Tough budget for Ekurhuleni
Ekurhuleni's total expenditure budget of R64.8 budget would be subjected to non-negotiable conditions
Ekurhuleni MMC for Finance, Strategy and Corporate Planning, Jongizizwe Dlabathi, on Thursday tabled a R65.5 billion budget.
According to Dlabathi, tough economic realities, lack of optimal collection, revenue leakages, weak liquidity position, ineffective expenditure management and the assumption that 90% of municipal revenue should be generated internally, were among key factors in the budget.
Bullish about improving alignment and effectiveness of existing revenue collection systems, Dlabathi projected an additional estimated R2.1 billion gross revenue in the current financial year.
'Given that we intend not to borrow over the medium-term, all departments that are involved in the revenue generation value chain will have to pull together to ensure the achievement of our revenue goals in the medium and long-term.
'This will be spearheaded at the level of the Revenue Enhancement Committee that has since been put in place by Executive Mayor Nkosindiphile Xhakaza.
'The budget posture is guided by the directive to ensure a responsive city, working with agility to restore service delivery to communities.
'This directive demands that we focus on the core basics – providing quality, equitable and sustainable services to all in a manner that ensures the ideal quality of life,' said Dlabathi.
Non-negotiables
He said Ekurhuleni's total expenditure budget of R64.8 budget would be subjected to non-negotiable conditions, which would include:
Spending within the allocated budget.
Linking spending to the provision of essential services and goods.
Fostering economic procurement and realisation of value for money.
Strengthening internal capacity to reduce over-reliance on contracted services.
ALSO READ: Joburg budget hanging by a thread: ANC fights to get their way as partners gun for them
Key expenditure breakdown allocations include:
Water and sanitation repairs will receive and maintenance R550 million,mainly to ensure resilient infrastructure that secures a sustainable supply of water and sanitation services—stretching to fixing water and sewer leakages.
From the total of R20.7 million earmarked for human settlements, R7.5 million will be channelled towards basic repairs and maintenance work for selected hostels—with the rest covering the maintenance of rental units, including Ekurhuleni Housing Company.
The Energy Department will receive R1.4 billion towards infrastructure and equipment maintenance related to substations, network enhancement, with R103 million allocated to the repairing of street and traffic lights, under the Operation Khanyisa Mhali. Additional R254 million has been allocated to the protection of energy infrastructure.
Through the ' Siyakhuculula Manje and Clean Kasi ' programme, a total of R226 million has been allocated to environmental resources, waste management repairs, maintenance materials and supplies to support internal capacity to cut grass, maintain cemeteries, remove weeds, prune trees, and maintain landfill sites, wetlands, lakes, and dams.
A total of R946 million has been allocated for roads and transport management, with road rehabilitation and pothole patching done under the auspices of the Hlasela Amapotholes project.
A total of R41.3 million will be used for repairing and maintaining traffic signals.
While more funds are still required, R54 million will go towards addressing sinkholes.
Capital expenditure has been allocated R3.1 billion.
An employee budget will be R13.4 billion – towards annual salary increments and the recruitment of additional workforce.
Dlabathi said the budget will implement the recruitment of 700 permanent cleaners and 290 permanent EMPD (Ekurhuleni Municipal Police Department) officers to maintain strategic offices and buildings.
'A budget of R303 million will be allocated over the medium-term to equip the staff with essential tools of trade necessary to optimise performance. Time provision must prioritise departments that are providing essential services.
'The long-term trajectory is that of implementing the 70/30 ratio for service delivery, wherein 70% of the services are rendered in-house, with 30% contracted.
'As we implement the capital budget, we must not be found wanting with our supply chain management, planning, organising and as well as overseeing the completion of capital projects within time, scope and quality,' added Dlabathi.
