Gardaí must learn from shortfalls in Hawe case investigation, head of policing body says
Dr Elaine Byrne made the comments as part of an interview with
The Journal
this week about her role with the
Policing and Community Safety Authority (PCSA)
which she chairs. The body has replaced the Policing Authority and Garda Inspectorate.
In August 2016 Alan Hawe, a vice-principal, killed himself after murdering his 39-year-old wife Clodagh and their sons, Liam, 13, Niall, 11, and Ryan, six, at their home near Ballyjamesduff, Co Cavan.
Now Clodagh's sister Jacqueline Connolly has said a review of the Clodagh Hawe case should be published to provide a greater awareness of the behaviours of 'family annihilators'.
She has written a memoir called Deadly Silence to raise awareness of what happened. She claimed that the deaths were not initially investigated thoroughly by gardaí and she wants this approach changed.
She has said that there was not adequate collection of CCTV and digital evidence as well as follow up interviews with 20 key witnesses.
Byrne said that the PCSA has been focused intensely on a review of homicide investigations – which has been ongoing for a period of time.
'The Commissioner did initiate a homicide review where it showed that there were lapses in the investigation of a number of homicides.
Advertisement
'But that is a constant focus for us, and it's on our agenda, and we will be asking the Commissioner [Drew Harris] more questions,' she said.
Dr Elaine Byrne of the Policing and Community Safety Authority.
Niall O'Connor / The Journal
Niall O'Connor / The Journal / The Journal
Byrne paid tribute to Connolly for documenting what happened to the Hawe family.
'I think that Clodagh's sister Jaqueline, she's done a public service in allowing the public inside that very tragic event, moment by moment, and I think society will learn something from it, and the guards must learn something from it as well.
'I have read everything, all those extracts of her book, and it is something that we will be bringing those issues that she's outlined are issues broadly match our concerns in general, around the homicide review that the Commissioner initiated, and one that we will have a constant focus on,' she added.
Jacqueline Connolly, whose has written about the murder of her sister and her family by her husband Alan Hawe.
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Last week, in an interview on RTE radio, Connolly said that a second investigation carried out by the serious crime review team, authorised by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris in 2019, highlighted what was missed in the first investigation.
This included CCTV that had not been examined, digital evidence that was overlooked, and 20 key witnesses who needed to be re-interviewed using different techniques.
Connolly said she has been told gardaí in training will be advised to gather evidence in murder-suicides as though it is a case that will be prosecuted, but she said she wants that rolled out to all rural garda stations because officers were not prepared to 'find Clodagh and the boys like that'.
She called on Harris to release the findings of the serious crime review, for which Connolly has seen a summary, because she said it was important that the recommendations are seen by domestic violence institutions.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
3 days ago
- The Journal
Man deported from Ireland on Nigeria flight earlier this year wins appeal to return
A POULTRY FACTORY worker who was deported on a government charter flight to Nigeria earlier this year has been granted permission for asylum in Ireland, effectively overturning his deportation order. The man, aged in his 30s, has been granted the opportunity to receive international protection after Irish authorities accepted that he faced persecution and threats to his life due to being a gay man in his home country. It's believed to be among the first successful attempts by one of the people on that flight to successfully challenge their removal. The man in this instance was able to present fresh evidence to support the asylum claim, on the basis that he was considered a wanted criminal in Nigeria due to his sexuality. He has now been given 10 days to get a visa and make his own way back via 7,000 km flight to Dublin for a meeting at the International Protection office in Dublin to pick up his life where he left it two months ago. He and his solicitors have sought an extension from the Department of Justice to ensure he makes this meeting in time, as the man has faced delays accessing an appointment accessing an appointment for a visa to make the return journey. 'I need to get things arranged to get to Dublin in time, but I'm in Nigeria right now – what can I do. I had good friends in Ireland,' he told The Journal , adding that they had assisted him with witness statements offering character references to Irish immigration authorities. He was arrested for his deportation while getting ready for work at a Co Cavan farm more than two months ago, and believes his old role has since been filled. The man was one of the 35 passengers on the government charter flight who was forced to leave Ireland as part of the government's crackdown on asylum seekers. Three such deportation flights have taken place this year so far, the first time they have been used in well over a decade. He spoke on condition of anonymity, due to fears of local police attempting to arrest him in the coming days before his departure back to Ireland. 'I can't go outside because of the fear and of the threat,' he said. 'I'm afraid where I am, I'm not safe.' 'Wanted by Nigerian authorities' The decision to allow the man to stay in Ireland comes after the immigration authorities set aside an earlier ruling which found he had no right to stay in Ireland. Advertisement In the new decision issued last week, the International Protection Appeals Tribunal (Ipat) accepted that he is a gay man who has faced persecution because of his sexuality in Nigeria and has even been the subject of police bulletins seeking his arrest over his sexuality. The fresh Ipat report – seen by The Journal – outlined that it was presented with 'clear evidence' that the man is 'wanted by the Nigerian authorities' due to his relationship with another man over a decade ago. This included a police report into the man and a document outlining he had a 'criminal record' due to his previous same-sex relationship, only some of which had previously been available. Same-sex relationships are criminalised in Nigeria. The man's legal team from Ferry Solicitors in Dublin had argued that their client faces harsh treatment by Nigerian authorities due to the African state's ban on same-sex marriages, introduced 11 years ago. The man described to The Journal how the past few months had been a 'roller coaster', as he outlined the need to stay out of public view as much as possible in his native country. This man arrived in Ireland in 2020 and worked for most of the past five years in chicken farms in Co Cavan and Co Monaghan until his removal in June. Family members of his partner have long sought the man since their relationship was discovered. His solicitors pointed to online news reports on Nigerian websites seeking an update on the man's whereabouts, after people in the community discovered him and his partner were in a relationship. His partner was someone he knew from their schooldays but he has had no contact with him since. 