O'Gorman says legal advice on Occupied Territories Bill did not mention issue with services
O'Gorman said the issues the government are now claiming exist in relation to services have only emerged since the last general election.
'It's a delaying tactic,' he said.
The Occupied Territories Bill, in its initial form, would ban trade in goods and services with illegal settlements anywhere in the world, but most notably in Palestine.
Passing the Bill, which has been in existence since 2018, was a promise made by the governing parties ahead of the general election last year.
But it has yet to be passed or even drafted because of what the government has described as 'constitutional issues' and complications related to the inclusion of services alongside goods.
Speaking on The Week in Politics on RTÉ today, O'Gorman said that when he was in government, legal advice provided by the Attorney General in July last year 'raised some issues' with the original draft of the bill, which he said were 'legitimate issues that can be addressed by amendment'.
Advertisement
However, he added: 'There was no reference to an issue around services in his very detailed legal advice.
'This is a new issue that has been brought in subsequent to the general election, a general election where Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael made extensive commitments about passing the Occupied Territories Bill and, to my mind, it's a delaying tactic.
'The Government have said they will publish a draft before summer, they haven't promised to pass it.
'This is about kicking the can down the road,' he added, adding that the Bill could be passed by the summer 'if there was the will'.
The government has been asked repeatedly for the legal advice it has received in relation to services to be published in order to put the matter to bed.
Minister for State Hildegarde Naughton was asked if the government would be willing to publish the advice that has led to the delays in producing a new version of the bill.
'I have no issue with that,' Naughton said, but she pushed back on the suggestion that the government was delaying putting forward the bill.
'This is not a policy difference – I want to be very clear – around goods and services, this is about ensuring that we get that legislation right,' she said.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
36 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Humphreys opens up strong lead over Kelly
Heather Humphreys' sprint towards the Fine Gael nomination continues this morning with an apparently unassailable lead over fellow hopeful, Seán Kelly. Ms Humphreys is understood to have the support of 42 members of the Parliamentary party - she needs 20 - and is continuing to seek backers. Under Fine Gael's rules, a candidate also needs the support of 25 councillors and five members of the Executive Council. There are 59 members of the Parliamentary Party, so if Ms Humphreys does retain the support of 42 TDs, Senators and MEPs, that would not leave Mr Kelly with enough support to make it through the nomination process. Fine Gael is giving candidates two weeks to secure the support needed to see whether the matter progresses to a vote within the party. Should Ms Humphreys secure the party nomination, she will face serious questions over her record in government. Last night, Sinn Féin's Mark Ward said she would have to "account for 14 years of Fine Gael failure." The Dublin Mid-West TD said Ms Humphreys' U-turn on whether to run "reeks of desperation". Sinn Féin still has to consider whether it will run its own candidate, with a decision expected next month. The party is still mulling the option of supporting Catherine Connolly who has the support of the Social Democrats, Labour, People Before Profit and some Independent TDs, meaning her name will be on the ballot paper. Yesterday, Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin poured cold water on MEP Billy Kelleher's call for an urgent meeting to decide the party's strategy. The Taoiseach said: "I've made it very, very clear, at the end of this month, I will be making it clear and engaging with the Parliamentary Party and outlining the Fianna Fáil position then." Businessman Gareth Sheridan's team say he is still in with a shout of making it onto the ballot paper. A spokesman for the 35-year-old entrepreneur said: "He has personally engaged with the significant independent councillor groupings in no fewer than ten local authorities; secured commitments from as many as eight of them that they are willing to propose and second his candidacy when the time arises, and this is what gives him the confidence to assert that he is assured of being nominated in at least four local authorities." This is another route to being officially nominated, one Mr Sheridan's team is confident of, but a lot will depend on Fianna Fáil's decision. If the party does not run its own candidate, will FF councillors be free to support Independents, or could they row in behind their coalition partner, Fine Gael's? Much will be decided in the next fortnight. The election is expected to take place around the end of October. The Electoral Commission notes that in 2018 and 2011, Presidential Election Orders were signed by the Minister in late August and Iris Oifigiúl notices published that month or early September. Nominations opened two days after the Order was signed and published. In the last Presidential election, nominations were open between 10am Thursday 30 August to 12pm Wednesday 26 September for 28 days or four weeks.
