TSLA vs. BYDDY: Which of These EV Giants is Better Positioned Now?
Tesla TSLA has long been the poster child of the electric vehicle (EV) revolution. Since its IPO in 2010, this U.S.-based company has grown into a global icon, known for its sleek designs, bold innovation and a loyal fan following. But the landscape is shifting fast. With the future of transportation being electric, many automakers are quickly catching up to challenge Tesla's dominance. And leading this competition is China's BYD Co. Ltd. BYDDY, which started in 1995 as a battery maker and has rapidly transformed into a formidable EV juggernaut. With deep roots in battery technology and a growing global footprint, BYD has emerged as Tesla's most serious challenger yet.
In the fourth quarter of 2023, BYD briefly took the EV sales crown from Tesla before ending the full year just behind. The same pattern repeated in 2024. In the first quarter of 2025, BYD delivered over 416,000 battery electric vehicles (BEVs), outpacing Tesla's 336,000 and securing the top spot for a second straight quarter. Meanwhile, Tesla's deliveries declined both year over year and quarter over quarter.
As the EV race heats up, both companies are pushing boundaries. However, with BYD's aggressive growth and Tesla's recent slowdown, the gap between the two is closing fast. So, in this high-stakes battle for EV supremacy, who should you place your bets on? Let's find out.
Tesla is facing rising pressure in its core EV business. Sales are slipping across key markets like the United States, Europe and China, while the brand's once-unchallenged appeal is starting to fade. CEO Elon Musk's growing involvement in the Department of Government Efficiency has raised concerns about his ability to stay focused on Tesla, especially as the company wrestles with slowing demand and intense competition. Although Musk still anticipates some growth in vehicle sales this year, he has dialed back his earlier 20–30% growth forecast. Adding to the concern, Tesla's automotive margins are shrinking as the company continues to roll out discounts and incentives to drive sales. Moreover, talks of its much-awaited affordable model getting delayed are adding fuel to the fire.
On the bright side, Tesla's Energy Generation and Storage segment is gaining traction. Products like the Megapack and Powerwall have been well-received, helping energy storage deployments jump 113% year over year in 2024. Musk expects at least 50% more growth in 2025. Tesla's charging infrastructure business is also performing well. Recently, TSLA claimed that its in-house 4680 battery production is now more cost-effective than external sourcing. That's a major milestone for the automaker.
Looking ahead, Tesla's big bet is on its autonomous driving ambition. The company plans to roll out unsupervised FSD in Austin this June. Last month, it secured the first of several approvals required to eventually launch its long-awaited robotaxi service in California. Progress in FSD approvals and robotaxi development is critical with no further delays.
Financially, Tesla remains on solid ground, with high liquidity and low debt. Its long-term debt-to-capitalization is just around 7%, and it has a strong interest coverage ratio of 27.7.
BYD has become a dominant force in China's electric vehicle landscape, commanding about one-third of the country's new energy vehicle (NEV) market. It holds the largest EV market share in China, thanks to its highly efficient, vertically integrated business model. From batteries and semiconductors to complete vehicle assembly, BYD controls nearly every part of its supply chain. This tight integration helps keep costs low and operations efficient — an essential advantage in today's price-sensitive EV market.
The company produces lithium-iron phosphate batteries under its Blade Battery brand. It recently introduced the "Super e-Platform," which promises major gains in range and charging speed. BYD claims its latest batteries can deliver up to 400 kilometers (roughly 249 miles) of range with just five minutes of charging, potentially a game-changer in EV usability.Its vehicle lineup caters to a wide spectrum of consumers, from affordable options like the Seagull to luxury models under the Yangwang brand. Popular hybrids and EVs such as the Song and Qin series continue to drive strong domestic sales. On the tech front, BYD is making strides with its new 'God's Eye' autonomous driving system, which offers advanced safety features at a competitive price.
Internationally, BYD is expanding rapidly, setting up factories in Brazil, Thailand, Hungary, and Turkey while growing its retail presence in markets like Germany and Australia. It aims to double overseas sales to over 800,000 units in 2025. However, rising regulatory risks—especially in Europe, where the EU is investigating Chinese EV subsidies—pose potential hurdles.
BYD's net profit jumped 34% in 2024 to RMB 40.25 billion, while revenues rose 29% to a record RMB 777.1 billion ($107 billion).
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for both Tesla and BYD's 2025 earnings suggests year-over-year improvement. However, the consensus mark for TSLA has declined over the past 30 days, whereas the same for BYD has risen.
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Tesla is trading at a forward sales multiple of 7.08X, above its median of 6.62X over the last two years. Tesla has a Value Score of F. Meanwhile, BYD has a Value Score of B, with its forward sales multiple at 0.95X.
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Given the current landscape, BYD appears better positioned than Tesla. BYD's strong domestic leadership, expanding international presence, cost advantages through vertical integration, charging efficiency and autonomous technology make it a better choice. Plus, BYD's more attractive valuation and positive earnings revisions offer additional upside potential.
Meanwhile, Tesla is grappling with slowing sales, shrinking margins and leadership distractions. Tesla's non-automotive segments are doing well but they make up a relatively small portion of the company's total revenues. Tesla's high valuation and southbound estimate revisions further dim confidence.
While BYD currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold), Tesla carries a Zacks Rank #4 (Sell).
You can see the complete list of today's Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report
Tesla, Inc. (TSLA) : Free Stock Analysis Report
Byd Co., Ltd. (BYDDY) : Free Stock Analysis Report
This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).
