Labor blocks debate on Coalition Senators Alex Antic and Matt Canavan's bill to restore biological definitions in Sex Discrimination Act
Liberal Senator Alex Antic and Nationals Senator Matt Canavan tabled a private senator's bill to amend the Sex Discrimination Act by removing references to gender identity, and 'restoring the act to its original purpose" on Thursday.
TheSex Discrimination Amendment (Restoring Biological Definitions) Bill would remove references to gender identity while returning clear definitions of a man and a woman as "members of the male and female sex respectively", Senator Antic said.
The Australian Sex Discrimination states it is unlawful to discriminate on the basis of age, disability, race, sex, intersex status, gender identity and sexual orientation, with the term 'gender identity' controversially added in 2013 by the Gillard government.
However, the Senate erupted on Thursday after Labor, the Greens and other members of the crossbench voted against the first reading being heard.
First readings are typically considered a parliamentary formality.
Deputy manager of Opposition business in the Senate Paul Scarr unleashed on Labor for vetoing debate and flatly rejecting the bill at the first reading stage.
'While the Senate has the opportunity to reject a bill at the first reading stage, in practise the first reading is almost always passed without opposition and is regarded as a purely formal stage,' Senator Scarr said in the Senate.
The Queensland Liberal Senator outlined that the Coalition in the past had supported numerous bills tabled by the Greens, Labor and the crossbench which it had 'strongly opposed'.
He said first readings were 'normal procedures' which should not be politicised.
'The normal process enables bills to be fairly considered and debated by the Senate before a substantive decision is taken. It should only be deviated from in the most extreme of circumstances, lest we deny the right of Senators to even have matters debated," he said.
Finance Minister and Manager of Government Business in the Senate Katy Gallagher conceded that first readings were a 'normal custom and practice'.
But she said the government would not allow the Senate to become a forum which could enable 'harm.'
'We do not agree with the Senate being a place where individual harm can be done to young people across this country. That is what would have happened had we allowed this bill to proceed in the normal course and we won't stand for it,' Senator Gallagher said.
The decision to block the bill's first reading was upheld and split down party lines, with the Greens and progressive independents siding with the government to quash debate completely while LNP and One Nation Senators voted in favour of Senator Antic and Senator Cannavan's bill.
The legislation was also scratched from the Parliament of Australia website, despite all other bills of the day being available for public viewing.
Queensland One Nation Senator Malcolm Roberts railed against the government for using its super-majority to clamp down on parliamentary debate.
'What we're seeing here is an example of control,' Senator Roberts said.
Senator Antic said that 'sex is not a social constrict' but rather a "core biological reality that underpins human nature" and that 2013 amendments "made discrimination based on appearance or mannerisms in relation to gender identity an offence.'
In mid-April over 5,000 academics, doctors, mental health practitioners and teachers urged the government to come clean on answering 'what is a women?' and to further remove the phrase 'gender identity' from section 5B of the Sex Discrimination Act.
In early April the UK's Supreme Court ruled that the term 'woman' is based on biological sex as opposed to gender identity.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
an hour ago
- The Australian
Evolution Mining CEO: Glencore smelter closure threatens green energy goals
A major Australian miner said it was nonsensical for the Albanese government to pursue lofty renewables targets without also stepping in to save Australia's only copper smelter and refinery, given the metal's importance as a supply source for green energy. The Glencore refinery and smelter in Queensland remain on the brink of closure after weeks of warnings from the company and talks with the state and federal governments. That's led to fears of another heavy industry shutdown just months after Labor campaigned on revitalising Australia's manufacturing sector, which is battling high labour and energy costs. The Albanese government is funding the underwriting of an expanded capacity investment scheme, which aims to fast-track the construction of major solar and wind projects to meet its 2030 target of 82 per cent renewables. Evolution Mining chief executive Laurie Conway said if the copper smelter closed, it would never re-open, and Australia would be forever consigned to importing the processed copper needed in big volumes for the energy transition. 'I think the Queensland and federal governments need to really understand that if that smelter closes, it will never reopen,' he said on the opening day of the Diggers & Dealers mining conference in Kalgoorlie. 'Having smelting capacity for a commodity that is going to be critical to the renewable pathway is fundamentally important, and I think the government has a role to play.' Anthony Albanese was given a green light to turbocharge his clean energy revolution, with the Productivity Commission declaring the net-zero transition will cost even more than expected and that greater government intervention, regulation, incentives and carbon pricing are needed to hit Labor's climate targets without crippling the power grid or damaging productivity. Mr Conway said the Queensland government's role was to provide services and support in the region, while the federal government needed to weigh up its responsibilities alongside its renewables targets and support for that industry. 