K-P seeks FED hike on gas, levy on oil
The Finance Ministry has raised concerns over the financial management of the oil and gas sector. PHOTO: PEXELS
Listen to article
The provincial government run by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) has demanded that the federal government increase federal excise duty (FED) on gas as well as introduce a similar levy on oil in the upcoming budget for fiscal year 2025-26.
Sources told The Express Tribune that special assistant to the K-P chief minister on energy and power took up the matter in a recent meeting with representatives of the federal government.
He apprised them that the FED on gas had not been revised for a long time and the duty had not been imposed on oil despite repeated requests from the provincial government.
Consequently, he said, Article 161 of the Constitution remains unimplemented. He requested the urgent attention of the federal government towards revising the FED on gas, based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI), and imposition of FED on oil in the upcoming budget.
K-P has emerged as a major oil and gas producing province. Therefore, it wants more revenue on the hydrocarbon production.
During the meeting, the federal and provincial governments decided that the director (oil) would carry out a consumer impact analysis in consultation with the K-P government and place the matter before the prime minister for a decision. In the meantime, the provincial government may also request the Finance Division and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to include the FED on oil in the FY26 budget.
Regarding the FED on gas, it was decided that the director (gas) would conduct a consumer impact analysis in consultation with the K-P government and place the matter before the prime minister for a decision. Meanwhile, the provincial government may also ask the Finance Division and the FBR to revise the FED on gas in the budget.
Moratorium on gas connection
The K-P government has also requested the federal government to relax the moratorium on new gas connections on an immediate basis in its oil and gas producing districts.
These districts are arguing that it is their right to receive gas supply. However, there have been many cases in some K-P districts where residents are receiving direct gas supply without paying bills, causing increase in the circular debt.
In order to expedite the execution of new gas development schemes in the oil and gas producing districts of K-P, it was decided that the director general (gas) would share cost estimates with the Energy & Power Department of the province. These schemes will be executed on a cost-sharing basis between Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and the K-P government through the provision of funds in the FY26 budget.
The special assistant to the K-P CM also drew attention towards the forced curtailment of gas supply from various fields in the province, which has not only resulted in production losses and damage to reservoirs, but also caused substantial revenue loss to the provincial government in the form of royalties, windfall levy, etc.
He requested the establishment of a mechanism to avoid the forced reduction of oil and gas production at local fields in the best interest of both the province and the federal government.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
8 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Pakistan's crypto bet: digital dream or power misstep?
On May 25, 2025, Pakistan's Finance Ministry threw open the gates to a digital frontier, allocating 2,000 megawatts (MW) of electricity — enough to power 1.5 million homes — to Bitcoin mining and AI data centers. Championed by the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC), this plan seeks to harness surplus power, lure foreign investors, and create tech jobs, riding the wave of Pakistan's 40 million crypto users and its ninth-place ranking in Chainalysis' 2024 Crypto Adoption Index. But in a nation where load-shedding once left families cooking by candlelight, diverting power to crypto farms while rural grids flicker ignites a fierce debate: is this a bold stride into the digital age or a reckless move that leaves Pakistan's people in the dark? Let's unpack crypto mining, its mechanics, and whether Pakistan can balance tech ambition with human needs. Digital gold with a steep power bill Crypto mining fuels currencies like Bitcoin, but its hunger for electricity puts Pakistan at a pivotal juncture. Picture a global ledger, open to all, recording every Bitcoin transaction — Ali paying Zara 0.1 BTC — without a bank's oversight. Miners deploy high-powered computers to solve cryptographic puzzles, ensuring no one double-spends their coins. In Bitcoin's Proof of Work system, the first to crack the puzzle earns 3.125 