Caster Semenya's right to a fair hearing was violated, ECHR rules
Semenya was legally identified as female at birth but has a condition which means her body naturally produces higher levels of testosterone than women without the condition.
She was unsuccessful in challenging World Athletics' rules at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and the Swiss federal court, but in July 2023 a lower chamber of the ECHR found her rights had been violated by the Swiss government because it had failed to provide sufficient safeguards for her complaint to be examined effectively.
Grand Chamber judgment Semenya v. Switzerland – Complaint by international athlete concerning set of World Athletics regulationshttps://t.co/JcWLWspX33#ECHR #CEDH #ECHRpress pic.twitter.com/6hFqJzTpgv
— ECHR CEDH (@ECHR_CEDH) July 10, 2025
The Swiss government referred the case to the ECHR's Grand Chamber in November 2023 and on Thursday morning, it was announced its judges had found by a 15 to two majority that Semenya's rights under Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights – the right to a fair hearing – had been violated.
A press release issued by the court said the judges had found the Swiss courts had 'fallen short' in providing what they felt should have been a 'rigorous judicial review that was commensurate with the seriousness of the personal rights at issue'.
The ECHR ruling, which cannot be appealed, should mean the case returns to the Swiss federal court.
The Grand Chamber ruled by a majority of 13 to four that complaints under Article 8 (right to respect for private life), Article 13 (right to an effective remedy) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) were inadmissible. It found Semenya did not fall within Switzerland's jurisdiction in respect of those complaints.
Seema Patel, an associate professor specialising in sports law at the Nottingham Law School, had said prior to the Semenya decision being handed down that it would be a 'pivotal moment for how sport engages with human rights in its rule making'.
World Athletics has not been a party to either of the ECHR proceedings but at the time of the 2023 ruling by the lower chamber it said it stood by its rules on lowering testosterone, describing them as 'a necessary, reasonable and proportionate means of protecting fair competition in the female category'.
Caster Semenya was a gold medal winner in the women's 800m at the 2016 Rio Olympics, having also won the same event at London 2012 (Martin Rickett/PA)
Earlier this year, track and field's global governing body strengthened its rules in this area further when its ruling council approved the introduction of cheek swab tests to determine biological sex.
The introduction of these tests are designed to ensure only athletes found to be biologically female can compete in the female category, effectively barring transgender women and some athletes with differences of sexual development (DSD).
Semenya's legal team and World Athletics have been contacted for comment following the Grand Chamber ruling.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Olympic champion Zheng withdraws from U.S. Open after elbow surgery
July 21 (Reuters) - Olympic champion Zheng Qinwen has withdrawn from the U.S. Open as she recovers from right elbow surgery, tournament organisers announced Monday. The world number six revealed last week on Instagram that she has been struggling with "persistent pain" in her right elbow, which affected her performance during both training and matches. After exploring various treatments with little success, Zheng decided to undergo arthroscopic surgery following consultations with elbow specialists and her support team. She has since announced she will be taking a short break from competition to focus on her recovery. The 22-year-old Chinese star enjoyed a remarkable run last year, capturing gold at the Paris Olympics and reaching the final of the 2024 Australian Open. However, her momentum was halted at Wimbledon this year, where she was eliminated in the first round by Czech player Katerina Siniakova earlier in July. With Zheng's withdrawal, France's Leolia Jeanjean will move into the main draw of the U.S. Open, the final Grand Slam of the season, which begins with main draw action on August 24 in New York.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Lord Coe raises concerns around Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track with athletes still yet to be paid for first meet in April
World Athletics boss Lord Coe has voiced concerns about the conduct of Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track, with athletes still waiting to be paid prize money months on from the competition. Johnson launched a new track series earlier this year, offering stars record prize pots of $100,000 (£74,200) for winning their category at one of the four scheduled meets. However, Grand Slam Track participants – including Britain's Zharnel Hughes - have still not received cash they were promised from the first event, which was held in the Jamaican capital of Kingston at the start of April. Money is also owed from the meets in the US cities of Miami and Philadelphia. The fourth event, which was planned for Los Angeles last month, was cancelled at late notice. 'This is not a good situation,' admitted World Athletics president Coe, whose governing body were not involved in the launch of Johnson's league and have not spoken to the US legend for 'several months'. 'It's a start-up, but the athletes do need paying. Conduct in our sport is important to us. We are following this closely. I've had conversations with individual athletes, athlete representatives and even meeting directors on this. 'It was in everybody's interest for something like this to be successful. But we were very clear that this had to be done properly and executed properly. For these things to work, they can't be vanity projects. They have to be suffused in practicality and deliverability.' Sources at Grand Slam Track insist athletes will be paid their earnings from Kingston by the end of this month, with cash from the other events following later this year. World Athletics chief executive Jon Ridgeon added: 'Grand Slam Track have asked for a little bit of time. Hopefully, in that time, it will be concluded. 'It just shows you how hard it is to launch new stuff. In any sport, it's really hard.'
Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Lioness fans eager to 'reclaim title' as Women's Euro 2025 trophy 'so close'
Italy will have huge support in the stands with more than 600,000 Italian residents in Switzerland, they make up the largest portion of foreign residents in the country England fans have said the Euros trophy feels so close 'you can almost touch it' as the Lionesses prepare to take on Italy in the semi-final tomorrow. But they'll have to contend with a 10,000-strong Azzurri blue army in the Stade de Geneva, as Switzerland is home to around 640,000 Italians. And after their nail-biting penalty shootout with Sweden, fans are hoping the Lionesses won't get complacent against the Italians, ranked 13th in the world. Leanne Woodall, 33, from Wythenshawe, Manchester, said: "The final is so close you can almost taste it. The Sweden game was so nerve-wracking I couldn't even watch the penalties, I was glancing at the pitch through my fingers. "But when we won and the final whistle went the atmosphere in the stands was like a final, it was electric. We can beat any team we want as long as our heads are in it, the passion is there and it feels like it's our time now to step up again and reclaim our title." Italians constitute the largest group of foreign residents in the country, with an estimated 640,000 people of Italian nationality registered in Switzerland, according to Statista. And the number of Italian speakers is significantly higher than the number of Italian citizens. The Swiss Federal Statistical Office estimates that roughly 8.4% of the Swiss population, or 720,000 people, declare Italian as their main language. But Julie Abbott, from Newark, Notts, and her pal, Clair Coyles, 36, from Whitehaven, Cumbria, are hoping the Lionesses will go all the way so they can watch them win the Euros for the first time together. The pair met at the Australian World Cup two years ago and are determined to rewrite the disappointment of the last final they witnessed together, when England were pipped by Spain. Julie, 55, said: "I wasn't at the last Euros final but Clair was, then we both had the disappointment of the World Cup Final, so to see them get there and lift the trophy would be immense. It would be amazing for the whole country, not just us fans out here, it would lift the whole of England. "Watching them win the Euros was euphoric... But it would be even better - the best feeling to be able to watch them win it, from in the stands stood together. We met at the World Cup in Aus and now we have this massive Women's Football Community now that comes together every tournament. It's like one big football family. We all sit together at the games. To get to celebrate it and experience it together would just be next level." The pair have been calming their semi-final nerves by enjoying as much as Switzerland's spectacular scenery as possible. Speaking to the Mirror on the train back from Switzerland's epic Matterhorn mountain, Julie added: "It's the semi final and whoever we were playing I think we would feel nervous because the final is within touching distance now, you can see it ahead of you. "It's just so close and it would be such a shame if we didn't get there again. Fingers crossed, with a good performance and a little bit of luck, we should be in the final." And while the band of the barmy army will be striking up in the stands, the Lionesses will also be feeling the support of fans 800 miles away back home, where pubs have been given a special dispensation to open late. In May the Home Office revealed plans to allow bars with an 11pm licence to stay open until 1am so no fan misses out on the action. Policing Minister, Dame Diana Johnson said: "Nothing quite brings people together like watching our national football teams, which is why we want fans to be able to enjoy every minute of these matches." And while the nation rallies behind them, the Lionesses have grown even closer as a team following recent revelations from Jess Carter about the racist abuse she has suffered during the tournament. Speaking ahead of the game yesterday Georgia Stanway, blasted the racist trolls adding 'they're not fans'. The 26-year-old from Barrow in Furness said: "I think being vulnerable is probably one of the most important things because it brings the group so much closer together. I think when times are tough on the pitch, you want to be able to rely on your teammates and you want to be able to look at them in both good and bad and understand that you're both on the right journey and you're both on the right path to exactly what you want at the end, which is to win. "We've talked a lot about vulnerability and we've talked a lot about opening our arms up and recognising who is next to us and having belief in the people next to you and not the people that are not in the bubble."
