I Quizzed ChatGPT About Home Safety: Here's Why You Can't Trust It
Generative AI excels at gathering and summarizing information in familiar language, but even the best can hallucinate, cite the wrong info, or just get stumped by current events. I tested ChatGPT thoroughly on questions about home security, security companies and home safety during emergencies: It turns out that's a bad idea. Here's what goes wrong.
Chat AIs hallucinate that Teslas are spying on your home security
BP's alternative fuels wing is expanding its EV charging presence in the US with the purchase of Tesla DC fast-charging hardware.
BP
Asking a chatbot about specific security technology is always a risky business, and nothing illustrates that quite so well as this popular Reddit story about a chat AI that told the user a Tesla could access their "home security systems." That's not true -- it's probably a hallucination based on Tesla's HomeLink service, which lets you open compatible garage doors. Services like Google Gemini also suffer from hallucinations, which can make the details hard to trust.
While AI can write anything from essays to phishing emails (don't do that), it still gets information wrong, which can lead to unfounded privacy concerns. Interestingly, when I asked ChatGPT what Teslas could connect to and monitor, it didn't make the same mistake but it did skip features like HomeLink, so you still aren't getting the full picture. And that's just the start.
Chatbots can't answer questions about ongoing home threats or disasters
Conversational AI won't provide you with important details about emerging disasters.
Tyler Lacoma/ChatGPT
ChatGPT and other LLMs also struggle to assimilate real-time information and use it to provide advice. That's especially noticeable during natural disasters like wildfires, floods or hurricanes. As hurricane Milton was bearing down this month, I queried ChatGPT about whether my home was in danger and where Milton was going to hit. While the chatbot avoided wrong answers, it was unable to give me any advice except to consult local weather channels and emergency services.
Don't waste time on that when your home may be in trouble. Instead of turning to AI for a quick answer, consult weather apps and software like Watch Duty; up-to-date satellite imagery; and local news.
LLMs don't have vital updates on data breaches and brand security
While ChatGPT can compile information about a security company's track record, it leaves out key details or gets things wrong.
Tyler Lacoma/ChatGPT
It would be nice if AI chatbots could provide a summary of a brand's history with security breaches and whether there are any red flags about purchasing the brand's products. Unfortunately, they don't seem capable of that yet, so you can't really trust what they have to say about security companies.
For example, when I asked ChatGPT if Ring had suffered any security breaches, it mentioned that Ring had experienced security incidents, but not when (before 2018), which is a vital piece of information. It also missed key developments, including the completion of Ring's payout to affected customers this year and Ring's 2024 policy reversal that made cloud data harder for police to access.
ChatGPT isn't good at providing a timeline for events and shouldn't be relied on to make recommendations.
Tyler Lacoma/ChatGPT
When I asked about Wyze, which CNET isn't currently recommending, ChatGPT said it was a "good option" for home security but mentioned it suffered a data breach in 2019 that exposed user data. But it didn't mention that Wyze had exposed databases and video files in 2022, then vulnerabilities in 2023 and again in 2024 that let users access private home videos that weren't their own. So while summaries are nice, you certainly aren't getting the full picture of security history or if brands are safe to trust.
Read more: We Asked a Top Criminologist How Burglars Choose Homes
Chat AIs aren't sure if security devices need subscriptions
ChatGPT can't adequately explain security subscriptions or tiers.
Tyler Lacoma/ChatGPT
Another common home security question I see is about the need for subscriptions to use security systems or home cameras. Some people don't want to pay ongoing subscriptions or they want to make sure what they get is worth it. Although chatbots can give a lot of recipe specifics, they aren't any help here.
When I questioned ChatGPT about whether Reolink requires subscriptions, it couldn't give me any specifics, saying many products don't require subscriptions for basic features but that Reolink "may offer subscriptions plans" for advanced features. I tried to narrow it down with a question about the Reolink Argus 4 Pro but again ChatGPT remained vague about some features being free and some possibly needing subscriptions. As answers go, these were largely useless.
