Alberta Court of Appeal dismisses Grassy Mountain appeals made by Northback and Piikani, Stoney Nakoda Nations
Article content
The Alberta Court of Appeal dismissed Tuesday appeals made by an Australia-based mining company and two First Nations for a new hearing over a proposed coal mine along the Eastern Slopes of the Rocky Mountains.
Article content
Article content
In 2021, the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER), acting as part of a joint provincial-federal review panel, had turned down provincial approval for the Grassy Mountain project proposed by Benga Mining, now Northback Holdings. The federal government also rejected the proposal that year.
Article content
Article content
Benga, Piikani Nation and Stoney Nakoda Nation challenged the AER decision, appealing both to the Alberta Court of Appeal as well as filing applications for a judicial review in the Court of King's Bench.
Article content
Article content
Permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal was denied, and Justice Allison Kuntz turned down three separate judicial review applications made to the Court of King's Bench in December 2023.
Article content
Following an Oct. 8 hearing, Justices Jane Fagnan and Karan M. Shaner upheld the dismissal of the judicial review applications, with Chief Justice Ritu Khullar dissenting.
Article content
In their majority decision, the justices noted that Kuntz had pointed out that none of the judicial review applications challenged the constitutional validity of section 56 of the Responsible Energy Development Act (REDA), which prohibits judicial review.
Article content
Kuntz had dismissed the judicial review applications because they were barred by the REDA section.
Article content
Article content
In upholding that 2023 ruling, the justices wrote that Northback and the two First Nations were essentially arguing that the section is 'ineffective for constitutional reasons.'
Article content
Article content
'The appellants did not provide timely notice of the constitutional issue raised before the chambers justice,' the justices concluded in Tuesday's ruling.
Article content
'In the circumstances, the chambers justice did not err in determining that s 56 barred judicial review by the Court of King's Bench in this case.'
Article content
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
6 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Who is Marc-André Blanchard? PM Mark Carney's new chief of staff comes from the worlds of law, diplomacy
As his new government enters its fifth week, Prime Minister Mark Carney continued to build out his inner circle Sunday, naming diplomat and lawyer Marc-André Blanchard as his chief of staff starting in July. In a statement posted to the social media platform X, Carney called Blanchard 'one of Canada's most accomplished builders, legal experts, executives, public servants, and diplomats.' Here's everything you need to know about the prime minister's new top aide. What is Blanchard's educational and professional background? Much like the prime minister he will serve, Blanchard graduated from some of the world's most elite universities; he holds degrees from the London School of Economics, Université de Montréal and Columbia University. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW A lawyer by trade, Blanchard, 59, spent six years as the chair and CEO of McCarthy Tétrault, a business law firm based in Toronto. He most recently served as the executive vice-president for CDPQ Global, a Quebec-based investment firm. He is still a member of the Quebec bar, according to the body's directory, where his area of law is listed as 'international.' Does he have experience in government? Yes, Blanchard served as Canada's ambassador to the United Nations from 2016 to 2020. The announcement of his ascension to the post received little fanfare at the time, seeing as it was made the same day as David MacNaughton's appointment to be Canada's ambassador to the United States. The UN post has a history of being held by prominent Canadian political figures; former Ontario premier Bob Rae succeeded Blanchard in the job, and Stephen Lewis and longtime Jean Chrétien cabinet minister Allan Rock have also represented Canada at the UN. Federal Politics Former UN ambassador Marc-André Blanchard named chief of staff to Mark Carney Elissa Mendes In addition, Blanchard sat on Canada's North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) Council alongside one-time opposition leader Rona Ambrose and Stephen Harper-era cabinet minister James Moore, among others. How are other public officials and politicians reacting to the news? Lisa Raitt, a three-term Conservative MP who once served as Canada's labour minister, said on X that she is a 'BIG fan of this appointment,' thanking Blanchard for 'coming back once again to serve Canada.' Ambrose, likewise, called the appointment an 'excellent choice.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Meanwhile, former Liberal MP and transport minister Omar Alghabra called it a 'well-deserved appointment,' while longtime Liberal party fixture Penny Collenette said that Blanchard and Carney form 'a powerful duo' that puts Canada 'in supreme hands.' Who else was considered for the role? The Star previously reported that former Trudeau senior adviser Mathieu Bouchard, who also served as chief of staff to the heritage minister, was in conversations for the position. The Globe and Mail reported that Trudeau aide and adviser Gerald Butts declined to take the job after being approached. Who are other notable chiefs of staff? Federal Politics Carney government recognizes 'there's no time to waste' on new housing, Olivia Chow says Mayor Olivia Chow says she is refreshed by the urgency with which the Mark Carney government is tackling the housing crisis. Federal Politics Carney government recognizes 'there's no time to waste' on new housing, Olivia Chow says Mayor Olivia Chow says she is refreshed by the urgency with which the Mark Carney government is tackling the housing crisis. Though perhaps not as glamorous and recognizable as the White House chief of staff in the U.S., a number of notable names have served in the position, including now-Senator Percy Downe and longtime Quebec City mayor Jean Pelletier. Former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's chief of staff, Katie Telford, for instance, was seen as one of the most important figures in the Liberal government. In describing her influence on the government's strategy and operations, the Star's Susan Delacourt observed in 2023 that no chief of staff had travelled with a prime minister as much as she had during the 10 years she spent in the role. Carney's outgoing chief of staff, Marco Mendicino, served three terms in the House of Commons representing Eglinton-Lawrence and had two different cabinet appointments in the Trudeau government. The Star recently reported that Mendicino is considering a run for mayor of Toronto in next year's mayoral election. With files from The Canadian Press. Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
