logo
‘Blackouts can happen anywhere': how power systems worldwide can collapse

‘Blackouts can happen anywhere': how power systems worldwide can collapse

The Guardian02-05-2025

Europe's biggest blackout in over 20 years on the Iberian peninsula unleashed hours of chaos for people in Spain, Portugal and parts of France earlier this week. But in the aftermath it has raised a common question for governments across the continent: could the same happen here?
Europe's political leaders and energy system operators have given assurances that such blackouts are extraordinarily rare, and that European power grids are some of the most stable in the world.
Yet energy experts have warned that although wide-scale blackouts may be rare, no grid is infallible. Prof Jianzhong Wu, the head of the school of engineering at Cardiff University, told the Guardian blackouts 'can happen anywhere'.
'Despite today's high standards of reliability, low-probability but high-impact blackout events can still happen. These networks are not designed to be completely blackout-free because achieving such a level of reliability would require investment far beyond what is economically feasible,' he said.
Charmalee Jayamaha, a senior manager at the UK government-backed Energy Systems Catapult, said: 'No system can be 100% resilient,' so risks 'need to be balanced with our willingness to pay to reduce them'.
If no power system is bulletproof, then what are the risks that could trigger a catastrophic blackout in any country? Here we look at the top reasons a power system might collapse.
Major power system collapses are frequently due to factors that are difficult to foresee or control.
Extreme weather events and natural disasters present a clear risk because storms, heatwaves and earthquakes can lead to devastating damage to critical national infrastructure. Lightning strikes and solar flares have also been known to damage vital equipment such as substations and power lines, which are crucial to maintaining the stability of the grid.
Early reports suggested that Spain's blackout had been caused by a 'rare atmospheric phenomenon' due to a sudden change in temperature, which may have destabilised the grid. But the grid operator, Red Eléctrica, later dismissed the theory.
Most outages due to natural disasters are easier to identify. In the US state of Texas, a series of three winter storms in early 2021 caused windfarms and gas power plants to freeze over, leaving 4.5m homes and businesses without power, some for several days.
The risk of these events is on the rise as the climate crisis increases the frequency and severity of extreme weather events.
Some blackouts are entirely human-made. Jayamaha said geopolitical factors and cyber-attacks had the potential to cause 'major interruptions' to the grid. Human error could also play a role.
After the Iberian blackout many questioned whether malevolent state actors had taken aim at the grid. However, Red Eléctrica was quick to insist there was no sign of an attack and later ruled the theory out.
Still, the risk of a cyber-attack on power grid infrastructure is 'not science fiction', according to the Dutch cybersecurity expert Dave Maasland. He told the Dutch press that 'attacks on power supplies are possible and have already caused disruptions in the past'. He pointed to Russia's attacks on Ukraine's power system in 2015 and 2016, and a failed attempt after its invasion in 2022.
In the most simple terms, a blackout is caused when the power system stops working: this can be due to an unexpected mechanical glitch involving power lines, substations or other grid infrastructure – or a more complex problem with how the system runs.
Sign up to Business Today
Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning
after newsletter promotion
A key concern to emerge after Spain's blackout is the role that renewable energy may have played in the system collapse. Without a clear explanation for the outage it is too soon to comment, experts have said.
What we know so far is that Spain's electricity system suffered two major generation losses in the solar-rich south-west of the country within seconds, which may have destabilised the grid connection between Spain and France, and ultimately led to a full loss of power across the energy system. The initial trigger remains under investigation.
It is true that a renewables-rich grid is more difficult to run than one powered by fossil fuels. This is because the grid was originally designed with big coal, gas and nuclear power plants in mind. These plants feature spinning turbines that create inertia on the system, which helps to maintain the grid's frequency at about 50Hz. Wind and solar farms do not create inertia on the grid, meaning that at times of high renewables output it can be more difficult to keep the frequency steady if there is a sudden loss of power. A significant fluctuation in frequency can cause generators to automatically disconnect, leading to a collapse of the system.
Jayamaha said the shift to renewables would require grid companies to invest in grid-stabilising technologies. 'The electricity grid is undergoing unprecedented change as we reduce our reliance on fossil fuels and move to solutions that are cheaper, better, and cleaner. This creates different resilience challenges that need to be managed,' she said.
'Resilience is no longer just about having enough spare megawatts you can simply switch on – but about the right mix of technologies and system capabilities to operate a grid with a lot more renewables.'
Kate Mulvany, a principal consultant at Cornwall Insight, said that in the UK, a key part of that effort had been the development of new balancing and system management tools, 'particularly the integration of grid-scale batteries, which play a vital role in maintaining stability'.
'The electricity system in GB is among the most reliable in the world. So, while a major blackout will always be possible, the extensive safeguards in place make it extremely unlikely,' she said.
In many cases, the risk factors outlined above can coincide, meaning relatively common or innocuous events can compound to create a cascading failure that leads to catastrophe. These 'black swan' events are nearly impossible to anticipate – meaning grid operators are under pressure to prepare for the unexpected.
In August 2019 the UK suffered its biggest blackout in over a decade, leaving almost 1 million people in England and Wales without electricity and hundreds of people stuck on trains for up to nine hours.
The blackout occurred after a lightning strike hit a transmission circuit north of London and managed to cause two electricity generators more than 100 miles apart to trip off the system within seconds of each other. It was described as an 'extremely rare and unexpected event' by the energy system operator.
Lightning strikes on energy infrastructure are relatively common, as are power plant outages, but the impact of the large double-outage on the grid's stability was severe enough to cause scores of small generators and batteries using incorrect safety settings to trip off the system and make it impossible for the operator to avoid a loss of power.
No single element in the event would cause a large-scale blackout on its own, but the combination proved devastating.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Canadian space firm unveils new Edinburgh office
Canadian space firm unveils new Edinburgh office

