Transgender pool player Harriet Haynes suing governing body over ban
The transgender pool champion at the centre of angry protests over her playing in women's events is suing one of her sport's governing bodies for banning her from female-only competitions.
Harriet Haynes, who on Sunday won a professional women's tournament after beating another trans player in the final, is in court this week after taking legal action against the English Blackball Pool Federation (EBPF).
It follows an August 2023 change to the EBPF's eligibility criteria to allow only those born female to play on its ladies' tour and county tournaments, a move Haynes says amounted to discrimination that had caused her a 'loss of opportunity' and 'injured feelings'.
The rule change left Haynes, who first competed in an EBPF event as a woman in 2015, unable to play for the Kent ladies' team and she is seeking damages at Canterbury County Court.
What is thought to be the first lawsuit of its kind brought by a trans athlete in the UK could prove a landmark case in pool and beyond, over rules designed to stop those born male taking part in female-only competitions.
A hearing began on Monday, the day after Haynes and Lucy Smith faced off in the Ultimate Pool Women's Pro Series Event 2 at Robin Park Leisure Centre in Wigan on Sunday.
Their match drew protests from demonstrators who shouted 'He's a man and we stand with Lynne Pinches' and held up banners saying 'Save women's sport' and 'He's a man' as Haynes walked past.
Pinches is the player who forfeited a 2023 final in protest at the participation of Haynes and is part of a separate legal action against the Ultimate Pool Group and World Eightball Pool Federation over their refusal to ban trans women from their own events.
Credit: X / @JeanHatchet
The EBPF, meanwhile, argues those born male have, on average, a higher break speed than female-born players. It also claims that male-born players benefit from greater hand span, stronger fingers and longer limbs, making it easier for them to play particular shots.
The governing body is represented at this week's court hearing by Sarah Crowther KC, who told the proceedings on Monday that female-born players were, on average, at a disadvantage compared to those born male when it came to physical strength, stamina or physique.
She said: 'Therefore, it is commonplace for competitors to be categorised. All categories are trying to do the same thing – to group competitors by their bodily characteristics.
'The reality is that all sports are predominately male sports and there are very few where it can be said there is no sex-based advantage. Women have to fight to seek inclusion.
'If girls and women do not have their own teams, they will lack the development pathway into sports and will give up.
'All cue sports have protected women's categories because the physique of male players means that male players have an advantage over female players.'
Haynes told the court that 'my success in pool in general is down to my efforts, whether in the women's section or open section' and that 'coaching helped me progress'. She also said that 'a big part of my life was playing county ladies' blackball pool'.
Cross-examining Haynes, Crowther asked if she would accept the proposition that, on average, males had an advantage over females. Haynes responded that she 'wouldn't know enough about the subject', adding: 'I'm not an expert on it.'
Crowther also cited the fact that Haynes was able to play on the EBPF's Open Tour, which was previously known as its men's tour but was rebranded in light of trans women being banned from female-only events.
Haynes's barrister, Robin White, told the court the extent to which sports were gender-affected was on a sliding scale, saying: 'It would be easy to make the case that tennis is gender-affected, given that men are able to serve so much faster than women.
'On the other end of the spectrum is chess. I'm prepared to accept that pool is close to the boundary.'
Citing the Equality Act 2010, White said: 'A 'gender-affected activity' is a sport, game or other competitive activity where the physical strength, stamina or physique of average persons of one sex would put them at a disadvantage compared to average persons of the other sex.'
Haynes submitted expert evidence to support her case, including from an American professor who argues that as long as a player could break above a certain speed – something achievable by both sexes – there was no inherent advantage gained by a higher cue velocity.
