Pub not liable for injuries door staff caused
JD Wetherspoon is not responsible for injuries a man sustained when two security guards restrained him at a Surrey pub, the High Court has ruled.
A lower court awarded Stephanus Bernardus Burger over £71,000 in damages in 2023 after finding the pub chain was vicariously liable for his injuries, sustained at The Rodboro Buildings in Guildford in 2018.
JD Wetherspoon challenged the decision, saying the security guards' employer Risk Solutions BG Limited is an independent contractor.
In a ruling on Wednesday, Mr Justice Sweeting ruled the original judge was wrong to find the pub company liable for the actions of the door staff.
"The fact that security is integral to the operation of a pub or that the security staff have to co-operate with other staff does not transform the relationship with an external security provider into one akin to employment," the judge said.
He did not state whether or not JD Wetherspoon would have to pay damages as a result of his ruling.
The High Court heard in March that Mr Burger required emergency surgery and a three-night hospital stay after the incident.
Mr Burger's barrister Lia Moses said in written submissions that door staff "engaged with and refused entry to Mr Burger" during the incident, with the judge finding "that two guards jumped on Mr Burger's back".
Ms Moses added that JD Wetherspoon should be held "jointly vicariously liable" and that the security guards' relationship with the company was "akin to employment".
Johnathan Payne, for the pub chain, said in written submissions that the lower court found it was "an unprovoked and cowardly attack on a man walking away from the pub" and "a vendetta for Mr Burger's rude and insulting behaviour".
But he told the court that JD Wetherspoon and Risk Solutions were "totally separate businesses and operating in that capacity", and that the former "had no control and took no part in what happened".
Risk Solutions was not represented at the hearing.
Follow BBC Surrey on Facebook, on X, and on Instagram. Send your story ideas to southeasttoday@bbc.co.uk or WhatsApp us on 08081 002250.
Pub not liable for £71k injury payout, court told
HM Courts & Tribunals Service
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
an hour ago
- Newsweek
Woman Learns What Really Happened To Rescue Dog, Been 'Haunted Ever Since'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The backstory of a two-year-old pit bull mix who is still waiting for a home is breaking hearts online. RescueMeATL, a nonprofit dedicated to saving shelter dogs from euthanasia, shared a video about Karamja, a dog who entered the shelter system three months ago on March 2nd, when Animal Control was called to a DeKalb County apartment complex in Georgia. While in the apartment complex, Karamja was being chased away by residents who were throwing rocks at her. While she had no severe or visible injuries, she was dangerously underweight and emotionally shut down. Her story gained momentum after RescueMeATL member Jennifer Galloway penned an Instagram plea, sharing the heartbreaking details of Karamja's past, which has amassed more than 82,000 views since being posted earlier this week. The caption read: "POV: You found out what broke her and you've been haunted ever since." She added: "Her eyes told me she was broken, before I found out what broke her." Shelter staff later confirmed Karamja had recently given birth—but no puppies were ever found. Pictures of two-year-old Karamja who is waiting for a home after a traumatic start in life. Pictures of two-year-old Karamja who is waiting for a home after a traumatic start in life. @rescueme_atl/Instagram The caption went into further detail about her heartbreaking condition, saying: "But that's not the worst part. The reason why she was wandering all around lost—she had just given birth. Her puppies nowhere to be found. Robbed from her "Her home. Robbed from her. Her body. Robbed from her. You could count every rib." RescueMeATL's Erica Perets told Newsweek: "She entered the shelter system: terrified, underweight, and abandoned. Karamja is a painful example of backyard breeding's devastating cycle. "In many cases, dogs are discarded after their litters are taken—left behind, often in poor condition, after being used for profit." In 2024, approximately 7 million animals entered U.S. shelters and rescues, according to Shelter Animals Count—an increase of nearly 3 percent from 2023. By the end of the year, 103,000 more pets had entered shelters than had exited, contributing to an ongoing capacity crisis in U.S. shelters. Around 748,000 animals experienced non-live outcomes, including euthanasia, death in care, and being lost in care, in 2024. While this represents a 1.6 percent decrease compared to 2023 and a 20 percent drop from 2019, the number remains high. Dogs made up a growing share of these outcomes, with euthanasia rates rising to 9 percent, compared to 7 percent in 2019. Currently at DeKalb County Animal Services, Karamja, who weighs just 39 pounds, is still waiting for a home, and RescueMeATL is calling for urgent foster placement or adoption to prevent her from being overlooked. "She's sweet, docile, and loving. Dog friendly," the Instagram captioned said. Newsweek reached out to DeKalb County Animal Services via email for comment. "She was recently taken in by a short-term shelter foster, someone who stepped up just to buy her more time," Perets said. But she added that Karamja still needs a more permanent place to call home: "Karamja urgently needs a long-term foster or an adopter who can give her the stability and love she's never known," she explained. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Clip shows fatal shooting in Brazil, not India's Bihar state
