Centre's school education assessment flags learning gaps—Maths least favourite, govt schools lag behind
The PARAKH Rashtriya Sarvekshan, formerly known as the National Achievement Survey (NAS), was conducted on 4 December last year, covering 21,15,022 students from both government and private schools in Grades 3, 6 and 9, across 74,229 schools in 781 districts, spanning 36 States and Union Territories.
New Delhi: Highlighting serious learning gaps in the subject of Mathematics among school students, a government survey has found that less than 60 percent of Class 3 students could fluently perform addition and subtraction of two-digit numbers, with less than 50 percent of Class 6 students able to recognise simple number patterns, like odd and even numbers. Additionally, only 28 percent of Class 9 students could understand and apply the concept of percentages to solve problems.
The survey was revised last year in line with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020. The last NAS in 2021 covered Classes 3, 4, 5, 8 and 10. Under the revamped format, it now assesses Classes 3, 6, and 9—marking the beginning of each stage of schooling as outlined in the new policy.
In Class 3, where students were assessed in both Language and Mathematics, the average score in Language was 64 percent, compared to 60 percent in Mathematics.
The survey showed that average performance in Mathematics declined as students progressed through higher grades. Language performance also showed a downward trend.
In Class 6, an additional subject—'The World Around Us'—was introduced alongside Language and Mathematics. Students scored lowest in Mathematics (46 percent), while Language averaged 57 percent, and The World Around Us scored 49 percent nationally. The World Around Us covers the environment and society. It describes the use of natural resources in our immediate surroundings, and basic social and behavioural norms, among others.
In case of class 9, students were assessed in Language, Mathematics, Science and Social Science. Among the four subjects, Language had the highest average score (54 percent), while Mathematics had the lowest (37 percent). Science and Social Science showed equal average performances at 40 percent.
According to Indrani Bhaduri, programme coordinator, CEO and head of PARAKH, the performance of Class 3 students has improved since the previous NAS in 2021, when the average Mathematics score was 57 percent. However, she said that the previous NAS surveys cannot be compared with this one because of the overall change in assessment method.
'In almost all states, the performance of Class 3 has improved due to the NIPUN Bharat initiative. It is only a few states that are pulling down the national average,' she told ThePrint. NIPUN Bharat initiative, or National Initiative for Proficiency in Reading with Understanding and Numeracy, was launched as part of NEP 2020.
For higher classes, Bhaduri said, the impact of NEP 2020 will take more time to reflect in student outcomes, as learning levels were significantly affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. 'This trend is visible in international assessments like PISA and TIMSS, where higher grades—those most affected by the pandemic—have shown consistently lower performance,' she said.
In terms of state-wise performance, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, Kerala and Chandigarh were among the top performers, while Meghalaya, Lakshadweep and Uttarakhand recorded the lowest scores across all classes.
The report said that instances where less than 50 percent of students were able to answer correctly indicate 'learning gaps'.
'These learning gaps highlight the need for focused interventions to strengthen students' skills, refine instructional strategies, and provide additional learning support. Addressing these areas effectively will help improve overall student learning outcomes in the nation,' the report read.
Also Read: CBSE releases final two board exam policy for class 10, makes first option mandatory; second optional
Govt schools lag in Mathematics
In case of Class 3, central government schools recorded the lowest performance in Mathematics.
Scheduled Tribe (ST) students had the lowest scores across both subjects. Other Backward Class (OBC) and Scheduled Caste (SC) students performed at similar levels, with better outcomes in Language, compared to Mathematics.
Similarly, in case of Class 6, government-aided and state government schools showed weaker performance, especially in Mathematics. In terms of social groups, ST students had the lowest overall scores, Mathematics being the most challenging for them. OBC and SC students recorded moderate performance, with better outcomes in Language than in The World Around Us and Mathematics.
In Class 9 as well, state government and government-aided schools recorded the lowest performance in Mathematics. ST students had the lowest scores across all subjects, with the largest gaps observed in Mathematics.
'SC and OBC students performed similarly, with Language being their strongest subject and Mathematics the weakest across all social groups,' the report read.
A significant rural-urban divide was also observed. While Class 3 students in rural areas performed better in both subjects, Classes 6 and 9 students in urban areas outperformed their rural counterparts across all subjects.
In his message in the report, School Education Secretary Sanjay Kumar said that the survey helped 'identify both our achievements and the challenges that lie ahead'. Moving beyond assessment, the next phase aims to 'translate the findings of the PARAKH Rashtriya Sarvekshan 2024 into meaningful actions', he added, which will involve phased data sharing through workshops at national, regional, state and district levels to 'prepare district-specific roadmaps, where roles and responsibilities are clearly defined'.
'Support will come from layered interventions—short-, mid-, and long-term—including teacher training, community engagement, digital materials, and a Management Information System,' he said.
Science & Social Science also challenging
Only 36 percent of Class 9 students could correctly classify matter based on physical properties (such as state, shape, transparency, magnetism, conductivity) and chemical properties (including purity, acidity, metallic nature and composition). Additionally, just 33 percent accurately described how electricity works by manipulating elements in simple circuits, and demonstrated the heating and magnetic effects of electricity.
