The Sleep Room by Jon Stock: Could an Irish version of this frightening scandal in British psychiatry yet emerge?
The Sleep Room. A Very British Medical Scandal
Author
:
Jon Stock
ISBN-13
:
978-0349128894
Publisher
:
Bridge Street Press
Guideline Price
:
£25
Day and night no longer held any meaning for the inhabitants of the Sleep Room at The Royal Waterloo Hospital in
London
in the 1960s.
They were all women, most being treated without their consent and spending weeks at a time in a state of deep sleep induced by a cocktail of antipsychotic and antidepressant medication, sedatives and electroconvulsive therapy.
They were roused every six hours by nurses and taken to the bathroom, had their vital signs checked, were administered enemas, drugs and ECT, and returned to their beds. These women had one thing in common: they were all under the care of the eminent
psychiatrist
Dr William Sargent.
Sargent was one of the most influential psychiatrists in postwar British society. He was appointed Physician in Charge of the Department of Psychological Medicine at St Thomas', one of the world's most prestigious teaching hospitals. He occupied other positions of considerable influence and impact. Sargent was lauded by many of his peers and he was a frequent contributor to the BBC and newspapers. He died in 1988.
READ MORE
It appears that Sargent's raison d'être was to treat mental health conditions by physical means. The brutal treatment regime at the Sleep Room was his brainchild and a manifestation of his near obsession to utilise physical interventions to treat mental distress.
It is also a chilling manifestation of his unfettered power and the acquiescence of the medical establishment around him.
Jon Stock in The Sleep Room captures this tyranny in a gripping manner. Stock has written several psychological thrillers; his writing here, however, is constrained in the best sense. There is a dignity and sensitivity embedded in Stock's accounts of the women's stories that make up this scandal.
Several chapters explicitly focus on individual women who were often involuntary inhabitants of the Sleep Room. Each of these chapters is titled using the woman's name. The actor Celia Imrie is one; she was just 14 when she began her de facto incarceration in the Sleep Room as a 'treatment' for anorexia.
Sargent offered the alluring promise of reprogramming the human mind, an offering that in the Cold War era was of immense interest to the CIA and M15. Stock goes into great detail concerning Sargent's somewhat tentative links to these organisations, describing a fascinating episode concerning a non-consensual trial of LSD as a potential 'truth drug'. However, at times I felt that this was almost a separate story and detracted somewhat from the brutal impact Sargent had on the lives of his patients.
Stock reveals a frightening scandal at the heart of the British medical establishment, a scandal that crossed class divides, had international reach, appears to have been facilitated by the establishment for decades and has had the most debilitating impact on the women involved.
While reading, I couldn't help wondering if Sargent's obsession with physical treatment of mental illness had reached Irish shores, and if there is a Sleep Room scandal yet to emerge here.
Paul D'Alton is a clinical psychologist and associate professor of psychology at UCD
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
17 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Sleep Room by Jon Stock: Could an Irish version of this frightening scandal in British psychiatry yet emerge?
The Sleep Room. A Very British Medical Scandal Author : Jon Stock ISBN-13 : 978-0349128894 Publisher : Bridge Street Press Guideline Price : £25 Day and night no longer held any meaning for the inhabitants of the Sleep Room at The Royal Waterloo Hospital in London in the 1960s. They were all women, most being treated without their consent and spending weeks at a time in a state of deep sleep induced by a cocktail of antipsychotic and antidepressant medication, sedatives and electroconvulsive therapy. They were roused every six hours by nurses and taken to the bathroom, had their vital signs checked, were administered enemas, drugs and ECT, and returned to their beds. These women had one thing in common: they were all under the care of the eminent psychiatrist Dr William Sargent. Sargent was one of the most influential psychiatrists in postwar British society. He was appointed Physician in Charge of the Department of Psychological Medicine at St Thomas', one of the world's most prestigious teaching hospitals. He occupied other positions of considerable influence and impact. Sargent was lauded by many of his peers and he was a frequent contributor to the BBC and newspapers. He died in 1988. READ MORE It appears that Sargent's raison d'être was to treat mental health conditions by physical means. The brutal treatment regime at the Sleep Room was his brainchild and a manifestation of his near obsession to utilise physical interventions to treat mental distress. It is also a chilling manifestation of his unfettered power and the acquiescence of the medical establishment around him. Jon Stock in The Sleep Room captures this tyranny in a gripping manner. Stock has written several psychological thrillers; his writing here, however, is constrained in the best sense. There is a dignity and sensitivity embedded in Stock's accounts of the women's stories that make up this scandal. Several chapters explicitly focus on individual women who were often involuntary inhabitants of the Sleep Room. Each of these chapters is titled using the woman's name. The actor Celia Imrie is one; she was just 14 when she began her de facto incarceration in the Sleep Room as a 'treatment' for anorexia. Sargent offered the alluring promise of reprogramming the human mind, an offering that in the Cold War era was of immense interest to the CIA and M15. Stock goes into great detail concerning Sargent's somewhat tentative links to these organisations, describing a fascinating episode concerning a non-consensual trial of LSD as a potential 'truth drug'. However, at times I felt that this was almost a separate story and detracted somewhat from the brutal impact Sargent had on the lives of his patients. Stock reveals a frightening scandal at the heart of the British medical establishment, a scandal that crossed class divides, had international reach, appears to have been facilitated by the establishment for decades and has had the most debilitating impact on the women involved. While reading, I couldn't help wondering if Sargent's obsession with physical treatment of mental illness had reached Irish shores, and if there is a Sleep Room scandal yet to emerge here. Paul D'Alton is a clinical psychologist and associate professor of psychology at UCD
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Mary Ann Kenny: ‘I was crying out for help, for myself and for my children'
