Trial begins for man accused of murdering pregnant Amish woman
Shawn Cranston, 53, of Corry, is facing charges of criminal homicide for the death of both 23-year-old Rebekah Byler and her unborn baby.
According to court paperwork, the trial of 53-year-old Shawn Cranston was delayed after it was expected to start in March, citing new information in the case.
The Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office will be prosecuting the case at the Crawford County courthouse.
Monday, we heard testimony from Andy Byler, Rebecca's husband, along with the first trooper on scene and a forensic state trooper. During opening statements, we also learned a possible motive of burglary.
Andy Blyer testified that when he came home from work on February 26, 2024, his two children, ages 2 and 3 came running out outside to tell him someone had killed their mom.
Andy said he didn't believe them… until he walked up to the door and saw Rebecca's white hat on the floor next to her legs.
The jury was then shown a crime scene photo of Rebecca on the floor. Those photos were not shown to the courtroom .
Andy said that after discovering Rebecca's body, his driver, Julie, stayed with his kids while he drove Julie's truck to the neighbors to tell them what happened. He then drove back to his house and stayed in the driveway until state police arrived. He never went inside his house.
Andy was then asked about a strange incident. He said two weeks before Rebecca's murder, someone came to the house around 10 or 11 o'clock at night. Andy said he got out of bed and went to the door with a flashlight and saw a white man with a bald head and beard walking up to the door. The man said he wanted to buy the Byler's house, but he'd be back the next day. He never came back.
When asked if that person was in the courtroom, Andy said, 'I think he's sitting over there,' referring to 53-year-old Shawn Cranston.
Andy told the court that after the murder, he noticed his safe was missing from the house.
The first Trooper on the scene told the jury about walking into the Bylers' home and finding Rebecca on her back, with a large laceration to her throat, a wound near her hairline and her head in a pool of blood.
The Forensic Trooper testified about finding Rebecca's body in the living room area with a bullet hole in her left temple and a suspected knife wound to the neck.
He also testified about other evidence, like shoe prints and tire impressions found at the crime scene, along with a small piece of a latex glove found in the Byler's trash.
Tuesday, Julie Warner, Andy Byler's driver, is expected to take the witness stand. We're being told the jury will hear the recording of the 911 call she made to report Rebecca's murder.
Related Stories:
Trial for man accused of killing pregnant Amish woman pushed to 2025
2024 Amish murder case transferred to Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office
New information takes center stage in Rebekah Byler murder trial
Daughter of arrested suspect reacts to pregnant Amish woman murder case
List of seized items released in pregnant Amish woman homicide case
Murdered Amish woman suffered injuries to head, neck: investigators
Community remains in shock following Amish woman's death, Corry man's arrest
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Emmanuel Haro Case: Authorities Seize Dad's Vehicle Amid Investigation
Originally appeared on E! Online Authorities are sharing updates on the search for Emmanuel Haro. Nearly one week after Rebecca Haro reported her 7-month-old son's kidnapping from a California parking lot, the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department confirmed that they had seized a car from the family. The Sheriff's Department told E! News that detectives had collected husband Jake Haro's car on Aug. 19 as evidence amid the ongoing investigation, following "inconsistencies" in Rebecca's story. E! News has reached out to Jake's attorney for comment and has not yet heard back. Rebecca alleged that she was attacked in a Big 5 Sporting Goods store parking lot in Yucaipa, about 70 miles east of Los Angeles, on Aug. 14, while changing Emmanuel's diaper. "I took him out of the car seat and laid him on the chair," she told NBC Los Angeles on Aug. 17. "I had his diapers here, and someone said, 'Hola.' I couldn't turn, and I don't remember nothing. I got up from the floor and didn't see my child. Someone took him from me." More from E! Online Blac Chyna and Dream Kardashian Are the Ultimate Mother-Daughter Duo in Rare Photos Teen Mom's Jenelle Evans Speaks Out After Son Jace Shares Explosive Text Messages Kirsten Dunst Shares Update on Her and Jesse Plemons' 4-Year-Old Son After Health Scare As the search for her and Jake's infant began, authorities raised eyebrows at Rebecca's recollection of the alleged attack. "Investigators interviewed multiple individuals, including Emmanuel's parents Jake and Rebecca Haro," the Sheriff's Department shared in an Aug. 16 press release. "During those interviews, Rebecca was confronted with inconsistencies in her initial statement and declined to continue with the interview." Authorities noted that due to the information they'd received, "investigators are unable to rule out foul play in the disappearance of Emmanuel." A closer look at the Haro household uncovered Jake's June 2023 felony conviction for child cruelty from a 2018 arrest, according to Riverside County Superior Court records obtained by The Orange County Register. He was ultimately sentenced to 180 days in jail and 48 months of probation. Despite authorities sharing that Rebecca "declined to continue with the interview" in connection with Emmanuel's disappearance, per the county's press release, Jake's legal counsel Vincent Hughes asserted that his client is more than willing to work with officials. "I'm telling you right now, Ashleigh, on national news," he told Ashleigh Banfield on NewsNation's Banfield Aug. 19, "if the San Marino County Sheriff's Department would like to speak with Jake Haro, we can make that happen tonight. I'm telling you that." For more information on other disappearances, keep reading. JonBenét RamseyNicole Brown Simpson & Ron GoldmanTupac ShakurNotorious AnthonyElizabeth Short a.k.a. The Black DahliaAndrew Borden & Abby BordenJack the RipperThe Chicago Tylenol MurdersThe Zodiac Killer For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Detectives search home of parents who claim 7-month-old baby was kidnapped
