Lions star accused of 'criminal' act as damning image emerges
Fans were left in disbelief at what they were seeing in the third Test in Sydney
Andrew Porter of the British & Irish Lions has found himself in the firing line after a controversial outing in Sydney in the third and final Test
(Image: Getty Images)
British and Irish Lions star Andrew Porter has seen his methods pulled under the microscope again by furious Australia fans, after the Wallabies saved a series whitewash with in an eventful victory in Sydney.
Tries from Dylan Pietsch, Max Jorgensen and Tate McDermott proved enough to seal victory for the hosts, with the Lions responding with touchdowns from Jac Morgan and Will Stuart.
On a day where play was delayed by severe weather, there were several key talking points to emerge from the contest. Sign up to Inside Welsh rugby on Substack to get exclusive news stories and insight from behind the scenes in Welsh rugby.
Loosehead prop Porter was just one such topic of discussion, with his scrummaging technique called into question by fans online.
The Irishman's angle in driving the scrum has been called out by fans before, but reached an apex on social media during this defeat, with some onlookers in disbelief at what he was able to get away with by referee Nika Amashukeli's whistle in the loss, but fans online are still dismayed by what he was able to get away with.
Just hours after the match, one user on X shared an aerial image of Porter's scrummaging, which appeared to demonstrate his unusual driving angle.
Article continues below
'Porter up to his normal tricks again yesterday," they wrote. "And the most astonishing thing is? It was the Aussies who got penalised in this scrum!'
Content cannot be displayed without consent
This post sparked plenty of healthy debate, with another user musing 'Not even Shane Warne got that much turn in Australia!'
Another fan wrote: 'How Porter is allowed to scrummage at that angle is beyond me. Should be a penalty almost every scrum."
"Andrew Porter would never win a scrum if he was forced to scrum straight," said another. "Nika allowing him to scrum skew just to get the ball out.'
'I'm sorry but Andrew Porter on those aerial views is a ****** criminal for the way he binds down to scrum," was the view of another fan. "WOW. And they are all in front of the referee!!!'
But despite the fume from some, there were a few onlookers that did offer some support to Porter.
Former referee Nigel Owens wrote: 'Although I am not disputing either way with you on this image, you can only make an accurate call if you see the whole sequence in motion, not just a still image.'
Porter was eventually taken off just after half-time and was replaced with Ellis Genge, but some felt even his replacement was guilty of attempting to manipulate the scrum laws.
Article continues below
"I noticed it consistently across all three games from both Porter and Genge. To the point where it felt like they'd been deliberately coached to do it."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
11 minutes ago
- The Guardian
First Nations group launches federal appeal to block construction of main Brisbane 2032 Olympics stadium
A First Nations group has applied to halt construction of the main stadium planned for the 2032 Brisbane Olympics. The state and federal governments plan to spend $3.8bn on a 63,000-seat stadium at Victoria Park in inner-city Brisbane. It will host the opening and closing ceremonies and athletics events. The park will also contain a 25,000-seat national aquatic centre, a warmup track, and other infrastructure. Victoria Park is one of the most significant Indigenous sites in inner-city Brisbane, according to historian Ray Kerkhove. It served as the town camp for up to 1,500 Indigenous people, who were victims of at least one massacre, and is on a songline, he said earlier this year. It is also known as Barrambin. Sign up: AU Breaking News email In May Queensland parliament passed legislation on party lines exempting Games-related development from a number of state planning laws, including the Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act, and from legal challenge. On Tuesday, the Yagara Magandjin Aboriginal Corporation (Ymac) lodged an application with the federal government for permanent legal protection of the park, under section 10 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act. The decision lies with the federal environment minister, Murray Watt. 'We know this is a place of great significance and history, not only for Yagara people, but for other First Nations and non-Aboriginal people as well,' said Ymac spokesperson and Yagarabul elder Gaja Kerry Charlton. The LNP leader, David Crisafulli, had promised not to build any new stadiums for the Olympics, and not to build one in Victoria Park, before last year's state election. It was also not mentioned during the May federal election campaign. Crisafulli apologised for breaking the election promise in March, saying the choice was between Victoria Park and a temporary facility in the city's south that wouldn't have proven suitable. Used as a golf course since 1931, Brisbane city council developed a master plan for the site in 2020, converting it back into a park. Local elders participated in a four-year consultation process for the scheme. The plan has been scrapped. Part of the park is heritage listed and the relevant department recommended in April that the protection be expanded to cover the entire area. May's legislation exempts Olympics development from the state Heritage Act. 'It was a complete shock when the premier came out with his stadium plans,' Charlton said. 'He said the park would be protected from stadiums; I thought the park was safe. Now the government wants to destroy it. We are very concerned there are ancient trees, artefacts and very important ecosystems existing there. There may be ancestral remains. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'We stand resolute in our responsibility to protect it.' The federal government threw its support behind the Olympic stadium plan last month, on condition that appropriate consultation was undertaken with stakeholders including First Nations groups. The deputy premier, Jarrod Bleijie, and the federal infrastructure minister, Catherine King, were contacted for comment. 'Once Victoria Park is gone, it's gone forever,' Yagara elder Uncle Steven said. 'Will photos be our only memory? Are we going to have to say to our children, our grandchildren: 'this is what your grandparents experienced, but it's not here for you any more?' 'We have so little left of our history, our culture, our social life that we cling to it. And we want to share that with non-Aboriginal people as well.' When built, the Victoria Park stadium will be Queensland's biggest stadium and will serve as the home of cricket and the Brisbane Lions AFL team.
