Conceived in secrecy and born in haste, Aukus is on its last legs. When will Labor call the undertaker?
Most of us avoid thinking about the end of life and the 'last things'. The Albanese government is no different: it is now deeply invested in Aukus, with no other solution to Australia's need for an effective submarine. While it may be a bit early to call for the undertaker there is no doubt that the Aukus patient is in serious trouble.
Aukus had a less than immaculate conception. It was conceived in secrecy and born in haste, a tribute to political opportunism and a travesty of disciplined planning. The enthusiasm of theatrical announcements notwithstanding, it was in trouble from the beginning. The US Navy had serious doubts about both the ability of US shipbuilders to deliver submarines in any workable timeframe and the ability of the Royal Australian Navy to integrate and operate them. That was not a question of trust but of capacity – on both sides.
And, of course, experienced and well-informed Australian defence planners rang the warning bells from the beginning.
Now reality has caught up with us. The Pentagon has announced a review of the Aukus agreement to ensure that it meets President Donald Trump's 'America First' policy. The US submarine construction program is in trouble. Australia's US$500m contribution to its submarine building industry will have no impact on the production rate, which needs to double if our ambitions are to be met. There's no money back offer here.
But injury is sure to follow insult. The US review will be led by Elbridge Colby, the undersecretary of defense. He is a clever Trump acolyte who signalled his scepticism well before Trump won the presidency. The passage of Trump's 'big beautiful bill' through the Congress, and the looming prospect of a massive debt blowout, can only have reinforced his doubts.
These doubts are well grounded. In several reports dealing with Aukus, the Congressional Research Service identified critical bottlenecks in the US production line for both the Virginia-class and the new Columbia-class ballistic missile submarines. And it is just as concerned about Australia's ability to absorb the new technologies. It should be.
The defense secretary Pete Hegseth's can-rattling at the Shangri-La conference in Singapore further diminished Aukus's chances. Hegseth told the defence minister, Richard Marles, that Australia needed to up its defence spending target to 3.5% of GDP. Of course, there was no suggestion on how the money should be spent. Spending for its own sake fits the bill, which is more or less what Aukus has been about from the beginning.
Quite properly, the prime minister's response was textbook: Australia will decide on its defence spending for itself. And perhaps now is the time for Albanese to institute a parliamentary inquiry into Aukus.
So, where does all of this leave the pact? Far from being in the deep oceans, it is further up the proverbial creek. The best that Australia might have hoped for was the homeporting of a few US Virginia-class submarines on rotation at Fremantle in Western Australia, stretching out over the next several decades. Even that does not really meet US needs for forward positioning of attack submarines in the northern Pacific – the entire reason, it would seem, for the former prime minister Scott Morrison's precipitate and unadvised decision in the first place.
From the beginning, the Labor team has been reluctant to call the ambulance or the undertaker. The Albanese government has no other submarine plan – Aukus is it. Or at least, Aukus was it. The Elbridge review is a circuit breaker. It forces the Albanese government to address Australia's submarine needs and capabilities in a considered and disciplined way for the first time in more than 20 years.
Thinking about the last things encourages some of us to think about resurrection and the next life. Just as Australia could marshal the engineering and technological skills to plan and build the Collins-class submarines, so it can do it again. The Americans have effectively made the decision for us. It's time for plan A – where 'A' is Australia, not Aukus. We have to get on with it – now.
Allan Behm is a special adviser at the Australia Institute in Canberra
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Exclusive Aussie brand beloved by Taylor Swift, Miranda Kerr and Jennifer Hawkins unveils its jaw-dropping new collection
An Australian jewellery brand worn by A-listers has unveiled an exclusive new collection of spectacularly unique rings. Whether it is to celebrate a special life milestone or for an unforgettable proposal, the Engagement & Milestone Edit from ALINKA Fine Jewellery is a bespoke line of customisable designs, handcrafted for individuality. Known for its stackable fine bracelets and necklaces, ear cuffs and statement rings, ALINKA Fine Jewellery is already beloved by a loyal clientele of Australian and international clients with it's ready-to-wear and made-to-order pieces. Featuring a jaw-dropping collection of dazzling diamond and fine coloured gemstones set in 18 carat gold, sourced specially for each bespoke, made to order design. Clients can take inspiration from the designs in the edit, customising the gold colour and stone size to their specifications. The OVAL Horizontal Diamond Ring is a timeless design with an oval cut GIA Certified Natural Diamond, set in the brand's signature basket with engraved detailing on the band. Truly unique and spectacular, the DUO ring features an emerald cut white diamond set beside an oval cut white diamond, set in the ALINKA Duo setting. Truly unique and spectacular, the DUO ring features an emerald cut white diamond set beside an oval cut white diamond Clients can make the ring their own, selecting the shape, colour and size of the two diamonds, with the design tailored to the proportions of the chosen gemstones. The show stopping ECLIPSE ring features a fine emerald mounted on a sculptural ALINKA eclipse band. This unique design is set with baguette cut and round brilliant cut white diamonds. The SHOULDER Diamond ring features an emerald cut fancy intense yellow diamond, set between two crisp tapering baguette cut white diamonds. Another double gem setting, the DUO Hearts ring features two heart-shaped diamonds side by side. The unique designs in the collection offer inspiration for clients, who can then customise the ring with their stone shape, size and colour preferences for a truly individual piece Every ALINKA ring includes a hidden evil eye secret diamond, to symbolise 'protection, unbroken love and good fortune that is bestowed upon the wearer'. The diamonds and gemstones are set in 18 carat yellow gold, white gold or rose gold. The jaw-dropping designs come with designer price tags that reflect the quality of luxury of the brand. Each piece is customised so price is on application and for anyone interested in learning more should book an appointment or request a quotation. 