logo
EXCLUSIVE — David Gower: World Test Championship is inevitably flawed

EXCLUSIVE — David Gower: World Test Championship is inevitably flawed

The Hindu17-07-2025
Former England captain David Gower isn't against Bazball — but he believes Test cricket's future hinges on something bigger than England's approach. One of England's most elegant batters, Gower scored 8,231 runs in 117 Tests at an average of 44.25, with 18 centuries to his name — and he's now calling for the ICC to urgently rethink how it supports its 'relatively poor' member nations if the longest format is to survive.
Speaking to Sportstar on the final day of the third Test at Lord's, Gower weighed in on the 'inevitably flawed' World Test Championship, praised Shubman Gill's early captaincy, and argued that for England, the challenge isn't to abandon Bazball — but to know when to rein it in.
With aggressive batting and quick results becoming the norm in Tests, how do you view this shift — and do you worry about its impact on batting craft?
The idea of batting positively isn't new. Back in 1985, during the Ashes here, we scored at over four an over in five of six Tests — which, for that time, was rapid. The Australians of the '90s did it too: they'd score quickly to give (Glenn) McGrath and (Shane) Warne time to bowl teams out — and still fit in a round of golf. So, the concept has always existed. What England have done under (Ben) Stokes and (Brendon) McCullum is take it to new heights. The (Jonny) Bairstows, the (Zak) Crawleys, and others who love their shots have recorded scoring rates that are the highest in the last three to four years. And on its day, it's thrilling to watch.
There's huge entertainment value in it, but also a slightly desperate need to prove that Test cricket can still be entertaining. We're talking on the fifth morning of this Test, and the buzz is absolutely electric. It was the same last night. This entire series has had moments that have reminded everyone what five-day cricket can offer.
For those lucky enough to be at the ground, it's a real event — something you feel. That isn't something you get with formats where you pop in for a couple of hours and leave with a result. I still believe Test cricket is the highest form of the game by some distance.
When Virat Kohli says it is, that's great PR — because 1.4 billion people hear him. But we need more people speaking up for it. What we — my generation especially — always wanted from England was a blend of flair and grit. In the Lord's Ashes Test two years ago, they collapsed in an hour of madness; only Stokes stuck it out. Since then, a few others have started to ride out the tough periods, then push on again with clear skies and fair winds. That's progress. Over the past four years, there were moments when a different approach for an hour or two might have changed the result. And now, in this series, you can see they've begun to learn from those.
The pace of the Lord's Test has been different. Batting hasn't been easy — there've been no soft 200s. That's fabulous. And you can feel it everywhere — the stands, the press box, the corporate boxes — this sense that you're watching something special.
(Smiles) I wasn't planning to come in today [final day]. But after last night, it felt like it would be a shame to miss it.
Is Bazball the way forward — or just a necessary tactic to keep Test cricket relevant in the T20 era?
If teams are capable of playing that way, then yes — it's important for Test cricket to prove it's still worth watching. In an era where white-ball formats dominate and data tells us fans love the instant thrill — balls flying to the boundary, sixes every few minutes — anything that shows how vibrant the long format can be is valid.
But not every team has the talent or depth to play that way. If you're lower down the pecking order, you've got to find the best way you can to win a Test — even if that means playing more conservatively.
Look at Australia. Sure, they have someone like Travis Head, who fits naturally into a more aggressive mould. But their overall approach has often been pragmatic. That alleged culture clash in the Ashes two years ago — England's ultra-positive style versus Australia's discipline — ended with the pragmatic side winning.
Ultimately, in iconic series like the Ashes or the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, or even the World Test Championship final, it's not about style points — it's about doing what it takes to win.
And part of keeping Test cricket relevant is showing people that drama can unfold in many ways. In that WTC final, the ball dominated for two days — low scores, not your usual white-ball fare — and then Aiden Markram played a stunning innings to snatch the game. That ebb and flow, those wild momentum shifts, are unique to this format.
I know it's a harder sell to younger fans — and nearly impossible to explain to Americans — but for those who still value Test cricket as the game's highest form, their voice still matters, even if it's a smaller group now.
Ashes reverie: David Gower, England's debonair captain, stands tall on the Oval balcony, cradling the Ashes urn — the gleaming symbol of a summer triumph. The 3-1 series win in 1985 is his crowning moment. Beside him, Allan Border embodies the stoic dignity of defeat. | Photo Credit: THE HINDU ARCHIVES
With T20 leagues on the rise and bilateral interest fading, what reforms can help safeguard Test cricket without ignoring the game's commercial realities?
Well, I never quite know the answer to that sort of question. But what's telling is how the conversation has shifted. Two years ago, influential voices were busy carving out windows for franchise cricket. Now, those same people are saying we need a dedicated window for Test cricket.
