TikTok granted permission to challenge €530m DPC fine
The fine was imposed on the video-sharing site last April, for what the DPC described as an infringement on data protection regarding its transfers of European users' data to The People's Republic of China via remote access to data stored in the US and Singapore by personnel based in China.
In addition to the €530M fine, the April 30 censure also included an order suspending TikTok's transfer of data to China if its processing was not brought into compliance with European directives on transparency within six months.
At the High Court today, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty granted permission for TikTok to pursue a legal challenge against the DPC decisions and put a stay on them pending the outcome of the legal review.
The High Court action is being taken by TikTok Technology Limited, with an address at The Sorting Office, Ropemaker Place, Dublin 2, and by TikTok Information Technologies UK Limited, Kaleidoscope, Lindsey Street, London, UK, against the DPC, Ireland and the Attorney General.
TikTok Ireland is a private company limited by shares incorporated in the Republic of Ireland and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of TikTok UK.
Both TikTok entities seek the quashing of the decision of the DPC of April 30, 2025.
Lawyers for the applicants appeared in the High Court today on an ex parte basis, where only one side is represented. They submitted that the sections of the Data Protection Act under which the DPC made their decision are invalid when viewed in relation to the Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU.
In papers lodged to the High Court, TikTok says that the Ireland and UK arms are "joint controllers" for the processing of personal data of users based in Europe but add that TikTok UK is "the entity that will ultimately bear the cost of the administration fines imposed in the decision".
Ireland and the Attorney General are joined as respondents to the proceedings.
TikTok submits that the imposition of "administrative" fines of €485M and €45M "constitutes the imposition of a sanction that in its nature and severity is properly characterised as 'criminal' or penal".
TikTok contends that "even if the imposition of the fine did not constitute a sanction of a criminal nature, the DPC was nonetheless not exercising merely limited functions and powers of a judicial nature within the meaning of Article 37.1 of the Constitution".
Article 37.1 aims to validate the delegation of certain judicial powers to administrative bodies without infringing on the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts in criminal matters.
TikTok claims that the fines "cannot be said to be of a limited nature".
TikTok submits that the ECHR provides that "in the determination of civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charges, an individual is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law".
The applicants further claim that the fine "constitutes an interference with the applicants' right to private property protected under Article 40.3 or 43, or both, of the Constitution".
"The decision to impose a fine, the amount of the fine and the absence of a full right of appeal constitutes an unjust, unjustified and disproportionate interference with the applicants' right to private property," TikTok claims.
Ms Justice Gearty granted leave for the judicial review and adjourned the matter to October.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
26 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Europe's best railway station that's one of world's busiest is getting £1bn revamp – and could launch direct route to UK
EUROPE'S best railway station is set to receive a £1billion upgrade with the possibility of a direct route on the cards. Plans to expand Advertisement 6 The major European station is set to receive a huge upgrade Credit: Getty 6 This upgrade will increase the station's capacity by 50 per cent Credit: Getty Major station set for huge upgrade This These upgrades will increase the station's current capacity by a staggering 50 per cent. Plans were publicly displayed on May 14 and have since been approved as Zürich Stadelhofen station braces for an upgrade. Commissioned by the Swiss Federal Government, the Swiss Federal Railways (SSB) aims to address a major bottleneck in the Zürich S-Bahn system, Advertisement SSB intends to achieve this through the station's expansion, as the current three-track layout already operates at full capacity. Plans for direct route to London This comes after SSB revealed hopes to create a According to This new expansion could be a step in the right direction as the proposed upgrade of one of the world's busiest stations will enable more frequent services and improve connectivity. Advertisement Most read in Travel One Brit told Swiss Info: "We feel so disconnected after Brexit. This kind of direct connection would be incredible." Currently, Brits can travel to five places by direct Picturesque English town is getting new £27m train line for first time in 60 years – & will cut journey times by an hour But Yann Leriche, the chief executive of Getlink, said: "We are keen to drive forward attractive opportunities for low-carbon [travel] with a range of new destinations in Germany, Switzerland and France. Advertisement A spokesperson for London St Pancras Highspeed added: "Many European cities could be reached directly by train in under six hours which we believe is really competitive with short-haul