Bitcoins per block, worth $340,000 at May 2025's $109,000 per BTC. The rub? Mining rigs are energy hogs, with global operations burning 160 terawatt-hours annually, per the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index, matching Poland's power usage. In Pakistan, 2,000 MW could run thousands of rigs, each guzzling as much juice as three air conditioners. With 40 million crypto users, Pakistan's poised to turn digital coins into real wealth, potentially netting $1 billion a year. Yet, with 25% of rural households lacking reliable power, per the Pakistan Economic Survey 2023–24, prioritising miners risks public backlash. But can crypto trump basic needs? Pakistan must weigh whether digital riches justify the social and environmental costs, or if this bet will widen existing divides. How crypto mining works Mining's mechanics reveal why it's a tech marvel and a power drain; a duality Pakistan must navigate. Miners collect pending transactions, bundle them into a block, and run them through the SHA-256 algorithm, guessing a random 'nonce' to produce a hash with specific leading zeros. It's like scouring a K2-sised haystack, requiring billions of calculations per second. The winner adds their block to the blockchain, pockets the reward, and the race resets every 10 minutes, with difficulty adjusting biweekly. A single Bitmain Antminer S19 Pro uses 3,250 watts; a farm of thousands could devour Pakistan's 2,000 MW allocation. Bitcoin mining relies on energy-intensive processes to secure its trust less network, but in Pakistan, it's already drawing backlash. The perception that miners receive uninterrupted, subsidised electricity while rural areas endure four-hour outages fuels resentment. While the government's phase two renewable energy plan offers some hope, the coal-heavy phase one — with inefficient plants like Sahiwal operating at just 60% — threatens to lock in pollution. Without a decisive shift toward clean energy, this digital leap risks deepening inequality and environmental harm. Surplus power, persistent struggles Pakistan's energy sector is a riddle wrapped in a crisis, making the crypto bet a high-stakes gamble. The country generates up to 10,000 MW of surplus power in winter, driven by coal plants like the 1,320 MW Sahiwal and Port Qasim facilities, locked into take-or-pay contracts costing $1.2 billion annually for unused capacity, per the Pakistan Economic Survey 2023–24. High tariffs — 35 PKR/kWh (12 cents) — have driven 113,000 households to solar and net-metering, per NEPRA, slashing grid demand by 1,500 MW. The PCC sees this surplus as a goldmine: 2,000 MW for mining and AI could yield $1 billion yearly at 10 cents/kWh, draw $2–3 billion in FDI (based on Kazakhstan's 2021 peak), and leverage the Africa-2 cable's 180 terabits/second to position Pakistan as a data hub. Tax breaks and the PDAA add allure. Coal's continued dominance adding an estimated 4–5 million tons of CO2 annually intensifies Pakistan's already dire air quality crisis. In winter 2024, Lahore's Air Quality Index soared to 180, underscoring the environmental costs of fossil fuel dependence. Public frustration is mounting, with critiques emerging across media platforms and urging the government to commit to a 2030 renewable energy target. The irony is hard to ignore: while Pakistan sits on a massive 104,000 MW hydropower potential, only about 10% of it is currently harnessed, according to WAPDA. Redirecting energy toward crypto mining while millions still face rolling blackouts risks undermining public trust. The broader question is one of priorities; should limited energy resources be used to power digital assets or to close Pakistan's widening electricity access gap? For the energy transition to be credible and inclusive, surplus generation must be channelled toward long-term development goals, not just short-term profit. Deepening inequality? Pakistan's energy shortfalls, especially in rural areas, make the government's 2,000 MW allocation for crypto mining hard to justify. In 2023, rural communities endured daily outages stretching up to 12 hours, and in provinces like Balochistan, where only 40% of households are even connected to the grid, the frustration runs deep. The optics of uninterrupted electricity for crypto farms while millions struggle with basic access are politically and socially fraught. A parallel can be drawn with Nigeria's 2021 crypto surge, where miners' use of private generators drove up fuel prices and stoked public anger. The same resentment is brewing here. According to NEPRA's 2024 report, rural electricity demand is growing at 3% annually — and the 2,000 MW earmarked for mining could power 1.5 million homes instead. Criticism is gaining traction in public discourse, where voices from underserved regions argue that national priorities seem