Lawyer tapped to study Giant Mine legacy comes with no 'preconceived notions'
Social Sharing
The lawyer and former British Columbia politician recently appointed to assess the historical impacts of the N.W.T.'s Giant Mine on Indigenous communities says he plans to travel to Yellowknife this month to meet with those affected firsthand.
Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Gary Anandasangaree named Murray Rankin as the ministerial special representative in a news release last week, saying Rankin's "experience and knowledge will support future recommendations to address the harms that resulted from the Giant Mine operations."
The mine operated near Yellowknife between 1948 and 2004. The site is one of the most contaminated in Canada. Since 2021, a $4-billion remediation project to clean up the site and contain 237,000 tonnes of highly toxic arsenic trioxide dust underground has been underway.
In a statement this week, the Yellowknives Dene First Nation, which has been pushing for a federal apology and compensation for years, said it welcomes Rankin's appointment and is hopeful for a resolution.
"The mine contaminated our core harvesting area. We no longer trust it as a safe place to harvest," said Ndilǫ Chief Fred Sangris. "We will share our peoples' message with Mr. Rankin that the damage is still felt today and will be felt for generations."
Murray Rankin joined guest host Shannon Scott on CBC's The Trailbreaker on Tuesday.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Why are you the right person for this job?
Well, I hope I'm the right person. I have had a long relationship with Minister Anandasangaree. We've done some, I think, pretty important things in British Columbia together on treaty making, for example, and reconciliation efforts. And I have worked as a lawyer with First Nations and with governments and with industry for a long time. I think the minister thought I might be able to give him advice and help to resolve this longstanding issue. It's been going on for some 56 years of the mine's operation, and then 20 years since, and there's some significant issues that need to be addressed.
What are your goals for this position?
My goals are to do what the minister has asked me to do, namely to work with the communities affected. There are several First Nations, in particular the Yellowknives Dene First Nation, of course, but there's Métis people as well, Tłı̨chǫ, and others that have been involved. The objective is to provide him with some very practical recommendations to try to address this longstanding problem. It's been around, as you know, for so long and promises have been made over the years — not all of them appear to have been met.
So the idea is to come up with recommendations as to what extent the government of Canada bears responsibility. What are the specific impacts on the Indigenous peoples that were affected by the mine over the years, and to try to both heal the land and heal the people who were affected by this mine.
One of the agreements that hasn't come to fruition yet around this is an apology and compensation. In 2021, the federal government signed an agreement to look into issuing that apology. What's your understanding of why that hasn't happened yet?
I'm trying to get to the bottom of that. You're absolutely right. There was talk as well in 2021 of a negotiating table, they called it. And that was something that a former minister, Carolyn Bennett, committed to. That doesn't appear to have got off the ground. The N.W.T. MP, Michael McLeod, had brought in a petition. It got, I think, like thousands of names, you know, 32,000 people signed it calling for that compensation and apology. So the government of Canada has been doing whatever they've been doing and there's of course lots of work going on on the physical remediation, the environmental impacts of the contaminated site, but the impacts on the First Nations that were affected — it's my job to try to find out what can be done about that.
I want to read a statement from Yellowknives Dene Chief Ernest Betsina about your appointment. He says "for decades we have advocated for an apology and compensation for the harms that our people have suffered as a result of Canada's authorization and administration of Giant Mine. We are hoping for a resolution for our claim before more of our elders pass away." Chief Betsina obviously wants a timely resolution. What is your timeline?
My timeline is, and I've been in correspondence with the Yellowknives Dene just yesterday, and I'm hoping to come up to Yellowknife in a week or so. I've got arrangements that are currently being made to meet him and his people and to discuss all of that.
I have the benefit of not really having spoken in the past, so I can hit the ground running with, if you will, a clean slate. My job is to report not to the public service, but to the minister himself and that I think gives me the opportunity to hear from them firsthand without any preconceived notions of what has happened or should happen.
On that note, given the longstanding calls for justice over Giant Mine, how do you plan to address any skepticism about this process?
Well, I hope I can, through the various conversations I have with a wide range of people, get to the bottom of it. There's obviously different perspectives on what has been done and what should be done. So my job is simply to listen to all sides of the issue and to try to come up with my best advice, my independent advice to the minister.