The National

time5 hours ago

  • The National

Canadian space firm unveils new Edinburgh office

PCI Geomatics, a leading firm in Earth observation, has opened its new office at the Future's Institute in the Scottish capital as it aims to become a key player in Scotland's space industry. PCI Geomatics, operating under the name Catalyst, gathers and analyses information about Earth's physical, chemical, and biological systems using remote sensing technologies and uses the data it collects to provide climate-related information. The Toronto-headquartered firm has more than 40 years of experience and joins more than 180 other companies that are already contributing to Scotland's satellite design and manufacturing industry. READ MORE: Scottish Government 'short-changed by £1bn' by Rachel Reeves, Finance Secretary says Business Minister Richard Lochhead welcomed the news as he said Scotland's space sector has grown at a 'phenomenal pace'. He said 'Scotland is well on the way to becoming a European leader in the space sector. PCI's arrival adds to Edinburgh's considerable reputation as a 'data capital' and takes us closer to our ambition to capture £4 billion of the global space market. 'The number of space-related organisations based in Scotland rose by 25% within a year, with the sector's total income increasing by 65%, demonstrating the phenomenal pace of growth and scale of opportunity before us. 'This is why the Scottish Government appointed its first ever Space Envoy, Daniel Smith, last year who is boosting Scotland's global standing and helping businesses forge strategic partnerships and identify new opportunities.' PCI said its business aligns 'strongly with Scotland's growing reputation' in space-enabled applications which includes more than 30 companies dedicated to observing and protecting Earth from space. The company is now recruiting for multiple roles in Scotland. PCI has also joined the industry body Space Scotland and participated in a recent Scottish Earth Observation showcase at the British Embassy in Denmark. President and CEO of PCI, June McAlarey, said she is excited to see the business expand into Scotland. She said: 'Scotland's rising profile in the global space economy has been unmistakable. When exploring locations to complement our Canadian headquarters, the UK quickly stood out as a strategic gateway to Europe and the Middle East. 'We now have a growing team across the UK and are excited to expand our Scottish office in the coming weeks.' Dr. Craig Brown, investment director at the UK Space Agency, also welcomed the news as he said Earth observation technology is vital to keeping the world safe. He said: 'Scotland's space sector attracts significant levels of private investment and is playing an important role in unlocking the value of space data for the wider economy. 'We welcome the presence of international companies like PCI as a key driver of innovation, expertise and creation. 'This new development supports our commitment to grow the space economy across the whole of the UK and to advance Earth observation technology, which is a vital tool for protecting our planet.'

