Israel and the Palestinians: The Road to 7th October review – deserves nothing but praise
The producer of this film, Norma Percy, has taken a more modern approach. Percy's strongest skill as a documentary-maker has always been her ability to secure access to the people who matter, such as Gerald Ford for 1994's Watergate series and Slobodan Milošević for 1995's The Death of Yugoslavia. Given that the authors of the Balfour declaration – a letter written by the British government in 1917 supporting the creation of a Jewish homeland – are all long dead, Percy has decided to venture back only two decades.
Her chronicle opens on 19 August 2003, the day a Palestinian suicide bomber killed 23 Israelis on a bus in Jerusalem. The attack, along with Israel's retaliatory missile strikes on Gaza, effectively froze the international community's hopeful Roadmap for Peace plans and threw the future of the region into disarray. We pick up at a time of great tension.
By its nature, Israel and the Palestinians is a sober, but compelling, watch. Percy presents a cast of powerful players from all sides who mostly want the same thing, but – thanks to a combination of political grandstanding, hubris and frustration – repeatedly snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
There is Israel's former prime minister Ariel Sharon, who planned to give Gaza back to the Palestinians, but whose approach to diplomacy led to wide mistrust and fury (we are shown how he neglected to engage with Palestinian leaders or his own government's rightwingers over his disengagement plan). There is Mahmoud Abbas, the former prime minister of the Palestinian National Authority who tried to run a free election, but, at the first sign that he might lose it, we are told, covertly asked Israel to help derail it. There is Ehud Olmert, the former Israeli prime minister and perhaps the figure who came closest to implementing a lasting two-state solution, complete with a shared Jerusalem; he found himself undone by corruption charges. This sort of thing happens time and time again – an uneasy peace is tentatively scratched out, only to collapse at the last moment.
And then there is Benjamin Netanyahu. Episode one covers the five years to 2008, so his time on screen will grow in episodes two and three, but nevertheless he spends the first hour looming in the periphery. When Sharon announced his disengagement plan, footage shows that it was Netanyahu who jeered the loudest. When Olmert imploded, the documentary lays out that it was Netanyahu who stood to gain most. Next will come clashes with the White House, the UN and his own people. The road to 7 October, Percy suggests, is about to get much uglier.
It is easy to look at this series with the benefit of hindsight. It presents us with the temptation to view every fork in the road with dismay, as if every wrong turn was diametrically opposed by a hypothetical decision that could have led to peace and prosperity; if only one person had thought things through a bit more thoroughly, or been more willing to compromise – even, in the case of Olmert, better at sharing his paper map with people – then the events of the last year and a half would have never come to pass. Clearly, things are too complicated for that to be true; the wounds are too deep and the strength of feeling too raw for anyone to simply finger-click things back into shape, no matter how much everyone wants that to happen.
However, there is a heft to this series that you don't see very often. By being able to streamline the subject, by talking to every side – an interview with Hamas's then political leader, Ismail Haniyeh, conducted weeks before his death in July 2024, is to come – and by refusing to be led by emotion over fact, Percy has created something that deserves to be talked about in the same terms as The World at War.
That storied documentary series was made after the event, when the ink was dry and the picture was clearer. In her ability to make sense of a process that is still unfolding – and, thanks to Donald Trump's plans for Gaza, may outlast us all – Percy deserves nothing but praise. This is vital work.
