Panel gives lecture theatres heritage protection
In a decision released today, the Archway Lecture Theatres and 128 other buildings will be given greater protection from demolition or modification without consent under changes to Dunedin's district plan.
At hearings in May, university vice-chancellor Grant Robertson had asked the panel — consisting of commissioners Rob van Voorthuysen (chairman), Cr Sophie Barker and Cr Jim O'Malley — that the theatres not be protected.
Mr Robertson said since 2010 the university had considered demolishing the theatres — possibly replacing them with a formal garden space, which would enhance nearby Gothic buildings.
The Archway Lecture Theatres represented the "poorest quality" of tiered lecture theatres on campus and were not part of the university's future needs, he said.
Mr van Voorthuysen accepted the university's evidence and recommended the building not be protected. However, Crs Barker and O'Malley did not — their majority finding formed the panel's decision.
In the decision report, Crs Barker and O'Malley said the building's architectural value was worthy of heritage protection.
The Archway Lecture Theatres were built in 1974, designed by notable Dunedin architect Ted McCoy, and won an Enduring Architecture award in 2020.
"Its presence is less negative on the Gothic revival heritage value on Union St than its loss would be to the record of late 20th-century teaching architecture," the councillors said.
In his dissenting view, Mr van Voorthuysen said not protecting the building would allow the university to operate more efficiently.
"Its intended formal garden space proposal will have greater benefits for the city's heritage values than would scheduling the theatres, primarily as that would enhance the aesthetics of the existing scheduled Gothic buildings," he said.
A further 17 properties were removed from the proposed schedule, including the Lookout Point Fire Station.
Patersons planner Kurt Bowen, working with Fire and Emergency New Zealand, told the panel the site needed to be upgraded and a new building was the best option.
The panel agreed protecting the existing building based on its design significance would hamper Fenz's operations which had a "high degree" of public benefit.
In a statement accompanying today's decision, Mr van Voorthuysen said the panel accepted, in some cases, high maintenance costs, low public benefit from protection and existing demolition approval for certain buildings outweighed the benefits of heritage protection.
"In all other cases, we consider the benefits of protection outweigh the arguments against it.
"We think we've got the balance right."
Submitters can appeal to the Environment Court within 30 working days of today's decision.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Studying mother acknowledged by YWCA initiative
University of Otago philosophy student Ellathea Fleming, holding her son Kahukura Tonginako-Fleming, 3, and Queen's High School student Malak Tamimi were named on the YWCA Y25 programme this year. PHOTO: GREGOR RICHARDSON Becoming a mother at 18 years old inspired a Dunedin woman to make a difference in her community. Ellathea Fleming was recently recognised for her work in the community by being named in the YWCA Y25 programme — a celebration of 25 young wahine and gender-diverse change-makers between 15 and 25 years old. Ms Fleming said it was nice to be acknowledged. The biggest thing she was involved in was the Hive, a group of young people who act as a two-way bridge between youth and the government started by Curative NZ. Ms Fleming was involved in starting Hive's rangatahi civics engagement group which involved talking to young people in different communities about politics. She got into the work when she was 18 years old and taking a break from university after having a child. "I was getting bored. "I was like 'no, there's still stuff I want to do'. "I want to see more change." She wanted people her age to understand the policies and vote. Ms Fleming said it had not been easy going through university with a child and some days were more frustrating than others. "It required a lot of patience not just with him but also with myself," she said. "This is the hard part; all the other stuff is easy." On top of being a mother and a student Ms Fleming is actively engaged in Talavou Village, and university-based networks. She has served as te aka mātauraka (academic officer) for the Otago Māori Humanities Students' Association, vice-president of the Otago Cook Islands Students' Association, and is a komiti member for te Manaaki o Tamariki Kōhanga Reo. Queen's High School student Malak Tamimi, 15, was also named on the list of the impressive young change-makers. She was a part of many different youth-orientated initiatives including the Dunedin Youth Council, the Mental Health Foundation of New Zealand Youth Advisory Croup and Gen Z Aotearoa as well as being involved in her family's Rozana for Palestine fundraiser. University of Otago medicine student Eleanor Dunn, 23, and Wakatipu High School head girl Manuella Sanches Pedrosa, 17, were also named on the list. The young women went to Auckland for a three-day wananga (learning retreat) last week where they networked with other young people from around the country.
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘Plants of utility' still making presence felt
Cupressus macrocarpa 'Coneybearii' at the Dunedin Botanic Garden. PHOTO: PETER MCINTOSH In the late 1860s - when still under the management of the Otago provincial government, it was decided to move the Dunedin Botanic Garden because of severe flooding of its old site. The garden was moved northwards on to the grounds of the Otago Acclimatisation Society, which had been used to trial the introduction of new species. The new site already had some plantings present, and some plants were able to be moved from the old site, including one of two oak trees planted by superintendent John Hyde Harris commemorating a royal marriage. Although some plants could be moved it was felt that more roses and ornamental plants were needed to shape the garden. Contact was made with the government of Victoria in Australia and a response was made by government botanist and first director of the Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria, Baron Ferdinand von Mueller. He sent ''plants of utility'', including walnuts and cypresses, to Dunedin, and commented that flowering plants were the business of nurseries. This time coincided with broader changes in Dunedin. The garden's relocation freed its original Leith-side site to be occupied by the expanding University of Otago, which moved from the Exchange in the 1870s. The acclimatisation society continued operations from Ōpoho, including a fish hatchery. The end of provincial government soon followed, with the shift to a centralised national government. These overlapping changes signalled a rapidly developing city - where education, public space and scientific institutions were beginning to take lasting form. Today, the royal oak is the best-known survivor of this time, but there are walnuts close to the old Great King St main entrance and the unusual yellow-topped Cupressus macrocarpa 'Coneybearii' at the Opoho entrance - could these be trees from von Mueller in Victoria? - Tom Myers is the botanical services officer at the Dunedin Botanic Garden.
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘Plants of utility' still making presence felt many years on
Cupressus macrocarpa 'Coneybearii' at the Dunedin Botanic Garden. PHOTO: PETER MCINTOSH In the late 1860s — when still under the management of the Otago provincial government, it was decided to move the Dunedin Botanic Garden because of severe flooding of its old site. The garden was moved northwards on to the grounds of the Otago Acclimatisation Society, which had been used to trial the introduction of new species. The new site already had some plantings present, and some plants were able to be moved from the old site, including one of two oak trees planted by superintendent John Hyde Harris commemorating a royal marriage. Although some plants could be moved it was felt that more roses and ornamental plants were needed to shape the garden. Contact was made with the government of Victoria in Australia and a response was made by government botanist and first director of the Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria, Baron Ferdinand von Mueller. He sent ''plants of utility'', including walnuts and cypresses, to Dunedin, and commented that flowering plants were the business of nurseries. This time coincided with broader changes in Dunedin. The garden's relocation freed its original Leith-side site to be occupied by the expanding University of Otago, which moved from the Exchange in the 1870s. The acclimatisation society continued operations from Ōpoho, including a fish hatchery. The end of provincial government soon followed, with the shift to a centralised national government. These overlapping changes signalled a rapidly developing city — where education, public space and scientific institutions were beginning to take lasting form. Today, the royal oak is the best-known survivor of this time, but there are walnuts close to the old Great King St main entrance and the unusual yellow-topped Cupressus macrocarpa 'Coneybearii' at the Opoho entrance — could these be trees from von Mueller in Victoria? — Tom Myers is the botanical services officer at the Dunedin Botanic Garden.
