Tetchy scenes between neutrality activists and politicians during Triple Lock abolition meeting
Politicians on the committee are hearing from experts on a government proposal to remove the need for formal UN approval from the existing triple-lock system for deploying Irish troops abroad.
Niamh Ní Bhriain of the Transnational Institute and Chairperson of the Peace and Neutrality Alliance Stephen Kelly appeared before politicians today to advocate for the retention of the triple lock.
The pair clashed with TDs and senators on many occasions, as it become abundantly clear that there were vast differences in ideology between some members of the committee and the invitees.
At one point, Fianna Fáil senator Diarmuid Wilson called out Kelly for comments he made regarding politicians' ability to approve future military personnel deployments and Ní Bhriain for remarks about the deploying of Irish children.
In her opening remarkers, Ní Bhriain said: 'I urge the members of this Committee to scrutinise this legislation as though it were your sons and daughters being deployed on EU battlegroup or NATO-led missions.
'For those who vote in favour of this legislation such that it is eventually passed, you should know that if Irish personnel are deployed to future wars from which they will return maimed, traumatised or in body-bags – because no one returns from war unscathed – your cards will have been marked and this will be your legacy.'
Speaking later, Wilson told her: 'I speak as a father of a member of the Irish Defence Forces. And as I said to a number of people who came before us as witnesses, we take every piece of legislation seriously in this house.
'And we take it as if we're talking about the sons and daughters or gender-neutral members of any family. No matter what the piece of legislation, I want to assure you of that.'
Advertisement
'I do not appreciate those comments'
Kelly, in his opening remarks, questioned how effective a 'double lock', the deployment of troops following Government and Dáil approval, would be. He said the Peace and Neutrality Alliance reject it as an adequate replacement from the Triple Lock.
Both invitees refused to say what would be an adequate replacement to the triple lock, arguing that the existing framework is the closest thing to ensure the neutrality of Ireland in law.
Kelly accepted that neutrality and the triple lock were separate, but described them as 'close cousins'. Many politicians challenged this view, claiming that the abolition of the triple lock was to provide more control to Ireland around Defence Forces' deployments.
Addressing Kelly's remarks, Wilson asked if Kelly had ever stood for election, to which the chairperson of the neutrality group said he did not.
'Well, it's important that you realise the fact that the people who put themselves forward for election – in every election there are hundreds of people who put themselves forward, be it at local level or national level – some are successful, some are not, but at least they tried.
'I would suggest to you, you should try it yourself sometime before you make those comments in relation to public representatives,' he said.
Wilson continued to ask his questions to the invitees. Before answering, Kelly said: 'I don't particularly appreciate your comment.'
'I'm sure you don't,' Wilson replied.
'I don't appreciate it – at all. I'm a citizen, I've come here, I was invited to come here. I didn't have to, I was invited, I took the day off work. And I don't like the implication that you have to run for election to have an opinion on something,' Kelly said.
The committee today also heard from Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews and Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Bill and Hillary Clinton called to testify in Washington about Jeffrey Epstein
US POLITICIANS HAVE subpoenaed former president Bill Clinton and former secretary of state Hillary Clinton for testimony on Jeffrey Epstein, in a major escalation of the controversy surrounding the investigation into the notorious sex offender. The Clintons were among multiple former Democratic and Republican government officials – as well as the Justice Department – targeted by investigators reviewing the handling of the disgraced financier's case after he died in 2019 while awaiting trial for sex trafficking. Other officials targeted by the Oversight Committee include former FBI director James Comey, former special counsel Robert Mueller and ex-attorney generals Loretta Lynch, Eric Holder, Merrick Garland, Bill Barr, Jeff Sessions, and Alberto Gonzales. Their depositions will take place between mid-August and mid-October. Comer also issued a subpoena to the Justice Department for records related to Epstein – including its communications with Trump's predecessor Joe Biden and his officials. Politicians have also been seeking testimony from Epstein's accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell, who is serving 20 years in prison for her role in his alleged crimes – although her cooperation is considered unlikely. The latest move from Comer comes after Democrats on the oversight panel forced a vote to issue a subpoena just before the August recess, with three House Republicans backing the effort. 'Justice must apply to everyone, no matter how rich, powerful, or well-connected they are,' said Summer Lee, the Democratic congresswoman who introduced the motion. On the back foot The White House has been facing increasingly intense demands to be more transparent after the Justice Department angered Trump supporters – many of whom believe Epstein was murdered in a cover-up – when it confirmed last month that he had died by suicide in his prison cell and that his case was effectively closed. The department also said Epstein had no secret 'client list' – rebuffing conspiracy theories held by Trump's far-right supporters about supposedly high-level Democratic complicity. Advertisement Trump has urged his supporters to drop demands for the Epstein files, but Democrats in the Republican-led Congress – with some support from majority lawmakers — have also been seeking a floor vote to force their release. 'By your own admission, you flew on Jeffrey Epstein's private plane four separate times in 2002 and 2003,' House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer wrote to former president Clinton. 'During one of these trips, you were even pictured receiving a 'massage' from one of Mr Epstein's victims.' Ghislaine Maxwell, Jeffrey Epstein and Bill Clinton pictured together in 1993 Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo The White House has been seeking to redirect public attention from uproar over its handling of the affair with a series of headline-grabbing announcements including baseless claims that former president Barack Obama headed a 'treasonous conspiracy' against Trump. Epstein was for years a friend and associate of Trump and numerous high-profile people before he was convicted of sex crimes and then imprisoned pending trial for allegedly trafficking underage girls. His death supercharged a conspiracy theory long promoted by Trump supporters that Epstein had run an international paedophile ring and that elites wanted to make sure he never revealed their secrets. After Trump returned to power in January, his administration promised to release Epstein case files. When Attorney General Pam Bondi announced on 7 July that she had nothing to release, Republicans were furious – and Trump has attempted to control the scandal ever since. The case got even more complicated for the president after a Wall Street Journal report that he had written a lewd birthday letter to Epstein in 2003. Trump denies this and has sued the Wall Street. Journal. The Wall Street Journal then dropped a separate story, saying Bondi had informed Trump in May that his name appeared several times in the Epstein files, even if there was no indication of wrongdoing. - © AFP 2025
