SC orders status quo in Ahmedabad slum demolition case, Assures to pay rent differential
New Delhi, Apr 25 (UNI) The Supreme Court on Friday directed that status quo be maintained at a slum site in Chharanagar, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, where demolition was allegedly being carried out despite the Court's earlier protective order.
A Bench comprising Justice Surya Kant and Justice N. Kotiswar Singh passed the interim order while hearing a plea by 49 slum dwellers who claimed that they were being forcibly evicted without proper notice or rehabilitation, in violation of the Gujarat Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1973.
The matter was first mentioned before the Court on Thursday, when temporary protection from demolition was granted till Monday (April 28). However, after reports emerged that demolition activities had resumed at the site, the petitioner's counsel, AoR Sumitra Kumari Choudhary, urgently mentioned the matter again, seeking enforcement of the interim relief.
The Bench questioned the petitioner's counsel regarding relocation of slum dwellers as part of the area's redevelopment plan. When it was submitted that the rent compensation offered of Rs 6,000 per month was insufficient even for a slum accommodation, the Court advised the petitioners to accept the available alternative housing, and assured that the Court would address the rent differential if necessary.
Posting the matter for detailed hearing on April 28, the Court emphasized that no further demolition should take place in the interim.
The petitioners had earlier approached the Gujarat High Court challenging a public notice dated January 29, 2025, which required them to vacate their homes within 30 days.
They contended that individual notices were not served, and only a public notice was issued, violating their rights under the Slum Act. They also alleged that demolition began on March 20, 2025, without proper procedure.
The State of Gujarat, in response, argued that the area had been declared a 'Slum Clearance Area' in 2019, and that all structures were unauthorized. A work order had been issued to a private developer, and multiple public notices were pasted at the site. The State maintained that the petitioners were attempting to stall a long-pending redevelopment project, which had already benefited hundreds of residents.
The High Court had rejected the slum dwellers' plea, holding that due procedure was followed and over 508 beneficiaries were already relocated and awaiting new housing. It further observed that seven residential towers had already been constructed, undermining the claim that the petitioners were unaware of the redevelopment process.
The High Court had granted 30 days' time for voluntary vacation, provided the petitioners filed an undertaking.
Now, with the Supreme Court stepping in and indicating sympathy toward the plight of the slum residents, particularly on the issue of inadequate rent compensation, the case is set to be further heard on April 28, with the Court's assurance of balanced relief keeping the demolition in abeyance till then.
UNI SNG SJC
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
40 minutes ago
- Time of India
Scheme sanction limit of mukhiyas up
Patna: CM Nitish Kumar on Thursday made several key announcements for representatives of the three-tier panchayati raj system, including a 1.5-fold increase in their monthly allowances. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now He also declared that mukhiyas of gram panchayats would now be able to approve administrative works up to Rs 10 lakh under MGNREGA, up from the previous limit of Rs 5 lakh. The announcements were made during a meeting with gram panchayat, panchayat samiti and zila parishad representatives at the CM Secretariat here. Nitish also said that the construction of panchayat sarkar bhawans would be completed in all panchayats before the upcoming assembly elections. According to an official statement, the CM made six major decisions. These included an ex gratia of Rs 5 lakh to be given in case of normal deaths of panchayat representatives during their tenure. Earlier, this amount was only provided in cases of accidental deaths. In addition, panchayat representatives suffering from illness will be eligible for health assistance through the Chief Minister's Medical Assistance Fund. The CM also asked district officials to process applications for arms licences submitted by panchayat representatives within the stipulated time frame, in accordance with rules. "We have set a target to complete the panchayat sarkar bhawans in all gram panchayats before the elections," the CM said. "For this, the state govt has also approved the remaining 1,069 new panchayat sarkar bhawans. Orders are being issued to transfer the construction responsibility to the respective gram panchayats. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now If land is not available in the headquarters village, it can be acquired from a nearby village. I hope you will select the land soon and begin the work so that construction is completed ahead of schedule," the statement added. To enhance the utilisation of funds from the 15th Finance Commission and State Finance Commission, departmental schemes of up to Rs 15 lakh can now be implemented directly. Addressing the PRI representatives, Nitish said, "It is a matter of great happiness that this meeting has been organised. I was informed about your demands by the chief secretary and departmental officials. The panchayati raj department is taking action on most of them in line with the rules. Many of your demands have been fulfilled today." The CM also recalled the introduction of 50% reservation for women in the panchayati raj system in 2006 and in municipal bodies in 2007. "A large number of women are now leading society as elected representatives. We have worked for the development of all sections. We continue to engage with the representatives," he said.
