Commentary: Gaza ceasefire talks collapse – what does that mean for the humanitarian catastrophe?
Both the United States and Israel have withdrawn their negotiating teams, accusing Hamas of a 'lack of desire to reach a ceasefire'.
US President Donald Trump's special envoy Steve Witkoff says it would appear Hamas never wanted a deal: 'While the mediators have made a great effort, Hamas does not appear to be coordinated or acting in good faith. We will now consider alternative options to bring the hostages home and try to create a more stable environment for the people in Gaza.'
The disappointing development coincides with mounting fears of a widespread famine in Gaza and a historic decision by France to formally recognise a Palestinian state.
French President Emmanuel Macron says there is no alternative for the sake of security of the Middle East: 'True to its historic commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East, I have decided that France will recognise the State of Palestine.'
What will these developments mean for the conflict in Gaza and the broader security of the Middle East?
HUMANITARIAN CATASTROPHE
The failure to reach a truce means there is no end in sight to the Israeli siege of Gaza which has devastated the territory for more than 21 months.
Amid mounting fears of mass starvation, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese says Gaza is in the grip of a 'humanitarian catastrophe'. He is urging Israel to comply immediately with its obligations under international law: 'Israel's denial of aid and the killing of civilians, including children, seeking access to water and food cannot be defended or ignored.'
According to the United Nations Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA, more than 100 people – most of them children – have died of hunger. One in five children in Gaza City is malnourished, with the number of cases rising every day.
Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini says with little food aid entering Gaza, people are 'neither dead nor alive, they are walking corpses … most children our teams are seeing are emaciated, weak and at high risk of dying if they don't get the treatment they urgently need'.
The UN and more than 100 aid groups blame Israel's blockade of almost all aid into the territory for the lack of food.
Lazzarini says UNRWA has 6,000 trucks of emergency supplies waiting in Jordan and Egypt. He is urging Israel – which continues to blame Hamas for cases of malnutrition – to allow the humanitarian assistance into Gaza.
PROPOSED CEASEFIRE DEAL
The latest ceasefire proposal was reportedly close to being agreed by both parties.
It included a 60-day truce, during which time Hamas would release 10 living Israeli hostages and the remains of 18 others. In exchange, Israel would release a number of Palestinian prisoners, and humanitarian aid to Gaza would be significantly increased.
During the ceasefire, both sides would engage in negotiations toward a lasting truce.
While specific details of the current sticking points remain unclear, previous statements from both parties suggest the disagreement centres on what would follow any temporary ceasefire.
Israel is reportedly seeking to maintain a permanent military presence in Gaza to allow for a rapid resumption of operations if needed. In contrast, Hamas is demanding a pathway toward a complete end to hostilities.
A lack of mutual trust has dramatically clouded the negotiations.
From Israel's perspective, any ceasefire must not result in Hamas regaining control of Gaza, as this would allow the group to rebuild its power and potentially launch another cross-border attack.
However, Hamas has repeatedly said it is willing to hand over power to any other Palestinian group in pursuit of a Palestinian state based on the 1967 borders. This could include the Palestinian National Authority (PNA), which governs the West Bank and has long recognised Israel.
SUPPORT FOR A PALESTINIAN STATE
Israeli leaders have occasionally paid lip service to a Palestinian state. But they have described such an entity as 'less than a state' or a 'state-minus' – a formulation that falls short of both Palestinian aspirations and international legal standards.
In response to the worsening humanitarian situation, some Western countries have moved to fully recognise a Palestinian state, viewing it as a step toward a permanent resolution of one of the longest-running conflicts in the Middle East.
Macron's announcement France will officially recognise a full Palestinian state in September is a major development.
France is now the most prominent Western power to take this position. It follows more than 140 countries – including more than a dozen in Europe – that have already recognised statehood.
While largely symbolic, the move adds diplomatic pressure on Israel amid the ongoing war and aid crisis in Gaza.
However, the announcement was immediately condemned by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who claimed recognition 'rewards terror' and 'risks creating another Iranian proxy, just as Gaza became. A Palestinian state in these conditions would be a launch pad to annihilate Israel – not to live in peace beside it.'
ANNEXING GAZA?
A Palestinian state is unacceptable to Israel.
Further evidence was recently presented in a revealing TV interview by former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak who stated Netanyahu had deliberately empowered Hamas in order to block a two-state solution.
