Nobel Prize Winner Warns About Astronomers Using AI to Make Discoveries
Reinhard Genzel, a Nobel laureate and an astrophysicist at the Max Planck Institute, expressed some skepticism regarding the team's use of AI, and the quality of the data they fed into the model.
"I'm very sympathetic and interested in what they're doing," Genzel told Live Science. "But artificial intelligence is not a miracle cure."
Raging at the center of the Milky Way some 26,000 light years away is Sagittarius A*, a supermassive black hole with over 4.3 million times the mass of the Sun, and an event horizon nearly 16 million miles in diameter.
Back when it wasn't clear what Sagittarius A* was other than a weird bright object in the galactic center, Genzel and fellow astrophysicist Andrea Ghez illuminated its colossal scale and eventually proved that it was a supermassive black hole, a feat that earned them both a Nobel Prize in physics in 2020.
But much of our galaxy's dark, beating heart remains a mystery, as do supermassive black holes in general. How and when do these cosmic behemoths form, and how do they gain such incredible mass? Astronomers agree that they would have to have been formed in the early universe, but the rest remains contentious.
One reason is that no star is heavy enough to directly collapse into an object of a supermassive black hole's size. True, they can grow by swallowing nearby matter, like an unfortunate star that wanders too close, or even merging with another black hole, but that doesn't explain all cases. Some are so massive that the time it'd take for them to accrete enough matter to reach their observed size would be older than the universe itself.
A breakthrough came in 2022, when astronomers revealed the first image of Sagittarius A* taken with the Event Horizon Telescope, three years after the same observatory — which is actually made up of several radio telescopes scattered across the globe — was used to stitch together humankind's first image of a black hole whatsoever.
But the image — and the data that comprised it — was fuzzy. There wasn't enough detail present to tease out the black hole's structure or behavior.
That's where this latest work, detailed in three studies published in the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics, comes in. In a nutshell, the astronomers trained a neural network on millions of synthetic simulations using discarded ETH data that was deemed too grainy to decode, largely due to the interference introduced by the Earth's atmosphere. Once the AI model cut its teeth on the synthetic data, it looked at the real observations of Sagittarius A* and produced a much clearer image.
"It is very difficult to deal with data from the Event Horizon Telescope," coauthor of the main study Michael Janssen, an astrophysicist at Radboud University in the Netherlands, told Live Science. "A neural network is ideally suited to solve this problem."
The AI-enhancement suggested that the supermassive black hole is rotating somewhere between 80 to 90 percent of its maximum possible velocity, which is blindingly fast, as these objects can spin at a significant fraction of the speed of light. Its rotation axis, in fact, appears to be pointing towards the Earth. The AI model also revealed that the black hole's emissions are coming from its accretion disk — the glowing disc of hot matter swirling just outside its event horizon — and not an energetic outburst called a jet that's produced by the black hole's absurdly powerful magnetic fields.
Genzel isn't totally sold on these findings. The renowned astrophysicist told Live Science that the poor quality of the data fed into the model could have biased it in unexpected ways. As a result, what we're seeing could be heavily distorted, and shouldn't be taken at face value, he said.
That isn't to say we should write off "AI" — a buzzword whose meaning has been diluted by tech companies shoving their unfinished products into every facet of modern life — being used in astronomy.
With the number of telescopes now in operation, it's impossible for humans to sift through all the data they collect manually. The European Space Agency's monumental Gaia survey, for example, has cataloged over two billion stars and counting. AI is already being used to classify cosmic objects. But it's worth being cautious about its application in the field all the same, since scientists aren't immune to hype, either.
Jannsen, for his part, seems well aware that his team's AI findings are far from definitive, but is sticking to his guns.
"That we are defying the prevailing theory is of course exciting," Janssen said in a statement. "However, I see our AI and machine learning approach primarily as a first step. Next, we will improve and extend the associated models and simulations."