The Hindu
40 minutes ago
- The Hindu
HC orders arrest of vessel owned by MSC on admiralty suit filed by five exporters
The Kerala High Court has ordered the arrest of Liberian-flagged vessel MV MSC Manasa F, along with among others, its paraphernalia, furniture, etc., at present anchored in the Vizhinjam Port, on an admiralty suit filed by five exporters who lost their consignment following the sinking of Liberian-flagged container vessel MSC Elsa 3 off the Kochi coast on May 25. This order will remain in effect until the owner firm of the vessels deposited ₹6 crore in the High Court. The counsel for the petitioners submitted that each one of them had lost containers in which they had sent their cargo, when the vessel sank. The warrant of arrest would be withdrawn, and the conditional order of arrest would automatically be vacated once the amount was deposited or security was furnished by the company in the court, without (waiting for) any further order, the court said. The shipping company does not have any movable or immovable properties within the territory of India, and hence, the petitioners were entitled to invoke the admiralty jurisdiction of the court for the arrest and detention of the vessel, their counsel said.
The Hindu
40 minutes ago
- The Hindu
After nudge by high command, Cabinet gives nod for fresh survey of castes
Nudged by the Congress high command, which had been petitioned by the politically-dominant Vokkaliga and Veerashaiva-Lingayat communities against accepting the Socio-Economic and Education Survey (caste census) report, the Karnataka Cabinet on Thursday gave its nod for a fresh survey. The Congress high command, on Tuesday, suggested to the Karnataka government to hold re-enumeration of caste data within a stipulated time to address concerns of some communities who complained of being 'left out.' With the Cabinet decision, the caste census of 2015 — which had been conducted for the first time during the colonial times in 1931 — is no longer valid. Reason for re-survey Saying that the lapse of 10 years since the conduct of the survey, by the Karnataka State Commission for Backward Classes headed by H. Kantharaj in 2015, as the reason for re-survey, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, in the post-Cabinet briefing, told presspersons: 'As per the Karnataka State Commission for Backward Classes Act, 1995, a fresh survey is mandated every 10 years. A lot of changes would have taken place in this last 10 years in the social and educational realm.' He also said that the Cabinet had, in principle, agreed to the survey report submitted by Mr. Hegde. When Mr. Siddaramaiah's response was sought on if the State government was under pressure from the high command, the Chief Minister said: 'The process was on. The high command has also advised for a new survey. We are not doing it just because they asked us to do a new survey. We have not succumbed to the pressure of the high command.' Asked why the State Cabinet had accepted the report in April, 2025, when it was nearly 10 years (survey conducted between April 11-2015 and 30 May, 2015), the Chief Minister said: 'It was only after discussions started that we realised that by law and Constitutional provisions it has to be done after a lapse of 10 years. As per Section 11 of the Act, any report after 10 years is not tenable. The provisions in the Act is clear that a new survey has to be conducted every 10 years after which a new list of backward classes could be drawn by either deleting existing castes or adding new castes.' It was also pointed out to the Chief Minister that when Mr. Hegde submitted his report, the survey had not completed 10 years. Within 90 days Stating that the fresh survey work would be completed 'within 90 days of notifying', he said that members to the backward classes commission will be appointed in the 'next two to three days'. Currently, barring chairman Madhusudan R. Naik, who was appointed in February 2025, posts of nominated members are vacant. Government appoints five members to the commission besides the chairman. It may be mentioned here that when the first Siddaramaiah-led government conducted the first survey in 2015 at a cost of ₹165 crore, Karnataka was the first State in the country to undertake the survey after the national exercise conducted by the British in 1931. Bihar and Telangana have done the survey after Karnataka completed the survey.
