Department of Justice investigation into public servant's hiring of 17yo relative deemed 'inadequate'
An investigation into allegations a senior public servant hired a family member and allowed them to skip the queue for government-funded housing was "wholly inadequate", according to the man tasked with overseeing WA's corruption watchdog.
In an episode that raised questions about how serious corruption and misconduct allegations are handled in the state, the employee's teenage relative was given a three-bedroom home in regional WA, seemingly bypassing a waiting list.
But, as outlined in the report tabled in parliament by the Parliamentary Inspector of the Corruption and Crime Commission Matthew Zilko, those allegations were "simply never investigated" and so no-one involved had been subject to a finding of serious misconduct.
The report said the allegation of wrongdoing first came to light from an anonymous report in July 2023, which said a "very senior public servant on a regional placement" within Department of Justice, had appointed a 17-year-old family member "to an administrative position without declaring a conflict of interest".
Neither the public servant nor their relative was identified in the report.
That initial three-month appointment was extended twice before the recent high school graduate was made permanent, according to the report.
The Corruption and Crime Commission (CCC) was notified and formed a "reasonable suspicion of serious misconduct", Mr Zilko said, but allowed the department to investigate the allegation itself because it said it had already begun its own investigation.
But Mr Zilko said once that probe was completed, it was so substandard it suggested the Justice Department had "insufficient regard" for its legal obligations.
In part that was because the department's investigation also uncovered that the public servant had allocated the relative a three-bedroom government-funded home which "was ordinarily reserved for families", seemingly skipping a waiting list for that housing, according to the report.
Despite those allegations, Mr Zilko's report said the department's investigation was "limited" because it treated the issue as a "disciplinary matter" focused only on the public servant not declaring a conflict of interest.
"Most damningly, whether through inexperience, incompetence or obtuseness, the department never addressed the allegation that [the public servant] had acted corruptly," he wrote.
Shadow Corrective Services Minister Adam Hort said the department's actions did not pass the pub test.
"These are such serious allegations that the community would expect that at the very least there would be a thorough investigation, if not significant consequences for the person at the end of that investigation," he said.
The Justice department declined to comment on whether the senior employee was still employed by the department or if their relative remained in the government house.
In response to the parliamentary inspector, Justice Director General Kylie Maj conceded "the investigation wasn't conducted as well as it might have been", according to the report, but declined to reopen the case because of the department's interpretation of public sector rules.
Ms Maj said she was convinced improvements underway to the department's internal disciplinary process meant "if a similar situation were to arise in the future, the investigation would be handled in a much more satisfactory manner", the report notes.
"That is reassuring, of course, but it does not address the current problem of [the senior employee's] behaviour not being properly investigated and [their relative] remaining in accommodation subsidised by the taxpayer which was intended for families on the housing waiting list."
A Justice department spokesperson did not answer a question about what changes had been made, only saying it takes allegations of misconduct "seriously" and it was confident future investigations would be handled appropriately.
A spokesperson for the Public Sector Commission, which is responsible for misconduct prevention and education, said the commission had accepted the inspector's recommendation to write to the heads of all government authorities "reminding them of their obligations … and the importance of ensuring allegations of misconduct are investigated properly".
Corrective Services Minister Paul Papalia said he had "requested the department provide ongoing updates regarding implementation" of changes made to address the issues raised in the report.
The situation also raised questions about how the CCC handled allegations which warranted investigation, but which it does not have capacity for.
The parliamentary inspector said the issue had been a "longstanding concern" because the legislation only worked if government departments took their obligations "seriously".
"Unfortunately, this is not always the case," he wrote.
In this instance, he criticised the watchdog for not stepping in and overruling the department's decision.
"The commissioner advised that, having weighed current investigative workloads, resourcing constraints and the strategic prioritisation of serious misconduct allegations, he had decided not to investigate this allegation," Mr Zilko wrote.
"I accept that the commission's resources are not limitless, and it is generally entitled to determine its own priorities.
"Nevertheless, the department's abject failure to investigate the allegation referred to it still troubled me."
That failure also troubled the Shadow Attorney-General, Nick Goiran, who echoed the parliamentary inspector's recommendations.
"If the CCC were doing the job the way that they should be, it wouldn't come to this," he said.
"But in the absence of them doing that, in the absence of them then changing their approach after it's been drawn to their attention, what else can the parliamentary inspector do but publish a report like this and say we then need to beef up the legislation?"
He called on Parliament's Joint Standing Committee on the CCC to consider Mr Zilko's recommendations as its first matter of business.
It is understood that committee will meet for the first time next week.
A spokesperson for Attorney General Tony Buti said he would "review the report and consider its findings".
