Forcing treatment for drug use could lead to overdoses, violate people's rights, experts say
Some experts say involuntary addiction treatment raises serious ethical concerns and could even increase the risk of overdose for some, as Ontario weighs whether it could mandate treatment for people in the criminal justice system.
Last week, the Ontario government announced that it plans to study how this can be done, how much it would cost, and what kind of help they would need from the federal government, among other factors.
But those working in the addictions and mental health field say there's little to no concrete evidence suggesting involuntary addiction treatment is effective.
"That type of research really hasn't been done," said Sarah Dermody, a clinical psychologist and professor of psychology at Toronto Metropolitan University.
"So we're in a position where people are advocating for involuntary treatment, we have some theoretical concerns and ethical concerns of that approach, and we don't have empirical evidence to suggest that it would be helpful in the short or long term."
In some cases, such as with people facing opioid addiction, it could even present risks of overdose if they return to using when their tolerance is lowered, Dermody said.
"If someone you know was using a certain dose and then returns to it several weeks later, that could be life-threatening for them."
Data from Massachusetts, where there is a legal mandate for involuntary treatment for adults with substance use disorders, published in 2016 found the risk of fatal overdose was twice as likely after involuntary treatment compared to voluntary treatment, according to information compiled by the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA).
Another Massachusetts study from 2023 that looked at 22 patients after they completed involuntary treatment found they all relapsed within a year.
Those studies suggest this type of approach can be "more like sort of holding someone than actually helping and treating someone," said Dr. Leslie Buckley, chief of addictions for the CMHA.
"It was supposed to be a diversion, but it looked a lot more like the regular criminal justice service system and there wasn't necessarily a helpful treatment component to that," she said.
"So I think that that the most important critical piece here is that it is a health-focused intervention and that we're thinking about how we can prevent somebody from getting involved in the criminal justice system earlier."
Chris Cull, a substance use disorder advocate who was once addicted to opioids for nearly a decade, says the government shouldn't even be discussing involuntary treatment until it addresses the need for treatment options for people who do want it.
"We don't even have enough voluntary treatment beds to be able to be manage what we have in society, as it is, for people who want it," he said.
Ethical concerns
An expert on bioethics says forcing people to undergo addictions treatment also goes against a core tenant of the Canada Health Act, which says consent is required for virtually any medical treatment.
"Each and every one of us Canadians has the right to consent or decline treatment of any kind," said Kerry Bowman, who teaches bioethics and global health at the University of Toronto.
"The fact that people are facing criminal charges does not necessarily change this. Yes, they've lost some of their rights, but that doesn't necessarily mean they've lost their right to consent for treatment."
From an ethics standpoint, Bowman said there would need to be evidence showing that the benefits of involuntary treatment outweigh the potential harm to individuals.
"To take away someone's fundamental rights to make decisions about treatment, which is the integrity of the of their own body and their own freedom, in the absence of compelling evidence is really going very far," he said.
In a statement, a spokesperson from the Ministry of Health said the province is "collaborating with a number of key community stakeholders and partners to ensure a coordinated approach for justice-involved individuals."
The government's announcement was one of many measures connected to a large justice bill set to be tabled last Thursday.