Polar bear remains donated to National Museum of Scotland
Polar bear remains donated to National Museum of Scotland

Edinburgh Reporter

time14 hours ago

  • Edinburgh Reporter

Polar bear remains donated to National Museum of Scotland

The body of the UK's oldest polar bear has been donated to the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh for scientific research. Polar bear Victoria died last month aged 28, at her home at the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland's (RZSS) Highland Wildlife Park near Aviemore. The wildlife conservation charity's experts carried out an on-site post mortem, which established that the 400kg bear had 'advanced arthritis in her limbs and spine'. Victoria's blood, tissue, ovaries, serum and liver have now been preserved for research by RZSS and other organisations, while her body was transported to Edinburgh for National Museums Scotland. The Museum's previous research on bear skeletons, conducted to establish the effect of arthritis on limbs, had informed end-of-life care for Victoria. An RZSS spokesman said: 'We undertake postmortem examinations of all our animals on site as standard. With Victoria we were able to establish that she had advanced arthritis in her limbs and spine. 'Various blood, tissue and organ samples have been preserved for research by RZSS, while her remains are now in the collections of National Museums Scotland.' Dr Nick Fraser, Keeper of Natural Sciences at National Museums Scotland, said: 'Our natural science collections form an invaluable resource for current and future researchers in Scotland and across the world. 'The development of a collection such as ours over centuries enables scientists to study developments in animal populations over those periods, and to apply new techniques as they emerge to learn more.' Victoria was born at Rostock Zoo in Germany on 12 December 1996, and had her first cub, a female named Malik, in 2008 at Aalborg Zoo in Denmark. She was transported to the Highland Wildlife Park in 2015 as a mate for resident male Arktos. They produced the UK's first polar bear cub in 25 years in December 2017. The cub, named Hamish, went to live with a group of other young males at Yorkshire Wildlife Park in November 2020, just weeks before his third birthday. Her third and last cub, Brodie, born in 2021, remains at the Highland Wildlife Park. The decision for Victoria to be 'put to sleep' was taken following advice from RZSS vets, 'taking into account her quality of life and wellbeing'. Keepers said 28 years-old was the equivalent of her being in her 90s in human years. Following her death, RZSS said in a statement: 'With only a small percentage of polar bears living past 18 in the wild, at 28, Victoria's age is testament to the world class care she received from her keepers and veterinary team. 'She leaves an incredible legacy through her cubs who play an essential role in the European breeding programme, which ensures a healthy and genetically diverse population of these bears living in human care.' Credit RZSS Like this: Like Related

UK weather: Exact date for 30C 'Iberian plume' heat blast as maps turn deep red
UK weather: Exact date for 30C 'Iberian plume' heat blast as maps turn deep red

Daily Mirror

time17 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

UK weather: Exact date for 30C 'Iberian plume' heat blast as maps turn deep red

The 'Iberian plume' will bring a warm and humid air mass to the UK this week, fresh from southern Spain where temperatures soared to 43C on Sunday, according to forecasters The UK is bracing for a dramatic end to the week as a blast of searing air from the Iberian Peninsula could push temperatures to their highest so far this year. The 'Iberian plume' will bring a warm and humid air mass - fresh from southern Spain where temperatures soared to 43C in Andalucía on Sunday. The heat blast is set to kick off midweek, with temperatures on Wednesday expected to reach 25C to 27C across central, southern and eastern England, with low 20Cs elsewhere. But the real shift will occur on Friday, June 13, according to Netweather. Forecast models show the mercury potentially reaching a scorching 30C in London and parts of East Anglia - making it the hottest day of the week. ‌ ‌ Elsewhere across England and Wales, temperatures are set to climb into the mid to high 20Cs. Scotland and northern regions won't escape the warmth entirely, but things will be a little cooler, with highs around 20C. But despite the upcoming heat, a thunderstorm risk looms large throughout the latter half of the week. From Wednesday evening, storms are expected to begin rumbling into the southwest, with two waves of thundery action forecast. The first will move across Devon and Cornwall overnight into Thursday, followed by a second line of heavy rain and storms sweeping northeast during Thursday morning. While these will lose some strength as they move further north, another burst of activity could spark more chaos on Friday evening and overnight. Forecasters say a pulse of warm air arriving from the south on Friday could combine with a passing cold front and generate more widespread thunderstorms, especially across southeast England and East Anglia. The Met Office echoed the warning, saying it will be 'very warm and humid on Thursday and Friday with the risk of some heavy and thundery downpours developing.' By Saturday, the outlook is for further heavy rain in places, but it will begin to feel fresher from the south. Met Office Deputy Chief Meteorologist, Mike Silverstone, said: 'After largely benign weather early in the week, some intense, thundery showers will move in on Wednesday evening. These thunderstorms are being triggered by some warm, humid air that is moving into the UK from the south. "The intense rainfall could see 20-40mm accumulating over just a few hours, which could cause some disruption. While there are no severe weather warnings issued at the moment, it is possible thunderstorm warnings may be issued this week.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store