'The more copper that you can process here, (the more it helps) in terms of renewables. You need copper to achieve those targets,' he said. 'If you don't have that capacity ... you are beholden to others.' It is understood Glencore held talks with the Queensland government on Monday but remains at an impasse in Canberra. Swiss-based Glencore is due to release its half-year results on Wednesday and provide an update on the future of the smelter and refinery that are losing about $30m a month. Glencore has said it will make its final decision by the end of September and has offered the federal government a range of assistance options, including handing part ownership to taxpayers. Mr Albanese talked tough on Glencore in parliament last Friday, but acknowledged his government wanted to protect the national interest and jobs in Mt Isa, where the smelter is based. 'Let's be clear about Glencore though. It is a highly profitable company. Just this year they paid $2.2bn in dividends to their shareholders. Australia has been pretty good to Glencore. It's about time that Glencore recognised it needs to be good back to Australia,' he said. Glencore's Mount Isa mining operation, known as MICO, closed last week, leaving it more reliant on supply from small and medium-sized copper mines in the northwest of Queensland. Evolution has a life-of-mine offtake agreement with Glencore covering copper produced from the Ernest Henry mine that Evolution acquired from Glencore for $1bn in 2021. The closure of the smelter would put the future of northern Australia's largest inland town in doubt. Mount Isa is the anchor city of Queensland's northwest, with its businesses and hospital servicing not only its 18,000 residents but the region as a whole. A global desire to decarbonise by 2050 would require a significant increase in the number of mines and volumes produced, according to experts. EY said part of the energy transition would require massive volumes of copper – about 41 million tonnes – necessitating the construction of about 40 new large copper mines globally. The Productivity Commission report also raised the issue of the government's controversial Capacity Investment Scheme for renewables which is due to stop in 2030 as potentially meaning the electricity sector might not decarbonise quickly enough in the next decade. Andrew Forrest's Squadron Energy said it advocated for policy settings that reflect 'the true value of firmed renewables' and enabled investment in generation storage, grid upgrades, and regional development. 'This aligns with the Commission's recommendation to replace the Renewable Energy Target and Capacity Investment Scheme with more effective market mechanisms post-2030,' Squadron said in a statement. Read related topics: Climate Change Politics Business leader Warwick Smith has warned Anthony Albanese to hasten slowly with any reforms agreed upon at the upcoming economic roundtable, amid warring unions and corporate groups. Business Australia will set minimum prices for rare earth minerals and broker national supply deals to break China's grip on the critical defence material.
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
2025 Tasmania Election results: Liberals and Labor fail to reach majority
The Liberals and Labor have kept the same number of seats in Tasmania, as two weeks of counting wrapped up in the state's snap election. Eighteen seats were needed to form a majority government but both parties fell short, the incumbent government secured 14 seats, Labor won 10 and the Greens five and other parties getting six. The final count played out on Saturday in the electorate of Bass in a race between Labor candidate Geoff Lyons and independent George Razay, seeing the independent take the final seat by 674 votes. Opposition leader Dean Winter introduced a motion of no confidence in Premier Jeremy Rockcliff in June, sparking a second state election within 16 months. Picture: NewsWire / Richard Jupe It was the second time Tasmanians voted within 16 months, after a no-confidence motion in Premier Jeremy Rockliff introduced by Labor leader Dean Winter passed 18-17 in June. Mr Winter claimed the botched roll out of new Spirit of Tasmania vessels, the state of the budget and the controversial Macquarie Point Stadium project were examples of Mr Rockliff's failed leadership. Instead of resigning, Mr Rockliff remained Premier, requesting a snap poll be held to determine his fate instead. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff was criticised over the budget and controversial plans to sell public owned companies which he scrapped in June. Picture: NCA NewsWire/ Nikki Davis-Jones Tasmanian Governor Barbara Baker approved the request, deciding there would be no alternative as the Opposition leader refused to put together a minority coalition of his own and the Liberal Party room 'unanimously' supported Premier Rockliff continue in his role. Following the election, the embattled Liberal government won most of the seats but fell short of the 18 required to form a majority government. Party leaders now need support from crossbenchers to form a minority government. The Liberal Party needs support from four crossbenchers to remain in government, while Labor requires support from The Greens and two crossbenchers to form a minority.