The move toward involuntary addiction treatment for people in corrections isn't inside the legislation itself, but officials say they intend to present a plan to the cabinet by fall.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
7 days ago
- CBC
Speed cams have cut speeding around Toronto schools nearly in half, new study finds
Automated speed cameras have reduced speeding around Toronto school zones by nearly half, according to a new study. The study, published in the journal Injury Prevention and led by researchers at The Hospital for Sick Children and Toronto Metropolitan University, looked at the effect of automated speed enforcement cameras deployed across 250 school zones around Toronto from July 2020 to December 2022. Looking at speeding data in these areas before and after speed cameras were installed, it found that cameras have reduced the proportion of speeding vehicles in urban school zones by 45 per cent. "We had a very substantial reduction in the speed of the traffic, more than we were expecting to see," said the study's lead author, Dr. Andrew Howard, who is also head of orthopedic surgery for The Hospital for Sick Children. "And what was especially pleasing about that was that the faster the cars were going, the greater the reduction in speed." While the proportion of drivers going 10 km/h over the speed limits decreased by 74 per cent, the study found the proportion of drivers going 15 km/h over the limit decreased by 84 per cent. Drivers going 20 km/h or more over the limit fell by 88 per cent, the study found. The study used pneumatic tubes, which are laid across the road and sense passing cars, to measure speeds in school zones before cameras were installed. WATCH | Toronto doubles number of speed cams in 2025: Heads up, Toronto drivers: Speed cameras are about to double 4 months ago Howard said every kilometre per hour counts in a collision. "Little reductions in speed mean big reductions in kinetic energy. [That] can mean a difference, literally, between life and death at the type of urban speeds that we're looking at," he said. "So getting that dangerous kinetic energy out of school zones is very important, and this is very promising." The study noted that research was done in the first two years of the COVID-19 pandemic, during "unprecedented disruptions" such as school closures, lockdowns and "significant changes in transportation patterns." "These factors may have affected vehicle speed and volume," read the study. "The observed results, however, strongly argue that [automated speed enforcement] was the primary factor in the speed reductions." Howard said he hopes reduced speeds in these zones will encourage more children to walk to school, helping to foster a habit of daily physical activity in their lives, which decreases many health risks in old age. "That's the single most important thing that you can do for this population of kids to make them healthier," he said. "And what we do know is that if you've got more cars going fast around schools, you will have less children walking." Speed cameras still prompting debate, vandalism Nearly three-quarters of Ontarians support the use of automated speed enforcement, according to a recent CAA study. It also found 76 per cent of respondents believe cameras deter speeding. Still, speed cameras in the city have been the source of much debate and backlash. Earlier this year, Toronto doubled the number of automated speed cameras it uses to 150. But there have been 25 cases of vandalism to speed cameras between 2024 and July 23, 2025, the city told CBC Toronto earlier this week. Eleven of the city's cameras were vandalized in the first week of July alone, including one on Parkside Drive that's been cut down six times in eight months. WATCH | Toronto speed cameras keep getting vandalized: A(nother) Toronto speed camera was knocked down 23 days ago Anthony Perruzza, city councillor for Humber River-Black Creek, has said the city's speed camera program should be put on hold until September, calling them "speed traps." He later said he would work with Mayor Olivia Chow on amendments to a city report to the infrastructure committee on Vision Zero, Toronto's road safety strategy. Council passed a motion last month to install larger, more visible signage around speed cameras, something Perruzza had been calling for. Later this year, a city committee will consider limiting how many tickets a driver can receive from a single camera before they get their first ticket in the mail. The installation of speed cameras in school zones is part of Toronto's Vision Zero strategy, created in 2016 to eliminate all traffic-related fatalities and serious injuries.
CBC
23-07-2025
- CBC
No health card, no car, no doctor? No problem for this travelling rural clinic
Pulled into the driveway of a local museum off of a rural road in southwestern Ontario, a 38-foot-long van with decals of cedar trees, a medicine wheel and an 2SLGBTQ flag is parked — ready and waiting for people seeking medical or mental health care. It's a travelling clinic, equipped with mental health staff, a nurse practitioner and in some cases a community paramedic, with the goal of abolishing traditional barriers to health care. No health care card, appointment or payment is needed. The service, aptly named the MobileCare Clinic, recently expanded its schedule to stop throughout rural areas in Chatham-Kent, Ont., based on a needs assessment from local hospitals and 911 calls. It's run primarily through the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA) and other community partners. "Our hope is that we are able to address some of the social determinants of health," says Andria Appeldorn, the director of fund development and communications with CMHA Lambton-Kent. She has seen the project manifest from its origin during the pandemic. "We really consider obstacles to care. It could be transportation, it could be reticence to walk into a doctor's office ... thinking about international workers who come into our communities, we're here to serve them as well." On a recent Monday afternoon, the van is at one of its regular stops in North Buxton, a small rural community that was established by escaped African-American enslaved people in the mid-1800s. According to Edna Cornwall Shadd, the staff mental health care coordinator onsite that day, the population is older and might face specific challenges to getting medical or mental health attention. "As a Black woman, it was very important for me to ensure that the communities I identify with were having this type of support available to them, especially in North Buxton," she said. Cornwall Shadd says it's a primary objective of MobileCare to solidify relationships over time, especially when a new community is added to the van's schedule. One recent addition as part of the expansion is Wheatley, Ont. "It's exciting trying to build that relationship [because] there may be some barriers that we ourselves might not even be aware of," she said. "Engagement with the community is really important." For the first time, the MobileCare clinic will also be in North Buxton's community parade, a longstanding heritage celebration called homecoming that draws hundreds into the community. It's something Cornwall Shadd is excited about. "North Buxton in particular is rich in Black history and it's actually quite amazing the number of people even within Chatham-Kent who aren't aware of that," Cornwall Shadd said. "So any way we can help promote the community and that history while also ensuring the population is getting good quality health care is very important." James Bromley, the CMHA's manager of integrated client services, oversees the service, which includes a second bus that services the area of Sarnia-Lambton. He says sometimes it takes a couple of visits for people to understand the breadth of what is available to them through the clinic. "It's a difficult time. There's long wait lists, primary care might not be available in some centres, so [we're] trying to address that, even taking some relief away from our local emergency rooms," he said. Inside the van, three areas are sectioned off. A client is greeted by staff, triaged through an intake form and then seen by professionals. Bromley says some visits are 15 minutes, while others can be up to an hour, addressing everything from wound care to addictions. Three people can be seen at one time on-board. "We can offer referrals, whether for therapy, housing supports, Indigenous supports and even our community paramedic team can arrange home visits [if follow ups are required]." Not every community has the same needs, however. Appeldorn says that the dynamic and needs can change drastically from stop to stop. "Some communities have a lot of seasonal agricultural workers who don't have time to see a family doctor, others have elderly residents who haven't seen a doctor in years. We can really catch things before they become too advanced to be cared for." Other stops on the van's schedule include Walpole Island First Nation, where an Indigenous services team member is added. In urban centres like Chatham, the team includes housing and homelessness support.