'I think people in Ireland will find it difficult to believe that this could happen,' he said. 'My situation was true. What happened to me is in the internet and it's there in the police documentation. It's really, really difficult for me.' After initially fleeing Nigeria, the man first went to Italy. However, he ended up in Ireland due to fewer barriers to enter the Irish jobs market and, critically, because Ireland and Nigeria share the English as a common language. He explained: 'I was like, 'Okay, let me just go to a place where they are able to understand my story better. I can be able to express myself and all of that.'' But his initial attempts to claim asylum had faltered and were rejected due to a lack of documentation and a deportation order was issued last summer, before the new evidence could be presented to Irish authorities. The Department of Justice was contacted for comment and not respond in time for publication. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
3 days ago
- The Journal
'I'm leaving this country': Migrant workers call for immediate action in wake of attacks
MIGRANT WORKERS AND representatives from various organisations protested outside of the Department of the Taoiseach today, calling for immediate action from Government leaders in the wake of a spate of attacks against Indian people. Around 300 people turned out for the lunchtime protest, with some migrant workers telling The Journal that they plan to leave Ireland due to a rise in what one called 'subtle racism, and direct attacks'. The Indian Irish Society, the African Solidarity Centre Ireland and other organisations came together to deliver a letter to the Taoiseach Micheál Martin's office demanding immediate action in light of multiple assaults on Indian migrants that have been reported in the media in recent months. 'No one has taken responsibility. Due to the fear and anxiety caused by these incidents, one Indian cultural event has been cancelled,' the letter said, referencing the cancellation of the annual India Day celebration at Farmleigh House. They are asking for the attackers involved in these incidents to be prosecuted, for training for gardaí on how to handle racist attacks, and 'effective strategies against racism and hate crimes'. The Journal / YouTube One Indian tech worker, Abin, said that having lived and worked in Ireland for over two years, he now plans to leave within the next six months. 'It's the attacks and the fear, but it's also the subtle racism. I can work in other countries, I am just here to live abroad and get more experience for a while, just like Irish people who go to Australia in their twenties. 'Our demands as a community are very simple, we want to see gardaí deployed more in areas where there is a high incident rate of these racist attacks, including in areas like Tallaght. Many people are established here and it is not easy for them to leave, and they shouldn't have to,' Abin said. One Indian worker at the protest today held a sign that read 'I'm leaving this country'. Lassane Ouedraogo, the chair of the Africa Solidarity Centre Ireland, has been in Ireland for two decades. Today at the protest he said that he is also now planning to leave. Lassane told The Journal that he has been physically attacked over five times in Ireland, and that no one was ever persecuted in relation to the attacks. 'Each time you go to bed you are wondering what the next day will be like. You aren't sure that you will go to work safe and come back safe. If something happens, people are filming you, [there are] bystanders, the police take ages to come to your rescue. Advertisement 'Looking what happened on Sunday in Fairview with that man, his eyes were deeply cut,' Lassane said. The Journal / YouTube He added that his organisation and others have repeatedly called on the Government to strengthen legislation around hate crime and hate speech. Green Party Councillor Feljin Jose, who is a representative for Cabra-Glasnevin, said that bringing in stronger hate speech laws is one of the actions that the Government could have taken before now to protect the migrant communities of Ireland. The Journal / YouTube He also said that there has been a lack of action from senior government figures in response to the attacks against members of the Indian community. 'We've heard nothing from the Minister for Justice about it. I'm quite disappointed that he hasn't said anything at all. He's responsible for crime and safety laws, and he's said nothing.' He added that members of the Indian community are contacting him because they don't feel safe leaving the house anymore, and also that some are contacting him because they are worried for his safety as an Indian public representative. 'My parents are telling not to go out too late, not to get on the bus, it's sad actually,' Feljin said. 'Mates that I grew up with and went to school with are talking about leaving Ireland. These are people who have been in Ireland since they were 9 or ten-years-old. 'One of my friends is a healthcare assistant who cycles from appointment to appointment in Finglas, and he is being racially abused everyday. He wants to go and work in healthcare somewhere else.' Winifred, a Nigerian woman who has lived in Ireland for over two decades, who works in the Department of Foreign affairs, said that she went to the protest to show solidarity and speak out against the attacks that have been happening. 'On my break I have to go and protest. My colleagues don't hae to do that, but I don't feel safe anymore coming in and out of work,' she said. Tánaiste Simon Harris and Minister of State with responsibility for Migration, Colm Brophy met with members of the Indian community on Monday to discuss recent attacks on Indian citizens. Gardaí have said that the Garda diversity unit is working with the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland to address present concerns and that the force 'would like to reassure those of an ethnic or minority background that we are here to keep you safe'. It's understood that the Justice Minister plans to meet with Indian community groups this week. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
4 days ago
- The Journal
Two men charged in investigation into attempted murder of senior PSNI officer in Co Tyrone
TWO MEN HAVE been charged by detectives investigating the attempted murder of a senior PSNI officer in Co Tyrone in 2023. Detective Chief Inspector John Caldwell was seriously injured after being shot several times at a leisure centre in Omagh in February 2023. The attack happened while he was off duty and with his young son, packing up after coaching a youth football team. On Monday, the PSNI arrested two men in relation to the incident. Advertisement A 45-year-old was arrested in the Stewartstown area in Co Tyrone, and a 25-year-old man was arrested in west Belfast. They were detained under the Terrorism Act. In a statement tonight, the PSNI said both men have been charged with the Preparation of Terrorist Acts and Perverting the Course of Justice. They are due to appear at Dungannon Magistrates' Court tomorrow morning. Caldwell retired from the PSNI last December on medical grounds. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
