starts on 17 June 2025 and ends on 30 September 2025. Only purchases made during this time are eligible for the offer. 2. Where can I avail the Apple Back to School offer in India? You can shop the Back to School offer at the Apple Store Online, through Apple's helpline (000800 040 1966), or at select Apple retail stores in Delhi and Mumbai. 3. Who is eligible for the Apple Back to School offer? The offer is available to the following Qualified Purchasers in India: University students currently enrolled or recently admitted Parents buying on behalf of university students Teachers and staff working in any educational institution (public or private) 4. What products are included in the Back to School offer? The offer applies to select MacBooks and iPads. With each eligible purchase, students can choose one free or discounted accessory such as AirPods, Magic Mouse, Magic Keyboard, or the Apple Pencil Pro — depending on the product. 5. Can I buy multiple devices under this promotion? No, each eligible customer can only buy one iPad and one Mac under the Back to School offer. The offer is valid for individual use only, not for institutions or resellers. 6. What if my order is delivered after the promotion ends? As long as the order is placed during the promotion period, it will qualify — even if the delivery happens after 30 September 2025. 7. Is Cash on Delivery (COD) available with this offer? Yes, but you must accept and pay for both the eligible product and the promotional accessory to receive the discount. If you refuse delivery of the accessory, Apple may cancel the discount on the main product. 8. Are returns and exchanges allowed under this offer? No, returns and exchanges are not available at Apple's retail stores for this promotion. However, your consumer statutory rights remain unaffected. 9. Can I combine this offer with other Apple promotions? Yes, this offer can be combined with other Apple promotions for individual customers, as long as they are valid during the same promotion period and do not conflict with these terms. 10. Are there any restrictions or exclusions? Yes, the following are not eligible for this offer: Purchases for resale or by institutions Products like iPad mini, iPad 10th Gen, Mac mini, Mac Pro, Mac Studio, or any refurbished devices Buyers who cannot prove student, teacher, or parent status 11. Can Apple cancel or change the offer? Yes, Apple reserves the right to modify or end the promotion at any time without prior notice. However, any orders already placed will still follow the existing terms. 12. Where can I read Apple's privacy policy? Apple's full privacy policy is available online at: For the latest and more interesting tech news, keep reading Indiatimes Tech.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Apple announces Back to School offer on Macs and iPads, to go live from June 17
Apple has announced its highly anticipated Back to School offer, which will be live between June 17 and September 30. The offer is available when you shop at Apple Stores in India, Apple Store Online, and Apple Store App. Besides, Apple specialists in stores and online will offer personalised support for consumers at every step. With the latest offer, students can purchase an eligible Mac or iPad for college with Education Savings; they can even opt for AirPods or Apple Pencil or any other eligible accessories. Consumers can buy one iPad with a promo and one Mac with a promo per customer. It needs to be noted that this offer is not applicable on iPad Mini, iPad 10th Gen, Mac Mini, Mac Pro, Mac Studio or refurbished. With MacBook Air or MacBook Pro, students can opt for Magic Mouse / Magic Trackpad / Magic Keyboard or AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation. With iPad Air or iPad Pro, students can opt for either Apple Pencil Pro or AirPods 4. Apple has said that the Mac and iPad are ideal for students and educators, as they are built from the ground up prioritising security and privacy. These devices excel at everything from productivity to creativity. Moreover, with Apple Intelligence, students can unlock exciting new capabilities that make Mac and iPad powerful tools for an assortment of tasks. Students can also explore their creativity with tools like Image Playground and Genmoji, and even make the most of their writing with Writing Tools. Mac