Zacks Investment Research
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Analysts Look to Tesla's Robotaxi Launch After Stock Hit From Musk-Trump Spat
Tesla is expected to launch its autonomous ride hailing service later this month, perhaps as soon as this week. The company has yet to confirm or deny a report from Bloomberg that it is targeting a June 12 launch for the robotaxi. The EV maker's stock could use a lift after a week marked by a spat between CEO Elon Musk and President (TSLA) is expected to launch its robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, as soon as this week, with the electric vehicle maker's stock in need of a lift after a week marked by political strife between CEO Elon Musk and President Trump. The stock rebounded nearly 4% to close just above $295 Friday, after tumbling 14% on Thursday. They've lost roughly one-quarter of their value since the start of the year. Tesla bulls believe a robotaxi program could drive substantial upside in the company's stock. Bloomberg last month reported that Tesla was targeting a June 12 launch, citing a person familiar with the matter, adding that the date could change. The company has not confirmed that date, and Tesla did not respond to Investopedia's request for comment in time for publication. Musk said in last month's earnings call and a May 20 interview with CNBC that the company was still on track to launch the program by the end of the month. The start of the program, Musk told CNBC, will likely be about 10 Model Y vehicles operating autonomously, with the company later expanding to more vehicles and cities. Tesla owners will eventually be able to add their vehicle to the available fleet of Teslas to rent for a ride, Musk has said, which could help Tesla scale the project before the Cybercab goes into production next year. Oppenheimer analysts recently wrote that the company's ability to get its software to drive fully autonomously with its current suite of cameras could be "key to its technology leadership and stock performance," but added they believe it might take at least one or two more hardware and software updates before Tesla can deliver reliable autonomous performance. More bullish analysts, like Wedbush's Dan Ives, have said they think successful autonomous driving software will be the start of technology that will eventually add $1 trillion in value to the company. Overall, analysts are somewhat divided on Tesla's stock, with 10 of the brokers tracked by Visible Alpha giving the stock a "buy" rating, with four "hold" and four "sell" ratings. Their average price target is about $304, slightly above Friday's closing level, but their price targets range from as low as $120 to as high as $500. Read the original article on Investopedia
Business Insider
27 minutes ago
- Business Insider
The advice Elon Musk's lawyer gives his high-profile clients in times of crisis
High profile attorney Alex Spiro has one key piece of advice for clients wading through tricky times: Don't panic. The words of wisdom were shared as one of his most high-profile clients, Elon Musk, is in the midst of a public feud with President Donald Trump. It's unclear if or how the attorney is guiding him through this particular debacle. The lawyer, who has also represented Alec Baldwin, Mayor Eric Adams, and Jay-Z, through muddy legal waters, shared the advice he gives to clients during times of crisis at the Forbes Iconoclast Summit on Thursday. "You got to get people to take a breath and not panic," Spiro said, adding that it's easier for some people to do so more than others. A source close to Spiro got more specific. Those who know him know that his No. 1 piece of advice is to "have an ice-cream cone." In other words, step away from the keyboard and cool off. "Nothing is better than chocolate ice cream," the source close to Spiro said. The attorney isn't certain whether clients listen to the advice, but they at least pretend to, the source said. Spiro, who spends a good chunk of his time on risk mitigation, told the Iconoclast Summit attendees that he tries to get clients to put their situation into perspective and focus on the facts and evidence in front of them. "The sky is not falling," Sprio said. "The things that we think are a big deal today won't be a big deal in a month." While most CEOs aren't publicly blasting the president on social media, many are navigating global and economic uncertainty, from looming tariffs to market volatility. Spiro said the best CEOs and CFOs he knows know how to take a "methodical" approach to uncertainty, which in the case of tariffs, would involve looking into their supply chains and preparing for what may happen next. "I try to follow and steal the best ideas from the smartest people I know and then tell others about it," Spiro said. "That works out usually." Musk is one of those people. Spiro said on Thursday that Musk likes to cut costs during times of uncertainty because it leaves organizations more nimble on the other side. The billionaire is most recently known for doing so in the government, where he led efforts to slash about 20,000 federal employees, or about 1% of its workforce. Musk also laid off 10% of Tesla's workforce in waves last year and cut Twitter's workforce in half after he purchased it in 2022.
New York Times
40 minutes ago
- New York Times
Trump-Musk Spat Creates More Problems for Tesla
Elon Musk's bitter falling-out with President Trump could be costly for Tesla. As long as he is persona non grata in the Trump administration, Mr. Musk, the chief executive of Tesla, will struggle to persuade Republicans not to gut climate policies worth billions of dollars to the electric car and battery company. Mr. Musk may also lose sway over federal regulators who could make or break his plans to deploy driverless taxis, which he has described as the future of the company. Tesla is already suffering steep declines in sales and profit. The company's share price plummeted 14 percent on Thursday, its biggest one-day decline, after Mr. Musk and Mr. Trump began insulting each other on social media. The stock recovered somewhat Friday, rising nearly 4 percent, perhaps on hopes that the men would reach a truce or because investors thought the stock was now a bargain after the previous day's drop. There was always a disconnect between Mr. Musk and his Republican allies on electric cars. The domestic policy bill passed by House Republicans and being considered by the Senate will hurt the electric car market in the United States, where Tesla is the largest manufacturer by far. The bill would eliminate tax credits of up to $7,500 for people who buy electric cars. It would quickly phase out subsidies for battery factories and lithium refineries, and end financial support for electric vehicle charging stations. The bill imposes an annual fee of $250 on electric vehicle owners that environmental groups say is punitive. Those measures would hurt all carmakers that sell electric vehicles. But the Trump administration and Republicans in Congress are also trying to kill regulations that are especially beneficial to Tesla. Those rules allow Tesla to sell clean air credits to other carmakers that fail to meet environmental standards. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