More on space: Long-Dead NASA Satellite Suddenly Lets Out Epic Blast of Energy
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Earliest Black Hole Ever Confirmed Could Explain Mysterious Red Dots
Astronomers have confirmed the earliest, most distant black hole yet – and it's surprisingly monstrous for its time. Residing in a galaxy called CAPERS-LRD-z9, it was already approximately 300 million times the mass of the Sun just 500 million years after the Big Bang, when the baby Universe was just 3 percent of its current age. Additionally, this discovery sheds literal light on an ancient, mysterious class of celestial objects called Little Red Dots (LRDs), which are perplexingly bright, small, red objects in the early Universe. They appear around 600 million years after the Big Bang then start disappearing less than a billion years later. LRDs have only recently been revealed by JWST's unprecedented infrared ability to explore Cosmic Dawn, the universe's earliest epochs. These are also the Universe's reddest epochs, as the light reaching JWST has been stretched to ever-redder wavelengths on its long journey through the expanding fabric of spacetime. Related: The newly confirmed supermassive black hole at the heart of CAPERS-LRD-z9 is known as an active galactic nucleus (AGN), the bright, rapidly feeding black hole at the center of a galaxy. It appears red because it's enveloped in a glowing cocoon of gas and dust, which may make it a science-fiction-sounding "black hole star." The gravity of this supermassive black hole is whipping the gas around it to mind-boggling speeds of around 3,000 kilometers (1,864 miles) per second, or 1 percent the speed of light. These gassy winds are what help astronomers reveal the presence of black holes via spectroscopy. "There aren't many other things that create this signature," explains lead author Anthony Taylor, astrophysicist at the University of Texas at Austin. Spectroscopy splits incoming light into its wavelengths to yield a spectrum that reveals information about an object. In this case, the light waves from the gas around the black hole gets stretched and turns redder when it moves away from an observer. Conversely, light becomes compressed and bluer when it's moving toward an observer. These changes reveal an object's velocity. Importantly, the spectroscopic confirmation of CAPERS-LRD-z9 supports the idea that LRDs contain supermassive black holes, with "supermassive" being an understatement: some reach 10 million solar masses within their first billion years. For comparison, the supermassive black hole at the core of the Milky Way is about 4 million solar masses. The black holes at the heart of LRDs may not just be supermassive, but "overmassive," with mass ratios approaching 10 percent to 100 percent of their host galaxy's stellar mass. Specifically, at up to around 300 million solar masses, the supermassive black hole in CAPERS-LRD-z9 has the equivalent of about half the mass of all the stars in its galaxy. By contrast, more local galaxies may have central black holes that are only about 0.1 percent of their stellar mass. For added size perspective, CAPERS-LRD-z9 is so compact that not even JWST can resolve it. It seems to be, at most, 1,140 light-years wide – in the realm of the dwarf galaxies that orbit the Milky Way. The researchers say that there are two ways for a black hole to grow so massive within just 500 million years of cosmic time. Both start with a big, heavy "seed" black hole growing at different rates. If it's growing at the theoretical upper limit of black hole growth, known as the Eddington rate, the seed might have started with around 10,000 solar masses. Or, it could have started off much smaller, at just 100 solar masses. That seed would have to grow even faster, at the super-Eddington rate, force-fed by gravity and the thick, dense envelope of gas around it. The seeds themselves may originate as primordial black holes produced when the Big Bang, well, banged. They may also form from the collapse of Population III stars (the elusive first stars to illuminate the cosmos), from "runaway collisions" in dense star clusters, or from the direct collapse of immense, primordial gas clouds. Overall, it's difficult to peer much farther in spacetime: "When looking for black holes, this is about as far back as you can practically go. We're really pushing the boundaries of what current technology can detect," adds Taylor. Finally, this research adds evidence that LRDs were an ephemeral phenomena in the early universe, and potentially an initial step in galactic evolution that may have birthed the Milky Way itself. This research is published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters. Related News Supermassive Black Hole Caught in The Act of Switching on Star Trying to Swallow a Black Hole May Have Triggered a New Type of Supernova Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Seen in Stunning New Hubble Image Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Our Closest Sun-Like Star May Host a World Where Life Could Thrive
There may be a habitable world at the Sun's closest solar twin. In the complex space inhabited by the Alpha Centauri triple star system, JWST has just discerned the presence of a giant exoplanet orbiting Alpha Centauri A, the most Sun-like of the three stars. Moreover, that exoplanet is in the star's habitable zone – the perfect distance from the star for liquid water to pool. But wait – there's more. Evidence of the prospective world, which is tentatively known as Alpha Centauri Ab, was discovered using direct imaging in what could be a significant breakthrough for exoplanet science. Related: "If confirmed, the potential planet seen in the Webb image of Alpha Centauri A would mark a new milestone for exoplanet imaging efforts," says astrophysicist Aniket Sanghi of the California Institute of Technology. "Of all the directly imaged planets, this would be the closest to its star seen so far. It's also the most similar in temperature and age to the giant planets in our Solar System, and nearest to our home, Earth." The Alpha Centauri system is located just 4 light-years away, a triple system made up of the binary pair Alpha Centauri A and Alpha Centauri B, orbited at a greater distance by the red dwarf star Proxima Centauri. Other exoplanets are already known in the system. Three have been found orbiting Proxima Centauri, including one within the star's habitable zone. But the conditions around red dwarf stars – which tend towards the tempestuous – may be less hospitable than those around stars like the Sun. The detection of worlds in the central binary has been more difficult to accomplish. "With this system being so close to us, any exoplanets found would offer our best opportunity to collect data on planetary systems other than our own," says astronomer Charles Beichman, director of the NASA Exoplanet Science Institute at Caltech. "Yet, these are incredibly challenging observations to