NOW READ: How Joburg plans to spend R89 billion
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
13 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Weaponising the Public Finance Management Act: A new legal trend threatening public sector discipline
A concerning trend is emerging in public sector employment. Employees facing disciplinary action are increasingly wielding the Public Finance Management Act 1 of 1999 (PFMA) not as the accountability tool it was designed to be, but as a shield against workplace consequences. This strategic pivot transforms financial governance legislation into an employment litigation weapon with potentially far-reaching implications for public administration. The PFMA was enacted in 1999 with the primary purpose of establishing a robust framework for financial governance in South Africa's public sector. At its core, the act aims to secure transparency, accountability, and sound management of revenue, expenditure, assets and liabilities across national and provincial government institutions. Among its core objectives, it provides mechanisms to prevent irregular, unauthorised, as well as fruitless and wasteful expenditure, thereby safeguarding public resources against misuse. The recent Labour Court case of Vico v The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and Environment offers a compelling illustration of this new phenomenon. Thembalethu Vico, a director within the department who faced dismissal following disciplinary proceedings related to the removal of confiscated abalone valued at approximately R7.5-million, sought to challenge his dismissal through an unusual legal avenue: by attacking the procedural aspects of his disciplinary hearing through the lens of the PFMA. At the heart of Vico's application was an attempt to secure declaratory relief related to what he characterised as incomplete disciplinary proceedings. His arguments centred on several PFMA-related assertions: that the employer had 'unjustly and unfairly terminated' the briefing contract of the disciplinary hearing chairperson; that this termination caused 'unreasonable delay' in his disciplinary hearing; that respondents 'contravened the applicant's right to fair labour practice'; and rather notably, that expenditure on recusal applications against the chairperson constituted 'fruitless and wasteful expenditure' under the PFMA. The Labour Court's response was unequivocal. In his judgment, Judge Robert Lagrange not only dismissed the application, but characterised it as 'vexatious in nature', ordering the applicant to pay the respondents' costs. 'An attempt to circumvent the proper forums for labour disputes' The court found that Vico was 'no stranger to legal principles and reasoning' and determined that his PFMA-based arguments represented an attempt to circumvent the proper forums for labour disputes — namely the General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council where he had already lodged an unfair dismissal claim. This case highlights a broader issue deserving closer scrutiny: the strategic repurposing of financial management legislation to serve employment law objectives. The PFMA, enacted in 1999, was designed to promote transparent and effective management of government finances — not as a mechanism for employees to challenge disciplinary outcomes. Yet increasingly, we witness creative legal arguments that stretch the PFMA beyond its intended boundaries. Several notable examples demonstrate this concerning pattern in other contextual scenarios: Unsuccessful tender bidders increasingly invoke the PFMA not to address genuine financial irregularities, but to contest legitimate procurement decisions they simply disagree with. By alleging technical PFMA violations, these bidders attempt to overturn procurement outcomes through financial management legislation rather than following appropriate procurement appeal processes. Some employees facing disciplinary action for performance or conduct issues have strategically repositioned themselves as 'whistleblowers' under section 51 of the PFMA. By claiming they were disciplined for reporting financial misconduct, rather than for their own workplace infractions, they attempt to transform standard employment disputes into protected disclosure matters. Some senior employees facing poor performance reviews have contested their evaluations by claiming they were instructed to take actions that would violate the PFMA. This transforms performance management into a complex legal dispute about financial legislation interpretation. Public entities facing pressure to implement organisational changes have cited PFMA compliance concerns as reasons to delay implementation, effectively using financial legislation as a strategic tool to resist operational reforms. Perhaps most troublingly, the PFMA has become weaponised in political contexts, with allegations of technical PFMA violations used to undermine political opponents in positions of financial accountability, regardless of whether actual financial mismanagement occurred. In the misconduct context, the implications of this trend are significant. Public sector managers face the daunting prospect of defending not only the substantive merits of disciplinary decisions, but also navigating complex arguments about whether their internal processes satisfy the technical requirements of financial legislation. This creates a chilling effect on departmental decision-making, potentially undermining efforts to address misconduct effectively. More worryingly, this legal strategy diverts valuable court resources. Judge Lagrange noted that the application was largely an attempt to revisit a matter that had already been decided, writing that 'it beggars belief that the applicant could have seriously believed that he could simply avoid the unequivocal effect of the judgment by approaching this court under the guise of an application for declaratory relief'. When courts must attend to such applications, genuine cases requiring judicial attention face delays. The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment's approach in the Vico case provides a template for addressing such claims. Rather than becoming entangled in debates about the PFMA's application