Ben Condon's father accuses Bristol doctors of 'cover-up'
The father of a baby who died in hospital claims doctors "intentionally" did not disclose his son had a fatal infection until after he was cremated.Ben Condon was eight weeks old when he developed a bacterial infection in April 2015, but his parents were told his death in the Bristol Children's Hospital was because of a virus, the second inquest into his death has heard.His father Allyn Condon has accused the trust involved of a cover-up. He said the harm caused due to not being told the correct information "cannot be underestimated."
University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust has previously admitted a failure to give Ben timely antibiotics contributed to his death.A previous inquest originally recorded his death as being caused by acute respiratory distress syndrome, human metapneumovirus and prematurity, which was quashed by the High Court, after new evidence emerged.A new inquest that started on Monday, and Allyn Condon read a written statement to it on Tuesday detailing Ben's parents' experience."Losing a child is a tragedy in any circumstances," Mr Condon read."But in this case, that tragedy has been compounded by the fact that we have at all stages been faced with a failure to be transparent and straightforward about the circumstances that led up to Ben's death."
The inquest heard that Ben developed a cough on 9 April, and on 10 April his parents became worried.They took him to Weston General Hospital before he was transferred to Bristol Children's Hospital the following day.Ben was diagnosed with hMPV – similar to the common cold in adults – and was later found to have acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS).Mr Condon said he was reassured by Dr Suzanne Dean that if Ben's condition worsened, he would be prescribed antibiotics, but this did not happen until 17 April – the day he died."We believe that had Dr Dean done what she told us she would do on 16 April and gave Ben antibiotics, he would be alive today," Mr Condon told the inquest.
'Waited until cremation'
In a meeting after Ben's death, Mr Condon said his parents were "misled" by doctors who wrongly told them that blood cultures and blood tests had been performed on 16 April.Antibiotics were prescribed at around 11:00 GMT on 17 April, but not administered until 20:00 GMT, by which point Ben had suffered a cardiac arrest.After his death his parents were told a post-mortem examination would not be necessary.He added that Ben would not have been cremated if his parents had been aware that he had a bacterial infection or had been diagnosed with ARDS."It is our belief that the trust intentionally waited until we had cremated Ben before disclosing any information to us about a secondary bacterial infection," he told the coroner.The inquest is expected to end in three weeks' time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
2 days ago
- BreakingNews.ie
HSE must specify when services will be provided to children with disabilities, Supreme Court says
The Supreme Court has delivered an important judgment concerning the obligations of the HSE towards children with disabilities, including a need to specify when services will be provided to them. Compliance by the HSE with its obligations under the Disability Act 2005 involves setting out and implementing 'measurable' actions, the court said. Advertisement Although there is 'nothing objectionable' about the HSE's Individual Family Support Plan (IFSP) model for delivering services to children with disabilities, the court said the HSE must ensure it complies with its obligations and with the legislature's intention to give 'enforceable rights' to individuals. The five-judge court on Wednesday rejected the HSE's appeal against the High Court's finding that it failed to comply with its legal obligations in relation to an eight-year-old girl assessed as having autism spectrum disorder and global developmental delay. Giving the judgment, Ms Justice Iseult O'Malley said the statutory process obliges the HSE to specify what services will be provided to children with disabilities and when they will be provided. Delays in assessments of need are a 'recurring' theme in cases before the courts, she noted. There was a delay of more than 18 months in assessing the girl and further delays in providing her with therapy services identified as being her health needs. Advertisement The High Court, in finding the statutory requirements were not complied with, said the only service for the girl where the HSE specified a time frame for delivery was the development of an IFSP, but that was not a 'clinical service'. The core issues in the HSE's appeal were whether the 2005 Act required that each health service identified in an assessment report should be specified in a service statement; and whether the statutory requirements regarding the content of service statements were breached by identifying the development of the IFSP as a 'specified' health service. Ms Justice O'Malley found, while not every service recommended in an assessment report must be included in the service statement, there must be 'a rational connection' between the content of both. On the second issue, she ruled an IFSP is a 'health service' within the meaning of section seven of the 2005 Act. Advertisement She said the commencement of an IFSP is the starting point for delivery of services and the plan continues as the evolving basis for development of further goals. The legislature had intended a process through which particular services and dates would be 'clearly identified' in the service statements, with a legal right to seek implementation through the courts if necessary. If each service statement only specifies a start date for the IFSP process, the right may appear reduced as the only complaint apparently possible would be the failure to commence that process, she said. The HSE can, within the IFSP model, comply with its obligations to set out and implement measurable actions, she said. Advertisement The first service statement should 'spell out' what will be involved in the IFSP process. Reviews of the service statement also required greater detail, including an overall assessment of the goals set out, whether those have been achieved, identification of overall goals for the near future and the work to achieve those, the judge said. That might mean 'relatively frequent' reviews. If the only service specified in the first service statement is an IFSP, the HSE should record that the needs specified in the assessment of need have not been included. This was necessary under the HSE's obligation to assist in measuring aggregate needs. In the case of the girl, represented by Derek Shortall SC and Colin Smith SC, instructed by solicitor Wendy Lyon, she said the original service statement and the first review statement did not meet these criteria. The original statement had been superseded and it seemed likely there would have been further reviews, she noted.