Daily Mail
41 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Melbourne Storm apologise for Welcome to Country scandal more than THREE MONTHS after it happened - but there's a twist that will leave many Aussies furious
The Melbourne Storm have finally apologised for the Welcome to Country scandal that rocked the club on ANZAC Day. The Storm abruptly cancelled a planned Welcome to Country ceremony just hours before kick‑off at AAMI Park on ANZAC Day – more than three months ago. Now the club has finally apologised to all of the groups and individuals impacted by that 11th–hour decision – but also revealed the team won't be holding a Welcome to Country ceremony at their Indigenous Round match on Thursday night. Instead, the Storm will hold an Acknowledgement of Country. Unlike a Welcome, an Acknowledgement can be performed by a non–Indigenous person. 'Melbourne Storm has been in ongoing communication with members of the Wurundjeri community following the events on ANZAC Day and has apologised to the individuals, groups, and communities involved,' the club announced in a statement. 'The Club extends that apology to First Nations and Māori and Pasifika communities impacted. 'As we continue to engage with the local community regarding connection to the Club and cultural protocols and out of respect for those involved, the Club will recognise the traditional owners of the land through an Acknowledgement of Country on Thursday night for Indigenous Round.' But the timing of their apology has set off another firestorm, and it's all to do with money, jerseys and timing. This week, the club unveiled its 2025 Indigenous Round jersey, to be worn against the Brisbane Broncos. The guernsey features artwork honouring Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander players who have worn the purple jersey. It will be sold to fans as part of the lead‑up to Indigenous Round celebrations. For many fans, the optics couldn't be worse. 'But they've still decided to not have a Welcome to Country for the upcoming Indigenous round,' one fan commented. 'Is this just about money or is this a change in accepting cultural diversity and inclusion of First Nations people. As your disgusting decisions over welcome to Country cannot be tolerated,' posted another. Footy fans questioned the Storm and accused the club of cashing in on Indigenous Round 'Won't have a welcome to country. Will make $ by selling an indigenous themed Guernsey,' added another. The backlash comes on the heels of the ANZAC Day Welcome to Country scandal that's been simmering since April. The decision blindsided Wurundjeri elder Aunty Joy Murphy Wandin, who has performed the protocol at countless Melbourne events. She was told she was no longer required, with no clear explanation. Two First Nations performance groups, also booked to appear, immediately withdrew in protest. Even when the club tried to backtrack, it was too late to save the moment. The fallout was instant and brutal. The Victorian Aboriginal Health Service, a long‑time partner, cut ties with the Storm entirely. Aunty Joy said she was 'heartbroken' and unsure if she could ever work with the club again. Club chairman Matt Tripp later claimed the board had not formally approved the ceremony. He blamed the debacle on a miscommunication between the board and management. But that explanation didn't wash with critics, who saw the move as a sign of disrespect. The scandal landed on a day already marred by cultural tensions. Earlier that morning, neo‑Nazis booed an Indigenous elder during a Welcome to Country at Melbourne's Shrine of Remembrance. The Storm has remained steadfast in its decision to ditch regular Welcome to Country ceremonies throughout the season.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Former All Blacks winger Bridge signs with Western Force
MELBOURNE, Aug 5 (Reuters) - Former New Zealand winger George Bridge has signed a two-year deal with Western Force and will return to Super Rugby next season, ending a three-year stint in French rugby. Bridge scored 12 tries in 19 tests for the All Blacks and played in the 2019 World Cup in Japan before heading abroad to play for Top 14 side Montpellier in 2022. The 30-year-old will replace Wallabies winger Harry Potter who left the Perth-based Force to join the New South Wales Waratahs. Bridge, who can also play fullback, was part of Scott Robertson's powerful Canterbury Crusaders from 2017-22, helping the South Island team win four Super Rugby titles and the domestic Super Rugby Aotearoa championship twice. "George is well known to a number of people on our staff and they can't speak highly enough of his professionalism, approach to the game and his rugby knowledge," Force coach Simon Cron said in a statement on Tuesday. "He's got a massive left foot kick. He can play multiple positions. He's a brilliant player. An amazing talent. He'll add to the guys that we have in the squad." The Force, who have never made the playoffs in any variant of Super Rugby since joining in 2006, managed only four wins last season and finished ninth in the 11-team competition. Bridge's former team, the Crusaders, won a record-extending 15th Super Rugby title.