to employment matters, they successfully redirected the court's attention to the jurisdictional question: Whether the Labour Court was the appropriate forum for what was essentially an attempt to relitigate disciplinary proceedings through a different legal framework. Distinct forums and remedies PFMA matters and employment disputes are meant to follow different procedural paths, with distinct forums and remedies designed to preserve the integrity of both systems. When properly invoked, PFMA concerns should follow established channels that begin with internal departmental controls, escalate to Treasury oversight, proceed through audit mechanisms via the Auditor-General's examination, involve executive accountability and operate through specific financial misconduct procedures established in the PFMA — all pathways that exist distinctly from labour dispute mechanisms. Notably absent from the PFMA is any provision making the Labour Court a forum for adjudicating PFMA violations, which is why the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment correctly focused on the jurisdictional question, highlighting that the applicant was attempting to bypass proper forums for both employment disputes (the General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council) and financial governance concerns (internal controls, Treasury oversight and potentially criminal proceedings). As this trend continues to evolve, public sector employers would be wise to develop proactive strategies. This includes ensuring that disciplinary procedures are documented with meticulous attention to detail, that financial decisions related to such proceedings are properly authorised, and that legal teams are prepared to address PFMA-based arguments directly. The PFMA represents a crucial pillar of democratic governance and institutional transformation. The act has become instrumental in the country's ongoing struggle against corruption and State Capture — challenges that have threatened South Africa's democratic foundations and economic stability. However, the judiciary's response in the Vico case sends a clear message: the PFMA cannot be weaponised to circumvent established labour relations processes. This judgment establishes an important precedent that may discourage frivolous applications of this nature. Ultimately, public administration requires both financial accountability and efficient personnel management. When these systems are placed in artificial opposition through creative litigation strategies, neither objective is well served. The Labour Court's firm stance in the Vico case represents a welcome correction — one that reinforces the proper boundaries between financial governance and employment law in South Africa's public sector. DM
Eyewitness News
a day ago
- Eyewitness News
Budget 3.0: SARS will have to go all out to justify massive cash injection
CAPE TOWN - The South African Revenue Service (SARS) will have to pull out all the stops to justify a massive cash injection through the latest iteration of the national budget that seeks to bolster its ability to collect more taxes. SARS Commissioner Edward Kieswetter said since the failed March budget, he's already been training additional debt collectors to reach the goal of collecting at least another R20 billion in taxes over the next year. ALSO READ: While the finance minister has had to cave to political pressure to scrap a planned value-added tax (VAT) increase to fund government expenditure, raising the fuel levy as of June will not be enough to close the fiscal gap over the medium term. Tabling the third version of the national budget on Wednesday, Minister of Finance Enoch Godongwana said he was giving SARS R7.5 billion over the next three years to improve its effectiveness in collecting more revenue and to modernise its systems. Godongwana estimates that as much as R35 billion more can be collected. Kieswetter said since April, he's employed an additional 500 debt collectors. Another 250 will be added to SARS's payroll in June. 'Our estimate is that this should at least give us R20 billion. We are targeting a debt collection of the overall composite debt of R120 billion.' One of SARS's targets will be the illicit tobacco trade. Kieswetter said there will be regular progress reports to Treasury, and by the mid-term budget in October, a level of confidence can be assessed.
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
This is where we would be if SA sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5%
It is enough to make you weep when you read how much better off South Africa could have been with economic growth of 4.5%. If South Africa had sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5% per year, in line with its emerging market peers, its GDP would have been just under R12 trillion in 2024 instead of the actual R7.5 trillion. Government revenue could also have been around R800 billion higher than it is. Investment strategist at Investec Wealth and Investment International, Osagyefo Mazwai, notes that although South Africa has grown over the last 15 years, averaging economic growth around 1% a year, the population has grown at a higher rate of around 1.3%. He points out that there has been a structural break in South Africa's economic performance compared to the rest of the world, with a stark dislocation in gross domestic product (GDP) per capita. 'In essence, people are worse off than they were in 2010, suggesting that economic policy has been ineffectual in addressing poverty, unemployment and inequality. 'On a per capita basis, the rest of the world is 50% richer than the average South African. Growth of 1% will not lead to the envisaged goals of lifting people out of poverty and meaningfully addressing the problems of unemployment and inequality.' This chart compares nominal GDP over the period with what it would have been if the South African economy grew at 4.5% a year to illustrate the point on the opportunity cost of foregone growth in policy formation and execution: ALSO READ: Experts say no way SA can achieve economic growth of 3% this year How does economic growth of R12 trillion sound? Mazwai says if the economy grew at 4.5%, South Africa's nominal GDP would have been just below R12 trillion in 2024, a significant number, especially considering the benefits that could have been derived from a vastly larger GDP. He points out that South Africa's economic growth rates similarly had an effect on government revenue. 