Meanwhile, a trip to CNET's guide on security camera subscriptions or Reolink's own subscriptions page shows that Reolink offers Classic and Upgraded tier subscriptions specifically for LTE cameras, starting at $6 to $7 per month, depending on how many cameras you want to support, and going up to $15 to $25 for extra cloud storage and rich notifications/smart alerts. Finding those answers takes less time than asking ChatGPT and you get real numbers to work with.
ChatGPT isn't the place for your home address or personal info, either
Don't let chatbots know too much about your personal info.
Vertigo3d via Getty
As the famous detective said, "Just one more thing." If you do ever query a chatbot about home security, never give it any personal information, like your home address, your name, your living situation or any type of payment info. AIs like ChatGPT have had bugs before that allowed other users to spy on private data like that.
Additionally, LLM privacy policies can always be updated or left vague enough to allow for profiling and the sale of user data they collect. The scraping of data from social media is bad enough; you don't want to hand personal details over directly to a popular AI service.
Be careful what data you provide as part of a question and even how you phrase your query, because there's always someone eager to take advantage of whatever data you let slip. If you think you've already given out your address a few too many times online, we have a guide on how you can help fix that.
Read more: Your Private Data Is All Over the Internet. Here's What You Can Do About It
For more information, check out whether you should pay for more-advanced ChatGPT features, and take a look at our in-depth review of Google Gemini and our coverage of the latest on Apple Intelligence.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
17 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
Tesla awards Elon Musk $29 billion in stock amid compensation battle. What to know
Tesla is awarding Elon Musk around $29 billion in shares as a legal battle looms over a prior multibillion dollar compensation plan for the chief executive. A special committee of the company's board of directors said the interim pay package would motivate Musk to "stay focused" on Tesla as the electric vehicle maker pivots to robotics and artificial intelligence. Under the pay plan, Musk would receive 96 million shares valued at around $300 each as long as he remains in an executive position at Tesla for the next two years. On Musk's social media platform X, the special committee said the executive has not received "meaningful compensation" for his work for eight years. One of the world's richest people, Musk owns about 13% of Tesla shares, making him the largest individual shareholder. The company is worth more than $969 billion based on current share prices. Tesla shares on Monday closed at $309.26, up 2%. Why did the board approve this plan? Tesla board members Robyn Denholm and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson said on X that the $29 billion award is a first step, "good faith" effort to compensate Musk in lieu of a longer term plan. As Musk splits his time and energy among several ventures, including AI startup xAI and space exploration firm SpaceX, Tesla board members said they are eager to keep his attention focused on the electric vehicle maker. Musk has garnered criticism from investors for getting distracted by his temporary role in the Trump administration. Tesla shares have fallen more than 18% this year following significant brand damage and plunging vehicle sales. The company is at a critical turning point where it must pivot to robotics and autonomous driving technology to remain competitive, analysts said. Musk has overseen Tesla's robotaxi launch in Austin, Texas, and frequently touts the potential of the humanoid robot Optimus. "While these impending changes are exciting, the outcomes are not guaranteed," wrote Denholm and Wilson-Thompson. "It is imperative to retain and motivate our extraordinary talent, beginning with Elon." "We are confident that this award will incentivize Elon to remain at Tesla," they wrote. What happened to Musk's previous pay package? A Delaware judge has twice struck down a 2018 executive pay package that would have awarded Musk more than $55 billion in stock, arguing that Musk exerted unfair control over the negotiation process. In 2018, Tesla shareholder Richard Tornetta sued the company to block the compensation plan, claiming the board misled investors and was not transparent about the approval process. Tornetta and his attorneys also argued that the board was too susceptible to Musk's influence. Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick, the judge in the case, sided with Tornetta and rescinded the entire pay package, calling it an "unfathomable sum." McCormick denied the pay plan again in 2024, after the board held another vote to approve it. Tesla has since appealed McCormick's second decision, citing his contributions to Tesla's growth. "This compensation issue has been a constant concern of shareholders once the Delaware soap opera began," Tesla analyst Dan Ives wrote in a note. If the 2018 plan is ultimately approved after legal battles, the recent $29 billion package will be thrown out to prevent double dipping, the board said. How does Musk's pay compare to other chief executives? The pay package brought to court in 2018 was the largest potential compensation plan for an executive of a publicly traded company, McCormick said, worth 250 times as much as the median peer pay. The new plan is still the highest executive compensation package by far. Blackstone Chief Executive Stephen Schwarzman earned $1.39 billion in 2008, compared to the $29 billion interim package for Musk. Another top earner, Palantir CEO Alexander Karp, earned $1.10 billion in 2020. In 2018, Musk agreed to forgo a cash salary for his work at Tesla and instead receive stock options based on his ability to meet company milestones. Board members argue that the value Musk brings to the company is worth hefty compensation. "We can all agree that Elon has delivered the transformative and unprecedented growth that was required to earn all milestones of the 2018 CEO Performance Award," the board's special committee wrote. "Retaining Elon is more important than ever before." Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.