misaligned. The message is clear: people need reliable lighting, not digital ledgers. Yet, Pakistan's 10,000 MW surplus, unlike Nigeria's 7,000 MW deficit, offers breathing room. Net-metering's 1,500 MW relief could free power for mining without cuts, potentially funding grid upgrades. The hurdle is perception: if miners seem to hog power, resentment could erupt. Pakistan must prioritise rural electrification — perhaps via solar microgrids serving 500,000 homes by 2030 — to prove it values people over pixels. Global playbook: blueprints and blunders The world's crypto experiments offer Pakistan a roadmap and a minefield. El Salvador's geothermal Bitcoin mining, launched in 2021, has minted 2,000 Bitcoins ($218 million) by 2025, strengthening reserves without grid strain. Iceland powers 8% of global Bitcoin mining with geothermal and hydro at 2–4 cents/kWh, attracting firms like Bitfury. Bhutan, a lesser-known player, mines Bitcoin with 3,000 MW of hydropower, exporting $100 million in crypto revenue in 2024, per Reuters, without disrupting its 750,000 citizens. Kazakhstan's 2021 $1.5 billion mining boom crashed amid 7,000 MW shortages, and Iran's 2020 2,000 MW mining push triggered blackouts, costing $500 million, per Bloomberg. These examples drive home a tough but important lesson: crypto mining can't be divorced from a country's energy and governance realities. Nations like El Salvador, Iceland, and Bhutan succeeded because they aligned mining with abundant renewable resources — geothermal, hydro, and solar. Meanwhile, Kazakhstan and Iran went all-in on fossil fuels and paid the price: blackouts, public backlash, and wasted investment. Pakistan appears to be edging toward the latter path, given its coal-heavy energy mix. If it doesn't pivot soon, it could face the same fallout as Iran. But there's a way out — Pakistan has massive untapped renewable potential: an estimated 50,000 MW in wind and over 100,000 MW in hydro. Tapping into that, alongside enforcing clear, future-proof regulations through the proposed PDAA framework, could help Pakistan avoid the pitfalls that dragged Kazakhstan into regulatory chaos. The bottom line? The energy source you choose — and how you govern it — will either power a digital leap or spark a crisis. The payoff: tech revolution on the horizon Pakistan's crypto bet could reshape its economy, but it demands surgical precision. Cheap power (4–6 cents/kWh vs. India's 15 cents) positions Pakistan to lure $2–3 billion in FDI, with a multiplier effect creating 10,000 jobs per $1 billion invested, per a 2024 ADB study. The PCC's promise of IT and engineering jobs targets 8.5% youth unemployment, with 60% of Pakistanis under 30. The PDAA's asset tokenisation, digitising farmland or SMEs could bank 100 million unbanked, mirroring India's 8% IT growth via tech training. The Africa-2 cable, linking 33 countries, gives Pakistan an edge over Singapore's land constraints which holds the potential that Pakistan could be crypto's Dubai. Still, there's a real danger that this so-called digital revolution could leave millions behind. According to a 2024 World Bank report, only 20% of rural Pakistan currently has access to high-speed internet, and nearly 70% of rural youth lack the digital skills needed to participate in emerging tech sectors. Without serious intervention, the benefits of blockchain and Web3 are likely to be captured by urban elites, deepening the existing digital and economic divide. Initiatives like proposed blockchain training centers in Punjab and Sindh — which aim to equip 100,000 youth with relevant skills by 2030 — could be a crucial equaliser. But if these programs stall or fail to scale, rural communities will once again be locked out of the future. It's not just about infrastructure — it's about inclusion. A digital economy that doesn't invest in its most disconnected populations risks becoming a lopsided success story: shiny on the surface, but hollow at its core. The perils: a nation at risk of division However, several risks could undermine this vision. For one, coal-powered crypto mining could add an estimated 4–5 million tons of CO₂ emissions annually — on top of Pakistan's already staggering 90 million tons in 2023 — further exacerbating the country's severe air pollution crisis. According to a 2024 WHO estimate, smog-related illnesses contribute to nearly 10,000 premature deaths each year. Civil society voices have already begun raising concerns. But there have been voices which are critical and asking if we are choking for Bitcoin? This exactly is a reflection of growing public unease. Meanwhile, critics argue that favouring mining infrastructure over basic rural electrification is shortsighted, especially given that 70% of rural youth lack basic digital skills. History offers a warning: China's 2021 crypto mining