'An ALINKA Fine Jewellery engagement ring is more than jewellery— it's a personal milestone,' Founder and Creative Director Alina Barlow said. Barlow started the brand in 2015, designing bespoke one-of-a-kind pieces for her Sydney clientele, before branching into ready-to-wear collections. Creating a custom ALINKA piece is a personalised, collaborative experience guided by one of the brand's jewellery and diamond specialists With a client-list featuring the country's elite, Barlow opened a flagship showroom in Sydney's exclusive Double Bay, while internationally her designs are also online on Farfetch. The brand has steadily grown a loyal following amongst Australia's most fashionable, and through subtle appearances on the red carpet worn by Jennifer Hawkins, Taylor Swift, Vanessa Kirby, Natalie Dormer and Alicia Vikander in recent years. Natalie Portman and Dua Lipa have been photographed adorned in the jewels for Vogue magazine shoots. The DUO Hearts ring features two heart-shaped diamonds side by side, customised for colour and size The brand's ready-to-wear pieces, such as the RIVIERA Midi Rainbow Sapphire Hoops and KATIA Classic Rainbow Sapphire Ring (left), and STASIA Mini Diamond Bracelet (right), can be purchased online Creating a custom ALINKA piece is a personalised, collaborative experience guided by one of the brand's jewellery and diamond specialists. Clients will select from the edit of signature designs and thoughtfully sourced and hand-selected diamonds and gemstones to create a completely unique piece. Once the design is made, it undergoes three rounds of quality control to ensure it meets the in-house team's exacting standards. For those not in the market for a diamond ring, the brand's ready-to-wear collections of fine jewellery and statement pieces can be purchased online with free delivery.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
The Crunch: how Ukraine drones hit Russia; marine heatwaves; and the collapse of Canada's third parties
Hello and welcome to another edition of The Crunch! There's been so much great datavis published over the last couple of weeks, it was a real struggle to whittle down. But in this week's newsletter we've got another great political▲triangle▲ chart, an analysis of the accuracy of Asian casting in Hollywood, a visual explainer on the Ukraine drone attack on Russia, an interactive map showing the extent of marine heatwaves and how you can mislead people by being selective with the data you show. The Greens lost three seats and their party leader in the 2025 Australian federal election, despite a relatively steady national vote. How did this happen? We took a deep dive into the Greens vote, looking at how dispersed Greens voters are across the country, why a seat redistribution affected Adam Bandt in Melbourne, and the 'three-cornered' contests between the Greens and the major parties in Brisbane. Stick around to the end of the piece to play with our interactive preferences calculator. Our colleagues in the US have also published this great visual guide to the Los Angeles protests. The map is particularly useful if, like us, you find it hard to tell the scale of the protests from the television coverage. 1. How accurately are Asian-Americans cast in Hollywood? There's a lot to like in this visual essay from Dorothy Lu and Anna Li at the Pudding. It starts with a lovely comic strip explaining the inspiration for the piece, then takes a detailed look at Asian representation in cinema. 2. Ukraine drone attack Even days after Ukraine's drone attack deep in Russian territory earlier in June, it was hard to imagine what exactly had happened. Reuters has a great visual explainer, showing what the drones look like and how they were smuggled into Russia inside modified trucks. 3. Marine heatwaves getting more frequent and widespread A quarter of the world's oceans experienced temperatures in 2024 that qualify as a heatwave. Delger Erdenesanaa and climate graphics wizard Harry Stevens at the NYT have produced this interactive piece looking at how widespread marine heatwaves have become ($), with an excellent, if confronting, interactive map that shows the spread of heatwaves over time. Sign up to The Crunch Our data journalists showcase the most important charts and dataviz from the Guardian and around the web, free every fortnight after newsletter promotion The map also works really well on mobile, which you can't always say about a lot of interactive maps. 4. ▲△▲MORE TRIANGLES ▲△▲ Regular readers of the Crunch will know that we love ternary scatterplots, so we were excited to see this view of Canadian election results which shows the movement of vote share in every federal riding (these are Canadian electoral districts), from third parties to the two major parties. The chart was made by designer Nick Abasolo, and you can read more about it here. The New York Times on boys falling behind in kindergarten ($) The Economist on girls falling behind in maths ($) Our World in Data on how childhood leukemia became treatable As The Economist's Archie Hall said, this chart posted by the UK Conservatives is the type where when you start the x axis really matters: And so the FT's Alphaville made this excellent edit of the chart, showing how inflation was far higher – and increased far more – under the Conservatives: Enjoying The Crunch? If you like what you see and think you might know someone else who would enjoy it, please forward this email or send them a link to the sign up page.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Explosions around Tehran as Israel announces strikes
Explosions around Tehran on Friday morning were quickly followed by Israel announcing its air force conducted strikes on Iran targeting its nuclear programme. US and European officials had been warned the day before that Israel was fully ready to launch a pre-emptive strike, even if Washington did not provide direct support