"In the era of good governance in Bihar, Pawan Dusadh was shot dead in broad daylight. If this murder took place during the reign of Tejashwi Yadav, every media channel would have said 'lawlessness has returned to Bihar'," reads a Hindi-language Facebook post. The clip, shared with captions raising concerns over public safety in Bihar, shows two people on a motorcycle shooting another person before fleeing the scene. It has been watched over 112,000 times since it was uploaded on May 30. Yadav will lead the state opposition Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) party to challenge the coalition government -- mainly made up of Chief Minister Nitish Kumar's Janata Dal (United) party and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) -- in elections in Bihar expected later this year (archived link). Leader of India's largest opposition Congress party Rahul Gandhi has accused Kumar of turning Bihar into the country's "crime capital", while BJP leaders in the state said the RJD was responsible for the increasing crime rate (archived here and here). The footage has circulated with similar claims on Facebook and X. Comments from users suggest they believed the claim to be genuine. "Young people who speak up and raise their voices in Bihar are being murdered in this manner to silence them and spread fear, so that the entire society remains intimidated", reads a comment. Another user wrote, "The common people are not safe at all in Bihar." But the video shows an incident from Brazil, not Bihar. A reverse image search on Google using keyframes found the video was published in a report by Brazilian broadcaster TV Tambau on October 4, 2024 with a headline that reads, "Man is killed on the road while riding a motorcycle in Mandacaru" (archived link). Further keyword searches show Brazilian website O Povo PB published a longer clip on October 8, 2024 showing the same scene from a different angle at the 3:09 mark (archived link). The website identified the victim as 22-year-old Gabriel Junior de Oliveira Medeiros, who was shot dead in the Mandacaru neighbourhood in Joao Pessoa. Images on Google Street View also show that the video was captured along the Avenida Dom Manoel Paiva in the city (archived link). AFP has debunked other false claims related to Yadav here and here.
Chicago Tribune
2 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Today in Chicago History: Bulls win 1st championship — and Michael Jordan named MVP of NBA Finals
Here's a look back at what happened in the Chicago area on June 12, according to the Tribune's archives. Is an important event missing from this date? Email us. Weather records (from the National Weather Service, Chicago) 1966: In Humboldt Park, white Chicago police Officer Thomas Munyon shot Arcelis Cruz, a young Puerto Rican man, in the leg. The incident ignited two days of rioting along Division Street that sprang from deep frustrations over bad police relations, poor schools and uncaring landlords. On the first day of unrest, the Tribune reported, three squad cars were burned, 35 people were arrested and 19 people were injured. Stores along Division Street were looted and set on fire. A firebomb was thrown into Schley Elementary School. Firefighters had a hose wrested from their hands as they tried to extinguish the flames of a burning police car. A Tribune photographer was robbed of his camera, beaten and kicked, until neighborhood residents rescued him. The nearby St. Mary's Hospital treated both civilians and police officers. The violence subsided after a heavy rainfall and hundreds of police officers were placed on patrol in the area. 1991: The Chicago Bulls won the first NBA championship in the team's 25-year history with a 108-101 victory in Game 5 of the NBA Finals over the Los Angeles Lakers. MVP Michael Jordan scored 30 points, Scottie Pippen had 32 and John Paxson added 20. The Bulls won three straight on the road at the Forum. Chicago Bulls beat Los Angeles Lakers for NBA title in 1991'(The championship) means so much,' said Jordan, in tears after the game, talking to a national television audience. 'Not just for me but for this team and this city. It was a seven-year struggle. It's the most proud day I've ever had.' 2019: Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker signed into law sweeping abortion rights legislation that established the procedure as a 'fundamental right' for women in Illinois. Subscribe to the free Vintage Chicago Tribune newsletter, join our Chicagoland history Facebook group, stay current with Today in Chicago History and follow us on Instagram for more from Chicago's past.