'Government revenue in 2024 alone could have been around R800 billion higher, while just a few weeks ago, South Africa faced a budget impasse due to a shortfall in funding, needing to raise R75 billion in the medium term to cover the shortfall. 'That shortfall is insignificant considering how much more could have been raised had the economy grown more in line with emerging market peers. 'The cumulative figure of revenue foregone is scary, at around R5 trillion over the last 15 years. 'That is material, considering the fiscal constraints facing South Africa and demonstrates the need to ensure economic growth to boost the fiscal war chest and further enable the capacity of the state to deliver services.' ALSO READ: IMF's bad news about economic growth for SA, thanks to Trump tariffs What economic growth of 4.5% could have meant Mazwai says these statistics put this into perspective: The R5 trillion lost would be enough to clear almost 90% of South Africa's gross national debt and bring the debt-to-GDP ratio down to just below 10%, compared to the currently expected 77% ratio this year. Eskom needs R390 billion over the next decade for transmission lines, a fundamental pillar of creating greater capacity in the energy sector. Electricity is the backbone of any structural improvement, especially considering the government's goals to build domestic manufacturing capacity and create meaningful employment opportunities. The R390 billion would be a drop in the ocean had growth been 4.5% over the last 15 years. Transnet needs R160 billion to upgrade rail and port infrastructure. Our logistics networks are key in connecting the economy across its internal nodes, but also key in building additional capacity to meet the demands of external markets. Again, R160 billion would have been a drop in the ocean had growth been in line with our peers. Eskom has debt of R400 billion. With economic growth at 4.5%, the government could have bailed Eskom out 12 times. Transnet has a debt of R140 billion, and the government could have bailed out Transnet many times, too. Social grants will cost the fiscus around R266 billion this year. With economic growth of 4.5%, these would have been more than affordable and potentially materially higher than what marginalised citizens receive now, also considering that many more people would have been absorbed into the labour market. ALSO READ: Fourth quarter GDP improved but economists say its still not great – here's why With higher economic growth, South Africa would have functioned better Mazwai says these statistics are significant because they show how South Africa could have been in a better position to address the prevailing needs of the state. 'Granted, if the economy was growing at 4.5% the assumption is that Transnet and Eskom and some of the other structural enablers of the economy would have been functioning properly. 'The numbers indicate the potential for vastly greater capacity to invest in the productive elements of the South African economy, such as in infrastructure, education, healthcare and the salaries of teachers, nurses and doctors.' He also notes that business confidence has been unusually correlated with the performance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in the post-pandemic environment, and therefore, SOE reform momentum must be sustained or increased. 'Business confidence is the key leading indicator of economic growth and employment creation. The unemployment rate would be closer to around 20% compared to the current 32.9% had the economy been growing at 4.5%. 'In other words, a third of those presently unemployed, according to the narrow definition of unemployment, would have jobs.' ALSO READ: Absa foresees economic growth of 2.1%, but Trump and budget can disrupt it But there have been some victories so far for the economy However, Mazwai says none of this should detract from some of the victories seen of late, such as: The formation of the government of national unity (GNU) and subsequent political stability and increased policy certainty, although the recent budget impasse showed that these are nonetheless fragile. The increased momentum of Operation Vulindlela in addressing the various structural impediments in the economy. The next steps are critical for addressing water infrastructure and local government inefficiencies. Improvements in the electricity supply and logistics network. Mazwai says there has been some stagnation in the recovery of SOEs, which may be cause for concern, although the worst of SOE performance appears to be behind us. However, he says a reacceleration in trend improvement is important for business confidence to grow. ALSO READ: Economic activity still moving sideways but optimism increases Recovery in PMI could mean higher economic growth 'We recently saw a modest recovery in the S&P Global Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), to a neutral level of 50. There must be a trend improvement in PMIs, which are typically linked to economic outcomes. 'Should PMIs continue to improve, the economy should continue on its path of recovery. This will likely be driven by the continued success of Operation Vulindlela.' Looking at GDP projections, Mazwai says data released so far suggest that while growth was likely weak in the first quarter, a persistent upward trend in PMIs can result in a marked acceleration in growth outcomes. 'PMI improvement will largely be a function of continued improvement in SOE performance. At present, the economy, by our estimates, is tracking at 1.3% for the year, which is well above the 0.6% seen in 2024 and 0.8% in 2023. 'This can then lead to more meaningful employment creation and a trend reversal in GDP per capita from the pattern of decline since 2011.' ALSO READ: World Bank has simple answer to improve South Africa's economic growth What SA can do to keep momentum going to grow He suggests that South Africa follow these steps to keep the momentum going and put South Africa on a firmer growth trajectory:
