'Still Inexperienced...": Ex-England Star's Clear Verdict On Shubman Gill As Captain Ahead Of 2nd Test
'What India must do is, with the new ball, they need to take wickets. That's what they've got to do and if they don't do that, I think they're going to always play catch up. They need, like they did in Australia, they were taking wickets with the new ball. Same thing they have to do here. The way to win Test matches is that India must take wickets with the new ball,' Panesar told IANS.
It certainly was not a great start to Shubman Gill's captaincy as Test captain as India began their 2025-27 World Test Championship Cycle with the loss.
Panesar believes that although Gill is inexperienced, his efforts should go into curating the best bowling attack. He believes Prasidh Krishna needs to be much better in English conditions and Kuldeep Yadav's inclusion as the attacking spinner can be a boost and also allow Ravindra Jadeja to take more wickets.
'He's still inexperienced as a captain. I think Prasidh Krishna bowls the Australian length. He doesn't bowl the UK length, which is slightly fuller, top of off stump. That's why I think if he does play, he needs to bowl the ball fuller. He needs to take wickets in his first spell. He can't be taking wickets, you know, later on.
' Kuldeep Yadav is going to be the attacking spinner if he plays, and Shubhman Gill, you should use him in an attacking role. I think Jadeja will definitely play because of his batting; he could be the defensive spinner. Jadeja being the defensive spinner, I think that will help him to take wickets.
"So, if Kuldeep Yadav plays, Gill must use him as the attacking spinner, have attacking field sets. Have a field set that looks to take wickets. Kuldeep Yadav's job is to take wickets,' he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
India vs England: Cagey India may adopt safety-first approach against rampaging England as second Test begins
Team India head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Shubman Gill. (Pic credit: BCCI) The Times of India in England: A day before the second Test begins against England, the skies were grey and overcast above Edgbaston, mirroring the dark clouds of uncertainty hovering over the Indian dressing room. Upon reaching the stadium, head coach Gautam Gambhir , chief selector Ajit Agarkar, selectorial colleague Shiv Sundar Das, bowling coach Morne Morkel and captain Shubman Gill were seen assembling at the pitch and indulging in an animated discussion for a good 45 minutes. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! It was an optional practice day. Gill turned up, addressed an intriguing press conference, went back to the field to go through an intense batting session before breaking away from the pack and getting busy with sprints and other fitness drills. Amid all this, Gambhir was seen walking up and speaking to him even as Gill was doing his fitness drills. Poll Should India play two spinners in the second Test against England? Yes, to strengthen the bowling attack No, stick to pace bowlers Depends on pitch conditions Only if one of them can bat well India are going into this Test a game down in the series after the loss at Headingley. These are not exactly desperate times yet but somehow the anxiety in the camp is palpable. The playing combination has taken centre stage. It's not just about star bowler Jasprit Bumrah's likely unavailability for this match. It's about how India want to approach the Test. When Shubman Gill and Gautam Gambhir looked at the pitch to decide India Playing XI Playing two spinners on this relatively dry surface is the only thing that they have been clear about. Going by Gill's statements on the eve of the match, India are still unsure about the role they would want the second spinner to play. It has come down to choosing between Washington Sundar's off-spin and Kuldeep Yadav 's left-arm spin. It's obvious that India are rattled by the high rate of scoring of the English batting lineup. 'Containment' was the operative word used by Gill on Tuesday. 'In the last Test our bad phases were so bad that the game got away from us. We expect a similar pitch here. We feel the second spinner can offer more control than the pacer. We should have bowled tighter lines in Leeds,' Gill said. 'Jaddu bhai (Ravindra Jadeja) was making things happen on the last day in the last Test. A second spinner could have given us a better opportunity.' And then he delivered a somewhat contradictory line. 'We want to have an attack that can pick 20 wickets. The only thing you have to see is how you manage the extra spinner on Day One. If at all there is anything on this kind of pitch, it is in the first session or first couple of sessions on Day One. So, that is the main call that you have to take on this kind of pitch.' Late selection meeting between Gautam Gambhir, Shubman Gill and Ajit Agarkar near pitch? The problem here is the team management's obsession with beefing up the batting order. The batting ability of the second spinner could be a big factor in selection. Washington, having batted long in the nets on Monday, didn't turn up for the optional training session. Kuldeep focused on his batting in the nets on Tuesday. Interestingly, this bunch of boys have played decisive parts in India's finest overseas Test victories in the last seven-eight years. Playing bold and fearless cricket was at the core of those victories. Leading into this Test, one gets the feeling that they are getting into a safety-first approach against an England team which thrives on no-holds-barred cricket. With Bumrah almost certain to take a break in this match and the lower middle-order batters the soft underbelly of the lineup, decision making has been difficult. Gill spelled out his preferred combination, which will give him steady batting options till No. 8 with three frontline pacers, two spinners and one bowler who can chip in. That the team management under Gambhir is fond of utility players is no secret now. The sudden ascension of Nitish Kumar Reddy in the last Test series in Australia is a reference point. Shubman Gill press conference: Playing XI almost final, time of Jasprit Bumrah call and more Reddy's century on a similar pitch at the MCG might tempt Gill to give him a go. Reddy was seen going through extensive fielding drill in the slip cordon and a thorough batting nets session on Monday. He too took the day off. Right through the press conference, Gill was insistent that he has a very productive pool of players to choose from. Now, it's just about clarity, about whether India want to be on the offensive against an ultra-aggressive England team or play percentage cricket in their bid to level the series. Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