It was a bright afternoon in April 2015 when Mary Ann Kenny, a university lecturer, received a call that changed her life. Her husband, John, with whom she had two young sons, had collapsed while out jogging near their home in south Dublin. Kenny was told to get to the hospital as quickly as she could and to bring someone with her. 'I said to my colleague just beside me at work: 'Something's happened to John. I think he's dead and I have to go to the hospital. Will you drive me?' And sure enough, I was told in the hospital car park. Actually, the guard met me there, and he told me John had died.' He was 60 years old. Struggling to cope with the shock of her husband's death and the loneliness that engulfed her life in the aftermath, her grief turned to depression, which later progressed into psychotic delusions. 'I developed very suddenly, out of the blue, a delusional belief that my children had been harmed by my medication and that it was in some way my fault, and that belief took hold of me,' she tells Róisín Ingle on the Irish Times Women's Podcast. READ MORE 'There was nothing else I could think of ... I believed somehow the children had swallowed my medication. I thought it was my fault, I thought maybe I'd left it lying around ... or maybe, worst-case scenario, that I had done it intentionally.' [ 'Losing my husband, losing my mind': Mary Ann Kenny says she is living proof people can recover from severe mental illness Opens in new window ] The mother of two says she was completely 'consumed' by this delusion, which led her to believe her sons had been 'irreversibly damaged', that their brains had been impacted and that they would 'fail spectacularly academically' or 'never be able to make friends'. While attending a mental-health day clinic, Kenny divulged this worry about her children and the medication to one of the staff, who referred her on for in-patient treatment at a psychiatric hospital. 'I think by sharing it like that, I was crying out for help – for myself and for my children. That's what I was doing by unburdening myself,' she says. 'It was dismissed as irrelevant ramblings, but there was a meaning to the whole thing and there was possibly even a purpose to the whole thing, which was to get help and – you know what – I did get help,' she says. Kenny details this journey from the depths of despair, into psychosis and then back to reality in her new memoir, The Episode . In it, she reflects on her 12 weeks in psychiatric care, why she ultimately felt let down by the healthcare system and how she gradually found health and happiness again. You can listen back to this conversation in the player above or wherever you get your podcasts.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Irish early risers try to help get South Korea's suicide rate down
It was shortly after 4am on Saturday and Yeouido Park near Seoul 's financial district was dark, a little chilly and mostly deserted. But on a plaza just inside the park stood a large group of adults, some of them accompanied by children and dogs, chatting and laughing as if they were at a party. These were members of Seoul's Irish community and their friends and they were about to set off on a walk through the park, emerging into the neighbourhood nearby as dawn was breaking. Organised by the Irish Association of Korea, Solas is an annual event similar to Ireland's Darkness Into Light, which aims to highlight positive mental health and wellbeing. 'There is really strong scientific evidence that the single most important thing you can do if you are struggling with your mental health is to talk about it and to be open about it,' Ireland's ambassador to South Korea Michelle Winthrop told the crowd. 'We, as a society, in Ireland, in Korea, everywhere, just need to get a bit better at speaking up. We need to get a bit more comfortable at listening if somebody is expressing some concerns. And the most important thing, really is to beat the stigma. So we just keep repeating that message: it's okay not to be okay,' she said. READ MORE South Korea has the fourth highest suicide rate in the world and the highest within the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). While the global suicide rate is declining, it has been rising in South Korea, with men twice as likely to take their own lives as women and with the highest rate among older people. The overall suicide rate is 25 deaths per 100,000 people but among those in their 80s it is nearly 70 per 100,000 and nearly 50 for those in their 40s and 50s. But the biggest cause of concern is the rising number of young people taking their own lives, with the number of primary and secondary students who die by suicide each year doubling in less than a decade. If one of the purposes of Solas is to raise awareness, the other is to raise money and this year's beneficiary was the Hospitaller Order of St John of God. Five St John of God brothers came from Ireland to establish the order in Korea in 1958, setting up a small clinic in Gwangju near the southern tip of the peninsula. Their services have expanded since then to include two centres in Seoul and apart from general medicine, they offer psychiatric services, programmes for alcohol and other substance abuse, and various counselling services. They offer counselling to families of people who have died by suicide, many of whom feel uncomfortable sharing the burden of their grief with friends and colleagues. 'This is one of the problems. It's not talked about openly. I suppose Ireland also, some years ago, it wasn't spoken about either. It's at that stage in Korea,' said Brother John Conway, a native of Greystones, Co Wicklow who moved to Korea with the St John of God order 42 years ago. 'The area of alcoholism is another. When I first came to Korea and we opened the very first alcohol treatment centre in Gwangju, we were almost told we were wasting our time. And then suddenly there was a huge interest in it, mainly due to Korean dramas that brought the problem out. And now it's all over the country, AA groups and everything. It's the same thing.' The order's alcohol treatment centres in Korea are based on the model of their hospital in Stillorgan but they adapt their services to take account of local sensibilities. The psychiatric hospital in Korea is called a Centre for Living and the nursing staff, who don't wear uniforms, refer to the patients as guests and never address them by their first names. Nana Kim, one of the Koreans on the Solas walk, was part of a group from the Seoul Gaels, the city's GAA club where she is an enthusiastic footballer. She said that Korea's competitive culture, where young people are constantly judging and comparing themselves to one another, often compounded mental health issues. [ Ask the experts: why are suicide rates reaching 20-year lows in Ireland? Opens in new window ] 'Ten years ago, people used to think that mental health is a kind of disease. So if you saw a counsellor you wouldn't tell anyone. But it's a more common thing now and they talk about it in the media too,' she said. 'So it's getting better, but I think we still need more be open for those kind of things. It's like everyone is thinking, I have to be happy. But you don't. You can't be happy every day.'