ban led to a $10 billion investment loss, while Iran lost $500 million. With only 20% of rural Pakistan connected to the internet, the digital divide could widen into a full-blown development gap, leaving millions further behind. This is Pakistan's high-wire act: innovation versus fairness. If mining enriches Karachi while Balochistan stays dark, it's a recipe for unrest. The government must weave rural communities into this digital tapestry, or the threads will unravel. Seizing the moment, dodging the traps Pakistan's crypto bet could catapult it into the digital age, but the pitfalls are steep. Training 100,000 youth in blockchain and AI by 2030 could turn Pakistan's 60% under-30 population into a tech powerhouse. Sindh's 50,000 MW wind, 1,000 MW solar, and 104,000 MW hydro potential could make Pakistan a green mining leader, drawing ESG investors wary of coal's fallout. The Africa-2 cable positions Pakistan to outshine Singapore, but execution is everything. But access and connectivity are also important; the demand to have access to 5G technology in rural areas to close the 80% connectivity gap is also legitimate. Policies like solar microgrids for 500,000 homes and tax-funded tech academies to mirror India's IT boom. The structural pitfalls of this strategy are increasingly hard to ignore. Lack of transparency in resource allocation has already raised alarm, with energy policy critics questioning how decisions are made and who stands to benefit. But regarding who picks the winners highlights the public's growing scepticism about elite capture and favouritism in energy investments. Delaying a transition to renewables beyond 2030 doesn't just risk environmental fallout; it could expose Pakistan to future trade sanctions and global isolation as climate accountability becomes stricter. Continued coal reliance is already exacting a human toll. Moreover, sidelining rural regions from the digital economy risks cementing a digital caste system, where unequal access to infrastructure reinforces long-standing economic divides. To truly future-proof its development, Pakistan must commit to public audits of energy investments, set a firm green energy deadline for 2030, and prioritise expanding 5G coverage to at least 50% of rural areas by 2028. Without these structural reforms, the current vision may end up being more of a gamble than a strategy — one that places the country's environmental, economic, and social future at considerable risk. Power for all, not just the blockchain Pakistan's 2,000 MW crypto venture could mint wealth, spark jobs, and plant the nation on the global tech map. But in a country where power cuts once defined life, every megawatt diverted to miners must answer to the people. By racing to renewables, training rural youth, and embracing transparency, Pakistan can make this a national triumph, not an urban elite's windfall. The stakes are sky-high, and the world's watching: will Pakistan light up its future or leave its people in the shadows? Ali Asad Sabir is working as project manager at Mahbub ul Haq research centre at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) All facts and information are the sole responsibility of the author
Express Tribune
12 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Retailers push for tax reforms
Listen to article Pakistan's organised retail sector on Friday urged the government to overhaul the current retail taxation structure in the upcoming Finance Bill 2025-26, highlighting the need for fairer policies to support compliant businesses and expand the tax base. In an appeal to Federal Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb, the Chainstore Association of Pakistan (CAP) — representing over 150 Tier-1 retail chains — called for inclusive policymaking through structured consultation with the private sector. CAP said the budget presents a key opportunity to address long-standing disparities and bring undocumented retailers into the tax net without penalising formal players. The association expressed confidence in the government's commitment to economic revival. CAP underscored the contributions of integrated retailers to employment, commerce, tax revenue, and exports, despite their small share in the overall retail sector. Currently, POS-integrated retailers contribute around 25-30% of turnover in taxes under various heads, while most of the sector remains either under-taxed or undocumented. CAP warned this imbalance has placed an unsustainable burden on documented businesses, forcing many to downsize or shut down. CAP Chairman Asfandyar Farrukh said strict enforcement actions and unresolved technical issues in the FBR-POS system have disrupted compliant retailers. The removal of GST concessions last year and the failure of the Tajir Dost Scheme due to poor planning worsened matters.