Instead there is mounting evidence Israel is seeking to annex the entirety of Palestinian land and relocate Palestinians to neighbouring countries.
Given the current uncertainty, it appears unlikely a new ceasefire will be reached in the near future, especially as it remains unclear whether the US withdrawal from the negotiations was a genuine policy shift or merely a strategic negotiating tactic.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Taiwan says reached 'a certain consensus' with US on tariffs
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Taiwan faces a 32 per cent tax and possible duties on semiconductor chips, which are a key driver of the democratic island's economy. Taipei - Taiwan has reached 'a certain consensus' with the United States on tariffs, a Taipei government official said July 31, but did not provide details on the agreed levy. US President Donald Trump has given Washington's trade partners until Aug 1 to reach an agreement with the White House or be hit with his threatened levies. Taiwan faces a 32 per cent tax and possible duties on semiconductor chips, which are a key driver of the democratic island's economy. 'We reached a certain consensus on issues including tariffs, non-tariff trade barriers, trade facilitation, as well as supply chain resilience and economic security,' Cabinet spokeswoman Michelle Lee said. She added that Taipei was 'still waiting for the US government's decision-making process to conclude'. 'Both sides have also conducted negotiations on a joint statement,' she said. 'We will report to the public once we have an update.' Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT's finances hit by 2024 EWL disruption; profit after tax for trains division dips 8% Asia US-Malaysia tariff deal set for Aug 1 after Trump-Anwar phone call Business Deepening S'pore-Latin America ties a matter of urgency amid global trade uncertainty: Alvin Tan Singapore Underground pipe leak likely reason for water supply issues during Toa Payoh fire: Town council Multimedia 60 years, 60 items: A National Day game challenge Life Milo tees, kaya toast pimple patches, crockery: Here are the SG60 merch to collect Singapore Driver in 2024 Tampines crash that killed 2 set to plead guilty in October Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' Several economies – the European Union, Britain, Vietnam, Japan, Indonesia and the Philippines – have struck initial tariff deals with Washington, while China managed to temporarily lower tit-for-tat duties. 'Our negotiators are literally working around the clock to strive to reach an agreement on reciprocal tariffs,' Taiwanese Vice-President Hsiao Bi-khim told journalists recently. She said Taipei wanted a trade deal with Washington that 'will benefit both sides'. 'The United States is indeed a very important trade partner for Taiwan,' she said. Washington also 'needs Taiwan in supporting resilient supply chains, in supporting manufacturing and some high-end technologies'. Mr Trump in April imposed a 10 per cent tariff on almost all US trading partners, while announcing plans to eventually hike this level for dozens of countries. But days before the steeper duties were due to take effect on July 9, he pushed the deadline back to Aug 1. Ms Lee said Taiwanese officials were 'continuing negotiations with the US side in Washington'. Taiwan is a global powerhouse in chip manufacturing and Trump has previously accused the island of stealing the US semiconductor industry. Soaring demand for AI-related chips in recent years has fuelled Taiwan's trade surplus with the United States – and put it in the cross-hairs of Trump's global tariff war. Around 60 per cent of Taiwan's exports to the United States are information and communications technology, which includes chips. To avoid Mr Trump's punitive tariffs, Taipei has pledged to increase investment in the United States, buy more of its energy and increase its own defence spending. AFP
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Ukraine's huge financing gap set to widen as war heats up and reforms stall
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskiy speaks during a press briefing following phone calls with U.S. President Donald Trump, amid Russia?s attack on Ukraine, in Kyiv, Ukraine, May 19, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Peter/File Photo KYIV - Ukraine's financing gap will widen significantly next year if Russia keeps up its intense attacks across the country and the government fails to act on demands for reform from foreign lenders, analysts say. The government spends most state revenues on the army and finances social and humanitarian spending with foreign aid, which state data shows has totalled $139 billion since Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022. Central Bank Governor Andriy Pyshnyi said that only about a third of the $65 billion needed for both 2026 and 2027 had been pledged, with talks underway on the rest. A poll of eight economists by the Centre for Economic Studies, a Kyiv-based think-tank, showed Ukraine will need between $39 billion - this year's sum - and about $58 billion in external financing for next year alone. The task is urgent. "A key challenge for the government now is to look for $10-15 billion in addition to that volume of aid which partners have already pledged for 2026," ICU, a Kyiv-based investment house, said in a research note. Those negotiations may become more difficult after Ukraine missed key targets agreed with lenders - including the appointment of judges and other key officials - and the president tightened control over the two main agencies investigating corruption. The move by President Volodymyr Zelenskiy sparked Ukraine's biggest wartime street protests and prompted strong criticism from Kyiv's European allies, who made it clear that strong anti-graft measures were key to the country's EU aspirations. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT's finances hit by 2024 EWL disruption; profit after tax for trains division dips 8% Asia US-Malaysia tariff deal set for Aug 1 after Trump-Anwar phone call Asia Malaysia PM Anwar says Trump to attend Asean Summit in October Singapore Underground pipe leak likely reason for water supply issues during Toa Payoh fire: Town council Multimedia 60 years, 60 items: A National Day game challenge Singapore Driver in 2024 Tampines crash that killed 2 set to plead guilty in October Life Milo tees, kaya toast pimple patches, crockery: Here are the SG60 merch to collect Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' Zelenskiy backtracked and has submitted a new draft law to parliament, vowing to restore the independence of institutions set up to root out corruption, even at the highest level. The vote on the draft bill is set for later on Thursday. But some damage has been done already, experts say. "Although Europe is unlikely to walk away from Ukraine, future financial and military support will likely come under much more scrutiny, leading to delays that Ukraine can ill afford," said Evghenia Sleptsova, senior economist at Oxford Economics. STALLED REFORMS To unlock the next tranches of multi-year lending programs from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund, Ukraine needs to make various reform steps which include hiring more judges to the highest anti-corruption court, overhauling the agency tasked with managing nationalised assets and appointing a head of the bureau for economic security. In the first quarter of this year, Ukraine failed to meet several funding targets under the four-year 50 billion-euro Ukraine Facility approved by the EU last year, two officials with knowledge of the matter said. In June, Ukraine requested 3 billion euros instead of the 4.5 billion euros it was meant to receive for the second quarter, they said. The economy ministry, a coordinator for the facility, said Ukraine was meeting all its obligations despite wartime challenges and expected a tranche worth about 3 billion euros in August. The ministry said it hoped to receive a 1.45 billion euro tranche at a later stage. Ukraine also has a $15.5 billion support program with the IMF and plans talks on a new lending program, officials say. Danylo Hetmansev, a lawmaker from the ruling party and the head of parliament's committee for taxes and finances, said the delays in meeting key reform targets were baffling. "I cannot say that among the uncompleted tasks there was anything extremely difficult or unmanageable," he said on the Telegram app. Officials say that the government is working to implement all required reform steps but some more complicated tasks require more time. Ukraine overhauled its government on July 17, appointing experienced technocrat Yulia Svyrydenko as the first new prime minister in five years to revitalise economic management. The economy grew 2.9% last year but for this year, the central bank has cut its forecast to 2.1% as hopes for a quick end to the war as predicted by U.S. President Donald Trump have faded. "While many of us have previously assumed that 2026 would be easier, we now anticipate that the war will continue into next year," said Oleksandra Betlyi, researcher from the Institute of Economic Studies in Ukraine. She cited mining and agriculture among economic weak spots. As Russian troops advance in the eastern Donetsk region, Ukraine has lost key assets, including the country's only coking coal mine near the besieged city of Pokrovsk. Russian strikes have also damaged Ukraine's gas production, Betlyi added. Trump set a new deadline on Monday of 10 or 12 days for Russia to make progress toward ending the war in Ukraine, threatening to impose new sanctions if it failed to do so. Analysts pointed out that Ukraine would be unable to cut its defence spending significantly next year, even if a ceasefire was agreed this year, given that its much larger neighbour Russia has hiked military spending to record levels. Ukraine will spend a record 2.6 trillion hryvnias ($62 billion) or about 31% of GDP on defence this year. REUTERS
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Trump set to attend Asean summit in October, Malaysian PM Anwar Ibrahim says
[KUALA LUMPUR] The US tariff rate on Malaysian goods will be announced on Friday (Aug 1), Malaysia's prime minister said on Thursday after speaking to US President Donald Trump. Anwar Ibrahim was speaking in parliament to table the country's new five-year economic plan. Anwar also said Trump confirmed that he would attend an Asean summit in October. REUTERS