The case continues.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
CBS Sports identifies Clemson's run game as what the Tigers must address for 2025 success
CBS Sports identifies Clemson's run game as what the Tigers must address for 2025 success Clemson enters the 2025 season with expectations as high as ever — and for good reason. The Tigers return more production than any team in college football, according to ESPN. Dabo Swinney also made rare moves in the transfer portal to strengthen the top of the depth chart and brought in former Indiana head coach Tom Allen to take over the defense. But despite the talent-laden roster, CBS Sports points to one remaining question: the run game. With Phil Mafah off to the NFL and Will Shipley gone as well, Clemson's backfield now features a less experienced group. Freshman Gideon Davidson, redshirt freshman David Eziomume, and third-year sophomore Jay Haynes — who is coming off a torn ACL — are expected to carry the load. Davidson enrolled early and impressed this spring, while Haynes averaged 6.9 yards per carry last season before the injury. Eziomume saw time in the Playoff but didn't record a touch. During the CFP semifinal loss to Texas, with Mafah limited and Haynes out, Adam Randall — a converted wide receiver — broke off a 41-yard run and finished with 44 yards on four carries. Jarvis Green and Keith Adams Jr. also saw light action, but the room enters 2025 unproven. Even with Cade Klubnik expected to lead one of the more pass-oriented Clemson offenses in recent years, offensive coordinator Garrett Riley will need short-yardage consistency if the Tigers are to contend for a national title. Clemson kicks off the season on August 30 against LSU (7:30 p.m., ABC), a matchup CBS cautioned LSU to approach with focus amid growing pressure on Brian Kelly and the Tigers to start fast after five straight season-opening losses. Contact us @Clemson_Wire on X, and like our page on Facebook for ongoing coverage of Clemson Tigers news and notes, plus opinions


USA Today
5 days ago
- USA Today
Notre Dame misses out on Zavion Griffin-Haynes, who commits to North Carolina
Notre Dame misses out on Zavion Griffin-Haynes, who commits to North Carolina The edge rusher will play with his brother instead of joining the Fighting Irish Notre Dame has missed out on a top recruiting target. The Fighting Irish had made an offer to edge rusher Zavion Griffin-Haynes in December, but Griffin-Haynes has committed to North Carolina, where he'll play alongside his brother Jayden, who has also committed to the Tar Heels. Jayden is a linebacker. Zavion had initially committed to North Carolina when Mack Brown was still the head coach. He reopened his recruiting after Brown was replaced by Bill Belichick, but has now reconfirmed that he'll be playing in Chapel Hill. 'It is great to be committed to North Carolina and to be going to the same school as my brother,' Zavion told On3 Sports. 'It came down to development, relationships and academics for me. I am planning to come in, work hard and play early.' Griffin-Hayes is coming out of Rolesville, N.C., which is under two hours from campus. He'll be playing close to home. Notre Dame, meanwhile, will continue trying to secure other commitments at the edge position. Contact/Follow us @IrishWireND on X (Formerly Twitter), and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Notre Dame news, notes, and opinions. Follow Tim on X: @tehealey


USA Today
24-05-2025
- USA Today
Nebraska football set to host a four-star edge defender
Nebraska football set to host a four-star edge defender Nebraska football is set to host 2026 four-star edge defender Zavion Griffin-Haynes for an official visit on June 13. This was reported by On3's Chad Simmons earlier this week. The edge defender is the 169th overall player in the 2026 class, the eighth overall player in the state of North Carolina, and the 17th overall player at his position, according to Rivals rankings. Griffin will visit Clemson on May 30, Michigan on June 6, Nebraska on June 13, and Florida State on June 20. He had 48 total tackles last season and 12.5 tackles for loss, according to statistics from He proved his worth as a pass-rusher as well, recording 20 quarterback hurries. The 2026 Nebraska football recruiting class has four commitments. That ranks 60th overall in the country according to team rankings. Griffin would give the Nebraska football program another talented edge defender that could rush the passer. He could fit well schematically in John Butler's defense. Contact/Follow us @CornhuskersWire on X (formerly Twitter), and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Nebraska news, notes, and opinions.