Express Tribune
12 hours ago
- Express Tribune
High dollar value fueling inflation
Listen to article The persistent high value of the US dollar against the Pakistani rupee continues to exert significant pressure on inflation within the country. Economists widely identify the exchange rate as a primary factor driving price increases. Due to this critical factor, the continuous drop in inflation, ie, 0.3% in April 2025 against 0.7% in March 2025, is not helping the federal as well as provincial governments to bring down prices of essential commodities, even the local produce did not match the price tag as it was a couple of years ago. "A weaker rupee directly increases the cost of all imports priced in dollars," said economist Osama Siddiqui. This includes essential items like medicines, industrial inputs and food Pakistan does not produce sufficiently. When the rupee falls from, say, 230 to over 280 per dollar, the landed cost in rupees for these goods rises substantially. "This cost-push effect is a major contributor to inflation, easily accounting for a significant portion of the price surge in imported goods. Recent data shows the rupee is trading consistently above 280 per dollar, compared to approximately 175 two years ago," he added. This dollar strength critically impacts petroleum prices, as Pakistan imports roughly 80% of its oil needs. "The kerb rate and official exchange rate directly influence the rupee cost of importing oil," said Muhammad Fareed, a money exchanger. A rise in the dollar rate translates very quickly into higher fuel prices at the pump. Higher petroleum costs then cascade through the economy via increased transportation expenses. Diesel and petrol are fundamental to logistics, said transport operator Riaz Hussain. "A 20% increase in diesel significantly raises the per-kilometre operating cost for transporting goods. This surcharge is inevitably passed on, inflating the prices of everything moved, from food staples to manufactured goods," he added. Economists estimate that fuel and transportation costs constitute about 35% of Pakistan's Consumer Price Index (CPI), directly linking fuel hikes to overall inflation, which peaked at over 38% last year. Global trade dynamics further complicate the situation. Disruptions in international supply chains directly increase the cost of Pakistan's essential imports like wheat, pulses and edible oil. "Events like the Red Sea tensions force longer shipping routes, doubling or tripling freight charges in some instances," Siddiqui added. "These are dollar-denominated costs. Any global supply chain issue or increased shipping risk translates into higher import bills for Pakistan, requiring more dollars and further pressuring the exchange rate and domestic prices." Geopolitical uncertainty, particularly surrounding major economies, adds another layer of pressure. Financial analyst Saad Mahmood pointed to concerns about potential policy shifts. "Global markets react to uncertainty and right now uncertainty is at its peak. The ongoing conflicts between, Russia, Ukraine, Israel and Hammas, with another threat of Iran being attacked in case they failed to reach any nuclear deal; and the Trump's trade war with China, European Union, etc, all are adding to the uncertainty. Capital often flows out of emerging markets like Pakistan towards perceived safer assets like the US dollar during such times." This reduced dollar supply within Pakistan makes the currency scarcer and more expensive. "When major international news breaks, especially involving the US or conflicts, demand for dollars often surges locally as people seek security, pushing the exchange rate up further," Mahmood said. The combined effect of the high dollar exchange rate, its impact on fuel and transportation, global trade disruptions and geopolitical uncertainty creates a challenging environment for price stability in Pakistan. The rising cost of essential imports, amplified by expensive transportation, continues to translate into higher prices for consumers across the board. To reverse the dollar's inflationary impact, Pakistan must boost exports and reduce import dependency, economists advise. "Increasing exports like textiles, IT services and agricultural goods is crucial to earn more foreign exchange," Siddiqui said. Simultaneously, promoting local manufacturing of essentials such as edible oils, pulses and industrial inputs would lessen the need for dollar-funded imports. Attracting foreign investment and securing stable financing to build reserves are vital to stabilise the rupee. Adequate reserves instill market confidence and reduce speculative pressure on the dollar while long-term fiscal discipline and policy consistency are essential to break the cycle of currency-driven inflation. "Right now remittances are the only window which is increasing decently, however, countries cannot only survive on this source of income, the world has entered into an era of artificial intelligence, we as a country must focus on this crucial aspect and catch the prosperity trains, which we have missed previously," he added.