STV News
2 days ago
- STV News
Former children's home manager convicted of historical abuse of ten children
A former children's home manager has been convicted of historical abuse of young people. Edward Stanton preyed on a total of ten victims including raping one girl. Jurors heard how at least one boy tried to raise the alarm what was happening, but that the accusations were 'brushed under the carpet'. The abuse occurred at three different children's homes in Lanarkshire. Stanton, now 73, had been the manager at one and a carer at the other two between 1985 and 1994. He had denied the accusations during a trial at the High Court in Glasgow. But, he was found guilty of 11 charges after the jury heard distressing accounts of how the victims had suffered over the years. Following the verdicts, it emerged he was previously jailed for 13 years in 1996 for historical abuse of boys at a children's home in Merseyside. In 2021, he was convicted of attacks on two other youngsters at the same establishment around that time. Stanton has also been jailed for possessing indecent images of children and breaching a Sexual Offences Prevention Order. He remains in custody and will be sentenced for these latest crimes at a later date. The trial was told how Stanton was physically abusive to a boy and carried out sex attacks on a teenage girl including at a campsite in Dumfries. Stanton preyed on another victim while she was initially asleep. A victim recalled how he was only young at the time, but knew what was happening was 'not right'. He was left feeling 'scared' of Stanton. One resident was molested while in a tent. This boy had alerted a member of staff at the time, but he was 'not believed'. He said he and others were 'vulnerable children…meant to be in a place of safety'. But, he added reports of such matters appeared to be 'brushed under the carpet'. Another boy was also left terrified of Stanton who gave him money to effectively buy his silence. A further victim remembered speaking to staff, but 'nothing was done'. In his closing speech to jurors, prosecutor Scott McKenzie said one then resident recalled Stanton as initially being 'nice' and that he had never previously had anyone show him any attention. But, the violent bully soon showed his 'true colours' by repeatedly punching and kicking him. One girl was aged around seven when Stanton targeted her and went on to rape her. The final victim on the indictment had only been at the children's home where Stanton was then based for two nights, but he was still able to take advantage of her. She has been left suffering from 'flashbacks'. Stanton was convicted of charges of rape, numerous indecent assaults, lewd and libidinous behaviour as well as physical attacks. Judge Andrew Miller deferred sentencing for reports. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Woman who 'died' walked through 'hell' and 'met God in heaven'
Kathy McDaniel 'had no idea she was dead' during the whole ordeal A woman claimed that she journeyed through hell to meet God in heaven after being put into a three-week coma. Kathy McDaniel, speaking on the DEAD Talks Podcast, said that she still recalls everything that happened so clearly that it cannot have been down to her imagination. The mother was put into a medically induced coma after facing lung failure caused by an aggressive strain of flu back in 1999, which saw her fighting for her life. Upon recovery, she alleges to have found herself in a place she could only describe as hell. Even decades later, she vividly remembers the experience and shares her story to validate others who have had near-death experiences. Speaking on the podcast, she insisted her memory of the ordeal was still "as crisp as could be", adding: "To me, it proves it happened not in my brain but in my soul - and you can't turn the soul off." Raised Catholic, Kathy spent her childhood attending Catholic schools and Sunday church services. However, life struggles and traumas, including divorce and the loss of a baby, led her to question her faith in God. She asked: "I'm a nice person, why does this stuff keep happening to me?" She caught a severe strain of flu after caring for a friend who was ill in Seattle, reports the Express US. With alarming symptoms, she said: "I was coughing up blood... I could feel my life force draining out through my feet." A doctor diagnosed Kathy with ARDS - known fully as acute respiratory distress syndrome - a life-threatening illness that occurs when your lungs are severely compromised. Kathy, who was in her fifties at the time, was put into a drug-induced coma and given a mere 38% chance of survival. She had an experience that she says 'haunts her to this day' that started by 'waking up' in a "totally dark place". She described witnessing an eerie "reddish glow" which she initially mistook for a sunrise. However, she claimed this soon developed into a "pretty but weird" swirling fog that started getting "a little too warm" and began to give off a "really bad" smell. She said: "Then this voice just boomed out, scared me half to death and it said 'do you know where you are'. I'm thinking, and the only thing I can come up with is hell. The voice did this maniacal laugh and I just ran into the darkness. I didn't care if I hit a wall, fell in a ditch, that thing was going to get me so I kept running." Things then took a bizarre turn as Kathy found herself being transported to various strange places. She says these included a ruined city with collapsing buildings and a warzone before encountering what she describes as "a demon". She said the 'demon' offered her a "way out" if she completed a simple gardening task. Kathy claimed she "had no better offers" when she was handed "children's scissors" and was told to cut down seven-foot-tall blackberry bushes that would keep growing back. She then spent a considerable amount of time walking along a dirt road, with nothing around but the occasional pile of rocks. All the while, Kathy claimed she had "no idea [she] was dead" and mentioned in the podcast that she came across some of her living relatives during the journey she took. Kathy told the podcast host that she never experienced a flatline, indicating no physical death occurred. However, she said: "It's very common, and is accepted now in the groups that I belong to, that if you're in a coma, your consciousness can wander off." She said: "I started off in hell but ended up in the presence of God". During her experience, Kathy claims to have found "an architect's book" with a plan. She continued: "It was halfway open and I thought they were telling me something. I remember saying, 'that's going to be too hard' and then I saw my friend who had died the month before." She claimed that he had reversed in age from 53 to 35 and looked nothing like he did on his deathbed. Kathy said: "If he's dead, and I'm standing next to him, I must be dead too." Her friend informed her she had "too much left to do" and it wasn't long afterwards that she was "welcomed back to Earth". Kathy said that people who hear her story often deny it, believing that they "don't want it to happen to them". An astounding 5 to 10% of the general population are estimated to have memories of a near-death experience, claims Scientific American. Lots do report having interactions with God and getting a glimpse of the afterlife.
