Albanese accuses Israel of ‘clearly' breaching international law but resists push to recognise Palestinian state
The prime minister has also accused Israel of a breach of international law in blocking aid into Gaza, saying 'you can't hold innocent people responsible' for the actions of Hamas, and warning that Benjamin Netanyahu's government is 'losing support' internationally.
'Quite clearly it is a breach of international law to stop food being delivered which was a decision that Israel made in March,' Albanese told the ABC's Insiders program on Sunday.
'Israel as a democratic state has a responsibility to ensure that innocent lives are not lost, and what we have seen is too many Israeli and Palestinians lives lost, and every life matters.'
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
Israel on Sunday, Australian time, said it would start airdrops with humanitarian aid in Gaza, Reuters reported, as well as establishing humanitarian corridors for UN convoys, though it did not say when or where. At least 57 people were killed in Gaza over the past 24 hours, many killed while seeking aid, as well as by Israeli airstrikes, amid a worsening starvation crisis.
Albanese said the airdrops would be 'a start'. Referencing widely published photos of an emaciated infant boy suffering from starvation in Gaza, as well as other starving children, the prime minister said innocent people must be protected.
'A one-year-old boy is not a Hamas fighter. The civilian casualties and death in Gaza is completely unacceptable. It's completely indefensible,' he said.
'My government has been very consistent in calling for a ceasefire. We have been consistent in calling out the terrorists in Hamas and saying that the hostages should be released. But we have rules of engagement and they are there for a reason. They are to stop innocent lives being lost and that is what we have seen.'
Albanese said it was 'quite clearly' a breach of international law to block aid deliveries. Asked by Insiders host David Speers to clarify whether he was specifically accusing Israel of breaching international law, Albanese responded 'I'm not a lawyer, those things will play out their course'.
'But I tell you what it's a breach of: it's a breach of decent humanity and of morality and everyone can see that,' he said.
'I'm a supporter of Israel and Israel's right to defend itself, but that boy isn't challenging Israel's right to existence, and nor are the many who continue to suffer from the unavailability of food and water. The fact that people have lost their lives queueing to get food and water distributed not by the UN, but distributed by the joint Israeli-American operation, is a tragedy.'
The Israeli embassy in Canberra was contacted for comment.
Albanese said the concerns he'd relayed to Israeli president, Isaac Herzog, reflected that 'sometimes friends have to say to their other friends when they are losing support'.
The prime minister issued his own statement condemning Israel for 'the killing of civilians, including children' seeking aid, but stopped short of saying Australia would recognise a Palestinian state, as French president, Emmanuel Macron, had committed.
On Sky News on Sunday, the shadow foreign affairs minister, Michaelia Cash, repeated previous claims that the Australian government should have more strongly condemned Hamas.
'The next sentence should have been, 'and we call on the terrorists Hamas, who commenced this war, and who are ensuring the suffering of the civilians in Gaza, to end this war tomorrow',' she said.
Albanese's statement on Friday said: 'Australia condemns the terror and brutality of Hamas and we reiterate our call for the immediate release of the remaining hostages.'
Former foreign minister Bob Carr, Labor MP Ed Husic and the Labor Friends of Palestine campaign group on Friday reiterated their calls for the government to move now in recognising a Palestinian state – a reform that has long been Labor policy.
But Albanese said such a move was not imminent. He raised concerns about ensuring Hamas was blocked from any involvement in a Palestinian state, how it would operate in a way that did not threaten Israel's existence, and how the Palestinian Authority would be involved.
Albanese also said it was 'critical' the United States play a role, including in security arrangements about settlements in the West Bank and the rebuilding of Gaza.
'We won't do any decision as a gesture. We will do it as a way forward if the circumstances are met,' he said.
'We'll make a decision based upon the time. Is the time right now? Are we about to imminently do that? No, we are not.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Spotlight on Keir Starmer's recognition of Palestine
I'm puzzled by the conditions Keir Starmer has set for Israel to meet, failing which he'll recognise Palestine as a state (UK to recognise state of Palestine in September unless Israel holds to a ceasefire, 29 July). Why does recognition depend on Israel's actions? Surely it should depend on Palestine's: commitments to abjure terrorism, disarm Hamas, hold democratic elections and, of course, to release the hostages. As for Israel, UK policy should be to impose draconian sanctions: if Israel continues to act like a pariah state, let it be treated as one. Without sanctions, there would probably still be an apartheid regime in South Africa. The UK must act now, not half-heartedly in September; thousands of children in Gaza can't wait until MaughanDunblane, Perthshire Like so many people in the UK, I thought that my despair and shame over the situation in Gaza could not be deepened. Keir Starmer achieved that. How like this prime minister to obfuscate further and kick any sense of decisiveness into the long grass of contingency. One might think that Britain has some special responsibility for recognising the state of Palestine, whose population it abandoned to the predations of its neighbour in 1948. What will be left of Gaza, the West Bank and its people by September? A genocide? A diaspora? The UK doesn't negotiate with terrorists, just with war Prof Graham MortLancaster University Soon after the atrocities of 7 October 2023 I heard someone on the radio say, with respect to Israel's imminent invasion of Gaza, 'Beware of being goaded by your enemy into doing what your enemy wants you to do.' Nearly two years on, the Israeli government seems hell-bent on creating a moral equivalence between itself and Hamas. If you become like your enemy, then your enemy has won. Thus, despite what it says about recent moves to recognise a Palestinian state, the Israeli government, more than any other, is 'rewarding' Hamas for its terrorist actions. The Rev Rob KelseyBerwick-upon-Tweed, Northumberland It is impossible for us to know the depth of despair Palestinians must feel to hear western nations pontificating that we will not recognise them as a nation if their oppressors stop killing