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
EU to appoint diplomat to help with efforts to free Gena Heraty
The EU will appoint a diplomat in Haiti to help in Irish efforts to free Gena Heraty and other hostages. It comes as the family of the kidnapped charity worker asked people to keep her in their hearts and pray for her safe and speedy return. Ms Heraty, from Westport, Co Mayo, was one of eight people seized from the Sainte-Hélène orphanage, about 10km from Port-au-Prince. As diplomatic efforts continue to secure her release, the Mayo woman's family issued a statement on Tuesday night through the Department of Foreign Affairs, saying they are still coming to terms with what has happened. 'We continue to work closely with Nos Petits Frères et Soeurs (NPFS) in Haiti and Ireland, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, and international partners who have all assured us that everything possible is being done to get Gena, and those taken with her, safely released as soon as possible,' the family said. 'Gena is loved and respected by so many people, as is evident in the outpouring of concern, support and prayers from everyone near and far. "We are truly so grateful for all the messages of support we have received over the past few days," they added. Earlier, Tánaiste and foreign affairs minister Simon Harris held talks his Haitian counterpart, Jean-Victor Harvel Jean-Baptiste, and said the minister assured him of his support in their work to ensure the safe release of Ms Heraty and all the hostages. Special point of contact Mr Harris has raised the case with the EU's high representative for foreign affairs and security policy, Kaja Kallas. Ms Kallas supported the Tánaiste's request for the EU to designate a specific point of contact in Haiti, working directly with Ireland on the ongoing efforts to free Gena and the other hostages. The EU currently has a team of representatives based in Haiti. A spokesman said the Tánaiste has been in 'constant contact with the Heraty family, and updated them on these developments'. They also stated that 'different avenues at both political and diplomatic level continue to be exhausted as part of the ongoing efforts to secure Gena'. " The kidnapping of Gena Heraty, her co-workers, and a three-year-old child is utterly devastating,' Mr Harris said. 'This is a particularly difficult time for the Heraty family. My Department and I will continue to provide them whatever support they need. "I was glad to secure the full backing of the EU's high representative for foreign affairs and security policy, Kaja Kallas. She has agreed to immediately put in place measures to support Ireland in relation to this case. "This is an important development, ensuring that this case is firmly on the agenda of the European Union and our EU colleagues," he added.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Foreign Affairs distances itself from Senator Martin Conway's speech in Finland
The Department of Foreign Affairs has stated that Senator Martin Conway, who has been the subject of a number of recent controversies, was not representing the State when he spoke at a recent political event in Finland. Mr Conway is subject to a Fine Gael disciplinary process following his arrest in January for being 'intoxicated' on O'Connell St in Dublin. In Helsinki last week he addressed the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE)'s Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) advisory panel on the political participation of persons with disabilities. The OSCE described the annual event as a 'chance to expand research, network with colleagues, and disseminate knowledge about the political participation of people with disabilities'. Mr Conway, who is visually impaired, was first appointed to the panel in 2021. More work needs to be done for inclusion & leadership of #PersonsWithDisabilities A great honor to provide opening remarks with Chair Martin Conway & @osce_odihr at the Advisory Panel meeting, in the spirit of #Helsinki+50 conference @IrishEmbFinland @Ulkoministerio @OSCE25FI — Katja Pehrman (@PehrmanKatja) July 30, 2025 In a post on social media platform X, Katja Pehrman, Finland's ambassador for human rights, shared a picture of herself and Mr Conway at the event. 'More work needs to be done for inclusion and leadership of Persons With Disabilities,' she said. 'A great honor [sic] to provide opening remarks with Chair Martin Conway.' She tagged the Irish Embassy in Finland in her post. A Department of Foreign Affairs spokesperson said Mr Conway was not representing Ireland at the event. 'Members of the ODIHR Advisory Panel on the Political Participation of Persons with Disabilities serve in their personal capacities as experts and do not represent any organisation or participating State,' they said. As such, this Department has no role in sanctioning participation or travel of members of the Advisory Panel. A spokesperson for Fine Gael stated that Mr Conway is 'no longer a member of the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party'. When asked about the ongoing disciplinary procedure, they referred to a previous statement from February confirming it had commenced. The Oireachtas did not pay for the trip. Senator Conway arrested in January Mr Conway was arrested on O'Connell St in Dublin in the early hours of January 22 'for being in an intoxicated state due to consumption of sleeping tablets and alcohol'. He was released without charge. He resigned from the Fine Gael parliamentary party just days after he was reappointed to the Seanad administrative panel for a fourth term. He was further accused of alleged inappropriate behaviour towards a female Oireachtas staff member working for Fine Gael. Mr Conway returned to Leinster House in early July. Sinn Féin TD Louise O'Reilly has repeatedly called for Fine Gael to address the scandal, amid reports that a €10,000 donation was made following alleged inappropriate behaviour. She told the Irish Examiner that the party and Mr Conway should be able to comment further now he is back at work. Ms O'Reilly said: There are questions for Fine Gael to answer in this regard and lots of questions left unanswered. 'He is still listed on the Oireachtas website as a Fine Gael member, so they will need to answer for him as a member. "I would definitely have concerns. I would definitely want to hear from him. 'Fine Gael really needs to settle all of these questions, given that the man is now back in work.' Mr Conway did not respond to phone calls or text messages.
