'Poor budgeting' has Government spending money faster than planned, says watchdog
The Government is spending money much faster this year than was planned, with Ireland's fiscal watchdog blaming poor budgeting.
In an assessment of the State's financial health, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) said spending has increased by 6% so far this year, well above the 1.4% implied by Budget 2025. IFAC said the rapid spending is because earlier overruns were not properly built into the forecasts, and Government estimates were 'simply not credible'.
The exchequer returns for May, published last week, show spending of €37.3bn to the end of May — €2.1bn (5.9%) above the same period last year.
'This pace far exceeds the growth rate that would be consistent with Budget 2025 forecasts, given the final level of spending in 2024,' IFAC said, adding that the overruns are in most areas of spending, not just health.
Presenting the returns last week, Jack Chambers, the public expenditure minister, said the increases were in line with the amount profiled by departments to be spent at this stage in the year.
IFAC said the Irish economy is in a strong position, but it warned of growing risks, saying that tariffs and trade tensions are a threat to investment and exports, and only 'phenomenal levels' of excess corporation tax are keeping Ireland in surplus.
'Without these revenues, there would be a substantial deficit, despite a strong economy,' IFAC said.
'Without these factors, there is a structural deficit of 2.4% of GNI — equivalent to €2,500 per worker.
"In the short term, corporation tax is likely to grow further. However, these receipts remain high risk.
A handful of large US firms pay most of the corporation tax
IFAC also raised concerns about Ireland's fiscal rules, saying the framework is not effective and that EU budgeting rules will not help as they rely on GDP and ignore the risks from volatile corporation-tax receipts.
'The reality is that both the new EU fiscal rules and their mirror in domestic legislation no longer provide any credible constraint for Ireland,' IFAC said, adding that the Government appears to have abandoned the national spending rule introduced by the last government, which set a 5% limit for net spending growth.
Extra stimulus
Regarding Budget 2026, IFAC said the Government should adapt its approach to the state of the economy.
'If the economy stays strong, there's no need for extra stimulus,' the council stated. 'In that case, budgetary policy should show some restraint. But if the economy takes a downturn, budgetary policy should provide support.'
IFAC said the Government should commit to a fiscal rule, use budgetary policy to reduce the ups and downs of the economic cycle, focus on infrastructure and competitiveness, and set realistic spending forecasts. Recent forecasts have ignored previous overruns and been unrealistic.
IFAC's chairman Séamus Coffey said: 'The Irish economy is in a strong position going into a period of uncertainty. The Government needs to ensure that budgetary policy reduces the ups and downs of the economy. Introducing a rule would help guide fiscal policy in the coming years.'
Read More
David McNamara: ECB ready to take a pause on rate cuts
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
39 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Entire country to be brought under Rent Pressure Zone in major change agreed by Government leaders
In a meeting on Monday night, leaders met and agreed on a new system of national rent control. The current system, which caps yearly rent increases at 2pc or in line with inflation, will be retained for existing tenancies. This 2pc cap would no longer apply to newly built homes, which would instead have a cap linked directly to the rate of inflation. This measure is aimed at increasing the rate of private sector investment in building more rental homes. But significantly, every area of the country will now be designated as an RPZ under the new national rent control system, meaning the remaining one fifth of tenants in Ireland not in an RPZ will benefit from rent controls. Leaders also agreed on stronger security of tenure protections for renters. This, it is understood, will include an end to no fault evictions in the case of large landlords. Landlords are also set to be categorised according to the number of properties they own with smaller landlords to be categorised as those with three or fewer properties. According to proposals going to cabinet, landlords will only be allowed reset rents if the tenant leaves voluntarily. If a landlord serves a tenant a notice to quit, the landlord will not be allowed reset the rent. The move will aim to remove the economic incentive for landlords to evict tenants. The move to expand the RPZs is seemingly one that goes against the recommendations in the report from Housing Commission. ADVERTISEMENT In its report last year, the commission said while the rental market was both challenging for both renter and landlord, the RPZs were constraining landlords. According to the report, it said the impact of RPZs has been mixed and the commission recommended changes to the system. In particular, the report said the RPZ system should be reformed and a new system of 'reference rents' be established instead. This would be landlords would be limited on how much they could increase rent by, and would be based off things like the size of the rental property and where it is located. The commission also said regulations should continue between tenancies. 