Europe imports more Russian gas, aiding wartime economy, report finds
When addressing Congress for the first time as US president on March 4, Donald Trump said, 'Europe has sadly spent more money buying Russian oil and gas than they have spent on defending Ukraine.'
Trump has not been known for his statistical accuracy, but on this occasion, he may be right.
A report released on Thursday by Ember, an energy think tank, estimates that European purchases of Russian gas amounted to 21.9 billion euros ($23.6bn) last year, compared with 18.7 billion euros ($20.17bn) in financial aid to Ukraine.
That figure did not include military aid.
The European Union estimates it has disbursed or committed $194bn in military, financial and reconstruction aid to Ukraine since the beginning of the war.
Ember's concern was that far from publishing a promised plan to phase out Russian gas completely by 2027, the EU, instead, increased its imports of Russian gas by 18 percent last year.
'The EU needs to move away from pricey and volatile fossil gas to meet its own security, economic and climate objectives, starting with a clear pathway for the Russian gas phase-out,' Ember wrote.
Vladyslav Vlasiuk, a Ukrainian presidential adviser, told EU ambassadors to Kyiv in January that Ukraine was upset by EU gas imports from Russia last year.
'It's time to cut off the petrodollar flow fuelling Russia's aggression,' he said.
Yiannis Bassias, a hydrocarbon industry veteran and energy analyst at Amphorenergy, told Al Jazeera, 'It's true that Europe increased imports of Russian gas in 2023 and 2024, and it will import even more in 2025 because the US cannot provide more.'
'Russian gas [consumption in Europe] in 2024 was about 45 billion cubic metres (bcm) and US gas was 57bcm.'
The broader context of this is that the EU has vastly reduced energy imports from Russia since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022.
At its 2019 peak, Russian gas supply to Europe amounted to 179bcm, said the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies in a new report on Wednesday.
In the year before Russia invaded Ukraine, Europe bought 142bcm of Russian gas.
'As a direct consequence of factors linked to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, that volume fell to just 31bcm in 2024,' said the OIES report, and 'could be as low as 16-18 bcm in 2025.'
That is because all Russian gas used to be supplied through pipelines that are now defunct.
Unknown actors blew up the twin Nord Stream I pipelines and one of the twin Nord Stream II pipelines in September 2022. Together, the four pipelines had been designed to carry 110bcm of gas a year to Europe.
Another 33bcm of Russian gas could enter Europe through the Yamal pipeline that runs across Belarus and Poland, but Russia stopped all gas flow by May 2022 – a move likely planned a year earlier, says OIES – and Poland banned further gas imports from Russia across its territory.
A further 65bcm of Russian gas imports were possible through a pair of pipelines running across Ukraine, but when a five-year transit contract expired last December, Ukraine did not renew it, and the pipelines were idled.
The only remaining Russian gas pipeline is TurkStream, which makes landfall in Eastern Thrace and proceeds through Bulgaria and Serbia to Hungary, but its capacity is limited to 20bcm a year at the Bulgarian border, the point where it enters the EU.
'The big debate within the industry at present is whether, if there is a ceasefire or peace, we are going to see a return of Russian pipeline gas and a relaxation of sanctions on Russian liquefied natural gas (LNG),' OIES director Jonathan Stern told Al Jazeera.
The report suggests that it will not be quick or easy, as pipeline operators now have to be bailed out of bankruptcy, repairs and maintenance have to be carried out, mutual sanctions rescinded and a number of breach-of-contract claims involving hundreds of millions of dollars resolved through arbitration.
The EU has similarly tried to divest itself of Russian oil, but results have been mixed.
It imported 88.4 million tonnes of oil from Russia in 2022 before sanctioning it in December of that year.
Official EU imports of Russian oil had fallen by 90 percent by the end of last year, according to the European statistical service, but that is likely misleading because there have also been illicit imports, two-thirds of them delivered by a Russian shadow fleet.
The Kyiv School of Economics estimated that Russia made $189bn through sales of crude oil and refined petroleum products last year, a rise on $178bn in 2023.
Ember believes EU choices make for bad economics.
It estimates that if all announced investments in gas import terminals and pipelines happen, the EU will have a gas surplus of 131bcm by 2030.
That, it says, saps Europe of money to transform grids and transition to renewable energy, and exposes it to price volatility and uncertain supply, because Europe imports almost all its hydrocarbons.
Stern disagreed with Ember.
Asked if gas was a dead-end investment by 2030, he said, 'No – and nor do most governments or the European Commission [think so], otherwise they wouldn't still be spending money on new infrastructure. If you change the date to 2050, the answer may be different.'
Others believed EU choices were primarily about good politics rather than economics.
Bassias believed that 'the big thing for the US and Russia is to open navigational routes in the Arctic and to do joint oil and gas exploration there.'