them. It seems this is the ultimate acknowledgment that they have no rights except those we deem to give them. We have expelled them from the land in which they lived to ensure that Europe didn't have the problem of resettling the thousands displaced by a European war. They are being attacked in Gaza and the West Bank with weapons supplied by western governments. They are being starved in Gaza to keep their oppressor-in-chief in office. And now our governments are praised for condescending to recognise the fact that they are a nation (that has existed for more than 1,000 years). How can we think we have any integrity left in our dealings with the oppressed?Michael McLoughlinWallington, London What will give greater weight to the call for a two-state solution is outlining the building blocks for establishment of a Palestinian state: for example, Gaza would be placed under UN control to allow for demilitarisation, the physical reconstruction and drawing up a basic law to guide the development of a constitutional WeirCape Town, South Africa Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Gaza student leaves France after ‘death to Jews' posts row
A student from Gaza in France on a scholarship has left the country after her anti-Semitic remarks on social media were branded 'unacceptable' by the government. Nour Attaalah, who arrived in France on July 11, called for the killing of Jews in posts made online in the past two years, it is claimed. In a statement by the foreign ministry Jean-Noel Barrot, the French foreign minister, 'stressed the unacceptable nature of the comments made by Ms Attaalah, a Gazan student, before she entered French territory'. The posts, which have since been deleted, led to a judicial investigation for condoning terrorism, and an inquiry to determine why they had not been detected in advance. The Sciences Po Lille school said Wednesday that her social media comments had been confirmed, without elaborating. Ossama Dahmane, the student's lawyer, said the 'alleged facts are largely based on shared tweets, taken out of context'. But the foreign ministry said: 'Given their seriousness, Ms Attaalah could not remain on French territory. She left France today to go to Qatar to continue her studies there.' Her lawyer said Ms Attaalah had chosen to 'pursue her studies in another country in a spirit of appeasement and to guarantee her security', even though 'she firmly denies the accusations made against her'. The young woman, who had received a student visa and a government scholarship as part of a programme for Gaza students, had been due to join Sciences Po Lille in the autumn. She arrived in France on July 11, according to a French diplomatic source. Last Friday, France said it would suspend a programme receiving Palestinians from Gaza until an investigation into how the student accused was allowed into the country was concluded. 'No evacuation of any kind will take place until we have drawn conclusions from this investigation,' Mr Barrot told Franceinfo radio. All Gazans who have entered France will undergo a second screening, he added. The foreign ministry would not say how many students have been affected, citing privacy reasons. But France has helped more than 500 people leave Gaza since the latest war between Palestinian militant group Hamas and Israel started, including wounded children, journalists, students and artists. The conflict, triggered by Hamas's October 7 2023 attack on Israel, has seen Israel retaliate with a deadly military campaign and an aid blockade in Gaza that some rights groups have qualified as 'genocide'. Following the suspension, Arthur Delaporte, spokesman for the opposition Socialist Party, said a blanket ban was inappropriate. 'France cannot suspend its policy of welcoming evacuated Gazans: our common humanity is at stake,' he said on X. Last Thursday, Lille's general prosecutor that a judicial probe has been opened against the student for allegedly trying to 'justify terrorism' and 'justify a crime against humanity'. The controversy erupted shortly after Emmanuel Macron, the French president, announced France would recognise a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly in September. Last week, Sir Keir Starmer said the UK would do the same unless Israel takes 'substantive' steps, including agreeing to a ceasefire in Gaza.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Nearly 600 Israeli ex-security officials appeal to Trump to end war
Nearly 600 retired Israeli security officials and former intelligence agency heads have written to Donald Trump urging him to put pressure on Israel to end the war in Gaza immediately. The Commanders For Israel's Security (CIS) group sent a letter to the US President with 550 signatories, including fomer Mossad director Tamir Pardo, ex-Shin Bet chief Ami Ayalon, and former deputy Israeli army chief Matan Vilnai. The CIS movement is made up of retired senior defence and foreign service officials, who support a two-state solution to secure Israel's future as 'the strong democratic home of the Jewish people via separation from the Palestinians '. 'It is our professional judgement that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel,' reads the open letter, which was sent on Friday and shared with the media later. 'You did it in Lebanon. Time to do it in Gaza as well.' 'Chasing remaining senior Hamas operatives can be done later. Our hostages can't wait.' The appeal comes as videos of two emaciated Israeli hostages in Gaza were released, sparking international condemnation and protests over the weekend. Evyatar David, 24, and Rom Braslavski, 21, were abducted from the Nova music festival on 7 October 2023 and recorded in fragile condition. They are among the 49 hostages believed still in Gaza, of whom 27 are believed to be dead. French President Emmanuel Macron, UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz were among the leaders condemning the videos. Protests also erupted in Tel Aviv on Sunday and in front of the prime minister's office in Jerusalem on Monday, calling to end the war and release the hostages. Indirect ceasefire talks have stalled and Benjamin Netanyahu is reportedly pushing to expand military operations in Gaza. The letter argued that the IDF has achieved its military objectives - dismantling Hamas' governance and military formations - and that securing the hostages now requires a deal. The letter continued: 'Your credibility with the vast majority of Israelis augments your ability to steer Prime Minister Netanyahu and his government in the right direction: End the war, return the hostages, stop the suffering, and forge a regional-international coalition that helps the Palestinian Authority (once reformed) to offer Gazans and all Palestinians an alternative to Hamas and its vicious ideology.' A UN-backed food security agency warned that a 'worst-case scenario of famine' is unfolding in the besieged enclave.
