Protesters take to Holyrood amid 'deadlocked' Ardrossan Harbour deal
Instead, the Glen Sannox has had to travel to Brodick from Troon, which takes longer and is widely viewed as much less convenient for the people of Arran who need to get to medical appointments at Crosshouse Hospital in Kilmarnock – for which there is a direct bus route from Ardrossan.
Transport Minister Fiona Hyslop announced back in February that money had been set aside to take Ardrossan Harbour into public ownership, but campaigners have become frustrated with a lack of movement since then.
This has only been compounded by the fact the Scottish Government pledged back in 2018 to ensure Ardrossan remained the gateway to Arran.
The project to upgrade the harbour was then paused in 2023 amid concern over rising costs and disagreements over how the bill should be split between the three partners: harbour owners Peel Ports, North Ayrshire Council and the Scottish Government.
READ MORE: Scottish Government accused of 'sidelining' climate action
Campaigners from both sides of the Firth of Clyde – who were supported by cross-party politicians - turned up in their dozens to Holyrood to say 'enough is enough', as they called for Hyslop and the Scottish Government to get directly involved in securing a deal.
'It's been going on for far too long. We've been neglected to the extreme. Businesses are closing in both areas and local communities are disgusted with what's going on,' said Margaret Roberts, from the Arran for Ardrossan Harbour campaign.
'The most important thing is hospital appointments are having to be cancelled, important medication and appointments are being missed.
'It's not fair on the local people. North Ayrshire needs this service to be resolved now.'
(Image: NQ) Chants of 'Fiona Hyslop, more hands on' and 'Ardrossan's the crossing' could be heard outside Holyrood as MSPs from Labour, the Conservatives and Greens spoke in solidarity with protesters.
Wyllie Hume, chair of the Arran for Ardrossan Harbour campaign, previously told The National a meeting with Peel Ports, CMAL and Transport Scotland had left him 'flabbergasted', as campaigners were left feeling as if the deal 'could fail'.
The Ardrossan Harbour issue was raised during FMQs by Labour MSP Katy Clark and SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson.
Gibson put to the First Minister that talks appear 'deadlocked', stressing if the situation is not resolved, Arran 'will not have the lifeline service it deserves' and Ardrossan 'will struggle'.
He asked if the Scottish Government would 'inject urgency' into the process.
(Image: NQ) Swinney said negotiations have the 'attention and focus' of ministers and CMAL and the Government is 'focused on a long-term solution for Ardrossan Harbour'.
He added it remained the 'key port' for Arran.
Clark asked the FM if he agreed a process of compulsory purchase needed to start if there was no progress by summer recess – the end of next week.
John Swinney said he would explore compulsory purchase but it had been indicated to him the Scottish Government 'does not have the basis to do so'.
'The Government is actively engaged in the dialogue to acquire Ardrossan Harbour to enable the long-term commitment that Katy Clark seeks.'
READ MORE: 300 jobs at risk as firm moves Scottish Power contract to South Africa
Save Ardrossan Harbour committee member Donna Cullinane said she wants to see ministers get directly involved to speed up negotiations, with shops in Ardrossan losing business.
She told The National: 'We want the deal done. We want the ministers involved, not CMAL.
'We want the harbour fixed. Why build two ferries that don't fit?'
Asked about whether she was concerned for the Ardrossan economy, she added: 'I'm very worried. You can tell even now there's a lack of vehicles coming through, lack of economy, because people are not stopping at the shops.
'A lot of the shops are losing revenue.
'It needs to be done for the sake of people on Arran who are coming for medical appointments. There's a bus route from Ardrossan to Kilmarnock every 20 minutes.
'If people from Arran are coming over for an appointment, they've got to really plan it [from Troon], and it can be an overnight stay for them.'
Transport Scotland has previously said to The National it is 'wholly appropriate' for CMAL to lead on negotiations on behalf of ministers.
Peel Ports has said, meanwhile, there has not been enough 'pace and energy' from CMAL and Transport Scotland, while CMAL has said it has to 'deliver the best value for the public purse'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
35 minutes ago
- The National
Should the SNP be relying on their stars of the past – or charting a new course?