They were 'tacitly cooperating under Biden, and it's official now', he said, suggesting the Ukraine war got in the way of that cooperation.
Energy analyst Miltiadis Aslanoglou agreed that 'if one wanted to be strict about [energy imports], one could be.'
'Europe has sent Russia the message it wanted to send – that 'we do not depend on you.' To take its gas trade to zero is very difficult [diplomatically], because, for better or worse, Russia will always be there, it will always be a neighbour. So Europe keeps a door open,' Aslanoglou told Al Jazeera.
He suggested Europe was keeping the once-mighty Russian gas giant Gazprom on life support.
'Gazprom is certainly not the trillion-dollar company it was five years ago, and no one even knows whether it will even exist in another five years,' Aslanoglou said. 'Right now, [it] is in dire financial straits. They can barely maintain the pipeline network within Russia, which is 50 or 60 years old.'
Ukraine has a different view.
Its long-range drone strikes inside Russia since last September suggested a policy shifting from striking ammunition depots to one of choking off Russian export revenues from gas, oil and refined petroleum products, according to analysis from the Ukrainian group Frontelligence Insight.
Ukraine has tried to kill Gazprom twice this year, sending attack drones to destroy the Russkaya compressor, which pressurises gas in Russia's one remaining pipeline to Europe, TurkStream.
Russia said it downed nine drones near the compressor in Russia's Krasnodar region on January 13 and another three drones on March 1.
Ukraine also tried to cut off Russia's crude oil offloading terminal at Novorossiysk in the Black Sea on February 17, and succeeded in damaging it.
Russian President Vladimir Putin's prioritising of a ceasefire in the Black Sea this week, likely aimed to forestall any further Ukrainian attacks on Russia's main economic lifeline.
Ukraine appears not to be the only loser in a 'good politics' scenario with Russia.
The International Energy Agency's Global Energy Review on Monday found that the world's decarbonisation efforts, in which Europe has played a leading role, were beginning to show real results.
Although world energy demand rose by 2.2 percent last year, emissions only rose by 0.8 percent, the IEA said, because renewable energy capacity increased by 700 GW – a 22nd straight annual record in new installed capacity.
That, said the IEA, proved that 'growth in energy-related carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions continues to decouple from global economic growth'.
Ember's message was similar. Unlike Russia and the United States, Europe is hydrocarbon poor.
According to Eurostat, dependence on imported hydrocarbons meant it produced only 37 percent of its total energy needs last year.
Ember believed a paradigm shift to clean energy technology would not only save Ukraine from Russia, but could also save Europe from climate change.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Fed seen on track to start cutting rates by September
Agencies New York Cooler-than-expected US inflation last month deepened conviction in financial markets on Wednesday that the Federal Reserve will start cutting interest rates by September and deliver a second reduction by the end of this year. A US government report showed the Consumer Price Index - a measure of underlying inflation - rose just 0.1 percent in May after a 0.2 percent rise in April, with overall consumer prices rising 2.4 percent from a year earlier, up just one-tenth of a percentage point from the prior month and less than the 2.5 percent economists hadexpected. Within minutes of the release, traders of short-term interest rate futures had priced in a 68 percent chance that the US central bank would cut rates by a quarter of a percentage point by September, compared with 57 percent before the data. They now also see a still small but rising chance of an earlier rate cut, putting about an 18 percent probability of that happening in July versus about 13 percent earlier on Wednesday. The Fed will almost certainly leave its benchmark interest rate steady in the 4.25 percent -4.5 percent range at the end of its two-day policy meeting next week. The policy rate has been in that range since December. Fed policymakers expect the Trump administration's tariffs to slow progress toward their 2 percent inflation target and to weaken the labor market, but feel that as long as the job market holds up - the unemployment rate has been steady at a relatively low 4.2 percent - they can leave borrowing costs where they are to keep continued downward pressure on inflation. Uncertainty over the path of tariffs and their effects on the economy remains high. President Donald Trump announced earlier on Wednesday that a US-China trade deal had been struck that would set tariffs on Chinese goods at 55 percent - lower than the 145 percent imposed in April but much higher than in recent decades. The US has otherwise struck only one other trade deal, with the UK, as the clock ticks toward the early July expiration of a 90-day pause on sharply elevated tariffs on imports from most of the rest of the world. Even so, financial markets breathed a sigh of relief after the inflation data. 'We are still cautious, but many of the risks that were present in early April appear to be receding at this time,' said Chris Zaccarelli, chief investment officer at Northlight Asset Management.