Israel and the Palestinians: The Road to 7th October airs on BBC Two and is available on BBC iPlayer
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Israel to continue with Gaza City offensive despite talks to free Hamas hostages
Israel will resume negotiations with Hamas for the release of all hostages captured during the October 7 attack, Benjamin Netanyahu has said - but its military will continue its Gaza City offensive despite international outcry. The remarks from Israel's prime minister are the first since Hamas agreed to a temporary ceasefire proposal. Talks will also be with a view to ending the war, but Mr Netanyahu said it must be on "terms acceptable to Israel". In the meantime, the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) have begun calling medics and international organisations in northern Gaza to encourage them to evacuate to the south ahead of the expanded operation in Gaza City. Many of Israel's closest allies have urged the government to reconsider. Some Israelis fear it could doom the remaining 20 or so living hostages taken by Hamas-led militants in the 7 October 2023 attack which ignited the war. Israel plans to call up 60,000 reservists and extend the service of 20,000 more. Speaking to soldiers near Israel's border with Gaza, Mr Netanyahu said he was still set on approving plans for defeating Hamas and capturing Gaza City. "At the same time I have issued instructions to begin immediate negotiations for the release of all our hostages and an end to the war on terms acceptable to Israel," he said. "These two things - defeating Hamas and releasing all our hostages - go hand in hand," he added. The latest ceasefire proposal drawn up by Egypt and Qatar is almost identical to an earlier one that Israel accepted before the talks stalled last month. The proposal would include the release of some hostages in exchange for Palestinian prisoners, a pullback of Israeli forces and negotiations over a lasting ceasefire. 'Don't tell us where to build' Israeli strikes killed at least 36 Palestinians across Gaza on Thursday, according to local hospitals, including at a tent camp in Deir al-Balah. Meanwhile, Israel's ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely, was summoned to the Foreign Office in response to a controversial West Bank settlement plan which has been given final approval. The project, known as the E1 settlement, would effectively cut off the occupied West Bank from East Jerusalem and divide the territory in two. The UK and 21 international partners have released a statement to condemn the decision "in the strongest terms" calling it "a flagrant breach of international law" and "critically undermining a two-state solution". Ms Hotovely gave Sky News her response to the meeting: "I said we wouldn't tell the British where to build in London. Don't tell us where to build in Jerusalem, our capital. We see E1 as part of Greater Jerusalem." 11:50 UK warns of 'horrifying starvation' The UK has also responded to comments from the head of the UN Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA that famine in Gaza is "deliberate" and being used as an "instrument of war". Minister for the Middle East, Hamish Falconer, has called for a "comprehensive [peace] plan to end this misery and get to a long-term settlement". "Israel must immediately and permanently lift all barriers preventing aid reaching the people of Gaza to prevent the horrifying starvation in the Strip continuing," he added. Demand for Gaza media access The Media Freedom Coalition, which includes the UK and 50 other countries, has called on Israel to allow foreign media access into Gaza. In a joint statement, the coalition, which is a partnership of countries working to defend media freedom, urged Israel to "allow immediate independent foreign media access" and "afford protection for journalists operating in Gaza". They said this was in light of the "unfolding humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza".
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Israel launches ANOTHER explosive attack on Anthony Albanese: 'Something is wrong'
The diplomatic stoush between Australia and Israel has cranked up another gear, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu using a television appearance to blast Anthony Albanese 's leadership record. Mr Albanese has flagged that Australia will join other Western nations, including the UK, France and Canada, in recognising a state of Palestine at the United Nations General Assembly in September, in response to the worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza. A furious Mr Netanyahu unleashed on Mr Albanese during an interview on Australian television on Thursday night. 'I'm sure he has a reputable record as a public servant, but I think his record is forever tarnished by the weakness that he showed in the face of these Hamas terrorist monsters,' Mr Netanyahu told Sky News. 'When the worst terrorist organisation on earth... which murdered women, raped them, beheaded men and burnt babies alive in front of their parents and took hundreds of hostages, when these people congratulate the prime minister of Australia, you know something is wrong.' Diplomatic ties hit an all-time low this week after the federal government denied a visa to far-right Israeli politician Simcha Rothman from entering the country for a speaking tour, following provocative comments. Israel retaliated by cancelling the visas of three Australian diplomats who cover the Palestinian Authority. 'When Prime Minister Albanese and the leaders of France and Britain and others, when they say we'll give them a Palestinian state, they are actually rewarding terror, they are saying it doesn't matter what horrors you people do,' Mr Netanyahu said. '(Australia and Israel) had a great relationship over the years. I think it's gone astray because leaders did not show the strength and conviction they should have, when we're fighting the war of Western civilisation against these barbarians.' Mr Netanyahu's broadside came as the Israeli military maintains pressure on Gaza City with heavy bombardments ahead of an offensive to seize the enclave's largest city. The military has called up 60,000 Israeli reservists. Mr Netanyahu hinted that the conflict could soon be over. 'We are on the verge of completing this war... when that happens, I think we will have tremendous opportunities to expand the peace,' he said. 'We will win.' Earlier this week, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said Israel was increasingly isolated on the international stage. 'Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up or how many children you can leave hungry. Strength is much better measured by exactly what Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has done,' he told ABC Radio National on Wednesday.