CBC
17-07-2025
- CBC
Ontario announces funding for Windsor physicians providing care to the unhoused in shelters
The Ontario government has committed up to $3.8 million to a physician group in Windsor that provides health-care services to people in homeless shelters in the city and to some people who have housing but require support. The money has allowed Windsor Shelter Health Associates to expand from two physicians working a total of around nine hours a week to 11 physicians working six days a week, said medical director Jennifer Bondy. It's also allowed them to build a team of family physicians, addiction medicine physicians, palliative care physicians, an infectious disease physician and psychiatry, Bondy said. "I used to see a lot of wound care at the very beginning before we were funded in any way," Bondy told reporters at an event Wednesday announcing the funding, which she said began flowing at the start of 2024. "Now we are able to regularly see people for their continuous care needs like diabetes, for example. Or if they might have a primary psychiatric diagnosis, we can see them for their schizophrenia, for example, and really make a dent in the care delivery." Bondy began providing services to unhoused people in 2021, partly as a volunteer and partly while working for the Canadian Mental Health Association, she told CBC. New funding model Another physician joined a couple of years ago, she said. Then at the start of 2024, Bondy's service received recognition under a new provincial funding model called the Homeless Shelter Alternate Payment Plan, which does not require patients to roster with physicians and which compensates physicians both for their time and for the complexity of their patients' needs, she said. "We've been able to go from three half-day clinics a week to multiple half-day clinics across five different sites," she said. Shelter Health serves people at the Salvation Army Men's Emergency Shelter, the Homelessness and Housing Help Hub (H4), the Welcome Centre Shelter for Women and Families, the Downtown Mission of Windsor, and Journey Home Hospice, according to a news release from the province. It also provides services to people who have housing but require support. Shelter Health secured Interprofessional Primary Care Team Funding through Ontario Health in the spring of 2024 to supplement the physician funding, Bondy said. That funding flows through the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA), she added. CMHA Windsor CEO Nicole Sbrocca said providing health care in shelters isn't just compassionate; it's evidence-based. "When care meets people where they are at, we prevent crises," she said at the news conference. "We build trust, and we contribute to healthier individuals and a stronger community." Program getting results: mental health association CEO Over the past fiscal year, the interprofessional team has provided more than 5,000 visits across the shelter sites, Sbrocca said. Physicians see an average of 200 unique patients per month. What's more, she said, there has been a reduction in emergency department use for issues that are being addressed on site in the shelters, and doctors are seeing an improvement in medication adherence. There have also been success stories, Sbrocca said. "We have attached nearly 200 people to primary care," she said. "We've achieved housing for individuals, and we have made meaningful steps forward in terms of wellness and recovery on an individual basis." Asked what the funding means to the program, Bondy told reporters it means "sustainability." "It means that we are going to be able to continue to provide services," she said. "We know we can future plan, and we can ensure that we have programs that are developed with our partners knowing that we're going to be able to continue to do the work that we're doing." Last month, the Windsor Essex By-Names Prioritized List for housing showed 899 households were experiencing some form of homelessness, of which 682 households, or 75.8 per cent, were experiencing long-term or chronic homelessness, according to data provided by the City of Windsor.