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Oil prices climb to 2-month high on US-China trade deal, worries about Iran supply
Agencies New York Oil prices rose 2 percent on Wednesday, to their highest in more than two months, as President Donald Trump said the US had a trade deal with China, feeding hopes for the outlook for energy demand in the world's two largesteconomies. Brent crude futures rose $1.32, or 1.97 percent, to $68.19 a barrel. US West Texas Intermediate crude was up $1.51, or 2.32 percent, to $66.49. Both Brent and WTI reached their highest in more than two months. Trump said Beijing would supply magnets and rare earth minerals and the US will allow Chinese students in its colleges and universities. Trump added the deal is subject to final approval by him and President Xi Jinping. The trade-related downside risk in oil has been temporarily removed, although the market reaction has been tepid as it is not clear how economic growth and global oil demand will be affected, PVM analyst Tamas Varga said. Trump said he was less confident that Iran would agree to stop uranium enrichment in a nuclear deal with Washington, according to an interview released on Wednesday. Iran threatened to strike US bases in the Middle East if nuclear negotiations fail and conflict arises with Washington. Ongoing tension with Iran means its oil supplies are likely to remain curtailed by sanctions. Supplies will still increase, as OPEC+ plans to boost oil production by 411,000 barrels per day in July as it looks to unwind production cuts for a fourth straight month. 'Greater oil demand within OPEC+ economies – most notably Saudi Arabia – could offset additional supply from the group over the coming months and support oil prices,' said Capital Economics' analyst Hamad Hussain in a note. In the US, crude inventories fell by 3.6 million barrels to 432.4 million barrels last week, the Energy Information Administration said on Wednesday. Analysts polled by Reuters had expected a draw of 2 million barrels. 'It's a bullish report,' said Bob Yawger, director of energy futures at Mizuho, adding that the demand for motor gasoline began to strengthen. Product supplied for motor gasoline, a proxy for demand, rose by about 907,000 barrels per day last week, to 9.17 million bpd. US consumer prices increased less than expected in May, deepening the conviction in financial markets that the Federal Reserve will start cutting interest rates by September. Lower interest rates can spur economic growth and demand for oil.
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
US-China trade talks ‘going well' on 2nd day: Howard Lutnick
Agencies Trade talks with China were going well, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said on Tuesday as the two sides met for a second day in London, seeking a breakthrough on export controls that have threatened a new rupture in fragile ties between the superpowers. Having agreed to step back from a full-blown trade embargo at a first round of talks in Geneva in May, the two sides are now seeking agreement after they accused each other of trying to throttle supply chains with a raft of export controls. White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett said on Monday that the U.S. could lift recently imposed export controls on goods such as semiconductors if China sped up the delivery of rare earths and magnets that are crucial to its economy. The blow-up over rare earths, which has sparked alarm in boardrooms and factory floors around the world, came after last month's preliminary deal in Geneva to cut tariffs, which eased investor fears that a trade war would lead to a global slowdown. '(Talks went on) all day yesterday, and I expect them all day today,' Lutnick told reporters. 'They're going well, and we're spending lots of time together.'Trump's shifting tariff policies have roiled global markets, sparked congestion and confusion in major ports, and cost companies tens of billions of dollars in lost sales and higher costs. But markets have made up much of the losses they endured after Trump unveiled his sweeping 'Liberation Day' tariffs in April, aided by the reset in Geneva between the world's two biggest economies. The second round of U.S.-China talks, which followed a rare phone call between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping last week, comes at a crucial time for both economies. Customs data published on Monday showed that China's exports to the U.S. plunged 34.5% in May, the sharpest drop since the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the impact on U.S. inflation and the jobs market has so far been muted, tariffs have hammered U.S. business and household confidence and the dollar remains under pressure. The two sides, led at the talks by U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Lutnick and U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, with the Chinese contingent helmed by Vice Premier He Lifeng, are meeting at the ornate Lancaster House in the British capital. The talks ran for almost seven hours on Monday and resumed just before 10 a.m. GMT on Tuesday, with both sides expected to issue updates later in the day. The inclusion of Lutnick, whose agency oversees export controls for the U.S., is one indication of how central rare earths have become. He did not attend the Geneva talks, when the countries struck a 90-day deal to roll back some of the triple-digit tariffs they had placed on each other. China holds a near-monopoly on rare earth magnets, a crucial component in electric vehicle motors, and its decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of critical minerals and magnets upended global supply chains. In May, the U.S. responded by halting shipments of semiconductor design software, chemicals and aviation equipment, revoking export licences that had been previously issued. Hassett said he expected any export controls from the U.S. to be eased and rare earths released in volume once the two sides had shaken hands in London. But he said any easing would not include the 'very, very high-end Nvidia stuff,' referring to Nvidia's most advanced artificial intelligence chips that have been blocked from going to China over concerns about potential military applications. 'I'm talking about possible export controls on other semiconductors which are also very important to them,' he said.