Irish Independent
4 hours ago
- Irish Independent
The Irish Independent's view: As race for Áras truly gets up and running, we can look forward to dignified contest
Mr Kelly says he was speaking tongue in cheek. Both were preparing to get in touch with the 'grassroots' in their separate bids to secure the Fine Gael nomination for the Áras. The race was truly on – until it appeared last night that Ms Humphreys could not be caught. Comebacks are generally a cause for excitement, but as neither has been quite out of the public eye, their return to the field was understandably mooted. Speaking on Northern Sound radio, Ms Humphreys said she has 'decided to go for it' after ruling herself out last May. For Mr Kelly, his original decision not to run was 'the hardest' he ever made. Their resurrections were prompted by the sudden withdrawal of front-runner Mairead McGuinness. Having been given a second chance, their first challenge is to avoid being viewed as a second choice. Their party had, after all, invested so much hope in Ms McGuinness. They can expect to be asked to explain why, if they were so confident in their abilities, they had not seized the moment and created their own opportunities, rather than waiting for someone else to bow out. Both can claim impressive track records, even if their late entries were providential. Winning the party's nomination requires 25 votes from councillors, 20 members of the parliamentary party and five members of the executive council. Last night, Ms Humphreys had secured what was needed, making it virtually impossibly for Mr Kelly to succeed. Procrastination is the grave in which opportunity is buried Independent candidate Catherine Connolly, who has the backing of Labour and Social Democrats, is also a contender, but many are surprised at the hesitance of Sinn Féin and Fianna Fáil in getting their dogs in the race. 'Procrastination is the grave in which opportunity is buried,' wrote Alyce Cornyn-Selby, author of Why Do Winners Win? A certain restlessness is clearly discernible within the ranks of Fianna Fáil. MEP Billy Kelleher has called for a meeting of the parliamentary party to 'urgently' discuss running a candidate. But his party colleague and fellow MEP Barry Andrews told RTÉ there was no cause for panic. Fianna Fáil was not dragging its feet or dithering. What we are witnessing is a master of what he called Micheál Martin's 'strategic patience'. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has hardly been a model of decisiveness either. 'Like the rest of the party, I'm weighing things up in my own mind,' she said. She hoped the campaign would be a serious political conversation about Ireland, not 'a personality contest'. One can but hope. US satirist HL Mencken once said: 'A national political campaign is better than the best circus ever heard of, with a mass baptism and a couple of hangings thrown in.' So, the cynics may sneer that it is time to send in the clowns, but the rest of us are looking forward to a dignified contest, as befits the office.
Irish Examiner
16 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Billy Kelleher calls on Fianna Fáil to meet sooner than planned to discuss presidential candidate
Fianna Fáil should convene a meeting urgently to discuss the forthcoming presidential election, according to Billy Kelleher, the party's MEP for Ireland South. Mr Kelleher added that without a meeting convened soon, Fianna Fáil TDs, senators and MEPs will not meet in person until mid-September at the earliest. The party has yet to name its candidate for the election, with Taoiseach Micheál Martin saying earlier this summer that he would take "soundings" from the party over the course of this month. However, Mr Kelleher said waiting until the party's pre-Oireachtas think-in in September to meet would be a mistake. He has written to the party's chairman Brendan Smith to ask that a meeting be convened. 'To my mind, this is too late in the day for the people who will ultimately be tasked with selecting a party candidate to meet to discuss the issue. 'In my opinion, Fianna Fáil, the largest party in the Dáil, the Seanad and in local government, should be actively involved in either running its own candidate or facilitating a candidate that represents our values and beliefs as a political movement,' said Mr Kelleher. The Fianna Fáil parliamentary party will decide the party's candidate, it is understood, but some have raised concerns about how much time they would have to run a campaign if that does not happen until the middle of next month. Party sources pointed to the fact that the Fine Gael candidate - either sitting MEP Sean Kelly or former social protection minister Heather Humphreys - and the only candidate currently with the requisite support to be on the ballot, Galway West independent TD Catherine Connolly, are well established names. "If we want to run someone like Mary McAleese, we need time to introduce them to the public, especially if Heather (Humphreys) is the candidate," one TD said. "It is going to be very tough if that person has no name recognition themselves." The party has not put forward a candidate for the presidency since 1997, when Mary McAleese would go on to win, but given its position as the largest party in the Oireachtas, TDs and senators believe there should be a Fianna Fáil candidate on the ballot. Mary Hanafin, a member of the Brian Cowen government which was in power until 2011, sent an email to the parliamentary party asking for support in seeking a nomination, but many within the party were quick to reject that notion. Earlier this month, Mr Martin ruled himself out of the race, saying he was committed to leading the Government. "No disrespect to the presidency or anything, but I gave commitments to the people that I would serve in Dail Éireann for the next five years and that is what I'm going to do." He said Fianna Fáil would decide on what it would do in the presidential election in the coming weeks, and he was 'taking soundings' from the parliamentary party on the matter.