Blackford, his party's former group leader at Westminster, has said supporters have been urging him to stand in the constituency of Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch after its current MSP, Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes, announced she will be standing down in 2026. Nostalgia is a powerful emotion, and it will no doubt have been a factor in those anonymous supporters deciding to try to tempt the 'humble crofter' back into Parliament. Just look at what it's done to Hollywood. Nostalgia has seen billions of dollars thrown at lavish remakes of old Disney favourites, from The Lion King and Snow White to Aladdin and Mulan. I didn't even realise there had been a Peter Pan remake until today. READ MORE: Scottish activists mark 80 years since atomic bombings with new 'peace garden' Other studios are also getting in on the action, with DreamWorks this year releasing a shot-for-shot remake of How to Train Your Dragon – which saw Gerard Butler deliver the exact same lines in the exact same Scots brogue as he did 15 years ago. Is that what Scottish politics needs? Blackford, while serving as SNP Westminster leader, did give the party one of its most iconic moments in recent history when, in 2018, he led MPs out of the Commons in protest after he was kicked out by the Speaker. In that moment, he stood for everything party members were calling for: the SNP standing up to Westminster. Party membership rose by more than 5000 in the 24 hours following the mass walkout. Not bad for a day's work. With membership now dwindling, branches haemorrhaging local activists, and others threatening to leave if Swinney doesn't allow alternative independence strategies to be considered alongside his at conference in October, this would be an ideal time for a membership surge powered by nostalgia for 'the good old days'. But would Ian Blackford's return work? In Hollywood, remakes have been branded 'uncreative' and 'cash grabs'. At Holyrood, it is not difficult to imagine the same accusations being levelled at the SNP and Blackford respectively, should he bid for an MSP's paycheque. Swinney himself is a case-in-point example of a former high heid yin coming back to provide some (arguably perceived) stability to a political party. It was the same with Cameron for the Tories in 2022 – with a Lords seat his reward in place of the First Minister job. They knew the workings of parliaments, had name recognition with voters, and the familiar face brought credibility in a time of 'chaos'. Great. But a key sticking point surrounding Swinney's entire leadership is the lack of renewed thinking. There is little spark, no fire, and a desperate repackaging of the old independence strategy is reigniting internal party tensions that have simmered since Nicola Sturgeon's day. He is proving uninspiring and failing to bring in new members, even if he is described as 'a nice guy'. With an eye on the future, members are looking instead to Cabinet Secretary Mairi McAllan (a mentee of Sturgeon) and at current SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn – the man who ousted Blackford. READ MORE: 'It won't work': John Swinney dismisses SNP members' rival independence plan Does Blackford bring gravitas and adaptability to a potential second hurrah? Gravitas, yes. That is why his supporters have been a-ringing. But adaptability? I can't see it. He is a senior enough figure that he could block chances of renewal within the party – and bring just a little too much political nostalgia to put off swing voters. The suggestion of Blackford returning doesn't give a sense of a broader renewal back to the SNP's heyday, it looks a lot like recycling the old guard – and signals that the party either cannot attract or does not want a new generation leading the way and changing the status quo.
Scotsman
4 hours ago
- Scotsman
Readers' Letters: Bridge the attainment gap with pipe bands in schools
A reader supports calls for the formation of pipe bands in schools to boost academic performance Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Professor Roderick Paisley (Scotsman, 5 August) is correct in noting the remarkable benefits offered to schools and their communities by forming pipe bands – and, of course, by sourcing serious cash for their continuing development. There are big lessons to be learned from the successes of Preston Lodge High School in East Lothian over the last decade or so, whether in terms of musical or academic performance. What has been achieved through imaginative public/private partnership deserves to be known across Scotland and beyond, as Preston Lodge proves itself to be a school well worthy of the accolade 'comprehensive' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Through the building up of discipline, ability, community and huge good fun the young people of Preston Lodge's bands have proved themselves willing learners to their teachers, giving so much to their fine school while enhancing so very clearly their own life prospects. Research found teenagers at Preston Lodge High who learned a traditional Scottish instrument outperformed their classmates in exams (Pictures: Jeff) If the SNP government is remotely serious about closing Scotland's dismal attainment gap in the short to medium term, it should pack its education boffins onto the Waverley to Prestonpans train and take a ride. This would prove to be a short journey of considerable discovery. Rev Dr Robin Hill, Longniddry, East Lothian Learn lesson On 1 August, five days before the 80th anniversary of America dropping the first nuclear bomb on Hiroshima (marked yesterday), in response to an ill-advised tweet by Dmitry Medvedev, Deputy Chair of the Security Council of the Russian Federation, President Trump ordered two ballistic nuclear submarines closer to Russia. A few days earlier the commander of the US Army in Europe, General Christopher Donoghue, boasted that he could 'take down' the Russian enclave of Kaliningrad in a shock and awe operation. Then Lindsey Graham, the Republican senator for South Carolina