Miami Herald
18 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
Palantir's blockbuster results sparks stock surge
Concerns were raging earlier this year that the artificial intelligence revolution was overhyped and AI stocks were due for a reckoning. It certainly felt like that were true this spring, when stocks got battered amid worries over peak AI spending and growing fear that the US economy was destined for recession. The risk-off environment led to a 24% drop in the technology-laden Nasdaq, and even bigger losses for individual stocks like Palantir Technologies, which tumbled 47% from its February peak to April's low. Don't miss the move: Subscribe to TheStreet's free daily newsletter Those concerns, however, have yet to materialize, and stocks, including Palantir, have produced substantial returns since April 8. The Nasdaq has rallied nearly 40% and Palantir, which is increasingly being viewed as an AI lynchpin, has seen its stock price more than double. The reality is that while concerns remain, there's little to suggest that companies are tapping their brakes on AI investments, and Palantir's latest quarterly results and guidance suggest spending strength will continue to prop up its business this year. The first wave of AI development centered on large language models, or chatbots, that could digest huge data sets and parse data based on user questions, including OpenAI's ChatGPT, Anthropic's Claude, Perplexity, and Google's Gemini. The spending on network infrastructure to support creating those chatbots was enormous, with hundreds of billions flowing out of enterprises and cloud service providers, including hyperscalers, to buy semiconductor chips from Nvidia and servers from Super Micro and Dell. Related: Major analyst who forecast stocks' rally sends 3-word message to investors While that spending is likely to continue, R&D is increasingly shifting to the second wave of AI -- solutions like agentic AI that can be used to assist and in some cases replace workers across industries. Developing those AI apps, however, isn't easy, especially since it requires breaking down data silos to find solutions securely. To do that, companies need help, and increasingly, they're turning to Palantir's Artificial Intelligence Platform. Palantir's (PLTR) roots stretch back to the early 2000s, when the Peter-Thiel founded company was tasked with securing data for the Defense Department. It still does a ton of work for the government, but recently, its seen explosive demand for AIP within companies using Palantir's Foundry platform. As a result, Palantir's sales and earnings are surging. The company's second quarter earnings results show solid and growing demand for its service. Palantir's revenue jumped 48% year-over-year to $1 billion, $61 million better than Wall Street was expecting. As a result, earnings per share (EPS) increased to 16 cents per share, 2 cents higher than analysts forecast, and up 78% from one year ago thanks to improving profit margins. Related: Apple CEO drops bombshell about its future Government deals contributed to the revenue beat, but the real shining star during the quarter was demand from corporations. US sales were up 68% from last year, reaching $733 million. US government revenue rose 53% to $426 million, while commercial revenue surged 93% to $306 million. "It's a blowout across the board. I mean, look, that's why they're the Messi of AI, right? I mean, it just speaks to, this is transformational, the type of growth they're seeing," said Wedbush Securities influential technology analyst Dan Ives on Yahoo!Finance. "I've covered tech 25 years. This is unprecedented territory. It speaks to our view. It's a trillion dollar market cap in the next two to three years." The company closed contracts worth a record $2.27 billion, including commercial deals worth $843 million, up 222% from one year ago. Net income of $327 million helped its cash and investment securities stockpile grow to above $6 billion from about 5.2 billion coming into the year. That's a lot of financial flexibility, especially given that the company is debt free. The growth rate of our business has accelerated radically, after years of investment on our part and derision by some," said CEO Alex Karp. "The skeptics are admittedly