First Minister not informed after massive UK Gov data leak
A massive data leak and a secret scheme to bring more than 18,000 at-risk Afghans to the UK was kept hidden from Cabinet Ministers and the Scottish Government.
Defence Secretary John Healey confirmed a super injunction banning the reporting of the Ministry of Defence fiasco was to be lifted last week.
He revealed that the personal details of thousands of Afghans who had applied to resettle in the UK after the Taliban seized power in Afghanistan had been leaked in 2022.
They had applied to the UK Government's Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP) scheme – for those who had helped British forces during the 20-year conflict.
It has now emerged personal details of special forces personnel and serving spies were also compromised.
Dave Doogan, the SNP's defence spokesman said: 'One breach of ARAP data could be considered careless albeit to a callous degree given what we were trying to protect the applicants on this list from, but sadly this was one of [several] leaks we know about.
'It therefore has the appearance of institutional incompetence comp-ounded by a galling lack of ministerial grip by the previous secretary of state.'
The Tories' then- defence secretary Ben Wallace was only told of the breach 18 months after it happened when details about the leaked data were mentioned on Facebook.
The MoD set up a secret scheme, the Afghan Response Route (ARR), to relocate those named. About 6900 people were relocated using that scheme, estimated to have cost about £800million.
Wallace personally applied for an injunction to stop the media from reporting the scandal or parliamentarians being informed.
The gagging order was only intended to last four months but when Grant Shapps succeeded Wallace it was upgraded to a superinjunction and remained in place until last week.
The Sunday Mail has now learned that no serving Cabinet ministers other than Wallace, Shapps and then-Prime Minister Rishi Sunak were told about the scandal.
One ex-Cabinet minister said: 'We were not informed.'
And despite the MoD setting up an entire scheme to relocate Afghans whose data had been compromised, including housing them in Scotland, they failed to inform Humza Yousaf, who was first minister at the time.
Senior Scottish Government sources said they were not told. An adviser said: 'We knew nothing about it until everyone else found out from John Healey and neither did Humza at the time. I'm sure he also learned about it from watching Parliament TV last week.'
The Labour government applied to extend the superinjunction three times – in May and November last year and this January – and commissioned a review into what options it had to put an end to the ARR.
The report by retired civil servant Paul Rimmer found there was 'little evidence of intent by the Taleban [sic] to conduct a campaign of retribution.'
It went on to say the leaked data 'may not have spread nearly as widely as initially feared. We believe it is unlikely the dataset would be the single, or definitive, piece of information enabling or prompting the Taleban to act.'
Thousands of Afghans have settled in Scotland since the Taliban took power in 2021. But thousands more are still thought to be living in fear there.
Doogan said: 'When the current Secretary of State for Defence took us round the houses on this mess in Parliament his statement included a curious focus on the cost to the taxpayer going forward, with an even more inappropriate stress on any impact on immigration figures. His statement should have been limited to an apology, the steps taken to remedy the apparently sieve-like nature of a government department entrusted with our security and the debt we still owe to those compromised.'
He said the government's reliance on the Rimmer Report showed 'a staggering degree of complacency from members of a bureaucracy whose collective and sustained incompetence, I greatly fear, has left brave Afghans, wherever they are hiding, to endure even greater threats'.
The MoD said: 'As the Defence Secretary outlined in his statement there was a super injunction in place meaning they could not inform others and knowledge was kept to a narrow compartment.'
A Scottish Government spokesman said: 'We were not made aware of this issue before the UK Minister of Defence's statement to the House of Commons.
'This incident is clearly deeply concerning and we urge the UK Government to ensure it prioritises the safety and protection of people affected.'
The 18,714 Afghans fearful of Taliban reprisals due to the leak are unlikely to get compensation. The MoD said any claims will be robustly defended.
