John Swinney at centre of fresh secrecy row after SNP's deleted Covid WhatsApp scandal
WIPE OUT John Swinney at centre of fresh secrecy row after SNP's deleted Covid WhatsApp scandal
JOHN Swinney is at the centre of a fresh secrecy row over the use of an app that automatically deletes content after five days.
A decision by the First Minister to allow the Microsoft Teams instant messaging service for Scottish Government business is being probed by Scotland's transparency watchdog.
Advertisement
3
First Minister John Swinney
Credit: Michael Schofield
3
Nicola Sturgeon was among those who deleted their WhatsApp messages
Credit: PA
It comes after Nats chiefs faced a huge backlash for scrubbing WhatsApp messages during Covid.
Critics blasted the latest tech move and said it provides a 'deliberate loophole'.
Scottish Tory finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: 'The SNP need to come clean on this state-sponsored automatic deletion of messages and why it is still being allowed.
'It looks as though a deliberate loophole has been left in place to allow senior figures to avoid scrutiny over key decisions. That is typical of this sleekit and secretive SNP government who only announced this apparent change in policy after already deleting Covid-related messages on an industrial scale.'
Advertisement
Information Commissioner David Hamilton confirmed the SNP's use to Teams messages forms part of an ongoing probe.
He said: 'This issue is currently subject of my investigation into how messaging apps are used in Scottish Government. It will be helpful to understand the rationale for such a short retention period and how compliance with any policies will be assured.
'Both will form part of my enquiries.'
In their new guidance, Nats chiefs say MS Teams chat is the 'core messaging functionality' of their internal system, allowing civil servants to 'message, call, screen share' others in the organisation.
Advertisement
Ministers say the chat function can be used for 'general day-to-day activities' with colleagues external stakeholders, as well as and 'urgent work communications'.
It is also allowed to be used with 'ministerial support or advice', including when ministers are in the Holyrood chamber.
Damning screenshots expose Jason Leitch's 'pre-bed WhatsApp ritual' during pandemic as SNP bosses branded 'shameful'
Civil servants and ministers can use the chat function for 'communication of urgent work issues' out of normal hours.
The change in rules means messages on government business, including advice to ministers or key discussions among senior civil servants, could be auto-deleted — potentially undermining any future inquiries into scandals.
Advertisement
It comes after Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes reconfirmed last month the ban on WhatsApp on government phones.
Former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon deleted Covid WhasApps despite telling Scots on TV that she would hand all of them over.
We told how mountains of messages between key ministers, including Ms Sturgeon, her successor Humza Yousaf, and Mr Swinney showed they joked about deleting the messages to avoid publishing them through transparency rules.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government's approach to Microsoft Teams is similar to the approach taken by UK Government departments.
Advertisement
'Microsoft Teams is a corporate system which operates under the direct control of the Scottish Government and in line with its published policies in respect of records management.
Jason Leitch, the National Clinical Director, also angered Covid bereaved groups for saying deleting his WhatsApps was a 'pre-night' ritual.
We also revealed in October how the UK's chief medical officers rallied round disgraced adviser Catherine Calderwood after her lockdown-busting trip to Fife, also revealed by The Scottish Sun.
3
Jason Leitch was at the centre of the covid WhatsApp row
Credit: Andrew Barr
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
39 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
UK Government to cut support for special educational needs
The latest concern is the UK Government's plans to cut support for special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) in English schools. In Scotland, SEND is akin to our funding for additional support needs (ASN) for children and young people in education. For every £1billion of cuts in England, the impact on the Scottish budget would be approximately £93million. READ MORE: 'Prime Glasgow gem' hits the market in 'rare opportunity' for buyers For example, when the Chancellor sought to remove the winter fuel payment (WFP) from most pensioners to save £1.5bn, this resulted in a consequential loss of £140m for Scotland. That policy was largely U-turned. English local authorities have accumulated a £3.3bn deficit in their 'high needs' education budgets, according to a report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies last December. Under English law, persons in education up to the age of 25 can seek education, health and care plans (EHCP) to identify the additional support required to meet their SEND at school. The number of EHCPs has increased annually since they were introduced, rising by 71% from 253,679 in 2018 to 434,354 last year, according to the Department for Education. The equivalent to EHCPs in Scotland is the coordinated support plan (CSP). Generally, children and young people with complex or multiple ASN will require a CSP. Last year, 248,448 pupils were recorded as having ASN in Scotland, including autism, dyslexia or a mental health problem, in contrast with 140,542 a decade ago. READ MORE: Cat found in minibus engine revealed as 'master escape artist' after this incident And yet, counter-intuitively, the number of pupils with a CSP dropped by nearly two-thirds. In 2014, there were 3128 pupils with a CSP, but this fell by 61% to 1215 last year. That's a reduction from 2.2% to 0.4% of those with additional support needs. If anything, these statistics strongly suggest there is a need for more funding and investment in ASN in Scotland. The possibility of Barnett formula cuts from the UK Government would make no sense at all. The House of Commons rises today for the summer recess. The White Paper on SEND reform in England was due to be published earlier this year, but has been delayed. We'll need to wait until the autumn to discover if these disability support cuts go ahead. Some of the possibilities mooted include restricting SEND support to those aged 18 or less. There might be a replacement of EHCPs altogether with something completely different. Wales has phased in a new additional learning needs (ALN) system. This is a single statutory scheme known as an individual development plan (IDP), designed to encourage collaboration with children and parents in the planning process. Only schools or local authorities can apply for IDPs, and not young people or their parents. READ MORE: Poundland bosses confirm Scottish store will close next month Scotland's ASN system is right to place children, young people and parents at its heart. Having a legal right to request a CSP enables the rights to additional support to become a reality in practice. It's unlikely Scotland would follow suit with the UK Government's policies here, but the potential for funding cuts must be a worry. That said, we've seen major U-turns on the WFP and the welfare reform bill in the last couple of months. Could Sir Kier Starmer's proposed SEND bill be the next big U-turn?
STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Government wasting taxpayers' money on DEI, Tories claim as total hits £20m
The Scottish Government have been accused of 'wasting taxpayers' money' on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) roles and training as it emerged almost £20m has been spent in five years. Figures released to the party through freedom of information legislation found £19.98m has been spent between 2019-20 and 2024-25 in the NHS, councils, universities, the justice system and by the Scottish Government itself. DEI practices – which aim to increase representation of marginalised groups and reduce discrimination – have been under attack across the world in recent years, fuelled by the opposition of politicians like US President Donald Trump. Spending increased from £2.1m to £3.7m over that period, peaking at £4.3m in 2023-24. The NHS spent the most, with the bill coming to £8.9m in total. The total spend, however, is likely to be higher, due to a number of bodies not responding to the information request. Tory deputy leader Rachael Hamilton accused the Government of 'prioritising ideological projects' over the issues Scots most care about. 'Hard-pressed Scots will be outraged that the SNP have squandered millions on woke DEI training and roles, when they are making savage cuts to vital public services,' she said. 'This is yet another example of the SNP prioritising ideological projects over the issues that people actually care about. 'It's difficult to justify this level of spending when the NHS remains in permanent crisis mode, educational standards are plummeting, and Scotland continues to have the highest drug death rate in Europe. 'It's no wonder Scots are fed up with left-wing politicians at Holyrood. They're wasting taxpayers' money like it's going out of fashion. 'Only the Scottish Conservatives, with Russell Findlay at the helm, are committed to taking a claymore to this culture of waste and championing common-sense policies that put people's priorities first.' The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment. Since Mr Findlay took over as the leader of the Scottish Tories last year, the party has shifted to include a more populist tone – as he pushes for 'common sense' policies in Scotland – as it seeks to ward off the threat of Nigel Farage's Reform UK before next year's Holyrood elections. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
New AI tool could speed up skin cancer diagnoses in remote areas
A researcher at a Scottish university has developed AI tools that could give people in remote areas of the world access to fast and potentially life-saving skin cancer diagnoses. Tess Watt, the PhD student at Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh who led the project to develop the technology, said it is intended to enable early detection of skin conditions anywhere in the world, and without the need for direct access to dermatologists. The technology also works without internet access. The system involves a patient taking a photograph of their skin complaint using a small camera attached to a Raspberry Pi device – a cheap, energy-efficient handheld computer that is capable of storing vast amounts of information. The photograph is analysed in real-time using the latest state-of-the-art image classification, comparing it to an enormous dataset of thousands of images stored on the device to reach a diagnosis. The findings are then shared with a local GP service to begin a suitable treatment plan. The project is understood to be the first of its kind to combine AI medical diagnosis with the aim of serving remote communities. Ms Watt explained: 'Healthcare from home is a really important topic at the moment, especially as GP wait times continue to grow. 'If we can empower people to monitor skin conditions from their own homes using AI, we can dramatically reduce delays in diagnosis.' A prototype of the device has already been demonstrated at Heriot-Watt's advanced health and care technologies suite. The research team said the tool is up to 85% accurate in its diagnostic capabilities, but they hope to increase this further by gaining access to more skin lesion datasets, aided by advanced machine tools. Ms Watt is also in talks with NHS Scotland to begin the ethical approval process for testing the technology in real-world clinical settings. 'Hopefully in the next year or two, we'll have a pilot project under way,' she said, noting medical technology often takes years to move from prototype to implementation. She added: 'By the time I finish my PhD, three years from now, I'd love to see something well into the pipeline that's on its way to real-world use.' The university said the long-term vision is to roll the system out first across remote regions of Scotland, before expanding to global areas with limited access to dermatological care. It added the technology could also offer vital support to patients who are infirm or unable to travel, allowing loved ones to assist with capturing and submitting diagnostic images to GPs. Ms Watt's academic supervisor, Dr Christos Chrysoulas, said: 'E-health devices must be engineered to operate independently of external connectivity to ensure continuity of patient service and safety. 'In the event of a network or cloud service failure, such devices must fail safely and maintain all essential clinical operations without functional degradation. 'While auxiliary or non-critical features may become temporarily unavailable, the core diagnostic and even therapeutic capabilities must remain fully operational, in compliance of course with safety and regulatory requirements. 'Ensuring this level of resilience in affordable, low-cost medical devices is the essence of our research, particularly for deployment in resource-limited settings and areas with limited or no connectivity, where uninterrupted patient care must still be guaranteed.' UK science and technology secretary Peter Kyle commented on the research, saying: 'Low-cost technology which could help detect skin cancer early and at home, without even the need for internet access, is an incredible example of AI's potential to break down barriers in healthcare and save lives. 'Promising, first of its kind research like this also demonstrates the crucial role UK innovators can play in improving the lives of people of all backgrounds, wherever they live, and makes clear the value of government investing in research to deliver our plan for change.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