In Social Science, only 33 percent of Class 9 students could explain key natural phenomena, such as climate, weather, ocean cycles, soil formation, and river flow, along with their spatial distribution. Meanwhile, 45 percent understood the process of the Indian Constitution's formation, and grasped the ideas and ideals of the Indian National Movement, including those rooted in India's civilisational heritage.
According to the report, the average national score in Social Science for girls was 41 percent, higher than boys at 39 percent. However, in Science, boys scored marginally higher with an average of 41 percent, compared to girls' 39 percent.
(Edited by Mannat Chugh)
Also read: IIT Kharagpur's two-pronged plan to help students in distress: 'campus mothers' & welcome committees
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
3 days ago
- Mint
All it takes is smarter use of existing resources to bridge India's learning gaps
Amitabh Kant , Mohit Bahri Current ICT infrastructure installed in schools across India can serve as effective learning labs, as various schooling experiments have shown. Tech-led education offers India a practical, cost-effective and scalable opportunity to improve outcomes. Technology-led learning could offer a practical way forward, especially since budget allocations for it already exist with the ministry of education. Gift this article India's aspiration to become a developed nation by 2047 hinges critically on the strength of its human capital. However, persistent learning gaps in public education— highlighted by assessments like the Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) and Performance Assessment, Review, and Analysis of Knowledge for Holistic Development (PARAKH)—pose headwinds to this vision. India's aspiration to become a developed nation by 2047 hinges critically on the strength of its human capital. However, persistent learning gaps in public education— highlighted by assessments like the Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) and Performance Assessment, Review, and Analysis of Knowledge for Holistic Development (PARAKH)—pose headwinds to this vision. In response to these learning gaps, the government introduced the National Education Policy (NEP) in 2020 and the National Initiative for Proficiency in Reading with Understanding and Numeracy (NIPUN Bharat Mission) in 2021, and is undertaking many other systemic reforms. The impact of these will unfold in the years to come, once the slow systemic effects of educational reform start to become visible. Also Read: India's National Education Policy has been a victim of ignorance The reasons behind learning gaps in public schools are well known and many—ranging from pedagogical methods, rote-based assessment practices and teacher shortages to structural issues in training institutions like District Institutes of Education and Training (DIETs), among others. Addressing each of these issues demands long-term solutions and sustained efforts, but the key question right now is: Are there potential pathways that can help bridge learning gaps and be implemented quickly, efficiently and within our existing resources? Technology-led learning could offer a practical way forward, especially since budget allocations for it already exist with the ministry of education. Over the past two decades, the government has invested heavily in establishing computer (ICT) labs in secondary schools, with such facilities sanctioned for over 120,000 schools till date. These labs are primarily intended to help students build basic digital skills. However, given the rapid advancements in tech-led learning solutions, India should use ICT labs for subject learning. Recent experiences by a few state governments with the use of ICT labs as 'learning labs' have shown promising results in bridging learning gaps. With the availability of advanced AI-based tools, these labs can complement classroom teaching and help students learn more effectively without the need for an additional financial outlay. This strategy is especially valuable for schools struggling with teacher scarcity or deep learning gaps. Early initiatives such as those led by Niti Aayog in aspirational districts (280 schools), Mission Buniyaad by Rajasthan's government (3,500 plus schools) and a similar programme in Andhra Pradesh (524 schools) offer hope. All three have effectively leveraged advanced AI-based personalized and adaptive learning (PAL) solutions within available ICT budgets for schools to support subject learning. These labs are equipped with PAL tools that deliver customized content to each student, based on individual learning needs. Two students in the same classroom can follow different learning paths tailored to their specific needs and pace. Did it work? Independent evaluations—one led by Nobel Laureate Michael Kremer for the Andhra Pradesh programme and another by an independent evaluator for the Niti Aayog initiative—clearly show the positive impact of a well-executed ICT-led intervention. When ICT infrastructure is consistently used for academic learning, students have demonstrated gains equivalent to 0.9 to 2.5 additional equivalent years of learning within 2 to 3 years of implementation in the Niti Aayog and Andhra Pradesh programmes. Students in Rajasthan showed an increase of 21 percentage points in their learning score within two years. The transformative potential of this approach is clear. To enhance its impact, Niti Aayog introduced a significant policy shift by linking payments to ICT providers with actual improvements in student learning outcomes. This marked a departure from the practice of vendors being paid simply for setting up ICT labs, regardless of their usage or impact. Under Niti's model, a substantial portion of the payment was withheld unless measurable learning gains were achieved. This outcomes-based approach—also known as 'pay for results'—created incentives for providers to work closely with schools and ensure that ICT labs were used to drive meaningful education. Interestingly, once digital-led learning becomes a regular practice in schools, anecdotal evidence from these programmes shows a positive shift in student behaviour. Enrolment and attendance rates have improved as students demonstrate a strong interest in engaging digital tools. States with adequate ICT infrastructure should consider blending classroom teaching with the use of 'learning labs.' However, a few critical elements must be addressed for integration success. First, states must pursue a vision where ICT labs are seen not merely as infrastructure, but as real 