'If a tenancy ends the same regulations apply to the subsequent tenancy. This will discourage termination of tenancies that is designed to increase rental income,' the report said. As reported in the Sunday Independent, the Government was considering new rules which will allow landlords to significantly hike rents beyond the current caps. Under original the proposals, landlords would be allowed to increase rents to market rates in between tenancies of at least six years. While current tenancies are expected to remain under the RPZ regulations, the cap would not apply to newly built apartments. Currently, rents in a Rent Pressure Zone can only be increased by 2pc or in line with inflation, whichever is lower. First introduced in 2016 to control the rapidly increasing rents in high demand areas like Dublin and Cork, it was a major intervention in the market. Since then, the scheme has steadily spread across the country with most areas now considered an RPZ. Almost ten years after they were first introduced, and with the current regulations are due to expire at the end of this year, it had been anticipated that the current rules around RPZs would change. The Government continues to be under pressure on the issue of housing, wth the rental sector a major focus, as the Opposition has swooped on the issue. Raise the Roof campaign will hold a rally outside Leinster House on Tuesday next week at 6pm, calling for urgent Government action on Ireland's housing and homelessness crisis. The rally is timed to coincide with a Private Members Motion tabled by Opposition parties in the Dáil, and will feature speakers from political parties, alongside a series of singers and spoken word performances. The Raise the Roof campaign group is coordinated by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, and includes trade unions, housing and homeless agencies, women's groups, human rights advocacy groups, and community organisations. Speaking at a press conference to launch the rally, Ethel Buckley, SIPTU Deputy General Secretary said: 'Ten years into the housing crisis, and that crisis remains the greatest political failure of our time. Workers are being priced out of homes or can only rent or purchase with considerable financial burden. 'In the last 10 years rents and house prices have doubled - and in some areas more than doubled - while wages have increased by less than 40%. If anything, this gap has widened in the last couple of years. Rents and house prices are out of control. 'Alongside the human cost of this, we are seeing the serious knock on effects, with thousands of unfilled vacancies in key sectors, and young people once again choosing to emigrate. 'We are deeply concerned at the lack of urgency shown so far by this new government. A government that is content to play the role of helpless bystander to this ever-worsening emergency. What is needed now is a radical reset with sustained action to deliver secure, affordable housing.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Expected changes to local property tax will lead to modest increases for most homeowners
Most homeowners will see modest increases in their local property tax (LPT) next year under changes likely to be approved by the Cabinet this morning to mitigate the effects rising property values have on tax bills. The changes require legislation to widen tax bands and reduce the rate of LPT, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe is expected to tell colleagues. Property prices have increased by almost a quarter since the last revaluation of properties for the tax in 2021. Fearing substantial hikes in tax bills, the Government is expected to change the way the tax is calculated ahead of the next date for revaluation on November 1st of this year. Properties on the lower bands – which include the vast majority of houses in the country with valuations under €525,000 – will see their bills increase by €5 and €23 a year. READ MORE Those with properties valued at under €240,000 will pay €95 a year, an increase of €5. Those with properties valued at between €420,000 and €525,000 will pay €428 a year, an increase of €23. Those in higher bands, however, will see their bills increase more sharply. In the top band, properties valued at between €1.995-€2.1 million will pay €3,110, an extra €389 a year. Properties valued above €2.1 million pay based on the valuation of the property, rather than a band. Projections by the Department of Finance suggest the tax will increase by 5-6 per cent for properties under €1.26 million. Local authorities will continue to be permitted to vary LPT downward by 15 per cent. In 2027, they will be permitted to increase the tax by 25 per cent in their area. [ Rent Pressure Zones: Pressure on Government as it proposes to link certain rents to inflation Opens in new window ] The Cabinet is also expected to approve proposed changes to rent caps, which are likely to be fiercely opposed in the Dáil today by Opposition parties. It is understood that Rent Pressure Zones (RPZs) will be extended to cover the entire country, with rent increases linked to inflation and capped at 2 per cent. The Government is also likely to promise new protections for renters, though some housing advocates have warned that the changes will mean higher rents and increased homelessness . In future, sources say, it will be possible to reset rents between tenancies – but only where a tenant leaves voluntarily or has breached their tenancy agreement. There was further worrying news for the Government when AIB's latest construction purchasing managers' index (PMI) warned that the