air travel." However, the plans are rather ambitious, with no set time frame for when these could launch. Key upgrades to major Zürich station With approximately 80,000 daily passengers and 770 train movements, Zürich Stadelhofen is the third-busiest station in the city and the tenth-busiest in Switzerland. The proposed upgrade will enable more frequent services and support the implementation of a 15-minute base frequency across the network. Advertisement Read more on the Irish Sun According to Railway Pro, these are the key upgrades to the station : The construction of a fourth track on the hillside of the station, aligned with the current shopping level Connection of the new track to existing tunnels A new single-track Riesbach Tunnel towards Zürich Tiefenbrunnen Enhanced station access Sun Travel's favourite train journeys in the world Sun Travel's journalists have taken their fare share of train journeys on their travels and here they share their most memorable rail experiences. Davos to Geneva, Switzerland "After a ski holiday in Davos, I took the scenic train back to Geneva Airport. The snow-covered mountains and tiny alpine villages that we passed were so beautiful that it felt like a moving picture was playing beyond the glass." - Caroline McGuire Tokyo to Kyoto by Shinkansen "Nothing quite beats the Shinkansen bullet train, one of the fastest in the world. It hardly feels like you're whizzing along at speed until you look outside and see the trees a green blur. Make sure to book seat D or E too - as you'll have the best view of Mount Fuji along the way." Kara Godfrey London to Paris by Eurostar "Those who have never travelled on the Eurostar may wonder what's so special about a seemingly ordinary train that takes you across the channel. You won't have to waste a moment and can tick off all the top attractions from the Louvre to the Champs-Élysées which are both less than five kilometres from the Gare du Nord." - Sophie Swietochowski Glasgow to Fort William by Scotrail "From mountain landscapes and serene lochs to the wistful moors, I spent my three-hour journey from Glasgow to Fort William gazing out the window. Sit on the left-hand side of the train for the best views overlooking Loch Lomond." - Hope Brotherton Beijing to Ulaanbatar "The Trans-Mongolian Express is truly a train journey like no other. It starts amid the chaos of central Beijing before the city's high-rises give way to crumbling ancient villages and eventually the vast vacant plains of Mongolia, via the Gobi desert. The deep orange sunset seen in the middle of the desert is among the best I've witnessed anywhere." - Ryan Gray 6 The Swiss station opened its doors for the first time in 1894 Credit: Getty 6 Stadelhofen is currently the third largest station in Zurich Credit: Getty 6 Work is expected to start by 2030 Credit: Getty Advertisement 6 The upgrade is estimated to cost of £1bn Credit: Getty
The Journal
32 minutes ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach acknowledges prices are 'elevated' - and gets told to 'wake-up' to the cost of living
PRICES 'ARE AT a relatively elevated level', Taoiseach Micheál Martin acknowledged today during Leaders' Questions which was dominated by a debate on the cost-of-living. Government ministers have repeatedly ruled out any repeat of one-off cost-of-living measures in October's budget, with Martin stating today that there has to be a 'degree of caution' with spending, given the US tariff threats. The Taoiseach also pointed out that inflation has fallen since its peak around the time of the outbreak of war in Ukraine. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald criticised the Taoiseach telling him 'what you're entirely missing is the fact that prices have not followed suit, and anybody who goes into a supermarket or a shopper who opens up their bill can tell you that we are in a place where households are still struggling'. She said told the Taoiseach that the government's record in the last five months has seen home heating oil prices up by €25, with petrol and diesel prices also gone up in May and again in October. Advertisement The government has shown no sensitivity to the realities of struggling households and workers, said McDonald. 'I am simply asking you to please wake up and become aware of the realities of people's lives. People need these supports,' she said. October's budget Martin said there would be supports in the Budget dealing with cost-of-living and food inflation. 'This government did an awful lot. We did more than any other European Government, actually, in terms of cushioning and trying to reduce the impact on people, and we continue to do that.' In April, the Government decided to extend the VAT reduction to 9% on gas and electricity, he said. 'This measure will save households €70 for gas and €55 for electricity. 'From September onwards, there will be a significant increase in the number of people who qualify for the fuel allowance. Related Reads Opinion: Want to curb rising grocery prices? Force supermarket chains to publish their accounts More than one in six households can't afford a one-week holiday with their children Why has the cost of a block of butter risen so much since last year? 'And since the first of June, women can receive HRT free of charge. At the beginning of June, the Carers Support Grant increased to €2,000. That's the highest level ever, and that benefits some 138,000 carers,' said Martin. McDonald said 'people are being fleeced'. 'For one thing, households in Ireland are paying 30pc more on their electricity bills each year than the EU average. That's nearly €350 more. 'The ESRI says that it is difficult to explain why electricity prices here are so far above other countries. People are being taken for a ride,' she added. The ESRI told an Oireachtas committee today that it is 'challenging' to explain why electricity prices in Ireland are a lot higher than other EU countries. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Sunday World
