Wild campers set to find out if they're banned from Dartmoor after wealthy couple's bid to keep public off their land
Landowners Alexander and Diana Darwall are challenging a Court of Appeal ruling which says that members of the public have the right to wild camp in the national park of Devon.
In recent years, the right to pitch a tent in the wilderness and enjoy an evening among nature has prompted a fierce debate, with Labour once promising it would legislate for a right to wild camp in all national parks.
In the case of Dartmoor, a 368-square mile area that features 'commons' (land that the public has specific rights to use), camping had been assumed to be allowed since 1985 under the terms set out under the Dartmoor Commons Act.
While wild camping is allowed in large parts of Scotland, Dartmoor marked the only place in England that such an activity was allowed without requiring permission from a landowner.
Mr Darwall, a multi-millionaire hedge fund manager, purchased the 4,000 acre Blachford estate in southern Dartmoor in 2013. He and his wife keep cattle on part of the land which is called Stall Moor, and have argued that campers cause problems to livestock and damage the natural surroundings.
Commenting on the case, Mr Darwall had previously said that many campers do not observe the 'leave no trace' principle, and that campfires can cause 'habitat destruction' or 'devastating damage' if it turns into a wildfire.
The case hinges on whether wild camping can be classified as open-air recreation. In the Dartmoor Commons Act 1985, it states that the 'public shall have the right of access to the commons on foot and on horseback for the purpose of open-air recreation'.
Lawyers for the Darwalls have argued that the nearly 40-year piece of legislation means that it only provides access for walking and riding.
This is strongly contested by lawyers representing the Dartmoor National Park Authority (DNPA), who have said that the phrase 'on foot' means access should be pedestrian and not by means of a vehicle.
The DNPA have also disputed the concerns of damage caused by camping, describing the reported impact to land and vegetation as 'absurd'.
In written submissions, Richard KC said: 'The suggestion that merely erecting a tent for backpack or wild camping damages the land and vegetation is absurd.
'Erecting a tent for backpack or wild camping for a night or two would do no such damage.'
Since launching his campaign to ban wild campers from his estate, thousands of campaigners have joined a protest movement asserting their right to camp freely around the beauty spot.
During the first stage of their legal battle in January 2023, the Darwalls won their High Court case, which ruled that the law did not give people the right to pitch tents overnight without landowners' permission.
However, just months later the Court of Appeal overturned this decision, finding the law gave people 'the right to rest or sleep on the Dartmoor Commons, whether by day or night and whether in a tent or otherwise' as long as byelaws are followed.
The Darwalls were then allowed to pursue their case in the Supreme Court, with a final ruling expected on Wednesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
37 minutes ago
- The Independent
Why Diane Abbott told Jeremy Corbyn not to set up new party
Diane Abbott advised Jeremy Corbyn against establishing a new political party, citing the difficulties new parties face under Britain's first-past-the-post electoral system. Despite her advice, Ms Abbott believes Mr Corbyn's unnamed new party, launched last month with Zarah Sultana, will exceed expectations due to widespread public dissatisfaction with current politics. Ms Abbott, a Labour MP for over 40 years, indicated she would not be joining Mr Corbyn's new venture, despite expressing disappointment with the current Labour government 's policies. She criticised the government's decision to proscribe Palestine Action, labelling it a "complete disgrace" and an attempt to suppress protest. Ms Abbott expressed anger at not being called by Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle to speak after racist comments by Conservative donor Frank Hester, suggesting political motives from both the Conservatives and Labour.