level of home building contracted during May for the first time in nine months amid a wider fall in activity at Irish construction firms. While some firms were able to increase activity, there were signs of 'softening market conditions and uncertainty', leading to a drop in all types of construction activity, AIB said, though the drop in home building was 'only marginal'. However, there was better news from the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac), the Government's fiscal and budgetary watchdog. [ Corporate tax receipts forecast to rise despite Trump tariff threat Opens in new window ] It said corporation tax receipts could surge by as much as €5 billion, as a result of changes in the tax rate applying to companies and the rush to export goods to the US ahead of the imposition of tariffs. Big companies will start making payments to the exchequer under the increased 15 per cent corporate tax rate by the middle of next year, Ifac said, while most of the biggest taxpayers here are forecast to report increased profits this year, resulting in higher tax payments. A host of capital allowances used by some of the State's biggest companies are due to expire, while pharmaceutical firms will likely pay more tax this year amid a surge in exports to the US ahead of the possible imposition of tariffs, Ifac added.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Government to raise concerns with EU about proposed retaliatory tariffs on aviation, medtech and agrifood
The Government is writing to the European Commission to raise its concerns about the possible inclusion of aviation, medtech and agri-food in the EU's list of potential retaliatory tariffs to be levied against the United States. Tánaiste Simon Harris will update Cabinet on Tuesday on Ireland's concerns about the list of potential European tariffs that will kick in if negotiations on a trade deal fail. It is understood he will raise his particular concern about countermeasures relating to aviation, medtech and agri-food. The concerns will be conveyed in a letter from Mr Harris to EU trade commissioner Maros Sefcovic in advance of the deadline for the public consultation period on the countermeasures. READ MORE Mr Harris, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, is expected to outline four arguments to Mr Sefcovic about the EU's approach to the tariffs: they should not harm EU business more than the US; they should avoid an escalation of trade tensions; they should not affect one member state disproportionately; and they should avoid unnecessary costs. [ EU warns it could accelerate retaliatory tariffs over US duties Opens in new window ] Talks on a trade deal between the EU and the US have continued, but the bloc's countermeasures are due to take effect from July 14th if no agreement is reached. Separately, Minister for Higher Education James Lawless will seek Cabinet approval to provide almost 500 new third-level places to train key workers in four areas experiencing staff shortages. Mr Lawless will bring a joint memo along with Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, Minister for Children Norma Foley and Minister for Education Helen McEntee. The four areas are health, social care, disability and education. The memo will outline how the funding will allow 461 additional places in priority professions, with the majority commencing in 2025. All places will repeat annually, which will provide a minimum of 1,600 new graduates at the end of the first cycle. This immediate expansion will be in nine key health and social care professions: physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, radiation therapy, radiography, podiatry, social work, medical science and dietetics. The Cabinet will also hear details of a proposed new law to combat terrorism being brought by Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan. The Criminal Justice (Terrorist Offences) (Amendment) Bill 2025 will allow for the prosecution of a broader range of terrorist activities in light of the evolving nature of terrorism. The Bill proposes to add three new terrorist offences to the statute book: receiving training for terrorism, travelling for the purpose of terrorism and organising or facilitating travelling for the purpose of terrorism. Mr O'Callaghan will tell colleagues the new law will bring Ireland's counter-terrorism laws into line with those of other EU member states. Mr Harris, in his role as Minister for Defence, will bring a separate memo seeking an incentive scheme to retain air traffic control personnel in the Air Corps. The Defence Forces has had difficulty retaining a sufficient number of highly skilled specialists in air traffic control in light of competition from the private sector. Mr Harris is proposing that a scheme with financial incentives for committed service – already available to pilots – should be extended to air traffic control personnel. The Tánaiste will tell the Cabinet that there is a worldwide shortage of air traffic control personnel and the measures he is proposing are needed to help return the Air Corps to a 24/7 service. At present, the air traffic control service is confined to limited hours because of staff shortages. Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary will present his department's annual report for 2024, which shows 2.78 million people are at work, while overall spending for his department is at €27 billion, which is a quarter of Government spending. The Cabinet is expected to approve a further 12-month extension for Prof Mary Horgan, the interim Chief Medical Officer.