Detectives descended on the home of a California couple who claim their 7-month-old baby was kidnapped last week, looking for answers in the mysterious case as unsettling new details emerged about their past. The search for baby Emmanuel Haro intensified over the weekend, days after his mother Rebecca Haro reported he had been abducted from a Big 5 Sporting Goods parking lot in Yucaipa. San Bernardino County sheriff's investigators searched the Cabazon home of Rebecca and the baby's father Jacob 'Jake' Haro on Sunday. A spokesperson for the department confirmed to The Independent that the home was searched with K9 units but declined to say what investigators recovered. She added that investigators are continuing the search for Emmanuel and are looking into everything and everyone. She confirmed that authorities have not ruled out foul play. Rebecca Haro initially told authorities that while she was changing Emmanuel's diaper outside her vehicle on August 14, a man attacked her and knocked her unconscious. When she came to, she said, the baby was gone. A search was launched and investigators interviewed the parents but said the pair stopped cooperating after being confronted with inconsistencies in her story. Family members told KTLA that deputies asked Rebecca to take a lie detector test, while Jake refused until they obtained an attorney. Meanwhile, Emmanuel's grandmother, Mary Beushausen, insisted the parents would not harm their son. She told KTLA that Rebecca had turned off her phone after receiving death threats, and that Jake was also not answering calls. Investigators have since removed the couple's 2-year-old child from the home pending the investigation. Adding to the scrutiny are revelations about Jake Haro's criminal history. Court records show he was convicted of willful child cruelty in 2023 following a case in which his infant daughter with a previous spouse suffered multiple severe injuries, including a skull fracture, brain hemorrhage, and broken ribs. Both Jake and his then-wife, Vanessa Avina, pleaded guilty. Jake was sentenced to 180 days in a sheriff's work-release program and ordered into a child abuser treatment program. Doctors who treated the child in that case wrote in a sworn affidavit that the injuries were 'indicative of abuse head trauma, child physical abuse and nutritional neglect.' The Uvalde Foundation for Kids, which had offered a $5,000 reward for information, pulled its support less than a day later, citing inconsistencies in the parents' story. Rebecca, who had previously made emotional public pleas for Emmanuel's return, has since retained legal representation along with her husband. Their phone numbers were removed from missing-person flyers, and relatives say the couple is no longer answering calls. As of Monday, investigators were again seen searching the Haro property, KTLA reported. Officials have not announced any arrests or charges. Emmanuel, who weighs about 20 pounds, has light brown wavy hair and was last seen wearing a black Nike onesie, according to the Sheriff's Department.
Wall Street Journal
5 days ago
- Wall Street Journal
‘Smoke and Mirrors' Review: A Magician, a Murder and a Mystery
First impressions often hide the full story in 'Smoke & Mirrors,' a debut mystery novel for middle-grade readers by Rosalyn Ransaw. Andy, our 12-year-old narrator, has been blamed for accidentally burning down a barn with a firecracker. The residents of the small Midwestern town where he is spending the summer readily accept this version of events, but the truth is more complicated. Andy has taken the fall because, as the only black kid in town, he thinks no one will believe him that a white boy was actually responsible for the damage. As punishment Andy must help the barn's owner, the cantankerous Mr. Gilbert, repair a dilapidated old house that once belonged to the Red Knave, a famous magician of the 1960s. The secretive masked performer used to stage magic shows on the property, drawing crowds eager to witness his illusions—until a man was murdered following one of his performances. Afterward, the Red Knave vanished. Though the police always suspected he was responsible for the death, no one ever cracked the case. Andy knows there must be more to the story. 'If there was one thing people were good at,' he thinks, 'it was assuming people were guilty because it was easier than doing the work of figuring out the truth.' He decides to investigate the decades-old murder, even if it means accepting the help of a local boy he is not entirely sure he trusts. 'Smoke & Mirrors' leans heavily on a classic whodunit setup as Andy and his sidekick work their way through a list of suspects and motives. Readers might crave more detail as the book builds toward its rapid-fire conclusion—a big reveal about the Red Knave's identity is glossed over far too quickly. Ms. Ransaw focuses instead on Andy's private, more nuanced motives for solving the mystery of the Red Knave: curiosity, yes, but also a keen sense of injustice. His father is in prison awaiting his parole hearing, and after Andy's own run-in with the police, he feels that no one is giving his family a fair chance. By solving the Red Knave case, Andy hopes he can get people to reconsider their first impressions—of the magician, and also of himself.