Ultimately it's the government of Canada that will have to decide what to do with my report. I will do that within the next few months. This has been, I think everyone agrees, taking far too long to get going and it's my job to show action as quickly as I can. That's why I've been immersed in trying to learn about this from reading. And now I have to get in, talk to the people who are directly affected, and that's what I intend to do, beginning a week or so from now.
How long will you be in Yellowknife?
The initial trip, I expect to be there for a few days and then I'm going to, of course, be coming back because as you can imagine, there have been mountains of research and reports over the years and I've got to get to the bottom of that. It's a significant learning curve for me.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
To fight wildfires and heat waves, Manitoba needs a climate plan
Opinion Facing a record-breaking heat wave in early May, Manitoba has had a devastating start to its unofficial fifth season — fire season — as wildfires continue to ravage communities and smoke blankets much of the province. Climate change is no longer a distant problem for future generations — it is here now. To tackle the crisis, Manitoba needs more than just new water bombers. We urgently need a strong provincial climate action and adaptation plan. Manitoba has already seen over 105 fires this season and smashed numerous temperature records, leading the province to declare a state of emergency. Tens of thousands of people have been evacuated, dozens of homes have been destroyed, and tragically, two lives have been lost. Buckland Fire and Rescue / The Canadian Press / HO-Facebook A Buckland Fire and Rescue tanker truck is shown on a highway after being deployed to La Ronge, Sask., on June 2. Evacuation and emergency response supports for northern communities have struggled to keep pace, with 2,000 residents of Pukatawagan left stranded for days as heavy smoke prevented air evacuations. Tragically, this hot, dry, and smoky spring and summer weather is becoming increasingly the norm. Winnipeg is expected to experience 52 days above 30 C each summer beyond 2050. Extreme heat and wildfires are public health emergencies. They cause increased illness and death from cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, injury, and heat-related illness. They contribute to rising anxiety and mental health difficulties for young people — all of which further stresses health care. Climate change poses an escalating financial crisis, with health and other climate damages in Manitoba slated to reach up to $2,235 per person annually by 2050. The climate crisis is an existential threat to Indigenous land-based knowledges and lifeways, and an ecological breaking point. These devastating impacts will continue to intensify if we keep putting off tackling the root of the problem: our reliance on fossil fuels. Failing to reduce our emissions is adding fuel to the fire. While the Government of Manitoba must meet the current moment of emergency response to ensure communities' safety, it also needs a strong and clear plan to swiftly transition off fossil fuels and proactively adapt to the impacts that are already locked in. The previous government's 2017 Manitoba Climate and Green Plan is outdated and inadequate, as it is not aligned with international targets through the Paris Agreement and lacks details such as short-term and long-term goals, specific timelines, and costing. It is not clear if this plan is being implemented because the last progress report was four years ago. Meanwhile, aside from Alberta, Manitoba is the only province with higher greenhouse gas emissions in 2023 than 2005. In 2019, the Manitoba NDP committed to reducing emissions 45 per cent by 2030 and pledged to develop a strong, science-based climate plan with solutions for every sector. However, after a year and a half in office, there is no sign of this plan. Meanwhile, the provincial government is proposing to expand fossil fuel infrastructure and is backpedalling on its clean electricity commitments. A strong provincial climate plan should have two main areas of focus. First, it should chart the equitable pathway for how Manitobans will move around, heat our homes, and feed our families — all without relying on oil and gas by 2050, and to meet their 2030 target. Though Manitoba's emissions are a relatively small contribution globally, Canadian's per-capita emissions are among the highest in the world and come with a responsibility to cut emissions and develop solutions that can be replicated elsewhere. Second, it must plan for the impacts of a changing climate, such as wildfires, extreme storms, and health emergencies like the ones we are currently experiencing. It should do these things in partnership with Indigenous communities, building a new economy rooted in equitable and reciprocal relationships. Some school divisions are taking it upon themselves to model a course, including Seven Oaks, Louis Riel, and Winnipeg School Division, that have begun to establish their own climate plans and are boldly advancing climate change education. However, a clear provincial plan for utilities, transportation, businesses, health and education is needed to make sound decisions aligned with a climate-safe future. In the absence of a plan, Manitoba Hydro's current long-term energy planning, for example, is relying on technologies that aren't commercially viable. A provincial plan will also need to reckon with the small, but not insignificant, oil industry in southwestern Manitoba. As international politics have recently demonstrated, Canada needs a robust, energy-independent economy. Given the province is forecasting a deficit of 23,600 trades people over the next five years, Manitoba should focus on training, education and job growth related to fossil fuel transition. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. With the U.S. abandoning its energy transition, Canada has an opportunity to attract low-carbon industries and bolster domestic production to create good green jobs. Manitoba, at the centre of the country, is well positioned to encourage federal action and investment in a clean energy future, increased east-west connections, and push back against new pipeline proposals. It is not too late to act. Instead of continuing to expand our reliance on dirty fuels, Manitoba can work together and be a world-class example of climate change preparation, adaptation and prevention. The vast majority of the public is in support of climate action and policy, and are looking for strong leadership. While first responders continue to fight the wildfires, the rest of us can fan the flames of the political will needed to prevent them. Scott Durling is with Educators for Climate Action Manitoba, Laura Cameron is with Manitoba's Climate Action Team), and Chris Morrow is with Manitoba Public Health Association.
Cision Canada
14 hours ago
- Cision Canada
Prime Minister Carney convenes the Incident Response Group Français
OTTAWA, ON, June 8, 2025 /CNW/ - Today, the Prime Minister, Mark Carney, convened the Incident Response Group with ministers and senior officials to address the ongoing 2025 wildfire situation affecting many parts of the country. The group was briefed on efforts to respond to the fires and support evacuations. This includes the mobilization of Canadian Armed Forces personnel to assist with the evacuation of Sandy Lake First Nation in Ontario. The Prime Minister emphasized the close contact between various arms of the federal government, premiers, and the Canadian Armed Forces. All orders of government remain engaged, including with Indigenous leadership. Prime Minister Carney and the group thanked all first responders and officials on the ground, and reiterated that the federal government stands ready to mobilize additional support wherever needed and in all aspects.
Calgary Herald
14 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Chris Selley: Earth to Liberals — First Nations are not an anti-development monolith
Article content Sean Fraser — the federal Liberals' supposed master communicator who did a bad job as immigration minister, and then a bad job as housing minister, and then said he wasn't running again to spend time with his family, and then opportunistically changed his mind and was rewarded with the justice and attorney general portfolio — laid his first dog's egg of the Mark Carney era this week. Article content Article content Fraser said Indigenous groups don't have a 'complete veto' over natural-resource projects or any other government decisions — but that wasn't the turd in question, because it was absolutely true. Article content Article content The turd came later, apparently after getting his ears boxed by Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse: Fraser disavowed his entirely truthful statement. Article content 'I think even accepting the premise of the question that was put to me (about a 'veto') really made people feel like there may be an attempt by the government to work unilaterally, not in partnership (with First Nations),' Fraser told reporters in a public apology. Article content 'Despite innocent intentions, I think my comments actually caused hurt and potentially eroded a very precarious trust that has been built up over many years to respect the rights of Indigenous people in this country,' he said. Article content Article content Coming up on 500 years since Jacques Cartier first set foot here and named it Canada, and 150-plus years after the Crown concluded the first treaties with First Nations, and with President Donald Trump suddenly bringing our crippling dependence on the United States into very sharp focus, if we can't even speak the plain truth to each other in plain language, we might be in even bigger trouble than we realized. Article content Article content But I think we can speak the plain truth to each other in plain language, so long as we rightly marginalize fringe and unreasonable voices. While apologizing for speaking the truth, Fraser also accurately pointed to 'a frankly dangerous trope that paints a false picture of Indigenous peoples as being anti-development.' Article content The 2021 Census recorded 1.8 million Indigenous Canadians — five per cent of the Canadian population, give or take. No one would ascribe monolithic opinions like 'supports/doesn't support resource development' to any other ethnic five per cent of the Canadian population. Yet most Canadian media reliably frame these issues as 'First Nations versus the colonialist menace.'