urged Trump to 'kick Putin's ass'. Not to be outdone Zelensky said 'if we don't stand firm Putin will advance further than Ukraine'. The hotline between Moscow and Washington is no longer in use, the Doomsday Clock is 89 seconds to midnight, and the Hiroshima bomb which killed hundreds of thousands is a pin-prick compared with the monstrous nuclear arsenals of Russia and America. We are in danger of sleepwalking into Armageddon. William Loneskie, Lauder, Scottish Borders Holocaust denial Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The egregious situation unfolding in Gaza is endangering global knowledge and understanding of the Holocaust. As a long-time, proactive supporter of the rights of Palestinians to self-determination and as grandmother to two Jewish boys, I fear that Holocaust denial is likely to gather hideous momentum due to the actions of the Israeli government. The asymmetric barrage of death inflicted on Gaza – alongside our present climate of 'fake news' and binary stances invoked by social media – is on course to re-shape our understanding of history in all its diabolic manifestations. Susie Macleod, Ceres, Fife Flawed tax Replacements for the much-derided council tax seem to have been touted forever. A spokesman from the Jimmy Reid Foundation, put it well: 'We've had consultations, commissions and countless commitments, but little has changed.' (Scotsman, 6 August) Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad And meanwhile, cash-strapped councils continue to struggle to provide much needed services, not least libraries and education. Taxation based on outdated property bands is clumsy and unfair. The trouble is that no system seems foolproof. My own view is that a tax system based on land valuation is the least flawed option. Land is something we all share, however infinitesimally and releases our taxes from a base in either property or income. We can only hope that after decades of consultations, commissions and countless commitments, everything will have changed, for the better. Ian Petrie, Edinburgh Forbes' exit The valedictory praise heaped on Kate Forbes could not have been greater had politicians and journalists been writing obituaries. Certainly, Ms Forbes is a good communicator and made encouraging noises about Scotland needing to nurture private business, which generates the wealth that the financially incontinent SNP regime spends at will. However, two queries need to be addressed. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad First, what did Ms Forbes actually achieve in government, beyond making soothing comments about intent? There is nothing visible to the naked eye. Second, her words that are sensible in comparison with pretty much anything any other SNP politician says were vitiated by her clear attachment to the falsehoods that underpin what passes for SNP policy. As an example, when, a couple of years ago, Ian Blackford revived the SNP lie that HM Treasury would continue to fund pensions in an independent Scotland, Ms Forbes said that she would not presume to disagree with him. Further, she may or may not have agreed with the SNP leadership's espousal of scientifically illiterate 'gender' theory, but we shall probably never know. She managed to absent herself from public discussion of that. Perhaps that is evidence of her political astuteness, but ordinary voters can scarcely find it a credible stance for an allegedly principled politician. Jill Stephenson, Edinburgh New deputy With Kate Forbes out of the picture, John Swinney will need to have someone else for the position of deputy leader ahead of the upcoming Holyrood election. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad This person needs to have a solid track record of success. Enter Jenny Gilruth, the Education Secretary? She has decreased the attainment gap between rich and poor pupils, Nicola Sturgeon's dream. In true SNP style, this was only by a rather meagre 0.1 per cent but in SNP circles this qualifies as a huge success. Don't forget all talk of Kate Forbes being leadership material was originally only based upon her short-notice speech when she replaced Derek McKay after his enforced resignation. This sums the SNP up in one word: lightweight. Gerald Edwards, Glasgow Darien II Council chiefs in Edinburgh and Glasgow have no chance of meeting net zero targets by 2030 (Scotsman, 6 August), just as the SNP at Holyrood will fail to meet the 2045 goals. It appears not a single MSP is aware that the cost to decarbonise Scottish homes increased from the Green Party estimate of £31 billion to £130bn once Humza Yousaf dispensed with the services of Patrick Harvie as a minister. That debt is about a cost of over £50,000 for every Scottish household! Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In addition, the total cost of meeting Scottish net zero goals will be around £1 trillion, which indicates Holyrood plans to inflict a Darien Scheme Mk2 on every Scottish taxpayer. Ian Moir, Castle Douglas, Dumfries & Galloway Bin day blunder On Sunday night, the UK was under an amber alert due to Storm Floris, with authorities urging the public to avoid unnecessary travel as train services were expected to be disrupted. Yet, come Monday morning – bin collection day – households were faced with a dilemma. With strong winds forecast for the afternoon, many were unsure whether to put their bins out or risk them becoming airborne hazard. Paper waste, collected only once a month, meant most households didn't want to miss the opportunity. Unfortunately, as predicted, the stormy winds arrived and paper bins began tipping over, sending cardboard and paper flying across streets and gardens. While such incidents aren't frequent, they're not unheard of either – especially in a country with decades-old waste collection practices and unpredictable weather. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad What's truly surprising is the lack of any clear guidance or contingency plans from the responsible authorities. In an age where weather alerts are timely and accurate, surely it's time for our waste collection services to adapt and communicate better with the public during adverse conditions. Imran M Khan, Cambuslang, South Lanarkshire Sign here In the 2024 general election, I stood as an independent candidate in the new constituency of Dunfermline and Dollar. I secured 323 votes. In good faith, I campaigned for a better Britain. In the event, Labour was gifted a parliamentary majority of 165, a totally demoralised and fragmented opposition, a lame and tame Speaker and considerable public goodwill. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Despite such favourable political circumstances, Labour has squandered a unique opportunity. They promised so much, but have delivered little. Britain is considerably worse off at every level. Labour now stands accused of a massive electoral fraud. They must be brought to book. I owe it to 323 voters in Fife therefor to fully support the Parliamentary Petition to demand a general election now. Inevitably Starmer will remind his MP's that there are good reasons for them to protect him. He will lean on the gullible Speaker and he will brush off any petition of modest numbers. However if the petition reaches one million signatures, even Starmer, with little or no integrity, will have to acknowledge the inevitable. I urge every Scot to sign the petition, without hesitation. Graham Hadley, Dunfermline, Fife Write to The Scotsman
Scotsman
4 hours ago
- Scotsman
The massive sums paid by Scottish universities to overseas recruiting agents revealed
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scottish universities are spending soaring sums of money on overseas recruiting agents to attract wealthy foreign students. New figures show seven of Scotland's mainstream higher education institutions spent £15.2 million on payments and commission for specialist operatives in one year to attract rich international students to enrol in courses. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scotland rank: 4. UK rank: 31 The University of Aberdeen is a UK Top 20 and World Top 200 University with outstanding levels of student satisfaction. Heriot Watt, Strathclyde and Aberdeen universities all spent more than £4m each on agent fees, the figures for 2023/24 show. The total spent since the 2019/20 academic year is £88.2m for the institutions which responded to Freedom of Information requests. But the true amount for the sector will be far higher, given the small number of the 15 universities surveyed that agreed to disclose the data. Others said the information was 'commercially sensitive' and opted not to share it. Neither Edinburgh nor Glasgow universities disclosed the level of payments made to overseas recruiting agents for 2023/24. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Universities Scotland, the umbrella body for the sector, said foreign students had become 'essential' to propping up cash-strapped organisations. Scottish Conservative shadow education secretary Miles Briggs said universities were 'enhanced' by international students who make a 'positive social and economic impact'. However, he added: 'Clearly cash-strapped institutions are having to speculate to accumulate. They know the SNP has created a near impossible environment, and they rely heavily now on foreign students for their fees. Miles Briggs MSP 'We also know that the SNP's approach to higher education is freezing out Scottish students from their own universities.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Two years ago spending on recruitment agents was at a high of at least £18m - an increase of 50 per cent on the 2019/20 academic year. Fees for overseas students are an average of £22,000 per year while there is an SNP-imposed cap on places for resident Scottish students. The University of Aberdeen has 102 'active agents', who it said were 'active in all regions except for the United States of America'. The university spent £5m on these workers. By contrast, the University of the Highlands and Islands employs five operatives working in areas as diverse as Brunei, Cambodia, Lebanon and Kuwait. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Agents are usually paid a referral fee for candidates who sign up for courses, either as a flat rate per student or a percentage of their fees. They can help applicants navigate the application and immigration process. Concerns have been raised the agents may prioritise chasing commissions over the best interests of students. The number of 18-year-olds from Scotland's most deprived areas securing places at university has increased by 100 to 1,960, which is a record high. The number of young Scots who have secured a place at university this year has also increased to a new high of 16,340 acceptances for 18-year-olds, up 4 per cent on last year. While there are caps on the number of home students who can access a place at a Scottish university - and receive free tuition - there is no limit on the number of overseas students. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A Universities Scotland spokeswoman said: 'A decade of public underinvestment in university teaching and research has meant that cross-subsidy from international student fees has become essential. 'Recruitment, particularly where institutions look to diversify into new markets, does require upfront investment.' The spokeswoman said investment delivered a 'strong return' for both universities and the wider Scottish economy, saying international students contributed £4.75 billion between 2018/19 and 2021/22. 'The fact tens of millions have been spent on these agents, working in literally every corner of the globe, shows how the SNP has forced universities out into the world just to make ends meet,' Mr Briggs added. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A Scottish Government spokeswoman said international students played a positive economic, social and cultural role in Scotland. "They add to the diversity of our communities, enrich the learning experience and support local businesses and jobs,' the spokeswoman said.