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
Anthony Albanese to announce $31m mobile TAFE centres during visit to the 2025 Garma Festival
Anthony Albanese will promise mobile TAFE centres to train Indigenous students in remote communities, with the Prime Minister set to make the announcement when he attends the Garma Festival in remote Arnhem Land this weekend. The $31m commitment, to be delivered alongside state and territory governments, will allow teachers to travel Australia using utes and trailers to train students in construction, mining, agriculture, carpentry, plumbing and community work, to ensure Indigenous people don't have to leave their communities to access that training. 'So that instead of communities relying on drive-in, drive-out workers to build and maintain the new homes we are delivering … locals get that training,' he is expected to say on Saturday. 'And instead of people having to move away from home to prepare for a career in mining or agriculture, construction or the care economy, we will bring skills and jobs to communities. 'Hands-on training, on country.' Anthony Albanese attending the Garma Festival in northeast Arnhem Land in 2024. Picture: Yothu Yindi Foundation/Nina Franova via NewsWire Labor will also promise $75m to help resource-strapped native title holders negotiate land use deals, to 'secure better deals, drive faster approvals and deliver a real and lasting economic legacy for communities. 'We must end the stalemate that arises when native title organisations with little in the way of back of house, or legal and commercial expertise, are expected to negotiate with multinational firms,' he will say. 'This is the tone and the standard we want this partnership to set, from the very start – pragmatic action that brings economic development, ownership and equity to communities. 'Not doubling-up on advice, or getting in the way of processes that are working.' In what will be his fourth time attending the large-scale event as Prime Minister, Mr Albanese will say that Labor's second term of government will be focused on 'delivery', with the government shifting focus to boosting economic empowerment among Indigenous Australians following the failure of the Voice referendum. It also coincides with this week's release of the Closing the Gap report which revealed Australia was only on track to meet four out of 19 targets, with efforts to reduce rates of Indigenous adult imprisonment, suicide rates and removing children in out-of-home care, and bring them in line with non-Indigenous peoples worsening. Australia was, however, expected to reach its targets to boost Indigenous preschool enrolments, employment and two land rights goals. Although Mr Albanese is expected to concede that there is 'more to do,' he will urge that 'closing the gap is a challenge all of us must meet' and took aim at the 'culture wars' instigated by the Coalition. This follows a successful motion at the WA Liberal Party state conference, which was supported by high-profile Liberal senator Michaelia Cash, and called for Welcome to Country ceremonies to be banned at official events. Mr Albanese will use his speech at Garma to call for an end to the culture wars saying they 'are a dry gully'. Picture: Yothu Yindi Foundation/Leicolhn McKellar via NewsWire Instead Mr Albanese will call on people to push back against people who 'choose the cheap politics of division over the patient work of lasting change or who seek to turn the grace and generosity of a welcome to country into a political weapon'. 'Culture wars are a dry gully. They offer us nothing, they lead us nowhere,' he will say. 'The way forward is to invest in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, trust in their aspirations and draw from their knowledge because when we lay these strong foundations together, there is no limit to what we can build.' New Liberal leader Sussan Ley will not attend the Garma Festival. Instead, shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser – who stood down from the front bench in 2023 because of his support of the Voice – will represent the Coalition. Ms Ley will, instead, travel to the Kimberley in Western Australia for a four-day listening tour with Indigenous communities and organisations. The Opposition Leader will also be joined by Coalition spokeswoman for Indigenous Australians Kerrynne Liddle and WA MP for Durack Melissa Price. Ms Ley said Mr Albanese had a 'personal obligation' to use his appearance at the Garma Festival to detail his government's plan to closing the gap. 'It is not good enough to just give speeches at festivals, we need to see his plan,' she said. 'Since the Voice Anthony Albanese has stepped back from Indigenous issues, that is not good enough. He led the referendum process, a process which was unsuccessful. So what is his path forward?' The four-day event, which started on Friday, will be the 25th anniversary of the Garma festival, which celebrates Yolngu culture – the name of Aboriginal peoples who inhabit northeastern Arnhem Land. The theme of this year's festival is 'rom ga waŋa wataŋu', or 'the law of the land, standing firm'. Read related topics: Anthony Albanese Jessica Wang NewsWire Federal Politics Reporter Jessica Wang is a federal politics reporter for NewsWire based in the Canberra Press Gallery. She previously covered NSW state politics for the Wire and has also worked at and Mamamia covering breaking news, entertainment, and lifestyle. @imjesswang_ Jessica Wang