‘Commentary became a diss about bowlers': R Ashwin questions why India batters aren't scoring ‘daddy hundreds'
Former India off-spinner R Ashwin has slammed critics for taking a swipe only at the bowlers after the harrowing defeat to England in the first Test when Shubman Gill's side failed to defend a 370-run total in the fourth innings at Leeds. Ashwin, who retired as India's most successful World Test Championship wicket-taker last year, said that experts and commentators immediately turned their focus only on the bowlers, while the batters failed to shore up India's totals to above-average scores on batting-friendly wickets. India became the first side to lose a Test despite witnessing five individual centuries in the match across both innings, where the side suffered lower-order collapses. Captain Shubman Gill's 147 was the highest score of the five centuries India tallied while putting up 471 and 364-run totals. 'Once 370 was chased down (in the first Test), I thought the commentary became a diss about the Indian bowlers. I felt that the narrative built was pointing towards how Indian bowlers failed to win the match. But with a little homework, many would have realised that in England, scores have been consistently chased down in 4th innings,' Ashwin said on his YouTube channel. 'Batters should take up responsibility. I know batsmen are making runs. Yes, we had five centurions, but where are the daddy hundreds? We have to resign to the fact that there would be no contribution (with the bat) from the lower order. Our fast bowlers cannot bat, they cannot muster runs,' Ashwin added. Ashwin also underlined the fact that India's bowlers, behind Jasprit Bumrah, must look at emphasising control and economy rather than focus on wicket-taking at the expense of runs. 'In Tests, I think maidens are quite underrated. Ideally, I would be okay with Bumrah going for a higher economy rate, but others should go low. I saw a show where someone said Siraj was unlucky to not be among wickets. I do agree he bowled well in the second innings, but the economy rate, you can't let go and hope that things fall in place. In Tests, you have to build your bowling gradually from Day 1, and the rewards will come in the final innings,' Ashwin highlighted. 'If you give away a lot of runs in the first innings, you tend to get conservative to stem the flow, and you won't get wickets in this approach. If I was Morkel, I would tell the other bowlers not to do much since Bumrah is there. As the old saying goes, bowl three maidens, and you will get a wicket. Don't you think a wicket would fall after three maidens in a row against this England side? Against this side, if you are giving two runs an over, it is as good as bowling a maiden,' he added.
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Panesar On Counter To England's 'Smarter' Bazball: 'What India Must Do Is...'
Last Updated: Monty Panesar advises India to use the new ball ruthlessly and apply early pressure on English batters to win the second Test at Edgbaston. Former England cricketer Monty Panesar has advised India to use the new ball ruthlessly and apply early pressure on the English batters to win the second Test at Edgbaston, which begins on Wednesday. Despite scoring a total of 835 runs across their two innings, India's bowling attack, except for Jasprit Bumrah, who claimed Zak Crawley's wicket in the first over of England's first innings, failed to dominate the English batters. This allowed the English team to navigate tricky situations and then attack as the ball aged, a strategy Panesar referred to as 'Smarter Bazball'. 'What we have seen with England, they play the first 10 overs very slowly because the ball moves around; it swings, and when the ball doesn't do as much, they will start accelerating the scoring. So what they're doing is they're playing smarter 'Bazball' cricket," Panesar was quoted as saying to IANS. 'What India must do is, with the new ball, they need to take wickets. That's what they've got to do and if they don't do that, I think they're going to always play catch up. They need, like they did in Australia, they were taking wickets with the new ball. Same thing they have to do here. The way to win Test matches is that India must take wickets with the new ball," he added. How Can Gill Lead India's Comeback? Shubman Gill's start as Test captain was not ideal, as India began their 2025-27 World Test Championship Cycle with a loss. Panesar believes that although Gill is inexperienced, he should focus on building the best bowling attack. He thinks Prasidh Krishna needs to adapt to English conditions, and Kuldeep Yadav's inclusion as an attacking spinner could be beneficial, allowing Ravindra Jadeja to take more wickets. 'He's still inexperienced as a captain. I think Prasidh Krishna bowls the Australian length. He doesn't bowl the UK length, which is slightly fuller, top of off stump. That's why I think if he does play, he needs to bowl the ball fuller. He needs to take wickets in his first spell. He can't be taking wickets, you know, later on. ' Kuldeep Yadav is going to be the attacking spinner if he plays, and Shubhman Gill, you should use him in an attacking role. I think Jadeja will definitely play because of his batting; he could be the defensive spinner. Jadeja being the defensive spinner, I think that will help him to take wickets. 'So, if Kuldeep Yadav plays, Gill must use him as the attacking spinner, have attacking field sets. Have a field set that looks to take wickets. Kuldeep Yadav's job is to take wickets," he added. First Published: July 01, 2025, 16:55 IST