And it's complicated, isn't it? There are so many factors — money, resources, infrastructure. Lord's is an exception: 28,000 people will turn up on a Monday for Day Five of a Test if the match is set up well. India still gets good crowds, though in a 100,000-seater, 30,000 can look sparse. Australia gets healthy numbers when we tour. But in the West Indies, the stands are nearly empty. Test matches there often lose money.
In New Zealand, they've at least adapted by using smaller grounds to make things feel fuller. But for many boards, the arithmetic doesn't work. You can understand why a board like Cricket West Indies, already under pressure, might prefer eight days of white-ball cricket over 15 days of loss-making Tests. That's a hard call to argue with.
So, unless the ICC can think of — I know it wouldn't go down well in India — redistributing the funds that can help out the poorer nations, we will see Test cricket declining apart from the top three, four, five nations. (This can't be) just an odd boost every other year or in three or four years, but year by year. So I'm not the Solomon who can tell you exactly how to solve this. But one of the things I do think very strongly is that if you want Test-playing nations to still be in business, then they need help.
With Bazball's rise, England's pitches seem flatter and more batting-friendly than before. Is old-school English cricket losing its edge?
(Smiles) I suppose these flat pitches suit Stokes' desire to chase — well, sometimes.
Even this England team would agree that a better contest between bat and ball makes for a better spectacle. That's been a mantra for so many of us over the years. Watching teams pile up 600 on certain flat pitches — it gets quite dull, doesn't it?
Then there's the commercial side to consider. Take this Lord's Test: if it finishes in three days, that's potentially two days of lost revenue. But how do you weigh that against the quality of entertainment the crowd has already had?
The dream is a fair contest, something in it for both batters and bowlers.
A game that lasts at least four days, stays tight, and builds toward a tense finish, like this one. That's when Test cricket is at its best.
When Tests wrap up in just two or three days — especially in the subcontinent — does it hurt the format's appeal?
Home advantage can be abused, of course. And when the temptation is to win at almost any cost, teams sometimes go too far. That series in India last year, for example — dominated by turning tracks — you could tell it wouldn't last five days. And you could probably guess the result going in. But if you're trying to reach the World Test Championship final, you want points and wins — that's the reality.
England's tour of Pakistan last October showed both extremes. One Test was on a flat pitch — Harry Brook's triple hundred was brilliant in its own way. Then the next games, the ball spun, and we watched a side that was dominant unravel.
So yes, pitch preparation can shape a series — that's undeniable. Whether that's right or wrong is open to debate. Some dream of a unified pitch formula: 'no, no, no, no, no, no. It's only seam, flat and spin' — as if there's a dial you can turn remotely. That would be ideal. But let's be realistic — you take what you get and try to win on it.
David Gower: 'As a captain, you can just try and find a way of motivating or inspiring every man to be at his best somehow. That's all you can do.' | Photo Credit: PTI
The WTC has added context to Tests — but what changes would make the format more relevant and engaging?
The World Test Championship is inevitably flawed — whether it's the percentage system or the points lost for slow over-rates. It's a brave attempt to address the issue, but clearly not enough.
The real problem is that it's not an even contest. Not all top sides play each other, and everything depends on where, how, and who you play. No amount of maths can fix that imbalance.
That said, it does add context — especially for the teams in the top four pushing for a final spot. But if you're sitting at number nine, frankly, no one gives a flying fox what happens.
India is in a rebuilding phase under a new captain. If you had a word with Shubman Gill, what advice would you give him on bringing the best out of his players?
Building a team depends on so many things. At the start of the series, people focused on the absence of Rohit (Sharma) and Virat (Kohli). But Shubman stepped up and played beautifully in two Tests.
You don't have to be 34 to lead — you can be 24, if you've got talent, a good head, and a solid technique. That kind of player can fill the gap. If you're one or two players short of a great side, you work around it and trust others to develop.
I trust my old colleague Michael Atherton when he says India won nine of the 10 days. That's not bad for a team supposedly in transition. In Birmingham, they bowled better than us. At Lord's, England finally found something in the ball we hadn't really seen before.
Team-building often comes down to individual moments. Look at Stokes at Lord's — this is the Stokes we've missed: bowling 90 miles an hour, driving the attack forward. You want all your key players at peak performance — that's what shifts a match.
I always say, if six of your XI are playing to their potential, you're in a good position. If six are having a shocker, you're likely coming second. If all 11 hit their peak — you're unbeatable. But that rarely happens. As a captain, you can just try and find a way of motivating or inspiring every man to be at his best somehow. That's all you can do.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ben Stokes Creates History, Becomes First England Captain To...
Ben Stokes Creates History, Becomes First England Captain To...