fewer now, having been defanged and bent into a kind of submission. Yet we see no reason to pause, to relent, here." The company's CEO, Alex Karp, expects the good times to not only continue but accelerate. Palantir raised its full year revenue guidance to between $4.142 billion and $4.15 billion. Consensus analyst forecasts were targeting $3.9 billion. For a startup, even one only a thousandth of our size, this growth rate would be striking," said Karp. "For a business of our scale, however, it is, we continue to believe, nearly without precedent or comparison." Palantir expects commercial deals to continue to be the big driver, guiding for US commercial revenue of $1.3 billion, up at least 85%. Palantir is also targeting adjusted income from operations of $1.912 billion to $1.92 billion and it raised its adjusted free cash flow guidance to between $1.8 billion to $2 billion. Overall, it expects to remain profitable throughout 2025. Currently, Wall Street consensus targets full year EPS of 58 cents, up from 55 cents ninety days ago. It wouldn't be surprising to see those earnings estimates climb more in the coming days following the updated guidance. Following the second-quarter results, Palantir's shares are up 4.6% to $168, a new all-time high. That move isn't going to let those concerned about the company's valuation sleep any better. Palantir was already trading with a forward price to earnings ratio (a key valuation measure) of 276, making it among one of priciest stocks out there. For comparison, the S&P 500's forward P/E is 22.4. Technology stocks often command higher than normal valuations, but even the price to sales ratio is arguably stretched, given shares are trading at about 123 times sales. Given that backdrop, Palantir is arguably priced to perfection, so it will need to continue to put up similarly eye-popping growth from here to keep investors happy. Todd Campbell owns Palantir shares. Related: Nvidia AI outlook resets after Meta Platforms, Microsoft update plans The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Palantir smashes expectations with $1 billion Q2 revenue as CEO boasts that skeptics have been 'bent into a kind of submission'
Palantir's earnings were buoyed by its US revenue, which surged 55% from the same period last year. Alex Karp called the earnings "bombastic," saying skeptics have been "bent into a kind of submission." Palantir was awarded a 10-year, $10 billion enterprise agreement with the Army in late July. Palantir's CEO, Alex Karp, saw no reason to be humble after his company's blockbuster second-quarter earnings. "As usual, I've been cautioned to be a little modest about our bombastic numbers, but there's no authentic way to be anything but have enormous pride and gratefulness about these extraordinary numbers," he said as he kicked off his part of the earnings call on Monday. He struck a similar tone in his letter to shareholders. "The skeptics are admittedly fewer now, having been defanged and bent into a kind of submission," he wrote. The Denver-based AI software company beat analyst estimates Monday with adjusted earnings of 16 cents per share on $1 billion in revenue, topping LSEG projections of 14 cents and $940 million, respectively. The stock peaked at more than 5% in after-hours trading compared to when the market closed at 4 p.m ET. Palantir's commercial revenue in the US nearly doubled since last year's second quarter to $628 million, while government revenue climbed 53% year-over-year to $426 million, mostly thanks to a 10-year, $10 billion contract with the US Army, which consolidated 75 contracts into one. Ryan Taylor, chief revenue officer and chief legal officer, said that the US Space Force awarded the company a $218 million delivery order and raised the spending ceiling for Palantir's Maven Smart System to $795 million in preparation for "significant demand." The company also raised its full-year revenue guidance midpoint to just north of $4 billion, a nine-point increase from last quarter. Karp concluded the call with a message for investors. "Maybe stop talking to all the haters — they're suffering," he said. Palantir did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Read the original article on Business Insider Sign in to access your portfolio