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
Famine officially declared in Gaza for first time by UN-backed group
Famine will be declared in Gaza City for the first time by the international body responsible for monitoring world hunger, The Telegraph can reveal. The UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) – a globally recognised system for classifying the severity of food insecurity and malnutrition – has been used to declare just four famines since it was established in 2004, most recently in Sudan last year. Although the IPC has previously warned famine is imminent in parts of Gaza, it has until now stopped short of making a formal declaration, citing a lack of hard data. However, on Friday morning, it will formally declare a famine in Gaza City, the last remaining major built-up area of Gaza and home to some 500,000 people. The declaration will outrage the Israeli government, which has consistently denied that famine is taking place in Gaza and is currently moving on Gaza City. Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, said on Thursday he would give final approval for the takeover of the city, one of Hamas's last strongholds. In order to declare a famine, three strict criteria must be met: at least 20 per cent of households face an extreme lack of food, at least 30 per cent of children suffer acute malnutrition, and two people for every 10,000 die each day due to 'outright starvation'. The IPC will state that a famine is taking place in the 'Gaza Governorate', which comprises Gaza City, three surrounding towns, and several refugee camps, according to a briefing shared with its partner organisations and seen by The Telegraph. 'After 22 months of relentless conflict, over half a million people in the Gaza Strip are facing catastrophic conditions, characterised by starvation, destitution and death,' says the IPC briefing. It adds that the famine is projected to expand to the governorates of Deir Al-Balah and Khan Younis by the end of September on current projections. Another 1.07 million people – over half of Gaza's population – are already facing 'emergency' levels of food insecurity, the second-highest level on the scale, the briefing adds. The Telegraph has contacted the Israeli government for comment. Mr Netanyahu has faced international backlash over the situation in Gaza, with Israel earlier this month announcing measures to let more aid into Gaza. He insisted 'hundreds of trucks' had been allowed in and said that if Israel was implementing a 'starvation policy', then 'no one in Gaza would have survived after two years of war'. He pointed to disturbing images of Evyatar David, a 24-year-old Israeli hostage who looked severely malnourished in a video released by Hamas. He said: 'The only ones who are being deliberately starved in Gaza are our hostages.' The Israeli prime minister vowed on Thursday to take over all of Gaza City militarily. The wide-scale operation in the city could start within days, with preliminary operations already under way in the area. Earlier this week it was announced that call-up orders were being issued to 60,000 reservists of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) ahead of the full-scale assault on the city. Israeli troops are now said to have established a foothold on the outskirts of the city after days of intensive bombing, and Palestinians are fleeing the area in large numbers. The IPC – whose 21 partner organisations include Save the Children, Oxfam and Unicef – is forecasting that food security in Gaza will continue to deteriorate between the middle of August and end of September. 'During this period, almost a third of the population – nearly 641,000 people – are expected to face catastrophic conditions, while the number of people in emergency will likely increase to 1.14 million,' it says. This marks 'the first time a famine has been officially confirmed in the Middle East region', the briefing says, although the region has suffered hunger crises historically. It is only the fifth time a famine has been formally declared by the IPC, with the previous four all in sub-Saharan Africa. Israel has been under intense pressure to allow more food into Gaza, facing international criticism over its aid blockade, which has ebbed and flowed since the Hamas attacks on Oct 7 in which nearly 1,195 were murdered and 251 were taken hostage. Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry said on Thursday that 271 people had so far died from starvation in Gaza, 112 of them children. More than half of that figure has been in the last three weeks alone. In total, the Palestinian death toll from 22 months of war stands at 62,192, according to figures from Gaza's health ministry. Mr Netanyahu last month defended Israel's handling of the humanitarian disaster in the enclave, claiming 'there is no starvation in Gaza'. 'We enable humanitarian aid throughout the duration of the war to enter Gaza – otherwise, there would be no Gazans,' Mr Netanyahu said. The famine declaration comes as David Lammy, the Foreign Secretary, signed a statement accusing the Israeli government of a violation of international law over its plans to press ahead with an illegal settlement that would divide the occupied West Bank Britain and Israel have been at loggerheads ever since Sir Keir Starmer announced the UK would recognise a Palestinian state in September. Israel's military on Thursday said it had warned medical officials and international organisations to prepare for the planned evacuation of Gaza City's residents ahead of its ground offensive to occupy it. The officials were told that 'adjustments' were being made to hospitals in southern Gaza to receive patients, a statement said.