The Corruption and Crime Commission declined to comment.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
23 minutes ago
- News.com.au
South Australia Police seek urgent help to find missing boys from Adelaide's inner suburbs
South Australia Police is seeking urgent help from the public to find three missing children. The missing boys are Zayden, who is almost 3, Izaha, 16 months, and Noah, 3 months. They are from Black Forest in Adelaide's inner south and have been missing since May. Police have reported they have concerns for the boys' welfare. Police reported that the three children are believed to be with a woman known to them. She is described as caucasian, in her early 20s, and 165cm tall with a medium build and long brown hair. The boys were last seen in Gilberton in Adelaide's inner north about 1pm on May 22. Anyone with information or who has seen Zayden, Izaha and Noah have been urged to call police immediately on 131 444 and reference #135439. The search for the boys has stretched interstate, as Victoria Police shared the missing persons call-out.


SBS Australia
24 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
Indigenous man who died in police custody was a dedicated educator
A Wadeye man who died after police prevented him from boarding a flight was a senior Wadeye Elder who lobbied for bilingual schooling and better education funding for his community. A death-in-custody investigation is under way after federal police stopped the 68-year-old from joining a flight out of Darwin on May 30, on reports he was intoxicated. He was taken into "protective custody" but on arrival at Royal Darwin Hospital he was found to be unconscious, prompting medical staff to commence CPR, with resuscitation efforts proving successful. He was transferred to the intensive care unit for ongoing treatment for a suspected medical event but died there on Saturday. "The cause of the man's death remains undetermined pending a postmortem," Northern Territory police have said. "The incident is being investigated as a death in custody as the man was in the custody of the AFP at the time of him first losing consciousness." The AFP has said the man was not arrested and was "not restrained at any point by AFP officers". Aboriginal leaders from the Top End's Daly region have expressed their communities' grief over the loss of the Elder. Thamarrurr Development Corporation representing Wangga, Lirrga, Wulthirri and Tharnpa peoples confirmed in a statement he was a "much loved and respected senior man, who was a mentor to us all". "A great visionary and educator, a campaigner for a better life for his community and a respected leader, he will be greatly missed." TN was a champion for bilingual education and had produced children's books in local tribal language. In 2007 he took part in a racial discrimination action in the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission arguing Wadeye children received less than half the school funding received by other NT children. Then-federal education minister Peter Garrett announced the community would get a $7.7 million funding package in exchange for dropping its complaint . Northern Land Council chair Matthew Ryan said TN, who had been a council member, was a "quiet achiever" whose legacy would live on. "My heart goes out to his loved ones and all mob across the Wadeye and Darwin Daly regions." Opposition leader Selena Uibo said TN's loss would be "be felt deeply across the territory". "He was a respected and strong leader - valued for the guidance he provided to those he worked alongside and the outcomes he helped deliver for his community," Ms Uibo said. NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro said her government recognised the "pain and grief being felt" and her thoughts were with the man's family and loved ones. Catholic Bishop of Darwin Charles Gauci said he had known the Elder for many years and he was "deeply saddened at his death". "I was able to accompany him on the last day of his life, I was in the hospital with his wife and family and to pray with him and to be there with them, walking with them at this very significant time," he told the ABC. "He believed in education as empowerment and he was an educator for many years himself. "He was co-principal at the school at Wadeye and really contributed deeply and widely there for the education of young people." NT Police will prepare a report for the coroner.

News.com.au
39 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Sydney preacher taken to court over alleged anti-Semitic speech
A Muslim preacher is being sued by Australia's peak Jewish body over alleged anti-Semitic speeches in which he allegedly described Jewish people as 'vile' and 'treacherous'. Wissam Haddad, also known as Abu Ousayd, is being taken to the Federal Court by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ) over a series of lectures he gave in November 2023. A three-day hearing in Sydney's Federal Court is set to begin on Tuesday. Recordings of the speeches made at the Bankstown centre, which allegedly included derogatory generalisations about Jewish people, such as descriptions of them as 'vile' and 'treacherous' people, were uploaded online. The proceedings have been brought by ECAJ co-chief executive Peter Wertheim AM and deputy president Robert Goot AO SC, who claim Mr Haddad breached the Racial Discrimination Act 1975. Mr Wertheim said they previously attempted 'in good faith' to resolve the matter through the Australian Human Rights Commission, but a conciliated resolution could not be achieved. 'Accordingly, we have commenced proceedings in the Federal Court,' he said. 'Australia has long enjoyed a reputation as a multicultural success story where people of many different faiths and ethnic backgrounds have for the most part lived in harmony and mutual respect.' Mr Wertheim added that all Australians were 'free to observe our faith and traditions within the bounds of Australian law'. 'Maintaining and strengthening social cohesion is the role of governments and government agencies, but lately they have failed us,' he said. 'It should not fall on our community, or any other community, to take private legal action. However, in the circumstances we feel we have no alternative.'