'learning labs' that are an integral part of the academic curriculum. This shift in perspective helps create a shared vision across all levels, right from senior bureaucrats to classroom teachers. Thereafter, any learning-focused initiative taken by the state education system would place emphasis on ICT labs for outcome improvement. Second, responsible procurement of future ICT labs is essential. This includes selecting advanced ICT infrastructure that has a long lifespan, requires less maintenance and enables the deployment of high-quality AI-driven PAL content (which is vital for personalised learning). Third, ICT providers must be held accountable for supporting schools in using these labs effectively. The 'pay for results' model offers a practical framework by linking vendor payments to measurable improvements in student learning. Fourth, regular monitoring, continuous learning during implementation and timely course corrections must serve as core guiding principles. Real-time data from ICT lab usage, combined with its ongoing impact on student learning, will offer valuable insights. Gaps need to be identified early and corrective action must be taken promptly. Systemic gaps in India's education sector must be addressed with urgency and sustained effort. Technology-led learning is not a substitute for quality teachers, but it can be a powerful complement. The use of existing ICT infrastructure presents a practical, cost-effective and scalable opportunity. As the country's education system strives to deliver more with limited resources, making better use of what already exists may well be the most impactful step towards better outcomes. The authors are, respectively, former CEO of NITI Aayog and co-founder, GDi Partners Topics You May Be Interested In
The Print
5 days ago
- The Print
Next chapter, India's military might. NCERT preparing module on Op Sindoor for classes 3-12
According to officials in the government, the NCERT modules will be released in two parts. While part one will be for classes 3rd to 8th, part two will be taught to classes 9th to 12th. Each module is eight to ten pages. Initiated in the early hours of 7 May, Operation Sindoor involved military strikes by India against terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. The strikes were in response to the Pahalgam massacre. New Delhi: The National Council of Educational Research & Training (NCERT) is preparing special modules on Operation Sindoor for students of classes 3rd to 12th with an aim to make students aware about India's military power, sources confirmed to ThePrint. 'The aim is to make students aware of India's military power and how Pakistan was once again defeated. Through this module, students will also learn about Operation Sindoor and the strategic strength of our armed forces,' a senior official told ThePrint. NCERT is also preparing special modules as supplementary reading material for students, focusing on key national themes, ThePrint has learnt. The programme aims to 'make students aware of the country's achievements' and instill 'a sense of pride'. So far, 15 such modules have been released on themes including 'Viksit Bharat', 'Nari Shakti Vandan', 'G20', 'COVID-19', 'Bharat-mother of democracy', and 'Chandrayaan'. Along with Operation Sindoor, the NCERT is also preparing some other modules. 'The upcoming modules will be about Mission LiFE, the horrors of Partition, and India's rise as a space power—from Chandrayaan and Aditya-L1 to Subhanshu Shukla's presence on the International Space Station. The idea is to highlight the road ahead by showcasing the country's achievements,' said another government official. The NCERT has included events from recent history in textbooks. In the newly released Class 8 social science textbook, it has mentioned the 'surgical strike'—referring to India's 2016 military action across the Line of Control (LoC). The book also compares Maratha ruler Shivaji's attack on Mughal nobleman Shaista Khan to a 'modern-day surgical strike'. (Edited by Amrtansh Arora) Also Read: Centre's school education assessment flags learning gaps—Maths least favourite, govt schools lag behind
Time of India
6 days ago
- Time of India
Students to learn about Operation Sindoor's military triumph in new NCERT module
NEW DELHI: In a move to familiarise schoolchildren with India's military prowess and technological advancements, the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) is developing a special educational module on ' Operation Sindoor '. The content, currently under preparation, will soon be released and integrated into school learning for Classes 3 to 12, sources in the education ministry confirmed on Saturday. The upcoming module -- spread across 8 to 10 pages -- will be structured in two parts to cater to different age groups. The first segment is designed for students from Classes III to VIII, while the second will be tailored for those in Classes IX to XII. Officials involved in the process said the initiative is intended to instil awareness among students about India's defence capabilities, scientific progress, and its growing stature in national and global security. Operation Sindoor, which showcased India's strategic and operational readiness, is being framed within the larger narrative of national pride and resilience. The module will highlight key moments from the operation and emphasise India's ability to defend its interests, including recent setbacks suffered by Pakistan. Apart from detailing the military achievements, the module will include sections on related national themes. Students will be introduced to Mission LiFE (Lifestyle for Environment), which promotes sustainable living practices; The Horrors of Partition, offering a historical lens on the trauma of India's division in 1947; and India's rise as a space power, tracing its journey from Chandrayaan missions to the Aditya L1 solar observatory. The module will also feature the story of Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla, who recently became the first Indian to visit the International Space Station. His voyage is being positioned as a symbol of India's forward march in space exploration, intended to inspire the next generation. NCERT sources said the content will be written in an accessible style appropriate for the respective age groups, combining historical context with present-day achievements and future aspirations. The move is part of the broader national curriculum efforts under the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 to integrate patriotic and contemporary themes in school education.