CBC
7 hours ago
- CBC
Pimicikamak Cree Nation wildfire evacuees to sleep in warm beds at Ontario hotel Sunday
Social Sharing Dozens of wildfire evacuees from Pimicikamak Cree Nation checked into a hotel in Niagara Falls, Ont., on Sunday after days spent without sleep in a Winnipeg evacuation centre. On Saturday, F irst Nations leaders from across Manitoba called on the federal, provincial and Winnipeg municipal governments to direct city hotels to make space for community members being displaced by more than two dozen wildfires burning across the province. The Manitoba government declared a provincial state of emergency on Wednesday, with more than 17,000 evacuees expected to be fleeing wildfires in northern Manitoba. Pimicikimak Cree Nation was placed under an emergency evacuation order and thousands were forced to leave home as a wildfire burned out of control near the First Nation. As of Sunday afternoon, that fire was 3,300 hectares in size, according to the most recent fire bulletin from the province. Community members from Pimicikamak, also known as Cross Lake, were first sent to Norway House Cree Nation, which has also been under an evacuation notice since Wednesday. From there, Pimicikamak evacuees were sent to an evacuation centre set up at a soccer complex in north Winnipeg. Sheena Garrick, who works with Jordan's Principle for Pimicikamak Cree Nation, said conditions at the Winnipeg Soccer Federation North facility are "horrible". "Everybody's crying, moms are crying, their kids, they want to go home. It's very heartbreaking," she said, adding the crying has been keeping tired evacuees awake. When the First Nation had the opportunity to send its citizens to a hotel in Niagara Falls, Garrick worked overnight on Saturday to organize a group of 47 people to fill a plane. The evacuees landed in Hamilton on Sunday morning and each had a comfortable place to sleep that night, Garrick said. "There was so much relief. Everybody was smiling. Everybody was so happy coming here to a warm meal, knowing they're gonna have a warm bed," she said. Denny Scott, an officer with Jordan's Principal, said the Pimicikamak evacuees finally had a chance to rest since they were first ordered to leave the First Nation on Wednesday. "But Cross Lake is coming together as one and we're together as one," Scott said. Garrick said her phone has been blowing up with questions from community members about when the next plane is going to leave from Winnipeg. On Sunday, she said two more planes carrying 119 people each were expected to arrive in Ontario.
Montreal Gazette
12 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Carney names Quebecer, former UN ambassador as chief of staff
Canadian Politics TORONTO — Prime Minister Mark Carney has named Canada's former ambassador to the United Nations as his chief of staff. Carney announced on Sunday that Marc-André Blanchard would begin his post in July, taking over from Marco Mendicino, the former Liberal cabinet minister who had been doing the job on an interim basis. 'Marc-André has a long and distinguished career as one of Canada's most accomplished builders, legal experts, executives, public servants, and diplomats serving as Canada's ambassador and permanent representative to the United Nations,' Carney wrote on X. Blanchard currently serves as an executive at CDPQ Global, a Quebec-based investment firm responsible for managing pension funds and insurance plans. The prominent Quebec lawyer served as Canada's ambassador to the United Nations from 2016 until 2020. In 2017, Blanchard was named as a member of the government's council struck on the new North American Free Trade Agreement, which was renegotiated by Canada, the U.S., and Mexico, during Trump's first term in office. In his post on X, Carney confirmed that Mendicino would remain his interim chief of staff into 'early summer.' He said Mendicino would be in the job as the Liberal government prepared to introduce its first legislation of the new session of Parliament and host G7 leaders when they meet in Alberta later this month, including U.S. President Donald Trump. Carney has named growing Canada's economy in the face of the president's trade war by knocking down interprovincial trade barriers and fast-tracking approvals for new energy and infrastructure projects as his top priorities. His government is also set to table a bill addressing Canada-U.S. border security, which has been another irritant of Trump's. Carney announced Blanchard as his chief of staff as he was set to meet with energy leaders in Calgary on Sunday and then travel to Saskatoon, where he will spend Monday meeting with the premiers for a First Ministers' Meeting. From Nova Scotia's 'Wind West' to Alberta's pipeline dream, here are the national projects premiers are pitching Carney Chief of staff is the highest-ranking official in the Prime Minister's Office and is responsible for shepherding the government's agenda. In terms of other changes, former Liberal justice minister David Lametti will become Carney's principal secretary, according to a government source familiar with the matter, speaking on the condition of background. Tom Pitfield, a former Trudeau operative who worked on past Liberal election campaigns, had been in the role on an interim basis. Lametti and Carney have known each other for decades, with the pair attending and playing hockey together at the University of Oxford. Since winning the April 28 federal election, Carney has been working to staff up his office. So far, the first twelve chiefs of staff have been named for various ministers. He won the election on a mandate of standing up to Trump's trade war and growing the Canadian economy, promising to deliver on an ambitious agenda and get the government to move at a pace not seen in the past.