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

Ben Stokes Creates History, Becomes First England Captain To...

For scoring a century (141) and taking a five-wicket haul (5/72) in the first innings of the Manchester Test, Stokes bagged the POTM award. Ben Stokes was on fire with both bat and ball for England in the fourth Test against India, which ended in a draw at Old Trafford in Manchester on Sunday, July 27. The 34-year-old cricketer picked up five wickets for 72 runs in the first innings and then scored 141 runs from 198 balls as well. In the second innings, he bowled 11 overs and dismissed KL Rahul (90). For his superb all-round show at Old Trafford, Stokes bagged the Player of the Match award. The POTM award in Manchester is Stokes' 12th POTM award in Test cricket. Only Joe Root (13 POTM awards in 157 Tests) has won more POTM awards for England in Tests than Stokes now. Most POTM awards in Tests for England 13 – Joe Root 12 – Ian Botham 12 – Ben Stokes 10 – Kevin Pietersen 10 – Stuart Broad Stokes has scored a total of 304 runs and picked up 17 wickets in the ongoing series. He is the first England captain in Test cricket's history to aggregate 300-plus runs and bag 15-plus wickets in a Test series. The only England player to achieve this double in a Test series in the last 40 years was Andrew Flintoff in Ashes 2005. Test ends in a draw India pulled off a remarkable draw at Old Trafford on the final day of the fourth Test, thanks to heroic centuries from Ravindra Jadeja (107*) and Washington Sundar (101*). After conceding a 311-run first-innings lead and losing both openers for ducks, India were staring at defeat. However, captain Shubman Gill (103) and KL Rahul (90) stitched a crucial 188-run stand before Ben Stokes and Jofra Archer struck back in the morning session. With the match slipping away, Jadeja and Washington showed immense grit, batting through more than two sessions and adding an unbeaten 200-run partnership to save the game. Their calm under pressure frustrated England, with even captain Stokes showing visible displeasure as India continued to play to reach individual milestones. This was just England's second draw in 40 Tests under the Bazball era. The series, now hanging in the balance, moves to a thrilling finale at The Oval on July 31. view comments First Published: July 28, 2025, 07:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

8 Records Broken By Shubman Gill During His 103-Run Knock In Manchester
8 Records Broken By Shubman Gill During His 103-Run Knock In Manchester

News18

time2 hours ago

  • News18

8 Records Broken By Shubman Gill During His 103-Run Knock In Manchester

1/8 It was the ninth century in the 25-year-old's Test career. All of Gill's centuries have come since the World Test Championship began in 2019. With nine, he's now equal to his preceding captain Rohit Sharma for the most tons in the competition. Gill equalled Don Bradman and Sunil Gavaskar's record of scoring four centuries in a Test series as captain. No other captain in the 148-year history of Test cricket has scored more than four centuries in a Test series. Gill now holds the record for scoring the most runs in a Test series for India against England. The 25-year-old broke Yashasvi Jaiswal's record to take the No. 1 position. Gill also became the first cricketer from Asia to score 700 runs in a Test series played in England. Before him the record of scoring the most runs in a Test series played in England was in the name of Pakistan's Mohammad Yousuf. Shubman Gill became the third Indian cricketer, after Sunil Gavaskar and Yashasvi Jaiswal, to score 700+ runs in a bilateral Test series. He is overall the fourth cricketer to score more than 700 runs in a Test series played between India and England. Shubman Gill joined Graham Gooch, Joe Root, and Yashasvi Jaiswal in an elite club after reaching 81 in India's second innings at Manchester, becoming the fourth batter to score 700+ runs in a Test series between India and England.

Uganda wins Pearl of Africa Cricket T20 Series 2025
Uganda wins Pearl of Africa Cricket T20 Series 2025

United News of India

time2 hours ago

  • United News of India

Uganda wins Pearl of Africa Cricket T20 Series 2025

Entebbe, Uganda, July 28 (UNI) Host Uganda won the Pearl of Africa Cricket T20 Series 2025 after beating the United Arab Emirates (UAE) by eight runs in the final at the Entebbe Cricket Oval on Sunday. Going into the match, Uganda was comfortably leading the standings with five wins. The hosts batted first and scored 170/7 in 20 overs. The UAE side attempted the chase but collapsed to 162/9 in 20 overs. The pairing of Alpesh Ramjani and Raghav Dhawan was instrumental for Uganda, with scores of 61 and 56 runs respectively. For the UAE, Ethan D'Souza top-scored with 32 runs, while Muhammad Zohaib and Muhammad Wassem contributed 30 and 5 runs, respectively. "We tried to play tight and only lost out in the later stages of the match. The Series have helped us get a lot of match practice," said UAE's Ethan D'Souza. Uganda's head coach Abhay Sharma said that he was very proud of his players who won all the six matches. "We played well, and the Series have helped us a lot," said Sharma. Uganda's second team only lost to Namibia's second team in a match that did not carry world ranking points. In an earlier fixture, Kenya defeated Nigeria by 6 wickets. Kenya, led by Sachin Gill, chased Nigeria's 113/9 in 20 overs and scored 116/4 in 19.1 overs. Gill scored 35 runs off 42 balls, while Rakep Patel contributed 33. Nigeria's captain, Systever Okpe, scored a team-high 35 runs, and Abdulmumuni Mohammed added 26. Uganda finished the series with 12 points, followed by the UAE in second place with 6 points. Kenya was third with 4 points, and Nigeria finished with no points. Uganda's and Namibia's second teams did not score any points. The teams used this series to prepare for the upcoming ICC T20 Men's World Cup Qualifier in September. UNI XINHUA RKM

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store