This month, Armed Forces minister Luke Pollard announced £1.6million in compensation for a separate incident involving the release of Afghan nationals' data.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
25 minutes ago
- Daily Record
John Swinney playing 'old tune' on Scottish independence, claims Lorna Slater
The SNP leader used his regular column in the Daily Record to announced that a majority for his party at next year's election would be required for an IndyRef2. The SNP is playing an 'old tune' on independence, Scottish Green leadership candidate Lorna Slater has claimed. First Minister John Swinney used his regular column in the Daily Record to announced on Monday that a majority for his party at next year's election should be enough to secure a second vote on independence, as it was for the first in 2014. Slater – who was launching her campaign for re-election as Green party co-leader in Edinburgh today – said she does not expect an SNP majority next May. "This is an old tune that the SNP have been playing,' she said. "There are several pro-independence parties in the Scottish Parliament – the Greens have been there all along, from the beginning. "John Swinney, I think, is being a little disingenuous. We had a successful pro-independence majority with the Bute House Agreement that the SNP decided to end.' On her ideas for forcing the UK Government to allow a second referendum, Slater said it is up to those who believe in independence to 'build support' for it. "We do that by setting out what independence looks like and why it's important,' she said. "We hear all the time how Brexit has damaged Scotland, it hurts our labour force, meaning business cannot hire employees that they need, it hurts our NHS, we cannot get the carers and workers, and it hurts all of us in our pockets. "Scottish independence would allow us to build a compassionate asylum system, it would allow us to rejoin the EU, it would allow us to rethink our taxation of wealth, for example. "Instead of waiting, waiting, waiting for the Government in Westminster to decide what to do, we could make those kinds of decisions here in Scotland, and that's how we win Scottish independence, by getting more people to share that vision.' Swinney said in his Record column: "For us to achieve that independence, the first step is to secure a legal referendum recognised by all. In 2011 we secured that reliable and dependable route when the SNP achieved a majority of seats at Holyrood. "That is the only mechanism that has been proven to deliver such a vote - so that is what we need to deliver again. "That is why I have submitted a motion to the SNP conference proposing that we work to deliver a majority of SNP MSPs in the Scottish Parliament to secure that referendum on Independence. "The SNP has high ambitions for Scotland, and we must be bold to deliver on those ambitions. We must be ready to follow the path which we know can lead us to an independent state."
South Wales Argus
30 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
SNP playing ‘old tune' on independence, says Slater
SNP leader and First Minister John Swinney announced on Monday that a majority for his party at next year's election should be enough to secure a second vote on independence, as it was for the first in 2014. But speaking to the PA news agency, Ms Slater – who was launching her campaign for re-election as party co-leader in Edinburgh – said she does not expect an SNP majority next May. 'This is an old tune that the SNP have been playing,' she said. 'There are several pro-independence parties in the Scottish Parliament – the Greens have been there all along, from the beginning. 'John Swinney, I think, is being a little disingenuous. 'We had a successful pro-independence majority with the Bute House Agreement that the SNP decided to end.' On her ideas for forcing the UK Government to allow a second referendum, Ms Slater said it is up to those who believe in independence to 'build support' for it. 'We do that by setting out what independence looks like and why it's important,' she said. Standing against the far-right. We can make a better future in a fairer, greener and independent Scotland. 💚🏳️⚧️🏴🦫 — Lorna Slater (@lornaslater) July 30, 2025 'We hear all the time how Brexit has damaged Scotland, it hurts our labour force, meaning business cannot hire employees that they need, it hurts our NHS, we cannot get the carers and workers, and it hurts all of us in our pockets. 'Scottish independence would allow us to build a compassionate asylum system, it would allow us to rejoin the EU, it would allow us to rethink our taxation of wealth, for example. 'Instead of waiting, waiting, waiting for the Government in Westminster to decide what to do, we could make those kinds of decisions here in Scotland, and that's how we win Scottish independence, by getting more people to share that vision.'
The National
34 minutes ago
- The National
SNP playing 'old tune' on independence, says Lorna Slater
[[SNP]] leader and First Minister John Swinney announced on Monday that a majority for his party at next year's election should be enough to secure a second vote on independence, as it was for the first in 2014. But speaking to the PA news agency, Slater – who was launching her campaign for re-election as party co-leader in Edinburgh – said she does not expect an [[SNP]] majority next May. 'This is an old tune that the SNP have been playing,' she said. READ MORE: 'Feeling was mutual, Donnie': Nicola Sturgeon responds to Donald Trump 'There are several pro-independence parties in the Scottish Parliament – the Greens have been there all along, from the beginning. 'John Swinney, I think, is being a little disingenuous. 'We had a successful pro-independence majority with the Bute House Agreement that the SNP decided to end.' On her ideas for forcing the UK Government to allow a second referendum, Slater said it is up to those who believe in independence to 'build support' for it. 'We do that by setting out what independence looks like and why it's important,' she said. 'We hear all the time how Brexit has damaged Scotland, it hurts our labour force, meaning business cannot hire employees that they need, it hurts our NHS, we cannot get the carers and workers, and it hurts all of us in our pockets. 'Scottish independence would allow us to build a compassionate asylum system, it would allow us to rejoin the EU, it would allow us to rethink our taxation of wealth, for example. 'Instead of waiting, waiting, waiting for the Government in Westminster to decide what to do, we could make those kinds of decisions here in Scotland, and that's how we win [[Scottish independence]], by getting more people to share that vision.'