Telegraph
38 minutes ago
- Telegraph
The longstanding neglect of working-class pupils puts Britain to shame
SIR – Bridget Phillipson, the Education Secretary, writes (Commentary, August 21) that the state has 'failed white working-class pupils', as in 2024 only 19 per cent of them achieved a strong pass in maths and English GCSE. This is hardly surprising, particularly in the case of boys. I taught at six high schools in a 40-year career, and never came across any initiatives that were specifically directed at such children. When I began teaching in 1977, there were no special plans for anyone. Then, the focus became improving the results of girls, especially in IT, science and technical subjects. When pupil performance data began to be used, focus shifted to different ethnic minority groups. Some of the lowest performing schools are to be found in towns such as Morecambe, Blackpool and Clacton – schools where the vast majority of children are white working-class. Another shift in focus is needed. David S Ainsworth Manchester SIR – The real problem is not that the state has failed pupils, but that parents have. Teachers attempt to educate their pupils to achieve the highest possible results they can – but without consistent support from parents, too many children will underachieve. Eric Mansfield Clitheroe, Lancashire SIR – I was a white working-class child – but I was not let down by the state: I studied at a grammar school. I have spent my life feeling so grateful for having been given that chance. Margaret O'Connell Rickmansworth, Hertfordshire SIR – Some 30 years ago I started teaching in a social priority school – one where a child with exceptional social circumstances is considered higher priority for a place. Most of the students had psycholinguistic problems, and there was a long wait for speech and language services. So I started a communication opportunity group scheme (Cogs). This involved integrating communication teaching into the curriculum. Cogs has been shown to get results – but has been taken up abroad much more than in the UK. When will we learn? Rosemary Sage West Haddon, Northamptonshire SIR – I have a school book completed by the brother of my grandmother, when he was a 14-year-old pupil in Derbyshire in 1860. The book includes all the mathematics necessary for somebody wishing to enter the building trade. Typical titles include 'Equation of Payments' and 'Measuring by the Yard Square as Pavers, Painters, Plasterers and Joiners'. The book is also beautifully illustrated. I don't know whether he became a builder, but his schooling provided the necessary education. It's shameful that we no longer seem able to do the same.
Daily Mail
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Hostage: Affairs, asylum seekers, 'Allo 'Allo accents... Netflix's drama is nuts!
Head for the bunkers — nuclear grade hokum incoming! The heart of British democracy is under attack, not from the Russians, nor Islamist extremists, but from an even bigger bunch of loonies... Netflix. The five-part political drama Hostage sees Suranne Jones playing a Labour prime minister who has to save the NHS (hurrah!) while facing down a neo-Fascist French president (boo!) planning to station Euro-troops in England (boo! hiss!). Meanwhile, there's a boatload of African asylum seekers fleeing persecution who need safe haven in the UK — and, gulp, they've all got ebola. And just when you think the stakes couldn't be any higher, masked gunmen only go and kidnap the PM's lovely husband, Dr Alex (Ashley Thomas). He's in South America with a Medecins Sans Frontieres team, giving vaccinations to happy village children and their poor-but-grateful mums, when terrorists take all the doctors prisoner. They shoot a translator dead. At first this appears to be more proof of what rotten rotters they are, but Dr Alex overhears them talking in English, so perhaps they just realised they wouldn't need a translator. With a gun to his head, Dr Alex is forced to record a video message to his wife. She must resign within 24 hours or one of the hostages will be killed. Suranne Jones, who excels at melodrama, does her best to breathe credibility into all this over-egged nonsense. We're so used to seeing her in extreme situations — wreaking vengeance on an unfaithful husband in Doctor Foster, solving murders aboard a submarine in Vigil — that it doesn't seem too delulu when she takes command of a hostage rescue attempt... and then apologises to the Chief of the Defence Staff for failing to let him know what she was doing. Mind you, it's not much of a rescue. British special forces have apparently been reduced to one soldier, a grizzled veteran called Thomas. And he's armed only with a pistol and a telescopic camera that looks as though he ordered it from one of those sales booklets that fall out of the Sunday supplements. He probably bought a nice pair of orthopaedic sandals and a reversible jacket at the same time. If the PM has any chance of getting her husband back, she's going to have to rely on the French military. But President Vivienne Toussaint (Julie Delpy) has her own problems — she's been having an affair with someone she really shouldn't, and now a blackmailer is threatening to release a video of them in bed together. No wonder Vivienne is so spiteful and mean to her family... though it doesn't explain why, when they're alone, they speak English with 'Allo 'Allo accents. If all that stretches your credulity, consider this. It's only in a fictional drama as bonkers as this that Labour can manage to elect a female leader.