make, even with the world's most powerful space telescope, because these stars are so bright, close, and move across the sky quickly." To date, Alpha Centauri B remains without a known world. However, glimmers of something have been spotted in orbit around Alpha Centauri A, the brightest of the three stars and belonging to the same G-type class as the Sun. In 2021, a team of astronomers led by Kevin Wagner of the University of Arizona announced a tentative detection of an exoplanet in the habitable zone of Alpha Centauri A, identified using direct imaging. Most exoplanets are found using indirect methods, such as looking for regular dips in starlight, blocked by the orbiting exoplanet, or changes in starlight associated with the gravitational effect of the exoplanet's presence. Sanghi, Beichman, and their colleagues used JWST to look for further evidence of this world, taking their first observations in August 2024, using a coronagraph to mask the light from Alpha Centauri A. After subtracting the light from Alpha Centauri B, their results showed a faint point source, at around twice the distance from Alpha Centauri as Earth is from the Sun. But follow-up observations conducted in February and April of 2025 revealed no such object. "We are faced with the case of a disappearing planet!" Sanghi explains. "To investigate this mystery, we used computer models to simulate millions of potential orbits, incorporating the knowledge gained when we saw the planet, as well as when we did not." These simulations also included the sighting of Wagner and his team. In about half the simulations, the exoplanet was too close to the star to be detected, its presence drowned out by all the bright light – supporting the case for Alpha Centauri Ab. This world, the researchers determined, would have a radius of around 1 to 1.1 Jupiters, a mass between 90 and 150 Earths, comparable to Saturn's 95-Earth mass, and orbit at about twice the Earth-Sun distance, squarely in the habitable zone. This set of properties describes a world that would have to be a gas giant, which places its potential habitability into question. However, gas giants in the Solar System are lousy with moons that could have habitable conditions – so the nature of the exoplanet doesn't rule out life around Alpha Centauri A. However, more work needs to be done to confirm the existence of Alpha Centauri Ab, and figure out how the heck it even formed in the complex gravitational environment of the Alpha Centauri system. "Its very existence in a system of two closely separated stars would challenge our understanding of how planets form, survive, and evolve in chaotic environments," Sanghi says. The finding is detailed in two papers in The Astrophysical Journal Letters. They can be found here and here. Related News JWST Delivers Bad News About Life on TRAPPIST-1 Planet Record US$5.3M Sale of Largest Mars Rock Sparks Global Dispute Earliest Black Hole Ever Confirmed Could Explain Mysterious Red Dots Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Building Blocks of Life Discovered Circling a Baby Star
Molecules capable of forming the precursors to sugars and amino acids have been detected, for the first time, in the disk of dust and gas whirling around a newborn star. The detection is tentative, but it offers a window into how complex life gets its start from the chemistry in space, not just before planets are born, but even before the formation of the stars. "Our results suggest that protoplanetary disks inherit complex molecules from earlier stages," explains astrochemist Kamber Schwarz of the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy (MPIA) in Germany, "and the formation of complex molecules can continue during the protoplanetary disk stage." Related: The Building Blocks of Life Are Left-Handed, And The Reason Could Come From Deep Space Stars and their planets are born from dense clouds of cold molecular gas and dust that drift through galaxies. When a clump of gas becomes dense enough, it collapses under its own gravity to form a spinning, dense mass. Material continues to fall in from the cloud as the newly formed sun grows, angular momentum forcing surrounding dust to arrange itself in the shape of a disk that spools into and feeds the star. Eventually, stellar winds and radiation pressure will push the material away from gravitational reach; what's left of the disk is what the planets form out of. You are literally made of star leftovers… that's a fun thought. The processes involved in this formation, in addition to rampant flare activity from a tempestuous new star, have been considered a barrier to the survival of biomolecules within the protoplanetary disk. Thus, any biomolecules that contribute to planet formation must, in theory, have formed after the star has undergone its destructive shenanigans. This brings us to a still-forming protostar called V883 Orionis, a star about 1,350 light-years away that is still in its destructive phase. Using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) in Chile, a team led by MPIA astronomer Abubakar Fadul has studied the spectrum of light, and found evidence of at least 17 complex organic molecules. Those molecules include ethylene glycol (a simple sugar alcohol from which more complex molecules can form) and glycolonitrile (a precursor of the amino acids glycine and alanine, and the nucleobase adenine). Their presence in the protoplanetary disk of an outbursting protostar suggests that they are inherited from the molecular cloud, filling in an evolutionary gap between pre- and post-stellar disk biochemistry. "Our finding points to a straight line of chemical enrichment and increasing complexity between interstellar clouds and fully evolved planetary systems," Fadul says. The conditions under which these molecules form are very cold ones. The researchers believe that they formed on ice grains in the cloud, which then clumped together, forming icy objects with the molecules locked inside. As the baby star grew, its increasing heat sublimated the ice, releasing the molecules from within, to drift in the disk where their signature could be detected by ALMA. Even so, the signal was a small one, and is going to require higher resolution observations at longer wavelengths. These won't just confirm the molecules that the researchers have already found, they'll also identify new ones. The researchers are particularly keen to see if they can find molecules containing nitrogen, which were curiously low in the ALMA data. "Perhaps we also need to look at other regions of the electromagnetic spectrum to find even more evolved molecules," Fadul says. "Who knows what else we might discover?" The research has been published in The Astronomical Journal. Related News 'Mysterious Giant' Hints at The First Detection of a Black Hole Trinary NASA Probe Could Intercept Interstellar Comet, Scientists Say Our Closest Sun-Like Star May Host a World Where Life Could Thrive Solve the daily Crossword