32 minutes ago
- Sunday World
TikTok videos by worker in injuries case may have been filmed before he was hurt, court told
Meat factory worker turned TikTok influencer Mario Pompa (37) made a successful personal injuries claim against Hilton Foods (Ireland) Ltd in March this year Tik Tok videos of injured factory worker may have been recorded when he was well - appeals court is told Dancing and exercise videos posted on social media by a factory worker, who claimed he had to stop work due to injury after years of carrying heavy bags, may have been recorded some time earlier, when his health was good, a court has heard. Meat factory worker turned TikTok influencer Mario Pompa (37) made a successful personal injuries claim against Hilton Foods (Ireland) Ltd in March this year. He claimed he had to stop working in 2022 due to an ongoing neck, back and shoulder injury he sustained after regularly carrying bags weighing up to 25kg. He alleged the injuries happened when he started doing heavy lifting in the 'spice room', where spices were mixed for sausage production. He said he worked three 13-hour shifts a week and had to carry bags weighing between 10kg and 25kg, and got two 30-minute breaks. Mr Pompa, originally from Slovakia but living in Ireland since 2005, was awarded nearly €18,000 in compensation at Dundalk Circuit Court. It had been argued by the food company that video footage showing Mr Pompa doing dancing and gym exercise contradicted what he had told various doctors about the extent of his injuries. The videos were from September 2021 – a month before he told a GP from the Injuries Resolution Board that he had not been able to go to a gym since 2020 due to persistent pain. Other videos of him dancing around the house were also played. Judge Terence O'Sullivan said at the time that he would give Mr Pompa the benefit of the doubt and that he had not set out to completely lie or misrepresent his injuries. Mario Pompa at Dundalk District Court. Picture: Arthur Carron Hilton Foods appealed that ruling, and the appeals court in Dundalk sat yesterday under Justice Sara Phelan. James McGowan SC, representing Mr Pompa, brought him through evidence that he had first gone to the doctor in August 2020 with shoulder pain, and that scans had shown he had rotator cuff tendonitis and a partial tear of a tendon, and should do physiotherapy sessions and take medication for pain. He said his work continued until 2022 when he started to have problems with chest pain. The cause of the chest pain was not being attributed to his work at the factory, the court heard. Mr Pompa said he was no longer working for Hilton Foods because he had been 'fired' a few months ago. His use of social media and TikTok started in 2019, the court heard, when he started posting fashion and clothes- related posts and then started doing dancing and singing videos lasting 30 seconds to a minute in duration. He said he still does some videos and making the videos made him feel better. He said that at one point, four livestreams had earned him €1,500 in total. Padraig McCartan SC put it to Mr Pompa that he was exaggerating his injuries and misled his own doctors and company doctors by not telling company doctors that he had received compensation at an earlier date for back injuries he sustained in a road traffic collision in 2008. Videos of Mr Pompa, which he had himself posted to social media in September 2021 and February 2023, were shown to the court. They showed him exercising in a gym, throwing and catching a heavy 'medicine ball', and dancing with a vacuum cleaner. Mr Pompa said that the fact that the videos were posted on certain dates did not mean they were recorded on those dates, and they may have been recorded in 2019 or 2020. Mr McCartan said that Mr Pompa had not made that argument about the timing of the recording of the videos being possibly different to the publishing date at his previous Circuit Court case. 'He has the benefit of hindsight and knowledge of the existence of these videos and the use they were going to be put to in this court and the court below to try to explain away the relevance of the date they came into being,' he said. 'It's my submission that this is no more than a minor injury. There is no frozen shoulder here. 'There is complete recovery. If you accept the video evidence certainly in 2021 he had made a substantial recovery within one year.' Mr McGowan said the fact that one video appears on two different days on his client's social media timeline proves the fact that the publishing date of the videos can be different from the day of recording. 'The dates that are seen does not prove the dates the recordings were made. Of course Mr Pompa has had an opportunity to consider the matter. He was ambushed with this stuff the first time around in the Circuit Court,' he said, adding that the defendants had not brought any evidence to show the date of posting the videos was the date of their creation. Judge Phelan adjourned the matter and said she would issue her ruling on July 25.