comes with a user-friendly interface and a seamless setup. It features Dock, which offers instant access to one's favourite apps. Spotlight instantly helps a user locate apps, documents, emails, and other items on their Mac. The Mac comes with built-in trackpad gestures that make navigation feel smooth and effortless. Both MacBook Pro and MacBook Air come with all-day battery life. While the MacBook Pro offers up to 24 hours, the MacBook Air comes with 18 hours of battery. It is an ideal companion to boost productivity, as it allows users to organise apps with Store Manager, work on multiple desktops, and offers features like Hot Corners, Quick Look, and Screenshots. Besides, Apple devices can sync effortlessly across one's ecosystem, boosting productivity and convenience. Universal Clipboard allows you to copy text, images, and videos from one Apple device and paste them to another. AirDrop lets users share files wirelessly instantly, while Instant Hotspot allows Mac to connect to the iPhone's internet instantly. Users can also make and receive phone calls on their Mac without having to pick up their iPhones. Features like Continuity Camera allow one to take a photo or scan a document on their iPhone or iPad and view it instantly on their Mac. AirPlay to Mac lets you stream content directly from iPhone or iPad. Apple has also enhanced AirPods integration with faster automatic switching and the ability to mute/unmute via the stem during calls. Moreover, with Sidecar, one can use their iPad as a second display for Mac. The iPad Pro starts at Rs 99,900, the iPad Air at Rs 59,900, and the iPad at Rs 34,900. Meanwhile, the 13-inch MacBook Air starts at Rs 99,900, and the 15-inch MacBook Air at Rs 1,24,900. The 14-inch MacBook Pro starts at Rs 1,69,900 and the 16-inch model starts at Rs 2,49,900.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Trump vs Tim: How the new T1 smartphone stacks up against iPhone 16e
As trade tensions escalate between former US President Donald Trump and Apple CEO Tim Cook, the surprise unveiling of the T1 smartphone, a flagship device from the newly launched Trump Mobile, signals a direct challenge to Apple's iPhone 16e. But how does it really compare? Here's a breakdown of how the T1 stacks up against the iPhone 16e, spec for spec and feature for feature. Trump T1 – Android-based, gold‑coloured handset, marketed as US-designed. Priced at $499, and shipped in September; backed by 'The 47 Plan' ($47.45/month MVNO service). iPhone 16e – Apple's lower-cost model, released early 2025. Exact pricing varies by region; typically positioned below the standard iPhone 16. T1: 6.78‑inch AMOLED display at 120 Hz. Equipped with 12 GB RAM, 256 GB expandable storage, runs Android 15. Powered by an unspecified processor. iPhone 16e: A14/A17-class chipset (Apple's current mid-range silicon), likely 6‑8 GB RAM, fixed internal storage (128/256 GB). Offers deep iOS integration and optimised performance. T1: Triple-lens rear setup: 50 MP main, plus 2 MP depth and 2 MP macro sensors; 16 MP selfie camera. iPhone 16e: Dual-lens rear (main + ultra-wide), expected 48 MP main sensor with Apple's computational photography stack; FaceTime HD front camera. T1: 5,000 mAh battery; 20 W USB-C fast charging with headphone jack included. iPhone 16e: Approx 3,300–3,500 mAh (Apple quotes multi-day battery life), supports MagSafe and USB-C fast/PD charging (around 20 W). T1: In‑screen fingerprint sensor and AI face unlock, 3.5 mm audio jack, expandable storage via micro‑SD. iPhone 16e: Touch ID integrated to side button, IP68 water resistance, deep iOS ecosystem: FaceTime, iMessage, AR features, AI capabilities like Apple Intelligence. T1: MVNO service through Liberty Mobile using T-Mobile infrastructure; includes roadside assistance and telehealth via its $47.45/month plan. iPhone 16e: Full carrier support (5G, Wi‑Fi 6E), seamless integration in Apple ecosystem, continuity across iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, AirPods. The T1 is less a technological revolution and more a political statement in silicon. It's big, bold, and American-made, exactly what Trump's base wants. But Apple's iPhone 16e still dominates on ecosystem, refinement, and AI smarts. For now, Tim Cook can rest easy, but the T1 shows that tech is fast becoming the next battlefield in the Trump vs Tim saga.
